Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help in thinking through the admin of becoming a SAHM

140 replies

BuffaloCauliflower · 27/07/2022 21:24

I know MN always has plenty of thoughts on protecting yourself as a SAHM so thought I’d ask for some help to make sure I’m not missing anything.

Currently have a toddler, and pregnant with no.2. I currently work part time but for various reasons (mainly because I want to) I’m thinking of staying home after this next maternity leave and not going back.

Some things I think we need to do/points I know I’ll be asked about

  • Don’t currently claim child benefit as DH earns too much, but will now and just not get the payment for the NI credits.
  • Pay into a private pension. I’ve got an old workplace pension not doing much, I think I’ll move it somewhere I can access and we can top that up
  • We already have one joint account for all money, and I manage that money and our savings, so no concerns about accessing money as I need
  • Yes we are married
  • Hoping to buy a house next year, we’re in a stupidly expensive bit of the country and have been waiting for some now forthcoming parental deposit help. We can buy what we want on just DH salary for affordability
  • We can pay everything we need to comfortably on DH wage, my wage is currently just for childcare and savings
  • DH very supportive of whatever I want, but does have a preference towards me staying home as he can see how much I’m not enjoying trying to balance all the things and not being the mum I want to be (he equally parents and does more housework than me so it’s not for lack of support that I’m wanting to stop working)
Anything else I might not have considered?
OP posts:
User952539 · 28/07/2022 08:46

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:44

Personally I think the higher the earnings the higher the stress of carrying that alone as it has more of a lifestyle impact.

Agreed

MrsBwced · 28/07/2022 08:45

@BuffaloCauliflower
Great, I suggest you have equal amounts in sole names as well as your general savings in joint names. The majority of our investments and assets are in my name as well. Complete transparency is essential. Do you have a financial advisor?

It's really important to keep the conversations going about your situation too. Particularly as your planning on this long term. We didn't but it's ended up that way and we've had relevant points to discuss it for example, when things have changed with my husband job.

Also think about even longer term. I don't know how old you are but once the children finish education what will you do? What are your husbands career goals? Will they fit in with what you want to do? When does he plan on retiring?

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:44

Personally I think the higher the earnings the higher the stress of carrying that alone as it has more of a lifestyle impact.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:43

@MercuryOnTheRise you seem to think home education involves no interaction with peers or people outside the home, this is a common misconception but is very much not the case

OP posts:
dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:41

Both workers earn good 6 figures

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:41

I think it depends I know 2 couples having marriage issues over working patterns. 1 the mum earns & the dad stays at home, he's feeling emasculated & insecure. The other the dad earns & the mum is at home, & they have help with childcare. He wants to reduce his hours & have more time at home but the change in lifestyle is not want the wife wants. Both of these relationships worked well for a number of years so I think it's also mid life crisis issues etc.

User952539 · 28/07/2022 08:36

Louise0701 · 28/07/2022 08:34

@User952539 @MolliciousIntent I think your situations are different as “can support us” is different to “can give us a good lifestyle”

In your situations where 1 income is tight so causes stress; it wouldn’t be advisable to live off of 1 income. There are wealthy families where this isn’t an issue because 1 income is large enough that there is no stress or being kept up at night worrying. The family can have a very good lifestyle with no worries. In your cases, it seems the income pays the bills and not much else therefore potentially causing resentment and stress. Unless 1 is a very high earner, I agree the resentment and stress will occur.

Well no since DH earns £275k

Louise0701 · 28/07/2022 08:34

@User952539 @MolliciousIntent I think your situations are different as “can support us” is different to “can give us a good lifestyle”

In your situations where 1 income is tight so causes stress; it wouldn’t be advisable to live off of 1 income. There are wealthy families where this isn’t an issue because 1 income is large enough that there is no stress or being kept up at night worrying. The family can have a very good lifestyle with no worries. In your cases, it seems the income pays the bills and not much else therefore potentially causing resentment and stress. Unless 1 is a very high earner, I agree the resentment and stress will occur.

Discovereads · 28/07/2022 08:31

User952539 · 28/07/2022 08:23

It most certainly isn’t nonsense. Dh and I both earn good money but I’ve been Ill for six months and not really earning. DHs income alone can support us but even so, the stress of knowing everything is on his shoulders financially is considerable and keeps him awake at night.

