Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dislike the way unions push for big payrises only at the bottom?

142 replies

WillitFit · 28/07/2022 11:50

I work in school. The lowest paid teachers are to get c.9% and everyone else 5% (if they accept it).

Support staff have been offered a fixed sum, just under £2000 on all points. Which is more than 10% for some, about 3% for me!

Everyone works hard and everyone deserves payrises that keep pace with inflation, surely? The more senior people have worked hard to get to where they are, often over many years, why is it OK to see their pay eroded?

OP posts:
Lopar · 28/07/2022 16:19

No, TLRs aren't only for HoD. That was an example, but in my school of 1300, core subjects of Maths, Science and English definitely have big departments, none of whom but the HoD would receive the additionally £2k you seem to think.

You'd get one for Head of Year too, but then for each of those (5 in an 11-16 school), there are ten normal form tutors for that year group receiving nothing extra. It's not most teaching staff.

hoping2021 · 28/07/2022 16:16

Surely you’re argument should be that all public sectors need a pay rise in line with inflation??? And that teachers should be paid more, not rail workers less???

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 16:16

Why is only one pay scale relevant?

Well most people don't live in London, so quoting London wages and then giving them a little TLR boost for some reason makes me wonder why you are doing that.

People generally accept that people in London earn more.

durellh · 28/07/2022 16:14

@noblegiraffe both of our experiences are relevant surely?

durellh · 28/07/2022 16:12

It appeared that you were trying to make out that teachers at the top of the pay scale were earning at least £10k more than the top of the pay scale figure. Why?

No, there are different payscales for the London fringe, outer London & inner London. Plus inner London has quite a wide scope. Why is only one pay scale relevant? There are thousands of schools & teachers working in London & outside since fringe can be home counties.

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 16:10

My maths dept has 13 teachers. I'm at the top of the pay scale, not in London and don't have a TLR.

durellh · 28/07/2022 16:04

I can only talk about my experience of working in London schools. I've never worked in a school with 12 teachers in one dept all on max grade. I don't think I've worked anywhere with 12 teachers in one dept regardless of grade. You don't only get tlrs for head of dept

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 16:01

durel I posted the pay for a teacher at the top of the pay scale in the vast majority of the country. You then posted the much higher London figure (due to much higher prices in London) and said that 'most' were also on a £2k TLR.

It appeared that you were trying to make out that teachers at the top of the pay scale were earning at least £10k more than the top of the pay scale figure. Why?

Lopar · 28/07/2022 15:53

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:35

Top of the teacher pay scale is £41,604

In London it's 50k for UPS3 & most will have a TLR with that so at least another 2k.

How will 'most' have a TLR? That's an additional responsibility, so for example one Head of Maths for about 12 Maths teachers in their department.

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:51

why bother taking on that workload and responsibility, if you can be a TA and get just a bit less.

I know teachers who left teaching & took TA roles but it's a significant salary drop.

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 15:50

You’re still doing the same job: you can’t expect increases forever for that.

12 years. That's when you stop going up the pay grades. Teacher experience is incredibly valuable, but not particularly well rewarded.

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:49

@noblegiraffe so what's your point?

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 15:48

The idea is broadly to create a situation in which nobody is working flat out and still on the breadline, so of course those on criminally low pay - which is many, many workers - are a priority.

In the case of teacher pay rises, this isn't the idea at all.

It was in the Conservative manifesto of 2019 to increase newly qualified teacher pay to £30k. This latest pay rise of 8.9% for new teachers is not to keep new teacher pay in line with inflation, it is to raise it to £28k which is not keeping their manifesto promise, but the intention is to meet that next year.

The £30k figure for new teachers was arrived at as an amount needed to address the critical recruitment crisis for new teachers, and to give the government a hope of meeting recruitment targets.

Obviously now this raise will be swallowed up by inflation. If the government want to meet their manifesto promise of 2019 and give an inflationary pay rise to new teachers, they should be aiming to pay new teachers £33k.

missbunnyrabbit · 28/07/2022 15:48

There has got be a decent different between jobs like TAs and teachers, because otherwise why bother training to be a teacher, why bother getting student debt, why bother taking on that workload and responsibility, if you can be a TA and get just a bit less.

