Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help in thinking through the admin of becoming a SAHM

140 replies

BuffaloCauliflower · 27/07/2022 21:24

I know MN always has plenty of thoughts on protecting yourself as a SAHM so thought I’d ask for some help to make sure I’m not missing anything.

Currently have a toddler, and pregnant with no.2. I currently work part time but for various reasons (mainly because I want to) I’m thinking of staying home after this next maternity leave and not going back.

Some things I think we need to do/points I know I’ll be asked about

  • Don’t currently claim child benefit as DH earns too much, but will now and just not get the payment for the NI credits.
  • Pay into a private pension. I’ve got an old workplace pension not doing much, I think I’ll move it somewhere I can access and we can top that up
  • We already have one joint account for all money, and I manage that money and our savings, so no concerns about accessing money as I need
  • Yes we are married
  • Hoping to buy a house next year, we’re in a stupidly expensive bit of the country and have been waiting for some now forthcoming parental deposit help. We can buy what we want on just DH salary for affordability
  • We can pay everything we need to comfortably on DH wage, my wage is currently just for childcare and savings
  • DH very supportive of whatever I want, but does have a preference towards me staying home as he can see how much I’m not enjoying trying to balance all the things and not being the mum I want to be (he equally parents and does more housework than me so it’s not for lack of support that I’m wanting to stop working)
Anything else I might not have considered?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jobconfused · 28/07/2022 18:41

@BuffaloCauliflower sounds like you got it all covered and it’s great that you’re putting all this infrastructure in place before making the move. Many don’t. Although reading this thread makes me glad I’m not a SAHM, too much to think about! I’d be really worried all the time.

MrsDooDaa · 28/07/2022 18:26

I would definitely keep your options open on schooling until you know the personality of your unborn child, the relationship dynamic between your two children and the impact on yourself and your husband of having 2 children full time at home.

So I would buy a house in an area that has good school provision as a backup.

SweetSakura · 28/07/2022 18:19

You can send them to school any time.

True. But that involves a bit of foresight that you might want to in the future, and ensuring that despite the decision to home educate you are in a good school catchment that isn't so oversubscribed you will be on the waiting list for years

rumplestiltskinp · 28/07/2022 17:57

Confusedteacher · 27/07/2022 23:20

Home educating families tend to have a great community network so I’d probably continue to be involved in that with them

Do they? How do you know? Are you in touch with one now? I know a few people who home educated and it all went a bit pear shaped. How do you intend to home educate teenagers? What about GCSEs?

Don’t want to piss on your chips, but on the other hand this is a MASSIVE decision.

You can send them to school any time. I home educated for two years and it was great but it demands more of your time as they get older and we've decided to send ours to school now, which is always an option. It's not make the decision then you can never change it, not sure where you would get that idea from.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 17:33

@JustLyra completely hear you. We’re already pretty good at bringing things fairly formally and dealing with them, but definitely not one to get complacent about

OP posts:
rumplestiltskinp · 28/07/2022 17:07

MolliciousIntent · 27/07/2022 22:20

I think you need to take into account the potential impact on your DH of carrying the entire financial burden for the family. It can be a very stressful thing, and can cause resentment long-term.

Not if the man values the role of an at home spouse. Be clear on your role and his role.

I don't expect anything of my husband when he's home housework -wise as it would only get in the way of my systems.

This works really well and we are clear on what is his and what is my responsibility.

When you home ed don't come on here, use facebook to find local groups and go and meet them in person. There are loads and loads of groups around these days for home ed activities.

There's no reason for him to resent someone who is facilitating his career and his coming home to a clean, welcoming place where he can offload his responsibilities completely. There's nothing to resent.

If you were both working his workload would increase, not decrease.

Many men enjoy and take pride in providing for their family.

ZandathePanda · 28/07/2022 17:04

Long term illness is harder to plan for, but we’re not moving too far from family support for a reason
If you see my earlier post, you will realise will will be the family support for others in the next 18 years. It is likely you will be the carer for older generations.

JustLyra · 28/07/2022 16:28

@BuffaloCauliflower

Yes I’m pretty confident that will continue to be the case as it is already. We’re both people who need to recharge alone so we’ve got really good at respecting that need in each other.

he’s never been this way before so I don’t see that changing, this year I’ve worked many more late nights/extra hours than him and he’s just got on with it. I’ve never been the 24/7 alone parent, even when I was on maternity leave. We both say ‘I need to do this, can you do this’ and it always works out pretty equal. I’ve been sick and pregnant the last couple of months and he’s done way more than his fair share.

