Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’re planning to refuse to pay energy bills?

138 replies

Gruffalocrumbles · 28/07/2022 13:35

I’ve seen a few posts here and there on social media about collectively refusing to pay energy bills when the price hikes in October.

I was wondering if many people are on board/planning to do this?
(YABU = not refusing to pay, YANBU = refusing to pay?)

Most recent post I have seen is by a page called ‘dontpayuk’ on Instagram www.instagram.com/p/CghIfyeseTv/?igshid=YzAyZWRlMzg=

I am really concerned about how our household is going to manage to keep up with bills this winter.

OP posts:
Fml1980 · 28/07/2022 21:43

My gas and electricity is already 350 a month, did look to fix but at them prices not a chance.
I'm frightened for the winter not going to lie.

To ask if you’re planning to refuse to pay energy bills?
TheHateIsNotGood · 28/07/2022 21:36

Nope - I'll be paying/servicing all of my debts no matter what - low income that I have, if it squeezes too tight I'll come to an arrangement for the interim.

It's the ebb and flow, even though finance and bills are mostly artificial, they still ebb and flow just like natural forces. The harsh conditions expected are not just UK-specific so getting disgruntled at politicians is pointless.

I've coined a new expression:

"Too stupid to know how stupid they are"

MsFrenchie · 28/07/2022 21:25

UxbridgeVoteBJOut · 28/07/2022 21:23

if the 8 biggest Uk energy supplier companies gave up all profits (suppose that 100% of shareholders voted to do that) : what difference would it make to the average household bill?

I have a suspicion the difference would be like £20 per year per household.

Say I'm wrong.

No, that’s about right, if you exclude the companies which actually lost money which would drop the average lower.

Mumtofourandnomore · 28/07/2022 21:25

Mumtofourandnomore · 28/07/2022 18:19

Centrica’s profits on their retail energy supply business fell by 43% according to their half year accounts and the media. The cost to buy the energy people use is MUCH higher than the price customers pay under the price cap. Centrica only makes a profit because it has hedged future volumes, it has effectively fixed prices in advance. Little suppliers did not do this and went bust.

Centrica makes a tiny profit margin on energy supply contracts even with hedging. I understand that under the special administrative regime, the government did not hedge costs at all, this is a terrible choice and will have cost a fortune (not sure if they are hedging costs now). So you can be assured that nationalising energy supply is not necessarily a great idea.

Energy companies have made the vast majority of their profit from Upstream (production) and energy trading. These profits go to their shareholders (including pension funds and the like !) or are reinvested in the business (renewables are very capital intensive) - it’s in everybody’s interests for companies to be well managed. The profits aren’t kept by fat cats.

Centrica is talking about reopening the Rough gas storage facility as early as this winter which will need a lot of upfront cash to update it.

It’s convenient to call energy companies thieving robbers, but it’s ultra-complex - think of transmission and distribution networks, long-term purchase contracts, complex hedging strategies, renewables, regulatory policy, volatile geopolitical risks etc, all for 2% margin. They don’t charge customers lots and just keep it ! Energy suppliers would probably like to leave their energy supply businesses to the government and keep the profitable elements - good luck to them…….

I should have added above that I was talking about Bulb when I referred the special administrative regime - the cost of the failure to hedge will also be passed on to customers too which is outrageous.

UxbridgeVoteBJOut · 28/07/2022 21:23

if the 8 biggest Uk energy supplier companies gave up all profits (suppose that 100% of shareholders voted to do that) : what difference would it make to the average household bill?

I have a suspicion the difference would be like £20 per year per household.

Say I'm wrong.

apwkLmws · 28/07/2022 21:01

@ChimChimeny my gas is down mainly because it's summer and I don't need the heating on but my electric didn't vary much at all due to summer. This reduction is because of specific changes I have made and the picture I attached is just showing electric use, not gas.

apwkLmws · 28/07/2022 20:56

@Funinthemud the 3 main things we have done is stopped using an electric heater we had in one room. Got rid of our second fridge/freezer from the garage and stopped using the tumble dryer. Then just generally been more careful with how we've been cooking and using the electric showers etc. Like you we have a hot water tank so using that hot water from there instead. Gas use is also really low, heating is off, hot water is only heated for an hour a day and that is plenty for us. To be fair we were higher than average users anyway so probably should have been looking at how we could cut back anyway.

Mumtofourandnomore · 28/07/2022 18:19

Centrica’s profits on their retail energy supply business fell by 43% according to their half year accounts and the media. The cost to buy the energy people use is MUCH higher than the price customers pay under the price cap. Centrica only makes a profit because it has hedged future volumes, it has effectively fixed prices in advance. Little suppliers did not do this and went bust.

Centrica makes a tiny profit margin on energy supply contracts even with hedging. I understand that under the special administrative regime, the government did not hedge costs at all, this is a terrible choice and will have cost a fortune (not sure if they are hedging costs now). So you can be assured that nationalising energy supply is not necessarily a great idea.

Energy companies have made the vast majority of their profit from Upstream (production) and energy trading. These profits go to their shareholders (including pension funds and the like !) or are reinvested in the business (renewables are very capital intensive) - it’s in everybody’s interests for companies to be well managed. The profits aren’t kept by fat cats.

Centrica is talking about reopening the Rough gas storage facility as early as this winter which will need a lot of upfront cash to update it.

It’s convenient to call energy companies thieving robbers, but it’s ultra-complex - think of transmission and distribution networks, long-term purchase contracts, complex hedging strategies, renewables, regulatory policy, volatile geopolitical risks etc, all for 2% margin. They don’t charge customers lots and just keep it ! Energy suppliers would probably like to leave their energy supply businesses to the government and keep the profitable elements - good luck to them…….

Ylvamoon · 28/07/2022 17:23

Not paying isn't going to solve anything.

You might not pay for a few months... but you'll be paying off the accumulated debt for years!

I think it would be better if we all turn off gas & electric every Monday and Wednesday... kids at school us at work and once back just use as little as possible!. This would really cause some interesting problems in terms of usage and storage.
Grated, initially we will suffer but it's short term and controlled by us.
Not paying bills is controlled by them.
I'm all for peaceful protest that is properly thought through.

Bpdqueen · 28/07/2022 17:22

The government is In the process of giving people a significant amount of money to pay towards gas and electric so I suggest u use that before u do anything else

Unforgettablefire · 28/07/2022 17:13

I've just read if you have a smart meter they can change it remotely to a prepay?

lot123 · 28/07/2022 17:12

There needs to be tighter regulation on profit margins in these industries that supply essential services.
If we all refused to pay, they would be FORCED to reduce their profit margin, rather than hurting the consumer.

As others have said, this simply isn't the case. The huge hike in wholesale energy prices has put 30 energy firms out of business, many of whom were supplying energy at a loss to people on fixed rate contracts.

Blame OPEC, blame the pandemic, blame the war in Ukraine if you want but it's not the fault of the retail energy suppliers.

MsFrenchie · 28/07/2022 17:09

Monika007 · 28/07/2022 15:52

I'm going to do it. And I won't sit in a cold home with a little kid. I always try to save energy as much as I can so thats nothing new, but there is a limit. We need national protest. At the moment this goverment doing basically nothing to help people.

So, you’ll stop paying, your power will be cut off, or you’ll be forced to have a prepayment meter; what then?

Unforgettablefire · 28/07/2022 16:59

I have payg meters so can't really not pay, but even if I wasn't I wouldn't want my credit rating ruined and I wouldn't want the escalated bills and people braying on the door.
What's everyone going to do about internet and charging their devices when they're cut off for not paying? They won't even be able to communicate with each other unless they go and use other peoples electric.

Itdoesntreallymatter · 28/07/2022 16:53

nellytheelephant1980 · 28/07/2022 13:50

People aren't planning to literally not pay, but to cancel direct debits and pay for what they can afford.
A massive act of public disobedience is quite honestly what needs to be done now.

I will be cancelling my direct debit on 1st October. I won't be getting into debt because I will still have the money put aside.

I did wonder about what would happen if we just paid what we are paying now and not the rest, or offer to pay either nothing or the amount we are used to. Will they really try to fit prepayment meters in millions of homes? That's a big task.

Some suppliers will go bust though as some of them are not producers, so would we really just be creating a monopoly instead and removing competition?

I think there will be a lot of civil disobedience with this and all of the other shit going on too. This has been predicted as occurring in the 2020's for a long time by those who study historical cycles, so very interesting.

What are your rights if you only partially pay the bill? Probably isn't any.

JassyRadlett · 28/07/2022 16:51

Remove VAT, SC and green levy.

Interested in these. VAT seems straightforward but doesn't SC cover the fixed costs of supplying electricity eg the electricity and gas networks among other things? Wouldn't removing that just push those costs onto the unit charge instead?

on green levy, are you including things like Warm Home Discount? What happens to the contracts that exist under the levy? Are you suggesting it just goes into general taxation, I can see how that would be fairer.

bellabasset · 28/07/2022 16:46

The one thing that annoys me the most is that the daily electricity standing charge has been increased by 20p a day to cover the failure by the bankrupt privatised companies to pay the levies to protect customers deposits. But we, as customers, need to take far more responsibility for our bills

  1. Read your meters regularly, take a photo
  2. Update your readings
  3. Know your usage
  4. Keep copies of your bills
  5. Know your tariff
  6. Understand how to calculate your dd
  7. Know how much debt you owe to your energy company

What could the government do to help people?

  1. Remove VAT, SC and green levy.
2 Tier the rates charged

@TheFormidableMrsC is paying for what she uses, but with winter coming and the rates increasing where is she going to get the extra?

As a pensioner I'm using £80 - £90 now wirh no debt but have been told my bills will be over £2,500 on a use of 6700kw gas and 2035kw electricity from October.

Darkstar4855 · 28/07/2022 16:46

No, I like having light, hot water and heating.

JassyRadlett · 28/07/2022 16:46

hoping2021 · 28/07/2022 16:25

I wish more people would back this campaign. There needs to be tighter regulation on profit margins in these industries that supply essential services.
If we all refused to pay, they would be FORCED to reduce their profit margin, rather than hurting the consumer.

What do you think a good profit margin would be?

As a PP said, the profits we're seeing from
Centrica and Shell and the like are from their upstream businesses, not their retail arms. With market prices going through the roof thanks to Russia but the costs of extraction not changing they're doing extremely well. But like all companies they're structured so that their retail business is a separate entity. If it was structured so that their wholesale business profits had to be used to subsidise their retail business, they'd simply shut down their retail business. It doesn't make nearly as much for them.

Windfall taxes makes a lot of sense here because it looks at those totally unearned profits that are down to luck and takes them to spread across the whole sector so that customers of standalone retail energy companies aren't disadvantaged.

CapMarvel · 28/07/2022 16:43

hoping2021 · 28/07/2022 16:25

I wish more people would back this campaign. There needs to be tighter regulation on profit margins in these industries that supply essential services.
If we all refused to pay, they would be FORCED to reduce their profit margin, rather than hurting the consumer.

Refusing to pay a utility bill is fucking stupid, and if you think that the companies that supply you with electricity are raking it in you are wrong. Why do you think so many of them have gone under recently?

AlohaMolly · 28/07/2022 16:43

i realise this isn’t quite the point, but I didn’t think they were allowed to cut certain groups of people off for non payment? The elderly, for example, and families with children - I read they weren’t allowed to cut people off between October and March.

im not saying you shouldn’t pay your bill, I just mean non payment doesn’t equal no fuel, for certain people.

xogossipgirlxo · 28/07/2022 16:36

It's my last winter in the UK, so I won't be going into debt by not paying gas bills, but it baffles me how people believe every word politicians say. UK doesn't depend that much on Russian gas to put prices up that high. But you have to read something else than BBC to understand it.

MarshaBradyo · 28/07/2022 16:36

Port1aCastis · 28/07/2022 16:29

Protest as much as you like but they'll still cut your supply if you don't pay anything so then you'll be in the cold and the dark

Agree it’ll be to the detriment of people not paying

Port1aCastis · 28/07/2022 16:29

Protest as much as you like but they'll still cut your supply if you don't pay anything so then you'll be in the cold and the dark

Bubblebubblebah · 28/07/2022 16:28

Sunnysideup · 28/07/2022 16:10

Also op beware rhe keyboard warriors encouraging others to do this whilst they secretly pay as they know full well the pain if they don’t. Don’t fall for it.

Yup. Half of people are sharing it on facebook like they would that post about lost dog in Alabama in 2010.... Not thinking.

Other part of people just wants to fuck with people by getting them in trouble