Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are we accepting migrant worker deaths in Qatar for the sake of entertainment?

131 replies

pieami · 28/07/2022 14:49

I'm disgusted that we have accepted any deaths for the mere purpose of putting on a sporting event - totally unjustifiable. One death is too many. Why could the event not be held in a country with existing infrastructure?

One reports found "50 workers died and more than 500 others were seriously injured in Qatar in 2021 alone".

I have a feeling there is less of an outrage due to the workers being brown.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
justasking111 · 06/08/2022 23:10

To die because your employer puts you to work in extreme heat to keep the city looking clean, pretty and Instagram worthy is obscene. BUT it happens

Florenz · 06/08/2022 23:05

Why do people accept migrant deaths to be able to get cheap clothes, smartphones, oil, tyres, cosmetics, everything else we buy?

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 23:03

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 19:18

In fact it’s much lower than one would expect, perhaps migrant workers in Qatar are fitter than British workers?

The bit I highlighted explicitly stated that they are. No life limiting health conditions, no pre-existing health conditions, no obesity, no drugs. They are screened for health before they are permitted to even enter the country for work. I feel like you really need to go back and read what we've both linked to. It doesn't sound like you've fully understood it. Or your Qatari and deliberately being obtuse.

I do understand it? To be clear, do you still think that 6,500 deaths over 10yrs out of a population of 1.7m workers is something to be concerned about? Yes or no?

Because the data shows that this is well below the death rate we have in the U.K. for 25-29yr old males.

This means that the media has written a shocking headline without giving any context. It might as well have written a headline “54,000 men under age 30 DEAD in U.K. over past ten years!!” (Also true)

It’s all OMG how horrible until you realise there is a constant attrition of people dying at all ages. The death rate increases as you get older, but it’s never the case that we all are going to get to pensioner age.

Now as to why the media wants to cast Qatar in the bad light, well there could be racism at play. The idea that only we “white” countries can take care of workers properly. That we are superior and so on.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 06/08/2022 19:40

The reports counting migrant workers deaths don’t usually look at cause of death. So the numbers seem high, but there’s no way of knowing whether they died due to the workplace or at work or from other causes

That's interesting, and something I didn't know

Ity's true that the human rights record of the gulf states isn't the best, but all the same this is worth bearing in mind

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 19:18

In fact it’s much lower than one would expect, perhaps migrant workers in Qatar are fitter than British workers?

The bit I highlighted explicitly stated that they are. No life limiting health conditions, no pre-existing health conditions, no obesity, no drugs. They are screened for health before they are permitted to even enter the country for work. I feel like you really need to go back and read what we've both linked to. It doesn't sound like you've fully understood it. Or your Qatari and deliberately being obtuse.

drbuzzaro · 06/08/2022 19:15

money talks. fifa can talk the talk about no homophobia and racism but if somewhere racist exploitation if rife and homophobia is illegal bribes then what re they gonna do say no?

Scautish · 06/08/2022 18:58

I still give up. Still to much stupidity.

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 18:48

Scautish · 06/08/2022 18:36

i give up. Too much stupidity.

The idea that France and UK attacked Ottomans because of the way they were treating Christians is also wrong.

Are you quite sure on that?

Just one last thing, did your books never mention the Triple Entente of 24 May 1915? Russia, France, and the United Kingdom—issued a declaration condemning the ongoing Armenian genocide carried out in the Ottoman Empire and threatening to hold the perpetrators accountable. This was the first use of the phrase "crimes against humanity" in international diplomacy

And it was the prelude to the subsequent military intervention in Syria. I think you need some military history books that cover the diplomacy which comes before these wars.

Scautish · 06/08/2022 18:36

i give up. Too much stupidity.

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 18:33

Forgot to link the statistic page death rate by age chart again. I’d linked it earlier too.
www.statista.com/statistics/1125118/death-rate-united-kingdom-uk-by-age/

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 18:31

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 17:23

Tim Noonan from the ITUC believes the comparison is misleading. The migrant workers in Qatar are not only young, they are fit. "Qatar requires them to be given a medical examination to screen them for pre-existing conditions, so this is comparing apples and pears," he says

I have to agree with the apples and pears comments in the article you linked.

Is it though?
Males aged 25-29 have a death rate of 0.6 per 1,000 each year in the U.K.
So let’s assume all the Qatari workers are just as young and fit, even though we know of a few deaths reported have been of workers in their 40s where the death rate is 1.9 in a 1,000. But let’s pretend, they are all 25-29 young and fit workers anyway.

Qatar has a migrant working population of 1.7m.
So 1,700 x 0.6 = 1,020 deaths per year
The 6,500 number was measured from 2011-2020 inclusive so 10yrs.
6,500 / 10= 650 deaths per year

This is a complete non story. There are no excess deaths of migrant workers compared to deaths of workers in the UK. In fact it’s much lower than one would expect, perhaps migrant workers in Qatar are fitter than British workers?

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 18:20

Scautish · 06/08/2022 17:18

This is my last response to you @Discovereads as it is now a complete thread derail but the statement below that you made regarding Syria is completely wrong and highly misleading.

You said: But the land carve up was along historic borders that pre-existed before the Ottomans took over
COMPLETELY UNTRUE

Syria in today’s context has completely different borders when compared with pre-Ottoman [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syria_(region) region of Syria]]

I have attached a map in attempt to demonstrate this. Where A is what the French wanted and B what the wanted. These split between A and B is almost exactly the split between Syria and Jordan/Iraq today.

And here is an excerpt from the Wikipedia page I have linked:

After World War I, The boundaries of the region were last defined in modern times by the proclamation of and subsequent definition by French and British mandatory agreement

With this huge error alongside the incredibly inaccurate figures you quoted for Syrian and Ukrainian refugee numbers, I do wonder what your agenda is - especially on a thread where the topic is racism.

I think you have misunderstood me in regards to Syria. The land carve up I was referring to wasn’t the notional 1966 map you’re showing of plans for foreign control of regions internal to Syria that never actually materialised IRL.

I was referring to the whole of Syria as a separate entity was carved back out of the Ottoman Empire along the same historic borders it had had as far back as when it was a Roman province.

the incredibly inaccurate figures you quoted for Syrian and Ukrainian refugee numbers,

I posted incredibly inaccurate figures for the 6.6m Syrian refugees? I beg your pardon but I was off by 1.6m Syrian refugees due using an older source, than you, but your number of 13.4m Syrian refugees was off by 6.8m…more than doubling the number of actual Syrian refugees listed in the source you linked.

I do wonder what your agenda is - especially on a thread where the topic is racism.
Here I was thinking the topic was racism in terms of lack of outrage over the 3 migrant worker deaths in Qatar building the FIFA world cup stadium. And honestly I don’t think there should be outrage. 3 deaths is one of the safest projects to date for the FIFA cup. When you think it matches the 3 deaths when the USA did the FIFA World Cup, it is far below the 21 deaths when the Russians did it, and the 24 deaths when the Italians did it. No outrage then, but I don’t think for a sexing it is because it was white migrant workers dying…it’s because construction is hazardous work. And workers do die in this industry.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/08/2022 17:58

Totally agree. Same with Syrian War vs Ukraine war. We’re falling over ourselves to help the poor Ukrainians (which we should) but actively try to prevent Syrian refugees from even getting to our country.

My personal opinion is that the problem is men not skin colour.
People originally intended on hosting women and children fleeing from Ukraine.
I've read loads of online comments criticising Ukrainian men for arriving, questioning why they aren't back in Ukraine.

Whereas the middle Eastern refugees are predominantly men so there was less people willing to accommodate.

Though I see how human life as no value in certain countries and I've no idea how to make these countries value life and treat workers well.

Seeing the footage of illegal miners in South African being beaten in the street without trial or evidence - not taking from the poor women who were raped in the crime they're being accused of.

The world is horrible.

CulturePigeon · 06/08/2022 17:46

I'm not accepting them.

I take no interest in football. Who is 'we'?