I think the “resentment” bit is nonsensical though. I’ve been sole earner in the family but that was as a result of our agreeing to it so DH could go to Uni and get a second degree. So he was a SAHD plus Uni student for several years. It was stressful being only income and I was a bit jealous of all the time he got with the DC. But I didn’t resent him because the whole point of it was for the DC to have that extra parental support while primary age and also to improve my DHs future earnings for when they would be expensive teens and Uni students.

The only time I had resentment from being sole earner was when DH was constructively dismissed for being a whistleblower and was then on JSA for 11 months during Covid. No one was hiring during the worst of covid except key workers which he couldn’t do as one of our DC is CEV. I admit while knowing he did the right thing whistleblowing I had wished he’d found a new job before blowing the whistle. Because his former employer was absolutely horrible to him until he resigned. ACAS said he had a case but we couldn’t afford the £1k to go to tribunal plus the £10k quoted to us by an employment solicitor “just to start things off”.

KILM · 28/07/2022 08:28
  • Homeschooling:
Have you got any prior experience in teaching/coaching children and if not could you somehow find a way to get some exposure before you commit to homeschooling? Appreciate that your mums a teacher so you'd likely have support/guidance but it might be a good idea to do it yourself solo first to identify areas you might struggle with (attention management, behaviour managememt etc) so you can spend time looking into those before you start.
  • Its great that you are not going for a maxed out mortgage but you mention its still based on your DHs earnings. One of the biggest problems that faces divorcing SAHMs is that they can no longer afford the family home because their income isnt enough to get a mortgage, or their income isnt enough to stay in their area by the kids schools, or their income isnt enough to rent/mortgage solo at all. So i guess if i were you i'd think that through a little bit - worst case scenario, what would your earnings be if you had to go back to work suddenly, would a bank take you on for a mortgage with those earnings, etc, what impact would it have on the kids to jump from homeschool to mainstream.
  • There are some fantastic homeschool communities out there but what my friend found when she ended up homeschooling her 12 year old is that the people in her local community who were homeschooling neurotypical children were people who had very different ideas to her - behaviour/time management largely non existent which had a resulting impact on learning, lots of anti-vax and conspiracy theorists, lots of 'do not conform/fuck the establishment' messaging as opposed to 'you can live life differently' and while its lovely to think they might learn a new off grid life, the reality is most of them will need to work to pay rent and bills and this attitude was resulting in active hostility towards any authority figures.
To be absolutely clear for anyone reading this whose about to jump on me: I am not saying this is all homeschoolers in the slightest, and im not looking for a debate on any of the topics above, this was ONE community in a relatively rural area - my point is, get a proper feel of what that community looks like and if that matches up with your values and goals. If not, whats the plan.
  • What is your plan post- homeschool?
HikingforScenery · 28/07/2022 08:27

CharlotteOH · 27/07/2022 22:29

Nonsense and unhelpful.

Not nonsense at all. Worth thinking about.

Incywincyspi · 28/07/2022 08:25

I think making decisions when you have tiny ones gives you a rosy glow to your vision. I understand that desire to stay at home and to create a role for yourself which enables you to stay with your children. However as they grow older there’s a possibility that your feelings may change. It might not be until ages 7,10 or teen years but the relationship dynamics change as your kids start to push away naturally from their parents. It can create horrendous tensions for some and being everything to your kids is a risk. If you have a huge row with a teen and then attempt to prepare them for a forthcoming exam… I can’t even imagine. I know you have a sociology background but the path isn’t linear here in terms of how this will go. It could be great for one of your kids but awful for another. I think as long as you are flexible it is better and you can respond to any changes that might be required. Just watch out for your employability in case of any split with your DH. May sound ludicrous but it can happen to the most idyllic seeming couples. It has happened to a significant proportion of friends and family and those who are SAHM are now retraining in their 40s/50s to ensure they can support themselves as the kids will no longer get maintenance payments due to age and leaving home.

User952539 · 28/07/2022 08:23

CharlotteOH · 27/07/2022 22:29

Nonsense and unhelpful.

It most certainly isn’t nonsense. Dh and I both earn good money but I’ve been Ill for six months and not really earning. DHs income alone can support us but even so, the stress of knowing everything is on his shoulders financially is considerable and keeps him awake at night.

MercuryOnTheRise · 28/07/2022 08:21

How will your children learn a good work ethic and how to socialise amongst the rough and tumble of school. They need examples from their parents and to learn how to deal with contemporaries outside the home to prepare them for adulthood.

I think it would be better for you to go to work, build your career and fund an independent education for them if you think state schools are broken.

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:18

I think home education can work very well. Not for me though! mine are at summer camps the next 7 days so I can have some peace and quiet at home 😆

FourChimneys · 28/07/2022 08:16

I know a family who home educated their three children. The father has a very high level job so finances were not a problem. The mum did a lot of the teaching but they were part of a home ed community so socialised a lot and did a lot of learning with other parents.

As the children got to teens and could be a bit more independent the mum set up her own company in a field related to her former work. The DC were involved as part of their education, although the youngest chose to go to sixth form. They now employ two staff and had a turnover above half a million last year.

They are one of the most grounded and solid families I know.

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:14

To whoever said it but I can’t find now - no, PILs are not selling anything to help us out

I said this because I was confused why you are waiting. Interest rates will only get higher.

we have a good amount of savings plus a 5% deposit

have you contacted a broker, You will get a far better rate if you can put down at least 20% so better to use your savings to do that & then start saving again.

we can easily afford mortgage payments which will be similar to our current rent

that's the same for the vast majority the barrier is the deposit

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/07/2022 08:05

I wouldn’t do this, for the reasons @Pigsears has outlined. I think you are making yourself vulnerable and isolated. And I am not generally a fan of home educational outside of very specific circumstances.

That said, you do seem to have thought it through carefully and to the extent that anyone going into such a vulnerable situation can protect themselves you seem to have done so. Your DH sounds supportive which is a big consideration.

As others have said, I would keep an open mind and be prepared to be flexible if things don’t go to plan.

silentpool · 28/07/2022 08:03

I probably would maintain some kind of part time work schedule to keep your hand in. The worst case scenario can and does happen and it's hard to recover from quickly.

Make sure you contribute as much to your pension as you would if you are working. And Godspeed for the rest of it.😄

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:02

@Rainbowqueeen yes it does, we still want to borrow less than that

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:02

@Confusedteacher because I want to, I want to be at home being with them. DH works entirely from home and is here all the time so does a lot more than most dads anyway. Him going part time would massively reduce our financial security which doesn’t seem like a very logical move

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:00

@MrsBwced we have a good amount of savings plus a 5% deposit, PILs are helping us get it to 10%. We live in a stupidly expensive area, though we are moving to a slightly less expensive one.
@Whadda we are housing ourselves no problem, we can easily afford mortgage payments which will be similar to our current rent, and we can save on top of that. Our income has leapt up dramatically the last 3-4 years but covid furloughs and pay reductions reduced our saving for a period of time. We also focused on paying off debt from less responsible times in our 20s first.

To whoever said it but I can’t find now - no, PILs are not selling anything to help us out

OP posts:
pd339 · 28/07/2022 08:00

CharlotteOH · 27/07/2022 22:29

Nonsense and unhelpful.

People can feel this way so it isn't nonsense, and it's much less unhelpful than your comment

Rainbowqueeen · 28/07/2022 07:59

Does the amount you think you can borrow from the bank take into account child number 2??? If not, you might find that the amount they are willing to lend will reduce once you disclose that.

Pigsears · 28/07/2022 07:59

Meh

You are swapping work for being a teacher, not taking an income, and everything else stays the same.

You are relying on your partner to provide financially 100% and his family to provide the deposit on your house.

If anything happens to your partner (you fall out of love, he leaves you, you leave him, you get divorced, he dies...) you are pretty much screwed- as your lifestyle choice relies on him financially supporting you 100%. So that makes the power balance totally uneven. Except if he dies- then you have insurance- which hopefully will be enough to cover your desire to be a SAHM and full time home educator.

I wouldn't do it. Doesn't matter how much insurance you have- I would feel far too vulnerable.

Also- I agree with earlier poster re his resentment. As the only breadwinner for our family for years, it is incredibly stressful. You have to make decisions based on security of finance rather than follow your heart. It can be galling if you are forced into this and can see your partner doing exactly what they want you have to suck it up as even if they did rejoin the workforce, no way could they take over financially.

It might start out even (ish) but the gap widens every year.