My DH is considerably more hands on than many, yet we fell into both of those traps briefly.

Its very very easy to do.

Complacency is a massive danger. For both of you. It’s so easy to slip into bad habits because it’s “just half an hour” and “just one night”.

The other thing I’d say is you need regular review points where you both sit down together and be bluntly honest about what is working and what isn’t.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 15:54

@JustLyra Great questions

Will you have an amount of money that’s your personal spends?


  • We’ve shared all money for quite a long time now, and haven’t felt the need to do a specific ‘me’ or ‘him’ pot. But we do use YNAB and allocate budget lines for different things, like going out, buying clothes, kids stuff etc.

  • Yes I’m pretty confident that will continue to be the case as it is already. We’re both people who need to recharge alone so we’ve got really good at respecting that need in each other.

  • he’s never been this way before so I don’t see that changing, this year I’ve worked many more late nights/extra hours than him and he’s just got on with it. I’ve never been the 24/7 alone parent, even when I was on maternity leave. We both say ‘I need to do this, can you do this’ and it always works out pretty equal. I’ve been sick and pregnant the last couple of months and he’s done way more than his fair share.

  • very aware of this as it was a mega downfall for my parents who did not deal with this well with us kids. We’ve always worked very much as a team, and because DH works 100% from home he’s here a lot more than the average which makes a difference. We’re very much on the same page parenting style wise and back each other up

  • short term illness I guess the same as is it now, if I can’t parent he takes the day off. I had covid badly earlier this year and he took 2 days off. When I’ve been suffering with pregnancy illness lately he’s come down during work to change nappies and give lunch and taken over as soon as he finishes so I can go to bed. Long term illness is harder to plan for, but we’re not moving too far from family support for a reason

OP posts:
wellhelloitsme · 28/07/2022 15:02

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 14:32

@SweetSakura if we needed to break up I’d get a job! I’ve had to get myself through life despite a significant number of setbacks, I’ve made my own path and been resilient and picked myself back up repeatedly. I’d do the same again. This is also why I’m thinking about things like private pensions, NI credits and savings rather than wandering blindly into the ether.

I also don’t want to live in fear.

That's why people including me have suggested you doing some freelance work each year, or idea some each month, so you can re-enter the workforce if needed without having had too much time away from your industry and can maintain your earning potential and not lose handy contacts.

It would be tough in most industries to re-enter with no work experience for more than a couple of years out, let alone 10/15/18, so definitely worth thinking about to keep your earning potential where it is now.

JustLyra · 28/07/2022 14:48

The smaller things are often where the downfall lies I’ve found.

Will you have an amount of money that’s your personal spends?
Will you have set time away from the children that is respected as your time?
What happens with your DH working late/going on work nights out etc? - he needs to commit to not just assuming you’ll be the 24/7 parent and he doesn’t need to even check.
Discipline - it’s so so easy to fall into the habit of you being the main one to discipline the children (which will be especially so if you also are the home educator) which can very much set up a good cop-bad cop situation where you are rules, homework and tidying and Dad is weekends, relaxing and days out.
What’s your back-up if/when you’re ill?

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 14:32

@SweetSakura if we needed to break up I’d get a job! I’ve had to get myself through life despite a significant number of setbacks, I’ve made my own path and been resilient and picked myself back up repeatedly. I’d do the same again. This is also why I’m thinking about things like private pensions, NI credits and savings rather than wandering blindly into the ether.

I also don’t want to live in fear.

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 14:28

@titchy where did I say that?! I don’t think schools are awful and useless and haven’t said that anywhere. But I also don’t think the school system is moving with the times or offering the education lots of people are going to need. Our system is also massively lagging behind many other developed nations, which do much better despite being much less pressured. This isn’t an unusual opinion, a vast number of educationalists agree. But this isn’t a conversation about the education system.

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 28/07/2022 13:17

What's your plan if he leaves you or treats you badly @BuffaloCauliflower ? Everyone should have a plan for that. Lots of "perfect" husband's let their wives down.

titchy · 28/07/2022 13:04

A good 80% of the jobs our children will do haven’t been invented yet, but there’s no drive to create a system that teaches creative or critical thought and problem solving to grow with this.

Yet you assume that the uninvented 80% will require skills which are not taught in schools...!

RedHelenB · 28/07/2022 13:02

Just her not get.

RedHelenB · 28/07/2022 13:01

CharlotteOH · 27/07/2022 22:29

Nonsense and unhelpful.

