Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are we accepting migrant worker deaths in Qatar for the sake of entertainment?

131 replies

pieami · 28/07/2022 14:49

I'm disgusted that we have accepted any deaths for the mere purpose of putting on a sporting event - totally unjustifiable. One death is too many. Why could the event not be held in a country with existing infrastructure?

One reports found "50 workers died and more than 500 others were seriously injured in Qatar in 2021 alone".

I have a feeling there is less of an outrage due to the workers being brown.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Discovereads · 07/08/2022 18:00

And @ilyx
May I remind you that according to the Global Slavery Index there are an estimated 136,000 modern day slaves in the U.K., mostly poor migrant workers, whereas there are an estimated 4,000 modern day slaves in Dubai, mostly poor migrant workers.

Where is your outrage against us and our country? Where is your outrage for the fact that 71% of modern day slaves are WOMEN and GIRLS? So forgive me for not being outraged about Dubai having a smaller modern day slavery problem than we have going on under our own noses.

Dotjones · 07/08/2022 17:58

I agree the world cup should never been awarded to Qatar (nor Russia before them) but we all know it's purely down to money - if you have enough money, you can do whatever you like. It doesn't matter how corrupt you have to be, or how many people die, you're rich and you can afford to pay.

There are a lot of double standards at play though. 3000 people die of workplace accidents and illnesses every single day. About one every two or three days of those are in the UK. People dying because of their job (one that often they ONLY do because they need money to live with) is an accepted part of many industries. Not tolerated, but realistically can't be eliminated. Whether you use gas or electricity, buy food or wear clothes, someone will have died partly because of your behaviour.

In the grand scheme of things, the World Cup deaths are just another statistic, but one that is thrown around by people who (like me) are opposed to it being held in Qatar in the first place.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 17:54

ilyx · 07/08/2022 15:05

@sst1234

Err no I wouldn’t travel to India and have no plans to. Why are you defending the disgusting abuse of people in the UAE? Why don’t you watch just ONE of the videos I linked above? Bear in mind this is all LEGAL and about 40% of the county is in this situation!

It’s crazy you are basing your research on Dubai on YouTube videos about the problem of modern slavery there and then thinking that it’s actually legal, when it isn’t, and that all the immigrants there are slaves.

You can find most anything on YouTube. Here’s some research on the slaves in the U.K.

Special Report: Exploited: Britain's Hidden Slaves
m.youtube.com/watch?v=VDcG2iwyGvU

Slavery is closer than you think
m.youtube.com/watch?v=yOe2-j3QzKI

Modern-day slavery’ revealed in UK garment factories
m.youtube.com/watch?v=oSIrkB7o0hY

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 17:46

ilyx · 07/08/2022 15:03

@Discovereads

You’ve obviously done no research on this. Those laws and protections do not apply to MIGRANT workers. They have zero rights. There are many articles and videos on this.

About 40% of the population of Dubai are poor migrant workers who have there passports stolen, are lured in from very poor countries and promised well paid work, then are forced to work ridiculous hours in the boiling heat to pay back “debts” to their agencies, have no way of escaping, and yes it’s all legal.

The laws do apply to migrant workers- including the ban on slavery and the ban on working outdoors during the hottest part of the day- 10 to 15:30 from 1 Jun to 15 Sept.

There isn’t a law on hours, but for the World Cup FIFA workers they were limited to 10hr days which includes 2hrs overtime (with over time pay). Their passports were not taken from them. There were no bunk beds but regular beds in the accommodation. They had free accommodation and board- it wasn’t taken from their wages. They had TV rooms and computer rooms with video chat to talk to their families. You have to read the actual worker welfare reports. None of the workers on the FIFA World Cup stadiums were modern day slaves.

You obviously have done very little research as the actually 86% of Dubais population that are migrant workers, not 40%.

The situations that you describe are NOT LEGAL in Dubai.

They DO HAPPEN, but it is similar to the modern day slave rings we have found here in the U.K. on our construction sites, car washes, farms and fishing boats. you are confusing the fact that there are modern day slaves in Dubai with what is actually LEGAL and the norm in Dubai.

sst1234 · 07/08/2022 15:09

ilyx · 07/08/2022 15:05

@sst1234

Err no I wouldn’t travel to India and have no plans to. Why are you defending the disgusting abuse of people in the UAE? Why don’t you watch just ONE of the videos I linked above? Bear in mind this is all LEGAL and about 40% of the county is in this situation!

Because your ‘activism’ and outrage doesn’t take into account the bigger picture. If you were really interested in a fix or getting to root cause, you would be posting videos about the abuse and rampant corruption in South Asian countries from where these migrants originate.

No, but that’s neither trendy, nor topical. It’s easier to jump on whichever bandwagon the press wants you to.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/08/2022 15:08

The employers are Arab Muslims. So criticism of them might be ‘racist’.

ilyx · 07/08/2022 15:05

@sst1234

Err no I wouldn’t travel to India and have no plans to. Why are you defending the disgusting abuse of people in the UAE? Why don’t you watch just ONE of the videos I linked above? Bear in mind this is all LEGAL and about 40% of the county is in this situation!

ilyx · 07/08/2022 15:03

@Discovereads

You’ve obviously done no research on this. Those laws and protections do not apply to MIGRANT workers. They have zero rights. There are many articles and videos on this.

