Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dislike the way unions push for big payrises only at the bottom?

142 replies

WillitFit · 28/07/2022 11:50

I work in school. The lowest paid teachers are to get c.9% and everyone else 5% (if they accept it).

Support staff have been offered a fixed sum, just under £2000 on all points. Which is more than 10% for some, about 3% for me!

Everyone works hard and everyone deserves payrises that keep pace with inflation, surely? The more senior people have worked hard to get to where they are, often over many years, why is it OK to see their pay eroded?

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 15:36

And that's because prices in London are way more expensive than the rest of the country. What's your point?

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:35

Top of the teacher pay scale is £41,604

In London it's 50k for UPS3 & most will have a TLR with that so at least another 2k.

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 15:32

There seems to be, on this thread, people putting forward the argument that because people nearer the top of the pay scale can afford to eat, they deserve a pay cut.

Why would anyone deserve a pay cut?

nojudgementhere · 28/07/2022 15:31

It's a bit of a shame to see Teachers complaining about TAs getting a better payrise as unfortunately we'll still be earning a pittance that's it's impossible to live on unless you've got some kind of additional income in place! I work as a TA and the job has definitely got a lot more intense over the last few years. I'm now regularly left alone in charge of classes and working 1-1 we're often the first to get kicked or punched if a child gets overwhelmed. When our Teachers last went on strike I took a day off unpaid to support them. I was prepared to do that again this time even when it looked like TAs weren't going to get a payrise at all, as I appreciate how hard they work. With the money for payrises coming out of school budgets I would imagine that a fair few TAs will lose their jobs anyway. We're usually the first to be culled in times of cutbacks, so I wouldn't get too het up about any perceived special treatment you think we're receiving!

Itisasecret · 28/07/2022 15:23

Sartre · 28/07/2022 15:06

But people in higher bands are already earning lots more then they’re still getting a pay rise so earning even more. The people in lower bands start off earning much less so even after a pay rise they’ll still be on much less money. I don’t really get your point tbh. Also TA’s have never earned enough. They didn’t go to uni so are somehow deemed inferior to teachers when they often do the same amount of work, certainly in primary schools.

They really don’t (I’ve been both).

Tas are extremely valuable but their workload, accountability and legal responsibilities are not the same.

KateRusby · 28/07/2022 15:19

Sartre · 28/07/2022 15:06

But people in higher bands are already earning lots more then they’re still getting a pay rise so earning even more. The people in lower bands start off earning much less so even after a pay rise they’ll still be on much less money. I don’t really get your point tbh. Also TA’s have never earned enough. They didn’t go to uni so are somehow deemed inferior to teachers when they often do the same amount of work, certainly in primary schools.

A TA does nothing like the same amount of work as a teacher. I'm honestly gob-smacked anyone could think they do.

Namenic · 28/07/2022 15:18

I think with cost of living people at the bottom end are disproportionally affected, so it is reasonable to give a higher pay rise.
but - they might want to consider retention premiums for shortage jobs (as some may be attracted away by alternatives)

Itisasecret · 28/07/2022 15:14

Yabu. Student teachers come out of uni about 80k in debt and not even earning enough to begin repayments. They need the money more.

Merryoldgoat · 28/07/2022 15:11

If £2k represents 3% of your salary then you earn something like £65k?

I know that the crisis affects everyone but it’s disingenuous to pretend that someone on your salary isn’t better able to cope with the situation that someone on £20k.

DH and I are not ‘high’ earners but above average and whilst we feel the increases we can absorb it. I’d rather know my colleagues on less are less likely to be cold.

Sartre · 28/07/2022 15:06

But people in higher bands are already earning lots more then they’re still getting a pay rise so earning even more. The people in lower bands start off earning much less so even after a pay rise they’ll still be on much less money. I don’t really get your point tbh. Also TA’s have never earned enough. They didn’t go to uni so are somehow deemed inferior to teachers when they often do the same amount of work, certainly in primary schools.

Newrumpus · 28/07/2022 14:51

The bigger issue is that, yet again, these pay rises are unfunded. So, for the privilege of taking a real terms cut in pay yet again, I have to deprive my pupils of a portion of their paltry funding.

jcyclops · 28/07/2022 14:19

KarrotKake · 28/07/2022 12:04

The other way to look at it, is percentage payrises are bad for the lower paid, and they get screwed more every time.

Take a hypothetical TA on 10k, and a teacher on 30k.
Both get a 5% pay rise. TA now on 10,500. Teacher on 31,500.

If the pay rises kept increasing the TA pay by 500 a year, and the teacher by 1500, after 10 years the TA is on 15k, and the teacher on 45k.

The gap between teaching and support staff has widened massively over the years, and a step increase for the lowest paid is required to narrow the gap again.

Go back a few decades when your hypothetical teacher was on £6k and the TA (on a third of that) was on £2k, and maybe the head teacher was on £7k. If they had received the same monetary increase in pay, then today the teacher would be on £30k, the TA on £26k and the head on £31k. Would a teacher want promotion to head the school for just £20/week more?

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 28/07/2022 14:18

You would love where I work then, the higher grades get higher % pay rise than lower grades for the same performance rating.

So someone awarded an 'Excellent' rating at Grade 1 would get say, 5% (In the past not now!) on a salary of £25K they would get an additional £1.25K. Someone at Grade 5 awarded the same Excellent rating gets an increase of 10% but their salary was already £60K so they get an additional £6K even though 5% would have been a higher amount for them anyway. Everyone thinks its wildly unfair.

rongon · 28/07/2022 13:50

It's the government that are pushing this 'tiered' pay rise system so the press can report 10% pay rise for school staff, when the truth is a pretty large real terms cut for the majority of staff.
You are right to dislike the strategy, but direct your anger towards the government.

GuesstheEnd · 28/07/2022 13:49

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 13:35

Top of the teacher pay scale is £41,604

General expectation is 12 years of teaching to reach that. Then that's it for the rest of your teaching career unless you take on management responsibilities.

Yes, I think you could argue that in most areas c. £26k (and £30k proposed) for a 22/23 yo graduate, straight out of college is a decent salary. £41k for a career professional, not so much.

KateRusby · 28/07/2022 13:42

I can see both sides and understand the argument that lower paid workers are more affected by price rises. Upper pay scale teachers have seen a 25% cut in real term to their pay since 2010 (I think it was), much more than main scale teachers. It means the career progression is not what they thought it would be when they entered the profession. If they were earning big bucks that'd be more understandable, but we're not talking higher rate tax payers here. I don't begrudge TAs any pay rise they're offered as it's a scandal that they earn so little (and near enough impossible to recruit to our beautiful village school full of well behaved children where I am) but I'm not sure I agree with higher percentages being applied lower down the teaching scale.

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 13:35

Top of the teacher pay scale is £41,604

General expectation is 12 years of teaching to reach that. Then that's it for the rest of your teaching career unless you take on management responsibilities.

GuesstheEnd · 28/07/2022 13:30

In these school jobs nobody is a "high earner" Maybe just a few of the leadership scale teachers, but none of the support staff trouble the higher rate tax band, for example.

GuesstheEnd · 28/07/2022 13:29

Ducksinthebath · 28/07/2022 13:12

Those on lower salaries are less able to absorb what life throws at them. It’s not a race to the bottom.

Surely if the higher pay bands don't keep up with inflation, it is a race to the bottom?

AprilRae91 · 28/07/2022 13:22

Yes where I work those earning over 30k are a getting a 3% pay rise (so real term cut) and those on lowest bands doing the jobs that don’t demand any qualifications are getting 9%.

I think it’s unfair as middle earners are so much worse off considering how much outgoings have increased, and that the NI increase meant we all got less take home than 2 years ago.

Ducksinthebath · 28/07/2022 13:12

Those on lower salaries are less able to absorb what life throws at them. It’s not a race to the bottom.

TitInATrance · 28/07/2022 13:09

I support the giving of higher rises to the lowest paid, who are likely to have least discretionary spending. Particularly where all of the payrise is over inflation rate.

But … in Kate’s example the gap between 10k and 15k moving to 30k and 45k does not mean that the gap (pay differential) has widened. Teacher still gets exactly half as much again as the TA, it’s just increased by inflation.

overitall1 · 28/07/2022 13:01

Sapphire387 · 28/07/2022 11:54

Payrises for the lower bands are more likely to be prioritised because these people are more likely to struggle to cover their basic outgoings. I'm a TU official.

It's not that other people's pay doesn't matter. It's that payrises tend to come out of a pot. And actually, if you keep on with the same percentage increases for all grades, then someone in a higher grade gets a bigger payrise than someone in a lower grade.

This.

% pay increases should be banned. In our Gov Dept the top bands get stupid amounts of money and us at the bottom get fuck all. Because 1% of fuck all is still fuck all. 1% of £80k is a months salary for me.

GuesstheEnd · 28/07/2022 12:59

Pinklady245612 · 28/07/2022 12:48

Tbh I'm slightly worried that you are obviously in a high position in a school, yet can't work this out.

Your 3% (heaven forbid) could be just as much if not higher in value than someone on a lower wage getting 10% rise. Will you really deprive your low paid colleagues a decent rise so they can afford their bills, over your need to expand your savings pot? How entitled 🙄

It's not about not understanding. Nobody wants to deprive low paid people of anything, but when inflation is 11% why is 3% OK for anyone?

comealongponds · 28/07/2022 12:54

YABU

people on lower salaries are more affected by cost of living rises as they spend more of their income (percentage wise) on essentials like housing, energy, food and fuel, and to have less financial wiggle room to cover increases.

someone on a high income is far more likely to be able to cover increased energy bills just by cutting back on luxuries or putting aside less in savings. Someone on a low income is far more likely to have to choose between heating and eating.

also, particularly for public sectors, I suspect it’s more palatable politically when increases are focused on low paid staff rather than highly paid ones.

Swipe left for the next trending thread