Not nonsense and not unhelpful. I think if she's a SAHM she may need to shoulder more of the housework burden too ( after what would be get maternity leave) otherwise it's just get that benefits from the arrangement.

BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 11:40

@SmileyClare you may see it as idealised but I’m basing it on what I can see. I’m sure it will be a really hard choice at times, but school is also a really hard thing for many children and parents. School is the norm in our society so I appreciate it’s the baseline for many people, but it’s really not as simple as home ed = hard and expensive for parents and school = easy and free for parents. School trips cost money, uniforms cost money, having a child who is bullied or not enjoying school is hard on parents. There’s a lot of factors at play.

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 11:33

@SweetSakura i don’t have a negative view of schooling, I went to some lovely schools, I do think the current system is narrowing education and not moving with the times. Focus seems to be on going backwards rather than creating a new system that prepares children for a different world of work. A good 80% of the jobs our children will do haven’t been invented yet, but there’s no drive to create a system that teaches creative or critical thought and problem solving to grow with this.

DH left at 16 and only has GCSEs, I left school at 15 for various reasons and didn’t take any qualifications, I did all my qualifications off my own back post 16, went to uni as a mature student in my twenties. My life has taught me there isn’t only one defined route through education, learning how to learn is what’s key

OP posts:
BuffaloCauliflower · 28/07/2022 11:29

I’m not trying to be defensive, and I’m not sure why it’s defensive when people say ‘what about this’ to answer with what I’ve thought about it?

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 28/07/2022 10:20

You must never let your children pick up on your negative views on mainstream school as you may be forced to need it.

I totally agree with this?

Also curious whether you and your DH went to mainstream school as clearly it has enabled you both to get qualifications and careers...

SmileyClare · 28/07/2022 10:05

I'd agree with others, you're very defensive when posters express their views or point out possible difficulties you may face.

I don't want to get into a debate over home schooling but there's a danger that you're setting yourself up for massive disappointment or failure (in your eyes) because your vision of home schooling sounds idealised and a bit naive, sorry!
I say this as a parent of teens and an adult.

As far as your finances go, and the protection you've put in place for yourself- fantastic.. you're very privileged to have the choice of not earning.

ZandathePanda · 28/07/2022 10:03

Now I am at the end of the school run days, I am thinking of the things that have happened to the families I know (some minor details changed as too outing but v similar):

  1. Most, if not all children, have at least one grandparent who has died. The caring for the remaining parent/in-laws falls on the women as being ‘non-working’ means you mop everything up. Many of us have ended up caring for a parent with dementia for a few years (violence/inappropriate behaviour) before they are put in a home. Social services have come for money gifted to parents when required for a home.
  2. Many divorces which are complicated by affairs and (particularly men) starting new families so they don’t have time for the old one.
  3. Two mothers have died. One father.
  4. One mother went blind.
  5. Several mums and dads have life-limiting illnesses and have been bedridden.
  6. Several children have had cancer and other illnesses that have required long hospital stays.
  7. One mum had a car accident and, to save the leg, had to be in a frame in bed for 6 months.
  8. A couple of children have been expelled from a private school for porn/drug related incidents. Been difficult transition to get them into state.
  9. Parents losing their jobs. Men particularly prone to depression.
  10. Mental illness hitting grandparents/parents/children to the point they cannot function.
Not great reading, but in 18 years time you will know people in these situations too. And you’ll be responsible for picking up the pieces. Many women are SAHP because of these pieces.

You need critical illness cover for both of you and you need to look at how to find a pension. If, whoever is lending/giving you money, is needing care/ homing in the future, think if morally is it up to you to provide it? Discuss this with them.

You must never let your children pick up on your negative views on mainstream school as you may be forced to need it.

ChokaWithaSeaView · 28/07/2022 09:58

With all the sensible plans you have in place, I would still work - eve if it was just 1 day a week.

Seriously.

I'm speaking from bitter experience here. Same situation as you - all the precautions in the world, everything in place and left high and dry with such a large gap in my career that my degree was rendered practically worthless by the time I had to look for work to support myself and DC because DH left.

If I'd kept my career going by working just that 1 day a week, covering maybe holiday cover every now snd then, it really would have made such a difference to my life now.

^this is my crystal ball

MrsBwced · 28/07/2022 09:53

So having read your post about the house deposits I'd strongly suggest saving more before you go into this especially as you are planning doing it long term.

Swipe left for the next trending thread