Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to pay for 12 hours of cleaning

112 replies

Lightningboltblue · 27/07/2022 20:29

I am disputing an invoice from a house cleaner. For reference I have used the same company twice, at my mums address and had a rough idea what I should be charged. I’m based in Notts and they charge £22 PH for a deep clean.

They are claiming that it took two cleaners 6 hours each to deep clean my home (it DEFINITELY wasn't 12 hours worth of cleaning dirty haha).

Firstly, they weren’t there for 6 hours. There is no way they could have been there any longer than 4 hours due to the time I left for work and DH came home. Secondly, I didn’t request two cleaners so didn’t agree to 2 x the hourly rate.

Where do I stand with payment of the invoice? I am of course happy to pay for the work that I asked for but I’m not happy to pay double when I didn’t request two cleaners

OP posts:
WidgetDigit2022 · 28/07/2022 07:01

You pay for what was quoted and agreed.

You've both made a big mistake here in assuming the cost before starting without confirming. Although ultimately I think it's probably their mistake more than yours as they can't prove what theyve provided.

woohoo54 · 28/07/2022 06:59

YABU a deep clean takes a long time. But do dispute the timings if you know they weren't there.
Could you have just missed them?

NumberTheory · 28/07/2022 06:59

I think it’s common for new properties to take longer. Cleaners are faster when they’re familiar with a place. So that might account for some of the additional time, but obviously nowhere near all of it.

I think you need to dispute it with them on the basis it was not 12 hours worth of work. I would not discuss the number of cleaners with them at all unless they bring it up in a way that needs addressing and then if you have to just express surprise they would bother sending two for such a small property when you know they don’t always for others of similar size. I assume you are suspicious that they didn’t even send two cleaners, but it isn’t really relevant. What is relevant is the number of hours they say it took and the fact they haven’t done nearly enough work for that to be reasonable. Make it clear you think it was closer to 4 hours of work. Use your mother’s house as a comparator. If you have pics of before and after for her place and yours, that should also help.

I would initially ask them if they have confused you with another property as you know cleaners did not attend for the hours stated as the property was occupied for a significant amount of that time (I wouldn’t say when, exactly, at this stage).

They may come back with adjusted hours that would be physically possible and some details that make you realise it could have taken more than the 4 hours you expected (maybe you have some things trickier to clean than your mum’s, or they did something at yours that they don’t bother with at your mum’s) in which case you need to accept that as you didn’t go over what work they needed to do.

If they don’t come back with a figure and explanation you find acceptable refuse to pay on the basis the work was not to performed proficiently and offer what you think the job is worth (I would aim on the high side in order to give them reason to settle). See if they will go as far as to sue you for the difference.

You might als ask neighbours if they have Nest or Ring doorbells that might have captured your house or the cleaners car(s) arriving or leaving, so you have more ammunition to show they have lied. But that’s mainly irrelevant because your argument is, even if they had two cleaners there for every second the house was unoccupied, they didn’t do enough work to justify it.

Hollyhead · 28/07/2022 06:54

I think it’s likely to be an innocent invoicing error - it sounds like 2 of them might have been there for 3 hours each so you should be paying for 6 hours, it’s not unlikely that someone’s had a brain fart moment and doubles it again by mistake. I’d query it based on the time the house was empty.

FrecklesMalone · 28/07/2022 06:49

A two bedroomed house unless exceptionally messy shouldn't take 12 hours if it's tidy. We had our 4 bed deep cleaned after building works and it took 6 hours

Mindymomo · 28/07/2022 06:29

What was actually agreed. Lesson to learn here, if you got a fixed price for doing a job, then it won’t matter how many people did it or how long it took. If you were paying by the hour and they were there 4 hours, not 6 then you have a case to ask for a reduction.

BloodyCamping · 28/07/2022 06:24

What time did you leave and she arrive?

TheTeenageYears · 28/07/2022 06:22

*contract

TheTeenageYears · 28/07/2022 06:21

If you complain absolutely do not mention the 2 cleaner thing. Lots of cleaning is done this way and you didn't have either a contact or conversation expressively saying it would be one cleaner - you assumed it would be one and will completely muddy the waters of your complaint. Focus on the 12 hours cleaning time not being possible given you left the house at X time and husband returned at Y. Those are the facts.

Marvellousmadness · 28/07/2022 06:20

Yabu for thinking DEEP cleaning a house wouldnt take long . It took my cleaner that I used to have 4 hours to do my small house. And that was a normal clean. Not a deep clean.

GoAround · 28/07/2022 06:14

The 2 cleaner thing doesn’t matter. Imagine it was your mum’s house that takes 1 cleaner 4 hours. If they sent 2 cleaners that took 2 hours each, you’d still pay for 4 hours of cleaning. The issue here is that they’ve charged you for hours they didn’t do. I’d go back to the company and ask for the start and end time of the cleaners. They’ll either realise they made a mistake like it was 2 cleaners, 3 hours each, 6 hours TOTAL (not 12 hours) or you’ll know for sure they’re lying and can confront them based on when you and DH were at home.

CakeCrumbs44 · 28/07/2022 06:14

The fact that there was 2 of them is not an issue.
The fact that they're overstating the hours worked IS an issue.
Don't tell them what time you and DH left and arrived, just ask what time the cleaners arrived and worked until. Then depending on what they say you can go back with "they didn't arrive at 8am, I was there until 9" or whatever.

knittingaddict · 28/07/2022 06:08

Does a deep clean include the inside of kitchen cupboards? I would expect it to, but I've never had a cleaner. What does it include?

Yerroblemom1923 · 28/07/2022 06:07

It would be the same price if it was one person, it just would've taken 12 hours instead of 6. Did you know and agree the price beforehand?

Ponderingwindow · 28/07/2022 05:56

You really need to let the two cleaner issue go. They should clean twice as fast. Sometimes we get a team of 4 even as we have a large house. They are able to get the job done very quickly that way which is great for us. It doesn’t increase the cost because the time taken is proportionally shorter.

the length of time definitely should be disputed.

Lightningboltblue · 28/07/2022 04:55

There was no contract in place. A deep clean was agreed and the property isn’t in a state. The reason why I opted for a deep clean is because the skirtings and insides of windows are included. For reference, my mum is in a 2 bed house (same as me) and her deep clean takes 4 hours, for one cleaner. No time was agreed as I (naively) assumed it would take the same time as my mums, due to living in the same size property.

To clarify my discrepancies are that they sent 2 cleaners which are both charged by the hour, when I didn’t request this and have previously only had 1 cleaner at a time from the same company. Also the length of time they were there

OP posts:
Foxylass · 27/07/2022 23:36

What agreement, contract did you have in place?

calmlakes · 27/07/2022 23:24

The actual hours worked definitely needs querying.
But a deep clean could take a good while depending on the condition at the start and what was being done.

EarringsandLipstick · 27/07/2022 23:19

calmlakes · 27/07/2022 22:29

It wasn't 2 cleaners doing it in half the time (so cheaper), it was 2 cleaners working the sane amount of hours

OP hasn't given us any indication that she was told the deep clean would take six hours.
She has just said that she agreed to a deep clean.

But she hardly expected the deep clean to take 12 hours? Which is what 1 cleaner working alone would have taken

Clearly there are 2 issues - lack of clarity about what a 'deep clean' meant in hours & cost (surely not 12 hours!) and the actual hours worked by the cleaners which seem inaccurate.

figmaofmyimagination · 27/07/2022 22:43

Ask them to confirm what time they arrived and left. Don’t offer up what times you were there yet.

calmlakes · 27/07/2022 22:29

It wasn't 2 cleaners doing it in half the time (so cheaper), it was 2 cleaners working the sane amount of hours

OP hasn't given us any indication that she was told the deep clean would take six hours.
She has just said that she agreed to a deep clean.

EarringsandLipstick · 27/07/2022 22:25

tenyrsago · 27/07/2022 22:07

why do you think 2 cleaners costs more?!

Because OP said: They are claiming that it took two cleaners 6 hours each to deep clean my home

It wasn't 2 cleaners doing it in half the time (so cheaper), it was 2 cleaners working the sane amount of hours ie 6 hours x 2 = 12. So it is costing her more! (As well as the hours discrepancy)

tenyrsago · 27/07/2022 22:07

why do you think 2 cleaners costs more?!

GreenClock · 27/07/2022 21:53

“Hi - could you quickly confirm the times between which the two cleaners were here please?”

Then take it from there.

Tiani4 · 27/07/2022 21:47

"x" time not x token

Swipe left for the next trending thread