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 17:23

Tim Noonan from the ITUC believes the comparison is misleading. The migrant workers in Qatar are not only young, they are fit. "Qatar requires them to be given a medical examination to screen them for pre-existing conditions, so this is comparing apples and pears," he says

I have to agree with the apples and pears comments in the article you linked.

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 17:19

Apologies it was FIFAs president who said it was 3 workers eufactcheck.eu/factcheck/uncheckable-only-three-people-died-in-the-construction-of-stadiums-for-the-fifa-world-cup-in-qatar/

Scautish · 06/08/2022 17:18

This is my last response to you @Discovereads as it is now a complete thread derail but the statement below that you made regarding Syria is completely wrong and highly misleading.

You said: But the land carve up was along historic borders that pre-existed before the Ottomans took over
COMPLETELY UNTRUE

Syria in today’s context has completely different borders when compared with pre-Ottoman [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syria_(region) region of Syria]]

I have attached a map in attempt to demonstrate this. Where A is what the French wanted and B what the wanted. These split between A and B is almost exactly the split between Syria and Jordan/Iraq today.

And here is an excerpt from the Wikipedia page I have linked:

After World War I, The boundaries of the region were last defined in modern times by the proclamation of and subsequent definition by French and British mandatory agreement

With this huge error alongside the incredibly inaccurate figures you quoted for Syrian and Ukrainian refugee numbers, I do wonder what your agenda is - especially on a thread where the topic is racism.

Why are we accepting migrant worker deaths in Qatar for the sake of entertainment?
Discovereads · 06/08/2022 17:14

“In the U.K. 300 out of every 500,000 working age people die every year (www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-33019838)”

Ive just noticed my BBC link isn’t working. But you can find the data here as well
www.statista.com/statistics/1125118/death-rate-united-kingdom-uk-by-age/

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 17:03

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 16:32

3 work related deaths doesn’t seem unusually unsafe to me? Out of 9 countries that have hosted the FIFA World Cup, Qatar has tied for 3rd safest with the USA.

@Discovereads Those are the official stats released by Qatar and are completely untrue.

No they’re not the official stats released by Qatar and completely untrue.
They’ve been independently validated.

The Guardian article you linked to is quite clear that the 6,500 figure is all deaths among all migrant workers in all jobs due to all causes in the entire country from 2010-2020 whether their deaths were work related or not or World Cup related or not. 94% of the workforce in Qatar are migrant workers, comprising a population of approximately 1.7m people. So a certain number of people in this working age group would die naturally every year. In the U.K. 300 out of every 500,000 working age people die every year ( www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-33019838). If you apply this baseline to the Qatar migrant workers population, then you’d expect to see 10,200 deaths over ten years if these migrant workers were working in the U.K. instead of in Qatar.

The same article you linked states
There have been 37 deaths among workers directly linked to construction of World Cup stadiums, of which 34 are classified as “non-work related” by the event’s organising committee. Experts have questioned the use of the term because in some cases it has been used to describe deaths which have occurred on the job, including a number of workers who have collapsed and died on stadium construction sites.

Thus there were 3 deaths that were work related AND on a FIFA construction site.

This “questioning” is 100% normal as the same questioning happened regarding the deaths on the U.K. 2012 Olympic site being ruled not working related and the U.K. ending up with zero deaths on record.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 06/08/2022 17:02

Out of sight, out of mind. And the British despite denying it all the time are highly racist. And politicians/businesses are good at brushing things under the carpet.

FallOutPloy · 06/08/2022 16:42

And let's not forget the female Fifa worker who was raped, and then sentenced to 100 lashes and 7 years in jail for "extra marital sex". I can't believe that anyone is willing to watch one single match of this competition.

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.lbc.co.uk/news/world-cup-official-faces-100-lashes-and-7yrs-jail-after-rape/

(apologies if this has already been shared - I haven't RTFT)

BeethovenNinth · 06/08/2022 16:40

Totally totally agree. No one gives a shit

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 16:32

3 work related deaths doesn’t seem unusually unsafe to me? Out of 9 countries that have hosted the FIFA World Cup, Qatar has tied for 3rd safest with the USA.

@Discovereads Those are the official stats released by Qatar and are completely untrue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread