Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to pay for 12 hours of cleaning

112 replies

Lightningboltblue · 27/07/2022 20:29

I am disputing an invoice from a house cleaner. For reference I have used the same company twice, at my mums address and had a rough idea what I should be charged. I’m based in Notts and they charge £22 PH for a deep clean.

They are claiming that it took two cleaners 6 hours each to deep clean my home (it DEFINITELY wasn't 12 hours worth of cleaning dirty haha).

Firstly, they weren’t there for 6 hours. There is no way they could have been there any longer than 4 hours due to the time I left for work and DH came home. Secondly, I didn’t request two cleaners so didn’t agree to 2 x the hourly rate.

Where do I stand with payment of the invoice? I am of course happy to pay for the work that I asked for but I’m not happy to pay double when I didn’t request two cleaners

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whynotwhatknot · 13/08/2022 20:13

any update?

i would have just paid for the hours they were there and then leave it up to them to take it to court if they wish

Purple52 · 30/07/2022 11:15

Whoops should have said chase you not scare you.

Purple52 · 30/07/2022 11:14

I total see your point OP and that of some commentators.
the only police matter is them threatening that they know where you live!
I’d pay 6/8 hours, leave an honest, polite but loaded review on their social media about timings and vote with your feet by not using them again.
if they scare you over for 4/6 hours now they’ve lost future business.

(for the review I’d say something like, deep clean was through, thank you, calculation of time keeping was poor. 9am-1pm is 4 hours, not the six I was charged. I was not made aware there would be two cleaners before the invoice arrived and I was charged for 12 hours. I have used previously and be delighted by the clean and pricing, will not use again do to time calculation issue, over charging and poor customer service when I raised a dispute, including a threat to my home/personal safety.)

keep it to the point.

write it off as a cost and a bad experience.

mumda · 30/07/2022 09:50

You need to consider the evidence you'll need for defending being taken to the small claims court.

  1. Time stamped photos of anything you use.
  2. Statement from you and husband relating to the time they could have been there.
  3. Any neighbour evidence from ring doorbell etc.
  4. Floorplan of your house.
  5. Photos of your house inside.
  6. Invoice from the deep cleaning on your mother's house.
  7. Photos from your mother's house showing its similarly to yours.
  8. Floorplan of your mother's house.
  9. Photos before the deep cleaning ... Difficult!
10. Photos after deep cleaning.
CrapBag39 · 30/07/2022 08:25

I would hone in on the “we know where you live” comment and ask them what exactly they mean by that. Is that a threat of violence against you or to come and damage the property? Ask them when they expect the police to visit you so you can show them that comment in black and white.

2bazookas · 28/07/2022 22:54

I would reply

"You have sent me the wrong invoice, charging for two cleaners for 6 hours.
This was not the work done at <address> on <date>.
We asked for one cleaner, who worked for no more than four hours. Please correct your staff records and send the correct invoice."

Tiani4 · 28/07/2022 22:07

*weren't there for

Tiani4 · 28/07/2022 22:06

I am standing my ground and they are threatening police action, which I’ve welcomed them to do as it is not a criminal matter, it’s civil. They are being most unpleasant and reminding me that they know where I live, I won’t be bullied in to paying the full invoice though.

Quite right too OP. Lol that they think it's a police matter . It will become a police matter if they threaten you though...

They are fraudulently claiming they did hours they didn't do.
It's a fraud to invoice when clearly not there. Can you report them to trading standards as invoicing for hours they falsely claim there worked in the house for when you can prove they were there for - its dishonest practice and indicates to me they may also be ripping off other people, including vulnerable people.

You should be able to put up a Yelp or whatever review - just be factual "was invoiced for 12 hours to clean a 2 bed property... on invoice they stated 2 cleaners were at property cleaning for 6 hours each (2x6 = 12) . We left and returned to the house less than 4 hours later and no cleaners were there. .. when we disputed the invoice as being factually incorrect and claiming for hours not done, they became unpleasant"

NumberTheory · 28/07/2022 17:28

wordler · 28/07/2022 16:02

As you have no contract saying you wanted one cleaner for x hours, you are going to have to pay for the service you received.

But - you shouldn't pay for a service you haven't received. So get confirmation of the hours the cleaners claim they were in your house and let the company know if that was incorrect based on you and your husband being at home and not seeing them.

You're obviously never using them again of course.

It s not true that you simply have to pay up for the hours the cleaners were there. They have an obligation to provide a reasonable service. If the amount of work should have been able to be done by a reasonably competent cleaner (or set of cleaners) in fewer hours, OP can refuse to pay for more and a court would not force her to cover the extra. Big caveat: assuming the court agreed with OP’s assessment of how much time it should have taken.

It is simply untrue that if you don’t have a written contract you have to pay up for whatever the other party decides to charge you. Reasonableness is a key part of unwritten contracts.

wordler · 28/07/2022 16:02

As you have no contract saying you wanted one cleaner for x hours, you are going to have to pay for the service you received.

But - you shouldn't pay for a service you haven't received. So get confirmation of the hours the cleaners claim they were in your house and let the company know if that was incorrect based on you and your husband being at home and not seeing them.

You're obviously never using them again of course.

MadeForThis · 28/07/2022 15:47

If you know they were only in the house for 4 hours then start by challenging that.

TibetanTerrah · 28/07/2022 15:43

FatBettyintheCoop · 28/07/2022 15:33

Hardly! Some people wrongly believe that if a there’s no agreement or if there’s a signed contract, that’s all that matters and that the plaintiff will automatically win. Not true.

The OP should write to the company offering to pay £X to cover what she feels is a reasonable amount on the basis of their previous cleans in her mum’s house, which is a comparable sized property and usually takes around 4 hours.

How can the company justify 12 hours cleaning time (2x 6hrs)?
In addition, she needs to state that the cleaners couldn’t have spent 6 hours in the house between her leaving in the morning and her DH arriving so on that basis alone, someone is not being truthful.

It’s far more likely that the judge will deem the defendant’s version the more plausible one. Plus as she’s presumably paid a fair portion of the bill, say 6 hours worth of cleaning, not 12, then I can’t see the company getting anything other than having to pay their own costs.

I've been there with small claims, and what you're saying isn't quite how a judge will see it, although I don't believe it would ever go to court anyway. There's mediation first and various opportunities for either side to settle.

I don't think she should be guesstimating how long it 'should' have taken based on how long her mum's took. There's too many variables. I've been into houses to do deep cleans for people who would consider themselves 'houseproud' but no. When you get stuck into a deep clean it can take longer than expected. Grime build up in places they regularly miss, not intentionally of course, but just don't think/see. Furniture, clutter on surfaces, knickknacks and books etc, every single property is different.

Imo OP needs to send one message saying as you were only here between x and y time (and how she knows this), I will pay you for that and trust the matter is closed, then leave it to them if they want the hassle of chasing the rest.

FatBettyintheCoop · 28/07/2022 15:33

TibetanTerrah · 28/07/2022 14:54

Threatening you and bleating about the police is a bit laughable. If they come to their senses and take you to small claims (and who knows, they might not bother and you might get away with it), I think you'll lose though.

You didn't get a quote, either job rate or hours estimate, you just guessed, and unless you have proof from a Ring doorbell or similar of what time they arrived and left it will be your word against theirs. As far as a judge will see it, you asked for a deep clean, they did it, invoiced you, and you ended up with a clean house you refused to pay for.

Hardly! Some people wrongly believe that if a there’s no agreement or if there’s a signed contract, that’s all that matters and that the plaintiff will automatically win. Not true.

The OP should write to the company offering to pay £X to cover what she feels is a reasonable amount on the basis of their previous cleans in her mum’s house, which is a comparable sized property and usually takes around 4 hours.

How can the company justify 12 hours cleaning time (2x 6hrs)?
In addition, she needs to state that the cleaners couldn’t have spent 6 hours in the house between her leaving in the morning and her DH arriving so on that basis alone, someone is not being truthful.

It’s far more likely that the judge will deem the defendant’s version the more plausible one. Plus as she’s presumably paid a fair portion of the bill, say 6 hours worth of cleaning, not 12, then I can’t see the company getting anything other than having to pay their own costs.

clingyclingy · 28/07/2022 15:25

OP you say you've only used them before at your mums house so they haven't visited your house

I have had a number of deep cleans as has my mum. We have the same sized houses but my deep clean is nearly double her costs (same company)

The size of the two properties is largely irrelevant here. A deep clean involves a lot more work than a simple clean and it's more about what's in the property than the size of it

Eg
How much furniture is there to be moved (deep clean usually move things like bedside tables etc)
Do you have pets? (I have a dog, my mum doesn't)
How much surface area is clear (I have more shelves with more things to be moved and dusted than my mum)
Things that need to be tidied away/cleaned around
My kitchen is bigger and kitchens are always the hardest area to clean and work around

It's really not as simple as 2 three bed properties should cost the same

Whilst I agree with you 12 hours of cleaning seems a lot (and I would absolutely dispute the times they say they were there) you didn't get an estimate before hand and really that mistake and the fall out is on you.

TibetanTerrah · 28/07/2022 14:54

Lightningboltblue · 28/07/2022 14:28

Just catching up. To clarify, I thought the clean would take one cleaner no longer than 3.5 - 4 hours at a push. Hence why I was so shocked that they are claiming it took 6 hours, plus the fact it allegedly took two cleaners 6 hours.

I am standing my ground and they are threatening police action, which I’ve welcomed them to do as it is not a criminal matter, it’s civil. They are being most unpleasant and reminding me that they know where I live, I won’t be bullied in to paying the full invoice though.

Naively I never got a quote, I asked for a deep clean for my home and reminded them I’ve booked previous deep cleans for my mum using their company

Threatening you and bleating about the police is a bit laughable. If they come to their senses and take you to small claims (and who knows, they might not bother and you might get away with it), I think you'll lose though.

You didn't get a quote, either job rate or hours estimate, you just guessed, and unless you have proof from a Ring doorbell or similar of what time they arrived and left it will be your word against theirs. As far as a judge will see it, you asked for a deep clean, they did it, invoiced you, and you ended up with a clean house you refused to pay for.

calmlakes · 28/07/2022 14:51

They should only charge you for the hours they worked obviously.
But you do need to pay them for the hours they have worked because you didn't set any limits on that when you gave them the job.
They could fairly easily pursue a claim through the small claims court I would think.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 28/07/2022 14:48

What does using the service previously have to do with the cost to you for this particular job?
And are you a cleaner?
No.
How are you calculating the cost?
Nightmare customer.
I'd let the bill go unpaid for 30 days then begin procedures to enforce the unpaid invoice.
CCJ for an unpaid cleaning bill.😂

bluekostree · 28/07/2022 14:46

Did you specifically mention that you thought it would take 4 hours (one cleaner)? You're right that not getting a quote was silly!

Lightningboltblue · 28/07/2022 14:28

Just catching up. To clarify, I thought the clean would take one cleaner no longer than 3.5 - 4 hours at a push. Hence why I was so shocked that they are claiming it took 6 hours, plus the fact it allegedly took two cleaners 6 hours.

I am standing my ground and they are threatening police action, which I’ve welcomed them to do as it is not a criminal matter, it’s civil. They are being most unpleasant and reminding me that they know where I live, I won’t be bullied in to paying the full invoice though.

Naively I never got a quote, I asked for a deep clean for my home and reminded them I’ve booked previous deep cleans for my mum using their company

OP posts:
FatBettyintheCoop · 28/07/2022 13:03

saraclara · 28/07/2022 09:27

Poster says she had used the company before so can roughly estimate how long it will take one person to deep clean her house. She clearly expected the clean to take ONE PERSON less than six hours to do

Nowhere has OP said how many hours she expected it to take @FatBettyintheCoop . She simply thinks that she's paid double because two corners were involved. And that simply isn't the case.

Yes she has! Presumably you hadn’t RTFT before berating me for supposedly making assumptions.

The OP isn’t suggesting she’s been charge double for having two cleaners. She’s saying it couldn’t possibly take two cleaners 6 hours or one person 12 hours to clean her small house. As she’s living in her home and it’s not a student let, I’m sure she’s probably correct.

For reference, my mum is in a 2 bed house (same as me) and her deep clean takes 4 hours, for one cleaner. No time was agreed as I (naively) assumed it would take the same time as my mums, due to living in the same size property.

FatBettyintheCoop · 28/07/2022 12:49

DangerouslyBored · 28/07/2022 09:56

Grin I love it when a smug poster comes on to delight in the OP’s supposed ‘mistake’… and then gets shafted by a wiser poster. Good life lesson to STFU 🤐

Ok, tell me which bit I got wrong smarty pants. 😂

Blahblahblab · 28/07/2022 11:45

Has anyone ever had a cleaner charge an hourly rate for travel time?! That seems madness.

Of course they price it in, but they price it by increasing the hourly rate for the time they actually do they work to allow for the non-billable travel time. Exactly the same as holidays.

I've always wondered if two cleaners do do exactly double in an hour what one cleaner would do in two. It seems unlikely as you'd need more breaks if working two hours than only one, but equally there is the start and finish period twice for two cleaners. Maybe it balances out.

coticsouledout · 28/07/2022 10:26

I'm a landlord and my tenants left my flat in a largely uncleaned condition. It wasn't awful but when you started looking you could see it was actually quite dirty. I must approx 10 hours cleaning and it's two bed flat, not huge. I got 'paid' £100 for the clean. Deposit company seemed to think cleaners earn £10 an hour for an end of tenancy clean. They don't (it should have cost more like £250). And nor should they. And nor should landlords if lazy tenants refuse to clean or pay for a cleaner.

In your case the house was probably more dirty than you realised. I'd just pay up and just get things in writing next time but £22 ph for a one off cleaning job is not unusual.

Oblomov22 · 28/07/2022 10:26

How many hours did you expect it to take OP? Did they visit? What was the quote? I think we need more details.

saraclara · 28/07/2022 10:18

Ugh. Ignore the £129. Fat fingers. £120 obv