About 40% of the population of Dubai are poor migrant workers who have there passports stolen, are lured in from very poor countries and promised well paid work, then are forced to work ridiculous hours in the boiling heat to pay back “debts” to their agencies, have no way of escaping, and yes it’s all legal.

sst1234 · 07/08/2022 14:50

ilyx · 07/08/2022 13:42

Slavery is completely legal in Qatar as it is in Dubai and most of the Gulf States, would never travel to any of these places.

Would you travel to India? One of the three top countries from where people migrate to Qatar. Because India is treating those people so bad that they choose to be ‘slaves’ in Qatar.

Like I said, this thread is nothing but a pointless exercise in ‘white saviour’ performative outrage.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 14:02

ilyx · 07/08/2022 13:42

Slavery is completely legal in Qatar as it is in Dubai and most of the Gulf States, would never travel to any of these places.

No slavery was outlawed in Dubai and Qatar in 1952, Saudi Arabia in 1962.
The last country on the planet to outlaw slavery was Mauritania in 1981.

The slavery that exists today is modern slavery- all completely illegal, black market slavery.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 13:47

@bellac11
Here also is the pdf report with methodology and suchlike behind the index
downloads.globalslaveryindex.org/ephemeral/GSI-2018_FNL_190828_CO_DIGITAL_P-1659875919.pdf

ilyx · 07/08/2022 13:42

Slavery is completely legal in Qatar as it is in Dubai and most of the Gulf States, would never travel to any of these places.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 13:33

bellac11 · 07/08/2022 11:24

I'd be interested to know how those statistics are gathered

Does the CCC and BBB relate to how accurate the statistics of each country are seen to be?

I know that when asylum seekers are met on arrival, assessments are completed as to whether they need a referral to the NRM, a very high number do, particularly children and females,, so they will make up a large number.

Who are the others?

No, the CCC and BBB are ratings of the governments response to tackling modern slavery.
There is more about the Global Slavery Index here:
www.walkfree.org/projects/the-global-slavery-index/

What others?

jeaux90 · 07/08/2022 11:46

I lived in Qatar for three years. Moved back 10 years ago and according to friends still out there nothing has changed.

It is an awful place for migrant workers in the construction and domestic jobs.

It's an absolute lottery on whether they get treated ok, if they get paid, if they get to keep their passports.

The construction workers living conditions are shocking.

Another example. There was a fire in a mall out there not long after I moved back, several young children died in the crèche. No one was held accountable for the lack of H&S/deaths (not entirely true, there was a scapegoat)

It's corrupt, their laws bounce around, they have a very different attitude to risk and death.

It was normal to see multiple kids bouncing around a car with no seatbelts on is probably the most day to day example of this.

It sounds bad, it is.

bellac11 · 07/08/2022 11:24

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 10:43

The U.K. has a higher rate of modern slaves per capita than Qatar does.
UK 2.08 in 1,000 people are slaves
Qatar 1.50 in 1,000 people are slaves

So yeah. We need to clean up our ownselves before casting shade on another country because they’re brown and Muslim.

I'd be interested to know how those statistics are gathered

Does the CCC and BBB relate to how accurate the statistics of each country are seen to be?

I know that when asylum seekers are met on arrival, assessments are completed as to whether they need a referral to the NRM, a very high number do, particularly children and females,, so they will make up a large number.

Who are the others?

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 10:52

@chilliesandspices
I wasn’t calling you racist, btw, I don’t think you are. I called the media racist for publishing such smears against Qatars construction efforts for the FIFA World Cup. The cold hard facts don’t support the narrative they are peddling with a few choice anecdotes of isolated deaths and cases of abuse. They wanted you to believe the workers are slaves being abused to death. That’s why they came up with the biggest headline number and published it with no context and no analysis against benchmarks.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 10:43

chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 09:59

Oh for goodness sake. The irony of you defending a country that keeps foreign slaves and calling me the racist? I have more argents but we're clearly wasting our time here. Let's agree to disagree.

The U.K. has a higher rate of modern slaves per capita than Qatar does.
UK 2.08 in 1,000 people are slaves
Qatar 1.50 in 1,000 people are slaves

So yeah. We need to clean up our ownselves before casting shade on another country because they’re brown and Muslim.

Why are we accepting migrant worker deaths in Qatar for the sake of entertainment?
Why are we accepting migrant worker deaths in Qatar for the sake of entertainment?
chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 09:59

Oh for goodness sake. The irony of you defending a country that keeps foreign slaves and calling me the racist? I have more argents but we're clearly wasting our time here. Let's agree to disagree.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 09:42

chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 09:31

SIGH

You still haven't read any of the articles either of us linked which detail the abuse of migrant workers. You're also ignoring the apples and pears comment. The 30 year old who grew up helping on a family farm in Nepal is very different to the 30 year old who grew up in a tower block in Manchester playing xBox. Looking at the death statistics in the Uk is useless because it includes young people who die from cancer, from pre-existing heart conditions, from asthma, from cystic fibrosis, from epilepsy or any other number of health conditions that don't exist in that migrant population because they're screened out. I also very much doubt they have to deal with drugs or knife crime that seems to be increasingly prolific here.

I have read the articles and they have a few anecdotes of abuse, but anecdotes of abuse abound in the U.K. Abuse of workers does happen, everywhere. The question is how does the level of fatalities amongst workers in Qatar compare to the U.K.? And when you compare, there’s no evidence of the horrific levels of abuse causing deaths that is being alleged by (racist white) media sources.

The 6,500 deaths reported in Qatar are ALL deaths from ALL causes- and ALL workers not just the ones fit enough to work construction. There are asthmatic house cleaners and nannies. Some construction workers even do have undiagnosed heart conditions as well. So many of these health conditions DO exist in migrant populations and the screening out of obviously bad ones for construction work would account for a death rate of only 6,500 when we’d expect to see 10,200 under normal circumstances.

I also very much doubt they have to deal with drugs or knife crime that seems to be increasingly prolific here.. This is absolutely laughable. You’ve obviously never been to the ME.

chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 09:31

SIGH

You still haven't read any of the articles either of us linked which detail the abuse of migrant workers. You're also ignoring the apples and pears comment. The 30 year old who grew up helping on a family farm in Nepal is very different to the 30 year old who grew up in a tower block in Manchester playing xBox. Looking at the death statistics in the Uk is useless because it includes young people who die from cancer, from pre-existing heart conditions, from asthma, from cystic fibrosis, from epilepsy or any other number of health conditions that don't exist in that migrant population because they're screened out. I also very much doubt they have to deal with drugs or knife crime that seems to be increasingly prolific here.

Discovereads · 07/08/2022 09:12

chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 02:58

I do understand it? To be clear, do you still think that 6,500 deaths over 10yrs out of a population of 1.7m workers is something to be concerned about? Yes or no?

In the context of everything else in those articles, yes, it's fucking horrific. These aren't just statistics they're human beings who are being treated appallingly. Yet you sit here defending their abusers because you don't think enough have of them have died. Let's ignore the fact that the statistics are blurry and reporters who tried to investigate were arrested. Let's not think of the workers who desperately want to return home or go anywhere else but are trapped in slavery. Honestly, the names I want to scream at you right now...

Sigh that’s not the case at all. If those same workers were in the U.K. over 10,000 would have died not 6,500. The statistics do matter because they are not showing any evidence of abuse of workers in Qatar. Yes, not enough have died to support the narrative of Qatar being this awful place where workers are slaves being worked to death. There is zero evidence. The workers are not trapped and desperately go home in regards to the FIFA World Cup workers in Qatar- their travel to/from is paid in full by their employer plus they get a free trip home once a year (that’s more than most armed forces get when stationed abroad).

You aren’t understanding that 6,500 deaths over a span of ten years, or 650 deaths per year in a population of 1.7m is WELL BELOW what we’d expect from natural causes for that age group of men in their twenties.

I know every number is a human being but you have to look at things rationally. You can’t then sit there and say it’s horrific, Im ignoring abuse because enough didn’t die. That’s not the case. The issue is that if there were abuse more would have died, you wouldn’t have a death rate that is well below what we see in the U.K. where ok, we’re not perfect , but since Qatar is doing better than the U.K. at keeping workers alive we don’t have a leg to stand on accusing them of worker abuse.

chilliesandspices · 07/08/2022 02:58

I do understand it? To be clear, do you still think that 6,500 deaths over 10yrs out of a population of 1.7m workers is something to be concerned about? Yes or no?

In the context of everything else in those articles, yes, it's fucking horrific. These aren't just statistics they're human beings who are being treated appallingly. Yet you sit here defending their abusers because you don't think enough have of them have died. Let's ignore the fact that the statistics are blurry and reporters who tried to investigate were arrested. Let's not think of the workers who desperately want to return home or go anywhere else but are trapped in slavery. Honestly, the names I want to scream at you right now...

LuckyStone · 06/08/2022 23:46

Yes its all white peoples fault... all the bad things that ever happen in this world and have ever happened... all white peoples fault... 🙄
What a simple world view some peoples simple minds come up with...

Georgeskitchen · 06/08/2022 23:34

What exactly do you mean when you ask why are "we" accepting it?
Why don't you ask the people of the countries where this is happening what THEY are doing about it?

Discovereads · 06/08/2022 23:23

Florenz · 06/08/2022 23:05

Why do people accept migrant deaths to be able to get cheap clothes, smartphones, oil, tyres, cosmetics, everything else we buy?

Or our fish and chips
www.theguardian.com/global/2022/may/17/migrant-workers-exploited-and-beaten-on-uk-fishing-boats

Swipe left for the next trending thread