Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if your children get on with one another, do you think it’s because of your parenting or just luck/personalities?

116 replies

Movingsoon21 · 27/07/2022 17:18

DH and I have one DC, seven months. We’ve always said we’d have 2 DC and DH has started asking what age gap we should have before the next one.

But I now know so many siblings who don’t get on at all, that it’s really putting me off having a second DC. I don’t want to deal with constant fighting and I don’t want current DC to have a miserable time arguing with someone at home.

As kids, my siblings and I hated one another and fought non-stop (although we get on fine now), and DH apparently bickered a lot with his DB and they hate each other as adults, which causes a lot of family stress. In both cases I think it’s a mix of personality clashes, exacerbated by certain parenting styles.

If your DC get on / if you’ve always got on with your siblings, do you think it’s because of a particular parenting style that assists sibling relationships, or is it just luck of the draw whether they have clashing personality types etc? If there’s a particular parenting technique I can use to help them get on I would feel more confident in having a second!

OP posts:
A580Hojas · 27/07/2022 20:20

I think this is 99% of the time down to luck/personalities.

I imagine there are very few parents on the planet who actively want their children to dislike or be indifferent to each other as siblings. Surely the vast majority of parents hope their children will get along and bring them up accordingly. If the children then don't get along, it's usually quite a sadness.

CoodleMoodle · 27/07/2022 20:15

Mine are DD8 and DS4, and they both adore and despise one another.

For the latter, most of the time it's because DD doesn't want to play and DS does, or DD does want to play but DS doesn't do it "right" and she gets annoyed. DS can also be quite aggressive when he's cross (we're trying desperately to get this sorted) and DD is often his target.

And then they can be the absolute best of friends, only want each other, miss the other if they're not there (and spend the whole time talking about them!), etc. They play beautifully together when they really try and it's my favourite thing in the world. It doesn't ever last for long enough and I really try to enjoy it when it does!

Blahdeblahaha · 27/07/2022 20:09

Ds 11 and DD 9 15 months between them and they bicker like cat and dog, they play together regularly but usually ends up with one falling out with the other. Both have strong personalities but Ds has always been a bit emotionally stunted and struggled with recognising how to deal with situations. He is getting better the older he gets, but it's always felt a bit weird that he has had to actively learn these things rather than it coming naturally from observation. DD loves her brother to bits, pretty sure DS loves his sister a lot too but it isn't as obvious!

Paintsplat · 27/07/2022 20:08

I appreciate its not what you're asking OP, but my mum's parenting definitely drove wedges between me and my siblings and it set us on a path of being very distant. I have a twin and we were close as young children but he was adored/babied initially then scapegoated when older. Older sibling was golden child. One thing that is noticeable to me is we were never encouraged to spend any time together, show concern for each other etc. That pattern naturally continued and is something me and eldest had to essentially learn for the first time once we were young adults. Unfortunately my twin felt so disconnected he left home at 16 and never looked back, I've tried to build a relationship but he has kept a polite distance. I do genuinely wonder sometimes how things would have turned out if we had been parented differently. In our case there were no obvious barriers though (eg no extremes of personality, or disabilities that are likely to have an impact on each other)

Vates · 27/07/2022 20:07

My Sister and I have 14 months between us. My Sister was the favoured child, first born. We got along to a certain degree as youngsters. My Sister turned into Satan as a teenager but she blonde, pretty and slim so my Mum lived through her (my Mum was obese and ginger; like me! as a teenager).

I honestly wished my Sister dead as a teenager. She was a total bully. Popular girl in school due to her looks and got good grades. She slapped me in front of my friends, as in straight across the face, as I was going to a concert with a friend outside of school. The worst thing she ever said to me was after bullying me for hours was 'if I was as fat and ugly as you then I'd kill myself'. Also I remember the twin towers falling but only because I was in sixth form, Sister year above me, literally punched me in the face (can't remember what displeased her at the time!).

Hated her as an early adult. Only became useful to her when she got a dog and I looked after them whilst she was at work. She finally matured during these years and I am close to her now. We lost our Mum unexpectedly 10 years ago which brought us closer.

She is Mum to two lovely children, she just morphed into an amazing Mum. As a child I thought she was horrid but adore her now.

Heatstrokeunsteady · 27/07/2022 20:05

They go through stages throughout their lives. So their relationship will vary with age and whatever else is going on. Of course you can do the groundwork by being fair, good tempered and encouraging sharing, talking through problems etc

imnotthatkindofmum · 27/07/2022 20:05

I have 3 girls. First 2 just under 2 years apart, get on very well generally (now 13 and 15, never actually had a time when they really couldn't get on, obviously have had fights and disagreements but not on a daily basis and not the norm) they are very different but have always hung out together when not at school and generally have fun. As teenagers they do spend more time on their own now but still together frequently.

3rd girl is 5 years younger than middle. She's now 8. The other 2 get pissed off with her as she is irritating.....as they were when they were 8! But they look after her and happily do stuff with her if I ask. (Eg 13 did tie dye with her tidal as I'd started but needed to get 15 from a friends) The only thing they argue about is putting her to bed 🤷🏻‍♀️

I think in the long runs closer age gap is easier in terms of getting on with each other though I can't speak for girl boy combination!

bonnieliesovertheocean · 27/07/2022 20:03

I have ds 18 and dd 16. When they were young they were totally unconnected, No fights but minimal interaction. ds had no time for dd although she probably would have like him to be more involved. For the last couple of years, they have discovered many areas they have in common and now often choose to go out together to movies or events. They get on really well and I am delighted. I, like a pp put it down to mostly luck although we tend to be a very respectful family to each other in general ie. Would never insult each other or speak rudely even if we have disagreements.

I have a younger brother with a 2.5 year age gap and we fought a lot when kids, physical and verbal but we were tight if we were both in trouble. We are close as adults and love spending time together with our respective families although we live in different countries. Maybe if we were together more often, we would not be so close.

I think it's probably best to go for the gap that suits you and your partner best, treat everyone in the family respectfully, expect the same from your children from a young age and offer the rest up to the universe, fingers crossed! Grin

lugeforlife · 27/07/2022 20:02

Modelled behaviour? I come from a family where siblings were close all the way up the chain on both sides. My parents were close to their brother, grandparents to theirs etc.

I was close to mine with 3 years difference (boy then girl). Probably a few years from when I was 10 where we argued a lot then close from mid teens onward. Dhs family full
of arguments and going nc on both side.

Mine are a nightmare - super close then hate each other. I find it distressing tbh as it was one of my most important relationships and I wanted that for them. Fingers crossed they'll move through this (early teens).

CatherinedeBourgh · 27/07/2022 19:58

I have a 15 yo and a 12 yo. They get along incredibly well.

I think it's mostly luck. They like similar things, and enjoy spending time together. They are also home ed, so spend a lot of time together.

The fact that ds1 is a bloody saint with the things he puts up with from his brother probably plays a part in it too. The only parenting thing we do with regards to their relationship is pull ds2 up every so often when he takes his brother a bit too much for granted.

I was always very close to my older sister (2 years older) and to this day I consider her my best friend.

Lomex · 27/07/2022 19:56

Ours love each other and I've always thought it's due to the personality of the older one. He's so patient and caring and always hated it when the younger one was upset, and therefore the younger one never had any reason to do anything other than adore him, as he was just another loving, older person, who always looked after him and cared for him. It's very sweet.

TheVillageBaker · 27/07/2022 19:54

DS1 and DS2 are 15 months apart and adore eachother. They couldn't be more different personality wise, but there's never been a cross word between them. DS2 and DD on the other hand 🙄I'm sure they used to disagree on things when she was still a bump! It's exhausting and I'm hoping they will get along better as adults. I didn't particularly get along with my sister when we were children, but now we're great friends.

Lilyhatesjaz · 27/07/2022 19:54

I have a 22 month age gap between my children they are now both in their 20s. They have always got on really well mostly I think by luck. DS is the most chilled person in the world and would often give in to DD, for an easy life and because he loves her.
Right from the beginning though I stamped down really hard on any signs of nastiness would not allow things like name calling which caused so much trouble with my sibling, and I think this helped.

TheOldLadyOfThreadneedleStreet · 27/07/2022 19:53

Mine DC are 19 and 16. They get on fine now, but are not very close. The eldest was always disinterested in the youngest, they never played together much at all. Though they didn’t fight / bicker much either! I always tried to give attention to both of them , the eldest did loads of sports , the youngest a lot of varied hobbies. I tried to facilitate both and to play with them individually. It’s always been difficult to do things as a family as they want to do very different things. Though we do all like a day at the seaside!

Dewsberry · 27/07/2022 19:53

I'm not sure it's either.

Mine get on brilliantly but I'm not so sure that's a good thing. A bit of clashing with your siblings is part of learning to stand up for yourself. Mine are too considerate to each other, especially my NT one to her autistic brother, and I worry it's linked to low self esteem and too much "people pleasing".

Alsoplayspiccolo · 27/07/2022 19:49

My 2 are 18 and 16, girl and boy.
DD has ADHD, which has had a big impact on their relationship, I think. She’s less mature than DS and extremely prone to scanning for any perceived favouritism/unfairness. Tbh, she’s hard work to live with a lot of the time.
In contrast, DS is pretty laidback, and finds life (academically and socially) pretty easy.

They get on ok most of the time, but I wouldn’t say they’re super close or particularly supportive of one another, which saddens me.

Growing up, I was one of 4 siblings, with a twin sister and older brother and sister.
My parents did a great job of diving and conquering, putting us against each other, with the result that my older siblings loathed each other, and my brother resented my twin and me for coming along and upsetting the status quo.
He and my twin sister took great enjoyment in bullying me (I was the shy, sensitive, “ good” child), and it continued into adulthood, so I’m NC with both of them.

My mum is a twin too, and hasn’t seen or spoken to her brother for about 20 years, so I do wonder if it’s something that gets passed down, subconsciously.

DH is an only child, as was my dad, so no examples of sibling relationships on those sides.

whiteroseredrose · 27/07/2022 19:45

You can't really predict.

DS and DD, 3.5 years apart really didn't get on during primary school, but after DD started secondary school they got on really well.

They are now 22 and 19 and it is great.

DH and his brother did not get on at all. BIL was 4 year older and used to beat DH up .... until DH grew taller and fought back. They still aren't close tbh.

IAMNOTTHEONE2022 · 27/07/2022 19:40

I made it my life time Mish for my young adult children to get on. I never played them off against each other. I made sure I was there for them, equally. I have separate relationships with them and anything they tell me does not get passed on. They all hang out, without me. They all go out, without me.

I see them most weekends. I am in contact with them, everyday. We tell each other we love each other, everyday. So, yes, I do feel like I have helped cement their relationship. After all, a lot of siblings don't get on because of childhood favouritism, etc.

Looking back at my own childhood, my mother always had favourites, couldn't keep a secret and secretly enjoyed the fact that we didn't get on- and we still don't today. She truly showed me how not to be. And I know she resents the fact that we are all so close. Weirdo.

ManateeFair · 27/07/2022 19:40

I think it’s mostly luck. I get on way better with one of my siblings than I do with the other one and it really is just that one of them has a vastly different personality to mine. We have similar views on many issues, and actually have many similar interests up to a point, but we have such different communication styles and ways of interpreting things, and we tend to react to situations in completely opposite ways, which means we’ve always had a lot of arguments. I love her and we can get on in small doses but we fought like cat and dog when we were in the same house.

PortalooSunset · 27/07/2022 19:39

There's quite a gap between my 2 but on the whole they get on pretty well. There's 2 years between me and dsis, and we get on much better now we no longer live in the same county 😂

RegardingMary · 27/07/2022 19:33

Mum of 4 ages ranging from teen to toddler.

I'd say there's nothing you can do to 'make' them get on. But there's certainly many ways you can foster resentment between them. If one of them feels hard done by they'll take it out on the other, Xmas gifts have to be carefully planned to make sure nobody feels like an after though.

They all generally get along, squabbles here and there as yoh can imagine, a few fights at times too. But we try to be equal and fair and explain our choices which helps.

We also have a weekly board game evening and family meeting where everyone's grievances can be heard without any backlash.

queenofthedryshampoo · 27/07/2022 19:33

I have 3 DC...quite big age gaps as they are 24, 21 and 14. They are all very close and love each other to bits..particularly the 24 and 14 year old. I am not close with my brother at all and we fought like cat and dog as kids so my kids sibling relationships makes me very happy as I know they'll always be there for each other. I think it's mainly luck but I like to think I've modelled how to be a caring person at least.

JustDanceAddict · 27/07/2022 19:26

To add - I don’t think I did anything to help or not help!!

JustDanceAddict · 27/07/2022 19:26

My DCs are young adults now but they get on so well. They have a lot in common and just ‘get’ each other. Their personalities are quite different- DS wears his heart on his sleeve and DD is more reserved.
When they were young they had a real ‘sibling’ relationship but have always been great company for each other (less than 2 years between them).

YerAWizardHarry · 27/07/2022 19:25

DS and DSS are almost 10 and almost 7. They’ve been in each other’s lives almost 6 years now and they love the bones of each other and play beautifully together. They do however get a “break” from one another when they’re at their other parents’ house