Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not find yoga calming?

93 replies

serenedream · 28/07/2022 13:43

Admittedly I am a newbie! I hope that I am unreasonable, because I have dearly wanted to learn for many years, and have only been able to commit to it recently.

I have a rather lousy local class and can't yet get to one further afield as not driving at the moment. By lousy I mean it is very large and the teacher can't really help individual clients.

So, I have tried many vids at home and have studied alone (books, documentaries, etc) and tried out small sessions here on my mat, going gently and trying to find a fit that feels right for me.

But some of even the easier poses feel stressful, it is even worse if I try to follow a video as my neck is twisting around to see it! I thought of planning a set of poses before hand then easing into them alone, but even then I can't quite seem to find it relaxing. I must admit that my muscles feel fab after though! Some dreadful soreness as a newbie (hope this is normal) but my mind feels odd and frazzled! Confused I felt even more stressed and hyper after doing it.

I have meditated for years so not a novice there, I am usually very comfortable being alone with myself and breathing/inner silence and calm. It's just that I can't seem to combine that with asanas - which is what yoga is supposed to be about!

AIBU to think maybe it is not for me? Perhaps it works for some and actually upsets others? I have had a really sore neck and feel unpleasant doing any kind of inversion. Even downward dog makes my head pound. Maybe I could do modifications?

OP posts:
serenedream · 29/07/2022 00:45

NovemberRain2 · 29/07/2022 00:26

Yoga isn't a fitness routine and is much more than asana. It's also mediation and breathing. The postures are there to help with movement but you can practice yoga without doing any strenuous asana.

If you want to exclusively keep fit or lose weight, perhaps try a different form of exercise such as pilates or running.

This! I am drawn to yoga for those reasons, to extend my meditation practice into the physical. I don't see it as fitness in the ordinary sense, so I can imagine if someone prefers vigorous or intense workouts yoga might not be very satisfying.
It is often marketed along with more typical exercises though, so I am not surprised many people are let down by it. It just isn't like that at all, and I strongly doubt there would be fast results or weight loss. And some people just like pushing harder, having more active workouts. It's all good if it is right for you.

What irritates me about yoga sometimes is the mythology/lifestyle mania surrounding it - the winning insta poses, expensive accessories, etc. It put me off for a long time.
I am open to the spiritual/mindful elements (although not religious myself) as I do feel we are more than just a brain on a stick, so would love to delve deeper in Grin

OP posts:
AuntTwacky · 29/07/2022 00:38

It depends on the teacher, mine is amazing I love her classes, anyone else is just not the same!

NovemberRain2 · 29/07/2022 00:26

Yoga isn't a fitness routine and is much more than asana. It's also mediation and breathing. The postures are there to help with movement but you can practice yoga without doing any strenuous asana.

If you want to exclusively keep fit or lose weight, perhaps try a different form of exercise such as pilates or running.

TheChosenTwo · 28/07/2022 23:14

I dislike them both! I’ve tried a few different classes over the years as friends have encouraged me to give it a go but I’m far too impatient and like my exercise/workouts to be quite aggressive and high intensity, I like to be really out of breath and sweating in my sports bra!
yoga and Pilates just totally enrage me with their slow doddery pace and so much time spent either concentrating on breathing or lying down - I just want to shout “stop wasting my fucking time and get on with it 🤬” only to discover that that really is ‘it’.
Not for me, but I know so many people are totally dedicated to it and would hate the type of classes I like. And some like both. Different strokes for different folk.

Delatron · 28/07/2022 22:46

Yes yoga makes me really angry. I used to come back from a class furious! So I googled it and apparently it is a thing.

Pilates is loads better.

serenedream · 28/07/2022 22:22

@megletthesecond Ah, I am good at switching off, but I can see how that might exacerbate it. People always say yoga is for everyone, but I think they mean 'everyone who gels with it'!

OP posts:
serenedream · 28/07/2022 22:21

Boxowine · 28/07/2022 20:51

I don't enjoy it either. I do like Tai chi, though. Try something different. Some of the benefits of yoga come from the stretching and focused breathing which facilitate respiration and lymphatic drainage and overall impact your physiological processes in a positive way. But you could get those effects from other types of classes. Zumba is fun too. As is water aerobics. Lots of low impact types of activities out there but you should do something you like. I just took up Nordic hiking.

I will definitely consider these, we do have a local tai chi class here. Always fancied that! Will see how I get on with my yoga for now and give it some thought as I go along.

OP posts:
serenedream · 28/07/2022 22:19

Gordonsgrin · 28/07/2022 20:56

Rather sounds like you are doing rather better than you thought! Your balance and core strength must be sound. Perhaps it is your blood flow that restricts your capacity, this may come from tension coming g from the desire to master the full range all at once.
keep the faith, you sound awesome.

This is interesting. I stopped for over a week, and since slowly going back in, I have taken a calmer, less demanding approach (with props, lol). It did make a difference, but I have done very little as of yet. I have just found a local teacher who may do private classes, and just one session might help me get started, we shall see how it goes when I call up!

When practising last week I felt very rushed (my own doing) and too confused. I was too excited to try many things at once, and discovered a lot of discomfort in my head being lower than my chest. For now I will do modifications, as I don't want to aggravate that, and my body is likely telling me it doesn't want to go there. I will adapt to my own comfort. I think many of us when starting out think we need to work up to acrobatics, sort of in a progression, but it's ok to follow one's own path - headstands are not compulsory at any level.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts:)

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 28/07/2022 20:57

Yanbu. I've never relaxed at yoga. Too much time to think.

Gordonsgrin · 28/07/2022 20:56

Rather sounds like you are doing rather better than you thought! Your balance and core strength must be sound. Perhaps it is your blood flow that restricts your capacity, this may come from tension coming g from the desire to master the full range all at once.
keep the faith, you sound awesome.

Boxowine · 28/07/2022 20:51

I don't enjoy it either. I do like Tai chi, though. Try something different. Some of the benefits of yoga come from the stretching and focused breathing which facilitate respiration and lymphatic drainage and overall impact your physiological processes in a positive way. But you could get those effects from other types of classes. Zumba is fun too. As is water aerobics. Lots of low impact types of activities out there but you should do something you like. I just took up Nordic hiking.

serenedream · 28/07/2022 20:44

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 28/07/2022 18:22

You should look at yin it's mainly mat based no down dog or inversions it's poses like pigeon, butterfly, seated fold, deer, supported fish, bridge etc

will do that, thanks!

OP posts:
BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 28/07/2022 18:22

You should look at yin it's mainly mat based no down dog or inversions it's poses like pigeon, butterfly, seated fold, deer, supported fish, bridge etc

serenedream · 28/07/2022 18:15

SarahSissions · 28/07/2022 17:57

I was always too worried about accidentally farting to find it relaxing

I have IBS, so god help anyone within a 5 mile radius Grin

OP posts:
serenedream · 28/07/2022 18:14

Gordonsgrin · 28/07/2022 17:54

Hi there, I am pleased you are persevering. It has taken me 18 months to find my flow! I attend a taught session once per week and then do a session on my own 2 or 3 ti each in between. Are there any poses that you are happy to perform?
Hopefully, now you have dialled back on the pressure to do the classic “I am a yogi” poses you will find you get to where you want to be.
I still struggle with any pose that requires hip mobility but I can do a crow to handstand! I will never ever be able to get my heels down on the floor in downward dog…..

I am the opposite! I can twist my hips and legs anywhere but inversions really bother me. I won't entertain any kind of headstand and full downward dog makes me neck/head feel uncomfortable. I am happy to find modifications though and may use a stool or chair for d.dog.

I am comfortable so far with:
Warrior poses, cat~cow, moon, triangle, etc. I am only uncomfortable with having my head lower than my heart.
I prefer slow flows........my interest in yoga is body/mind so if i wanted to feel invigorated I'd probably do something else.

Agree that it will take time, I keep stopping but going back after a few days. It works out better the calmer I approach it. I would love to mix class with home practice, ultimately!

OP posts:
SarahSissions · 28/07/2022 17:57

I was always too worried about accidentally farting to find it relaxing

Gordonsgrin · 28/07/2022 17:54

Hi there, I am pleased you are persevering. It has taken me 18 months to find my flow! I attend a taught session once per week and then do a session on my own 2 or 3 ti each in between. Are there any poses that you are happy to perform?
Hopefully, now you have dialled back on the pressure to do the classic “I am a yogi” poses you will find you get to where you want to be.
I still struggle with any pose that requires hip mobility but I can do a crow to handstand! I will never ever be able to get my heels down on the floor in downward dog…..

Comtesse · 28/07/2022 17:37

Yin yoga or yoga nidra with a live teacher - zoom class then you don’t need to travel - I have gone to Catherine Annis classes for years and love her

Words · 28/07/2022 17:31

I hated yoga too, and also mat based Pilates. I am not very co ordinated and would either collapse in giggles or go home more stressed than when I arrived.

Then I discovered Reformer Pilates classes. A reformer is a piece of spring loaded equipment - a sliding platform that supports the various moves.

It's absolutely ace. I love it and the results are amazing.

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 28/07/2022 17:26

Anonymous48 · 28/07/2022 14:02

Is yoga supposed to be relaxing?

I do it because it's great exercise - strength, flexibility and cardiovascular. It's always nice to end with shavasana though - that part's relaxing!

Is yoga cardio? I've never got out of breath doing it. Is it a specific type thats cardio? Maybe I've been doing the easy version!

serenedream · 28/07/2022 17:17

@PlaygroupWoe Thank you, I will have a look..

OP posts:
PlaygroupWoe · 28/07/2022 17:11

The thing is there are so many different kinds of yoga, that it takes a while to find what suits you. And yes, very difficult to do if you don't have a variety of classes to try!

I do iyengar yoga which is very slow and precise. Very rare for people to hurt themselves doing it because we take care to use props etc to support us. I find other styles very unnatural, and often as you say feel the teachers can't quite give the attention you need.

Also, some of the asna are relaxing, some are invigorating. Some generate heat, some don't. A good teacher will include this information in their classes...

There are some iyengar classes on YouTube if you want to give it a try. The ones I've used before are Yoga with Lin and Leo.

Good luck!

serenedream · 28/07/2022 17:06

I suppose focusing on the breath and stretches pulls the mind in tightly so stops the internal 'noise' somewhat. But I would imagine a lot of fitness routines do this, as well as making us feel energised later. I used to love cycling, but it plays havoc with my knees. The feeling after a long ride was out of this world!

OP posts:
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 28/07/2022 16:59

I also feel oddly tense and anxious sometimes after yoga.
I keep wondering why that is! I'm sure the spiritual people would says it's something to do with your energy systems. Who knows! 😂

Danceswithkids · 28/07/2022 16:56

I think you have to do it for a while so you just know the postures without having to look before you can get properly into the breathing and headspace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread