Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help in thinking through the admin of becoming a SAHM

140 replies

BuffaloCauliflower · 27/07/2022 21:24

I know MN always has plenty of thoughts on protecting yourself as a SAHM so thought I’d ask for some help to make sure I’m not missing anything.

Currently have a toddler, and pregnant with no.2. I currently work part time but for various reasons (mainly because I want to) I’m thinking of staying home after this next maternity leave and not going back.

Some things I think we need to do/points I know I’ll be asked about

  • Don’t currently claim child benefit as DH earns too much, but will now and just not get the payment for the NI credits.
  • Pay into a private pension. I’ve got an old workplace pension not doing much, I think I’ll move it somewhere I can access and we can top that up
  • We already have one joint account for all money, and I manage that money and our savings, so no concerns about accessing money as I need
  • Yes we are married
  • Hoping to buy a house next year, we’re in a stupidly expensive bit of the country and have been waiting for some now forthcoming parental deposit help. We can buy what we want on just DH salary for affordability
  • We can pay everything we need to comfortably on DH wage, my wage is currently just for childcare and savings
  • DH very supportive of whatever I want, but does have a preference towards me staying home as he can see how much I’m not enjoying trying to balance all the things and not being the mum I want to be (he equally parents and does more housework than me so it’s not for lack of support that I’m wanting to stop working)
Anything else I might not have considered?
OP posts:
EternalPoinsettia · 28/07/2022 09:51

I think the concept that your pay pays for childcare needs reconsidering, half is paid by his half yours. Part of the benefit of keeping your hand in work is you can keep a career on back burner, you both paying for that is important to take into account. So dont discount your salary as just covering childcare and therefore not worth having, make sure you don't feel continuing some work is an investment in your future employability

Mardyface · 28/07/2022 09:50

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 07:51

@Mardyface I’m not sure where you’re getting ‘you think you don’t need to formalise it because your husband is a good guy’ from, I’m basing my opinion on the fact we’ve lived together for 9 years through multiple different changes of life where everything has been shared fairly in different ways at different times. Of course we’ll discuss how things would change with various house things, we already have. I don’t need to ’give’ him tasks, we decide together who’s doing what. On the laundry - I tend to put things in the machine and on, he tends to take them out, hang them and put them away.

You got defensive when I was genuinely trying to be helpful and with the benefit of experience of doing more or less exactly what you're talking about, also married to a good guy. The clue was in 'it's difficult for you BOTH to remember...'

I would explain more but I'm taking my bat home. You asked what you were forgetting and I told you what you were forgetting. You're welcome.

SweetSakura · 28/07/2022 09:48

It's not just life insurance, you also want to make sure he has decent critical illness cover. And private health insurance, because he can't afford to be to unwell to work.

And I would ensure you are near decent schools in case it doesn't work out. I have quite a few friends who were evangelical about homeschooling - but within a few years all their children were in normal schools.

Finally, what is your plan if he cheats on you or similar? Because everyone should have a back up plan. No one can be sure their partner won't. (A quick read of the relationship boards tells you this). Will it be easy to get back into your profession? Or should you keep up some training/voluntary experience so ut is easier to gwt a job if you need one

wellhelloitsme · 28/07/2022 09:42

What's the plan when the children are no longer school age?

I would think that re-entering your industry, whatever it is, after almost 20 years, would be incredibly tough.

The landscape will be entirely different after that length of time (or 5/10 years even) in any industry and there are things you can't simply pick up / learn looking from the outside in.

Therefore I think you need to do some freelance work every year (other than during maternity leave) to keep your finger on the pulse and maintain contacts.

Otherwise what happens if the kids turn 18 and your DH has a breakdown and stops work, is very ill so can't work, or you split up and he doesn't want to give you any more than he absolutely has to?

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 09:40

@SmileyClare no it’s not a choice for a small child to make, we are making the choice to home educate because I think it’s what’s best for them, but with an older child/teenager they would be involved in making decisions about their lives. I’ve said many times I’m open to things changing. But you’re also looking at this from the perspective of school being the default, and therefore somehow better. I don’t think a 14 year old who’s fallen out with their best friend would be open to learning much in a classroom either! And I don’t think schools have a monopoly on teaching socialisation and emotional maturity

OP posts:
catfunk · 28/07/2022 09:38

Have you factored home ed into your budget long term? Increased utility bills from being home all day, lots of various clubs which tends to be the norm and driving to them all so needing a second vehicle?
My friends home ed and it costs them a fortune.

SmileyClare · 28/07/2022 09:34

If my children want to go to school, that's absolutely their choice to make

This is all hypothetical as you have one toddler right now but how would the "choice " thing work?
Is it fair to allow big decisions like that to be made by children? What if they started school and then decided they didn't want to go because they'd fallen out with Tommy in year 2? Their choice?
What would their choice be based on? Would they have the emotional maturity and experience to navigate the social side of a school setting at age 10 for example.

What if your 14 year-old dd had an enormous row with you over her new boyfriend? Are you then able to sit down with her and teach algebra?

I personally think your home schooling / free parenting vision will look very different in reality.
In conclusion; I'd advise being more open minded instead of planning this one vision.

dostyh · 28/07/2022 09:21

@User952539 exactly role & industry make such a difference. A relative was a partner at a mc firm and was super stressed during the 08 crash. My dad was a banker & the 90s recession was a blood bath. Of course if you have family wealth to fall back on it's far less stressful but my dad was an immigrant from a very wc background.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 09:13

Thanks @GrouchyKiwi I might take you up on that 🙂

OP posts:
30mph · 28/07/2022 09:12

Keep your professional development up to speed and have a side hassle related to it, even if on a very small scale. Otherwise you risk being 20yrs down the line and unemployable, when you might prefer to be working. It is also a good insurance move against changes in circumstances.

Don't underestimate the need and value of having some dedicated time available for your own wellbeing and health. If you are with your children 24/7 then you need to factor in when you will have some recharge time. Consider what support your husband is able and willing to give. There may be areas of home-education that he would like to be involved in. He might want to contribute towards family life, other than providing financial security. Encourage his involvement. Avoid becoming insular.

Consider the costs of home-educating too. Although, like most things in life, you can do things as cheaply as possible, a reasonable budget helps. For example, accessing groups where there is a shared cost involved, online learning, books, materials. If you are going to continue to GCSE level, then exam entries are ££ and add up per subject, plus texts and resources etc., If you continue to A level, then £££ for exam entries.

dostyh · 28/07/2022 09:12

@BuffaloCauliflower I had help as I said as did most of my friends. We also saved like mad as needed to put down 6 figs 10 years ago. Obviously dc impede the ability to save but I understand why people don't/can't wait. Maybe you should wait a bit more & save what you can, if house prices are hit by the economy I don't think it will "show" until a few yrs.

GrouchyKiwi · 28/07/2022 09:06

Sounds like you've thought through the practicalities and have a good plan in place. Some good advice on this thread too.

I'm a home edding SAHM (and have done it from the start with my 3) so if you'd like to chat about the day-to-day realities feel free to PM me. It's mostly fantastic, but there are days when I wonder if I've made the right decision.

I've also just started doing some very part-time work so I have something for myself, now that my youngest has mastered reading.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 09:04

@gatehouseoffleet i currently work part time and it isn’t working for me. It should be the best of both worlds but for me it feels like the worst.
Its got nothing to do with him being a man, but he does currently earn 3 times what I do and it’s increasing sharply. I don’t think reducing his income is very sensible at this point.

OP posts:
User952539 · 28/07/2022 09:02

Louise0701 · 28/07/2022 08:47

@User952539 and he’s up at night worrying about what exactly? Is his income not secure? Is your mortgage not paid and school fees paid in advance? Do you not have investments and savings?

Well this isn’t a thread about me but obviously when you have a high income you tend to have a large house, school fees etc. DH is a lawyer and so his income is actually profit share not salary so if there is a downturn in business they can ask partners to put money in and hold back the profit share. Plus it varies year to year. And if he was suddenly unable to work, lost his job etc then there are high outgoings. We can’t pay schools fees in advance.

im not asking anyone to feel sorry for us clearly, I’m just saying that if everything is on the shoulders of one person it can be stressful for them.

dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:59

A wealthy family could have 1 part time and 1 SAHP and not be “stressed” I’m assuming large mortgage costs etc for the PP who’s husband earns a couple of hundred thousand.

Yes but wealth & income are different though aren't they which is why a higher earner who is servicing everything from a salary could feel more pressure than someone who is wealthy. Most younger people even with a good income find housing costs eat a chunk of salary.

gatehouseoffleet · 28/07/2022 08:58

MolliciousIntent · 27/07/2022 22:20

I think you need to take into account the potential impact on your DH of carrying the entire financial burden for the family. It can be a very stressful thing, and can cause resentment long-term.

Yes. You really do have to consider what you would do if he lost his job. Would he easily walk into another one, or could he be unemployed for some time? And what if he got ill?

Personally I'd look at both of you working part-time - you share the financial and childcare burdens and you've always got the safety net of two incomes.

I know you're going to come back and say that couldn't possibly work because he's the main breadwinner and he's a man after all, but think about it with an open mind. It would also be better for home educating as well - the two of you will be better at different things.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:54

@dostyh yes we’d get a much better rate putting 20% down, but sadly have nothing like £80k lying around so not much hope there 😂
We have house deposit savings in a LISA, and money to cover things like car repairs, unexpected bills, Christmas etc (which is more than my parents ever had my whole life) we don’t have a whole extra house deposit just waiting in the wings. I’d love to know if there’s many people in their early 30s who do.

OP posts:
dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:53

and he’s up at night worrying about what exactly? Is his income not secure? Is your mortgage not paid and school fees paid in advance? Do you not have investments and savings?

The income isn't always secure because most high earners don't earn those figures for decades. Burn out is a thing & industries can be cut throat. Investments can suffer (plenty lost loads during covid & financial crash) & it's rare for savings to match years of higher earnings plus low interest rates have eroded them.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:52

Thanks @Discovereads 🙂

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:51

@demotedreally and others that have expressed similar things - I’m completely open to the fact things may change, in many ways, and school may be something we do after all. Life throws many things up, you can’t foresee every route. But I think it’s more prudent to try and prepare for all options not just the being at home short time - hope for the best, prepare for the worst I suppose. If my children want to go to school that’s absolutely their choice to make

OP posts:
Louise0701 · 28/07/2022 08:49

@User952539 @dostyh its ok. We’re talking about very different levels of wealth here. Not circa 300k. A wealthy family could have 1 part time and 1 SAHP and not be “stressed” I’m assuming large mortgage costs etc for the PP who’s husband earns a couple of hundred thousand.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:48

@easyday my dad died suddenly fairly young, before retirement, so I’m definitely not blind to these concerns. We will definitely have life insurance that covered the mortgage (this saved my mum)

OP posts:
dostyh · 28/07/2022 08:48

Of course, it was more the point I need my time away from them so I couldn't home educate!

Louise0701 · 28/07/2022 08:47

@User952539 and he’s up at night worrying about what exactly? Is his income not secure? Is your mortgage not paid and school fees paid in advance? Do you not have investments and savings?

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 08:46

@dostyh absolutely get that! My children will do plenty of clubs and groups outside the home, and probably do some holiday camp weeks as well because they’re great experiences. My godchildren are doing a drama camp week and a sports week this summer which both look fab, this activities aren’t closed to home ed kids 🙂

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread