Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if your children get on with one another, do you think it’s because of your parenting or just luck/personalities?

116 replies

Movingsoon21 · 27/07/2022 17:18

DH and I have one DC, seven months. We’ve always said we’d have 2 DC and DH has started asking what age gap we should have before the next one.

But I now know so many siblings who don’t get on at all, that it’s really putting me off having a second DC. I don’t want to deal with constant fighting and I don’t want current DC to have a miserable time arguing with someone at home.

As kids, my siblings and I hated one another and fought non-stop (although we get on fine now), and DH apparently bickered a lot with his DB and they hate each other as adults, which causes a lot of family stress. In both cases I think it’s a mix of personality clashes, exacerbated by certain parenting styles.

If your DC get on / if you’ve always got on with your siblings, do you think it’s because of a particular parenting style that assists sibling relationships, or is it just luck of the draw whether they have clashing personality types etc? If there’s a particular parenting technique I can use to help them get on I would feel more confident in having a second!

OP posts:
DaisyWaldron · 27/07/2022 19:24

Mostly luck. My two teenagers are genuinely close friends, and it's mostly just down to their personalities. I'll take credit for having nurtured the relationship and not done done anything to mess it up, but even that I didn't do particularly consciously, and I couldn't have done it at all without them being compatible in the first place.

Cotswoldmama · 27/07/2022 19:22

I feel like its random as you don't really know what personality your kids will have. I have a sister 2.5 years younger and we never got on, we'd play as a group with all the kids on our street but never together at home other than maybe on a games console. As adults we get on but maybe that's because we don't live together!
Brothers always seem to get along a lot of my male friends who have a brother had them as their best men.
I have two boys with a 3y3d age gap and they seem to get on well most of the time. I think the eldest can be quite nurturing and because of the age gap they're not competing with each other to be the best at something. They don't always play together at home but play nicely in parks, playgrounds etc and don't really fight much. Definitely not as much as my sister and I did! I really hated her!

Gherkingreen · 27/07/2022 19:20

I have two DSs, 18 and 16. They've always got on really well and still do now. They're close, with lots in common but very different personalities.
They tease each other mercilessly and get annoyed occasionally but they rub along well, go to the gym together, spent a lot of time together on holiday recently, older DS gives younger one lifts etc
It's down to luck but I do like to think we've had a tiny bit to do with helping them develop a strong bond.

PersonaNonGarter · 27/07/2022 19:15

It’s my parenting and it is the thing I am most proud of. Literally. Most proud of.

Lots of parenting fuck ups but not this one.

CatsCakeandCosy · 27/07/2022 19:13

I have 3, aged between 14 and 8. It’s inconsistent! They definitely love each other and are quick to defend each other if anyone else is unkind to one of them (eldest will step in if he thinks I’m being too strict with the younger ones, which drives me potty). Sometimes they get on brilliantly, but there is a fair amount of bickering too. It goes through phases and I think is developmental - eg there is usually one of them trying to assert their independence and pushing siblings away, and (although it changes) it’s usually clear which 2 are currently the closest.

I often feel like I have had no impact here at all - as their personalities have developed they’ve found their own paths and relationships with each other.

Favouritefruits · 27/07/2022 19:10

definitely personality means they get on, my children are very best friends love each other to bits but its because my eldest is so lovely and gives in to his little brother too much so there’s no arguing to be had.

JockTamsonsBairns · 27/07/2022 18:41

22 months between DS (nearly 15) and DD (just turned 13), and they really don't get on at all. I thought I'd done the right kind of things to encourage their relationship, but it hasn't worked. Their personalities are polar opposites, and they have no shared interests.
It's a real source of sadness to me, and I envy people who have siblings who get along.
Days out and holidays much be so much easier!

Louise0701 · 27/07/2022 18:38

@Xiaoxiong I read that book; really recommend it!

I have 9yo DD, 5yo DS, 3yoDS. They all get on very well. DD & DS1 have an amazing bond and she loves sitting and playing with him; he is the quietest of the 3 and very sensitive. DD & DS2 have lots of fun together; they’re very similar personalities both very mischievous and there’s always a lot of giggling when they’re upto something. DS 1 & DS2 are the best of friends. They’re 19 months apart and adore one another. Very different but fiercely protective of one another and both, although young, are very good at compromising so games usually go well.

obviously the 3 of them do squabble at times as all siblings do but, for the most part, they’re a tight unit.

DH & I both have 2 siblings and we’re close with all of them and with BILs and SILs. I would say the closest is me and my sister. She’s my best friend and we talk every day and see each other at least twice a week.

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 27/07/2022 18:36

My sister (4 years younger) & I didn’t get on at all as kids but we’re really close as adults.

I think it’s because our parents never forced us together, so we were able to become friends when we were ready, which was when I went to university.

Although if I’d had to share a room with her I don’t think the relationship would have ever recovered.

flashpaper · 27/07/2022 18:30

My sister and I didn't get on at all growing up and still don't now. We tolerate each other enough to sit for family get togethers, but we aren't close at all and it's definitely a personality thing. She isn't my usual type of friend but no matter how much effort I put in, she doesn't like me. I've stopped bending over backwards for her so now she really doesn't want to know.

DP and his sister aren't super close but actually like each other. They're very different personality wise but when we all meet up they get on so well. It's nice to see, I'm jealous of them.

I hope my DC get on when they're older but I really do think it's down to luck.

JanJanBillyBearHam · 27/07/2022 18:27

17 months and get on really well. I agree that I think it's personality. My DD is very kind and gentle and puts her db's wants before her own, she won't even take a party bag at a party if he doesn't get one. I worry about this as I feel my DS might take advantage and also wonder why not everyone treats him like a little prince.
I'm an only and I find their bond astounding. I spend most of my time wondering why they don't hate eachother.

EddyReadyGo · 27/07/2022 18:26

Mine get on - I think from never comparing them and reading dr Laura Markhams’s booking ‘siblings without rivalry’. That set us up really well.

would recommend reading it. I am sure personalities make a difference but it makes sense to be prepared.

also there are lots of things you can do when the second baby is born that make a difference, like prioritising 10 mins ‘special time’ with the elder one.

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 27/07/2022 18:24

I have 4.5 year old DC (twin girls) and they are very close, although very different.
I think they get on as they have similar interests (at the moment), despite being totally different temperaments.
I can't tell how the future will pan out, but they get on well, despite bickering. Even though they are twins, neither refers to the other as her best friend, and they are close to different little pals.
I don't involved in their arguments, unless one is being truly harsh/mean to the other and I encourage them to seek space from one another if they need it.
My mother forced my sister and I (16 months difference) to always be together, wouldn't 'let' us argue and forced my poor sister to let me tag along wherever (I was the youngest).
My sister and I have a toxic relationship as adults and are currently NC.

Chasingsquirrels · 27/07/2022 18:24

19yo & 15yo, both male.
They get on well enough most of the time, and always have.
Mostly connect over gaming, they chat, soend time together, cook for each other.
Ds1 is quite dogmatic and ds2 just goes along with things for the easy life, except when he decides he doesn't want to and ds1 usually recognises that he gets his own way most of the time and so acquiesces.

Mainly luck I think!

PlanetNormal · 27/07/2022 18:22

Luck, definitely. Me & my younger brother were always very different people with very different outlooks, interests & friends. There was nothing my parents could have done to change that. I was the odd one out in the family, not my brother. Now, as adults, we get on fine when we see each other, but we have little in common and are not close.

Echobelly · 27/07/2022 18:22

Total luck, I think, but I wouldn't avoid having a second for fear of squabbles - very few siblings fall out so badly that it impacts negatively on their lives and while it can be very tedious when kids have patches or even years of fighting, it's not forever.

Our two (DS and an AFAB non-binary one) are three years apart and seem to get on - we're probably heading for a slightly tricky bit when oldest is in mid teens and DS is coming into adolescence and it wouldn't surprise me if they rub one another the wrong way for a while then - even my older sister and I, who got on well, were a bit tetchy at that point. Bickering between them has only been very momentary, like lost tempers on a car journey.

I'll admit, I have seen friends really struggle with kids who are constantly arguing, but it is the exception and not the rule.

Tiredalwaystired · 27/07/2022 18:18

Mine adore each other. One is a stress magnet and the other super chilled. The stress magnet doesn’t trigger the chilled kid so there’s very little friction.

TaraRhu · 27/07/2022 18:17

Mine are 4 and 1. Seem to love each other. They are very young though.

Numbersarefun · 27/07/2022 18:15

My 3 get on well (all in their 20s now). They’ve always got on well but did go through a phase where they didn’t do well as a 3, but any pair would get on.
My DH and I are both one of 3 and we get on well with our siblings and we see each other fairly regularly (although none of us live nearer than 75 miles from each other) so I guess they’ve had that modelled to them growing up.

Ticksallboxes · 27/07/2022 18:12

They say you're defined not by your relationship with your parents but with your siblings.

I have got on really well with my sister since she grew taller than me at 14 and I had to respect her. Until then though I was a domineering bully and very territorial with regard to my parents.

Unfortunately I think those years really affected negatively on her self-esteem. She presents like an incredibly confident high-flyer, but has a history of bulimia and cocaine abuse (now resolved).

My DS18 and younger DD15 have a respectful relationship now and are generally lovely people. But DS treated DD horribly for the first ten years of her life. It's had a negative effect on her own self-esteem and he also suffers I think from being 'replaced' in his eyes when she was born (which is exactly how I felt as a toddler too).

I don't really think there's much you can do about it - IME if you either have two girls or a boy and a girl, they'll work any issues out naturally in the end. But unfortunately I don't actually think you can do a huge amount to control it.

MintJulia · 27/07/2022 18:12

I am one of 6, five sisters and a brother.

We are spread in ages so never really played with each other. There was never enough money so we competed with, and resented, each other.

As adults, I am very close to one sister and on good terms with the rest, based on our personalities & interests. The others get on ok but see each other maybe once or twice a year.

I think it's down to luck rather than planning.

Lottsbiffandsmudge · 27/07/2022 18:09

I have 3. DS1 & DS2 are 19 months apart and in consecutive school years. DD is 23 months younger than DS2. So 2 school years below him.
I think age gap has a lot to do with it. I wanted them close together and luckily it worked out for us. They have always been a tight unit. I didn't really have friends over for play dates as they all played together once DD got over the destructive terrible 2s. DS1 is super bossy, DS2 is super laid back DD is super competitive and it all just gelled.
We are on hols at the mo and they are 18, 16 and 15 (DS2 nearly 17) and yes they wind each other up CONSTANTLY which drives me to distraction but both the younger 2 are dreading DS1 leaving in Sept.
I hope they stay close as the get older

I encouraged them to do things together. Especially oitdoor stuff. Tbey lived ib the garden/ at the field and still do. They were all into the same things as each other at the same time. The older 2 have just been in 6th form together which has bonded them even more.
Without DS2 (I call him.my jam in the sandwich) I don't think DS1 and DD would have got on as they are too similar and a 3yr age gap seems trickiest from what my friends say!

Shodan · 27/07/2022 18:07

Mine get on well- but there is a 12 year age gap. Ds1 is 26 and ds2 is 14.

DS1 was very excited to finally have a sibling. They're at very different life stages obviously but ds1 is very caring towards ds2.

As for whether it's my parenting or their natures- I don't know. We're all close generally though (although I'm a single parent, that might make the difference?) and are going on holiday together in a couple of weeks.

I myself have five siblings and only get on with two of them. But that's because two of the other three are dicks and the other one is weird 😄

Roselilly36 · 27/07/2022 18:07

I had a 21 mth gap between my two DS’, they are adults now 21 & 19, they are really close, best friends as well as brothers. They are complete opposites in personality, so that probably helps.

StarShapedWindow · 27/07/2022 18:03

My DC have a 3 year age gap and they row as much as they’re friends. But my brother and I have a 5 year age gap and have always got on really well. I think it’s all down to personality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread