Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wibu to charge DSS rent to live here whilst he is studying?

114 replies

loubielou31 · 28/07/2022 09:08

I know this should probably be in parenting but aibu gets more traffic. DSC has asked to live with us whilst doing their final year at uni, when little they lived with their mum but has gone to a uni fairly near us and next year it just works to live here. Obviously we have said yes, and DDs are really excited to have their big sibling here for a longer time, that might wear thin when they have to share the bathroom.
Anyway my aibu is, should we charge rent? Which I sort of think we should as a principle but how much is fair? They had to pay rent for shared houses/hall of residence in the other years. Do we just ask for a contribution to the food bill which will massively increase with another fully grown adult in the house. I don't think it will impact our energy bills having one extra person, the heat and light is the same (and I think all of us will be on timed showers come the winter to try and keep costs down)
If they were working and earning it's a straight yes, you pay rent, but adults who are studying I am not sure what is fair.

What have others done in this situation? Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onetoffeetin · 31/07/2022 18:17

I'd charge a small amount and then give them it back at the end as a surprise. Would obviously let other parent know.

SueSaid · 28/07/2022 13:37

'He can use his money to save for something useful, or maybe have a bit of fun.'

Exactly. It costs so much to support dc living out at uni you'd think most parents would be pleased fo have the much cheaper at home set up.

DarkShade · 28/07/2022 13:33

I really really really would not charge him anything. This is your chance to truly support him, if you can afford it. He is young and just starting out. He can use his money to save for something useful, or maybe have a bit of fun.

SueSaid · 28/07/2022 13:32

No. Rather you'll just stop the money you will have been giving him monthly the last 2 years towards living expenses. Then use that money towards extra food costs.

PhotoDad · 28/07/2022 13:29

Plenty of Mumsnet threads would indicate otherwise, @ArcticSkewer !

feistymumma · 28/07/2022 13:26

If you would charge your own flesh and blood under the same conditions then yes. I didn't charge my DS when he was going to Uni therefore would not charge my DSS either.

ArcticSkewer · 28/07/2022 13:00

chesirecat99 · 28/07/2022 12:53

OP hasn't answered that question, @ArcticSkewer, so I'm guessing not. The DSS lived with his DM growing up so student finance would have been based on her household income when he first applied. TBF, her DH might still have been contributing by paying child maintenance until he leaves education or giving his DS money informally and might not have been involved in the SFE application so don't know how it works, maybe his DS received the full loan because his DM's income is less than £25k.

Eurgh. Would anyone do that? Not pay for two years and then go a step further and actually charge for the final year? I can't imagine it. Surely everyone knows the student loan needs topping up by parents?!

chesirecat99 · 28/07/2022 12:53

OP hasn't answered that question, @ArcticSkewer, so I'm guessing not. The DSS lived with his DM growing up so student finance would have been based on her household income when he first applied. TBF, her DH might still have been contributing by paying child maintenance until he leaves education or giving his DS money informally and might not have been involved in the SFE application so don't know how it works, maybe his DS received the full loan because his DM's income is less than £25k.

Nothappyatwork · 28/07/2022 12:51

Ffs 🤦‍♀️
You get one chance to offer meaningful support in most cases to your children. This is it.

mrsfoof · 28/07/2022 12:44

No. They're DH's child. Presumably you wouldn't charge his other children (your children) if they choose to live at home when studying in the future.

I would, however expect DH to reduce his contribution to their living costs (hopefully he's helped them out so far?) on account of the fact that they'll be living at home and have less outgoings. Depending on how much DH was contributing in previous years and how much of that he will now withhold, possibly I'd consider asking DSC to make a small contribution to the household budget for food etc.

I would also expect them to live like part of the household and not as a guest. So to do their fair share of chores, babysit their siblings occasionally (if applicable depending on their age) and to not come and go at antisocial hours without prior agreement.

PhotoDad · 28/07/2022 12:43

chesirecat99 · 28/07/2022 12:27

His maintenance loan will be reduced by £1500 if he lives with one of his parents, unless you are in London, when it is reduced by £4500! So you need to take that into account.

Also, do you realise that if your DSS lives with you, you and his DF are responsible for topping up his maintenance loan, @loubielou31?

The maintenance loan is means tested. When parents are divorced, it is based on the household income of the parent that the student usually lives with. If he is living with you, it will be based on your household income (not just his DF's income, your income is included). If your joint household income is over £25k, you will be expected to top up his maintenance loan. The amount you are expected to contribute increases with income, up to £4574 per year (for a student living at home) for households with a joint income of more than £60k.

Yes, he should definitely notify Student Finance of the change of circumstances, and the means-testing will switch to your household income rather than his other parent's. That could have big implications for him and for you.

KatherineJaneway · 28/07/2022 12:42

I think that a contribution to food would be good to ask. However more importantly you need ground rules for behaviour. Laundry, cleaning their room, getting home late, overnight guests, cleaning up after themselves when cooking, using the bathroom, noise levels early and late etc.

ArcticSkewer · 28/07/2022 12:38

Presumably they've been topping up already though, the last 2 years?

Nanny67 · 28/07/2022 12:38

omg no!!!

loubielou31 · 28/07/2022 12:36

That's very useful thank you.

OP posts:
CornishGem1975 · 28/07/2022 12:34

If he has no income? Then definitely not, but also if they're studying pretty much full time I'd be happy to support that.

chesirecat99 · 28/07/2022 12:27

His maintenance loan will be reduced by £1500 if he lives with one of his parents, unless you are in London, when it is reduced by £4500! So you need to take that into account.

Also, do you realise that if your DSS lives with you, you and his DF are responsible for topping up his maintenance loan, @loubielou31?

The maintenance loan is means tested. When parents are divorced, it is based on the household income of the parent that the student usually lives with. If he is living with you, it will be based on your household income (not just his DF's income, your income is included). If your joint household income is over £25k, you will be expected to top up his maintenance loan. The amount you are expected to contribute increases with income, up to £4574 per year (for a student living at home) for households with a joint income of more than £60k.

LittleOwl153 · 28/07/2022 11:43

He will get some form of maintenance loan. I assume that will be the reduced level as he is 'stay at home' I'd look at the difference between last year's Live out loan, and this year's stay at home and any additional parental contributions and see what the balance is.

I would charge him something as he will still be getting a loan I assume so needs to be realistic about it costing to live. But it might be that difference in loans means that he looses quite a bit. I would be clear that he should not expect additional support from your household in terms of cash/paying for stuff(phone,bus,student events etc) if you are accommodating him though.

rumplestiltskinp · 28/07/2022 11:36

I wouldn't. I would ask that they buy their own food though, but I would still include them in family meals they were there for.

Highfivemum · 28/07/2022 11:33

No. If they are full time students and no income how could they pay ? They may have applied for a maintenance loan but if they state living with family they will not get the full Wack. I wouldn’t. Family is family.

AchatAVendre · 28/07/2022 11:33

Poor kid. He's probably only doing this because he can't make ends meet. I'm sure he would much rather continue living with friends in a flat or something.

My father tried to do this with me, except he wanted to charge me for living at home during the university holidays, even though I had to pay for university accommodation over easter and Christmas. The result was that I never went home again. I organised my life so that I had a variety of live in jobs each Easter, Christmas and summer. Fortunately, I had a particular skill that made finding live in jobs easily.

My father died a few years later, and I can't even recall the last time I saw him before his death. He wasn't interested or supportive. Please whatever you do, try to make your DSS feel supported, and welcome.

ninjafoodienovice · 28/07/2022 11:17

What about takeaways? My DSS wanted to order in - but just for himself. When he'd already been fed a proper meal plus snacks available. I'm afraid we said no way but definitely ask this question too. Mainly because it's a total waste of money as he'd already been catered for but that's my issue. I just couldn't see one person ordering a food delivery for a family home just for themselves. DSS is 18 by the way and lives with us and I love him like my own but my god is he lazy. Make a fricking sandwich if you are hungry 🤦🏻‍♀️.

I absolutely wouldn't charge rent though in your position- definitely a food contribution though. Enjoy this year though. It's lovely he wants to live with you.

Missebottom · 28/07/2022 11:14

If they are at uni ( on a first degree) then they are classed as dependants i think.
? If at home am.unsure if they wd get loan for accom costs.?at be worth checking?
Otherwise, id assume they are classed as a dependant and just ask for them to get their own food as a usual student would .( if affordable )

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/07/2022 11:13

A nominal amount for food is fine. If they are also working, perhaps more.

Hankunamatata · 28/07/2022 11:13

I wouldn't charge but I would say you expect him to certain chores like hoovering once a week for example.