LeFeu · 28/07/2022 15:46

Unions aren’t pushing for this. In my sector it’s been offered to keep pay at the lower end legal! Unions are balloting to strike to fight for higher pay rises for everyone…

nojudgementhere · 28/07/2022 15:46

Great post @Greensleeves. I completely agree!

missbunnyrabbit · 28/07/2022 15:45

Sartre · 28/07/2022 15:06

But people in higher bands are already earning lots more then they’re still getting a pay rise so earning even more. The people in lower bands start off earning much less so even after a pay rise they’ll still be on much less money. I don’t really get your point tbh. Also TA’s have never earned enough. They didn’t go to uni so are somehow deemed inferior to teachers when they often do the same amount of work, certainly in primary schools.

TAs do the same amount of work as teachers? Either you're completely stupid or this is a wind up!

ParsleySageRosemary · 28/07/2022 15:45

For schools specifically you have to factor in the fact that TAs are now doing much more demanding jobs than they were, for no extra wages. Many TAs are now effectively being junior teachers, but paid well below the teacher wage scale. Regarding the main teacher pay scale, I have no idea why it is so large in comparison to every other sector anyway. Other sectors’ job roles usually cover a 5k or 10k range, not nearly 20. You’re still doing the same job: you can’t expect increases forever for that.

Nationally percentage increases have been one of the factors increasing income inequality, in that annual 5% increases on 50k are double that on 20k, so corrections are needed.

The increases I find annoying is those that have resulted in low skill jobs such as retail or cleaning now being paid the same or higher than jobs requiring education.

Namenic · 28/07/2022 15:43

It’s not that anyone deserves a pay cut, but in many industries pay rises are not in line with inflation at this time. If companies can help it, it would be better to prioritise the lower paid workers to help them meet more basic needs. Of course there are market forces at play as well, so companies will probably pay a premium for in-demand roles.

Greensleeves · 28/07/2022 15:43

WillitFit · 28/07/2022 11:50

I work in school. The lowest paid teachers are to get c.9% and everyone else 5% (if they accept it).

Support staff have been offered a fixed sum, just under £2000 on all points. Which is more than 10% for some, about 3% for me!

Everyone works hard and everyone deserves payrises that keep pace with inflation, surely? The more senior people have worked hard to get to where they are, often over many years, why is it OK to see their pay eroded?

The idea is broadly to create a situation in which nobody is working flat out and still on the breadline, so of course those on criminally low pay - which is many, many workers - are a priority.

I really dislike this line that's so often trotted out that "senior people have worked hard to get where they are". It misses the point, perhaps wilfully - many of those on the lowest pay are also working hard. There have always been people working incredibly hard, often in the most back-breaking and unrewarding jobs, who don't have the opportunity to rise through the system and access better pay and a higher standard of living. If you're a middle manager or a teacher or whatever, don't assume you've worked harder than those 'under' you, those who empty your bins and care for your sick and elderly relatives. It's bollocks, and it's an assumption that underpins and justifies inequality and chronic poverty.

KarrotKake · 28/07/2022 15:42

jcyclops · 28/07/2022 14:19

Go back a few decades when your hypothetical teacher was on £6k and the TA (on a third of that) was on £2k, and maybe the head teacher was on £7k. If they had received the same monetary increase in pay, then today the teacher would be on £30k, the TA on £26k and the head on £31k. Would a teacher want promotion to head the school for just £20/week more?

Except, go back few decades, and the (hypothetical) numbers were teacher 6k, TA 3.5k.

Over the years the teachers have, rightly, been identified as a group who are underpaid for their skills. Support staff salaries have not been increased to the same extent - and usually teaching and support staff are on different pay rise amounts, it's not a "school" payrise percent.
This one off flat amount is a way to help start correcting this.
Teachers pay scale increases have been out for a while. The numbers here are not news to them. It is the support scale payrises which have caused the "waaa, not fair" response.

noblegiraffe · 28/07/2022 15:40

It was my post you were replying to.

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:39

@noblegiraffe my point was clear as I was replying to a post. apologies if it confused you.

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:38

plus uni costs

durellh · 28/07/2022 15:38

I think it's fair to give lower bands more personally, as they tend to be younger & young people obviously have it tough when it comes to housing. It's difficult as we need to retain experienced staff too