Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if your children get on with one another, do you think it’s because of your parenting or just luck/personalities?

116 replies

Movingsoon21 · 27/07/2022 17:18

DH and I have one DC, seven months. We’ve always said we’d have 2 DC and DH has started asking what age gap we should have before the next one.

But I now know so many siblings who don’t get on at all, that it’s really putting me off having a second DC. I don’t want to deal with constant fighting and I don’t want current DC to have a miserable time arguing with someone at home.

As kids, my siblings and I hated one another and fought non-stop (although we get on fine now), and DH apparently bickered a lot with his DB and they hate each other as adults, which causes a lot of family stress. In both cases I think it’s a mix of personality clashes, exacerbated by certain parenting styles.

If your DC get on / if you’ve always got on with your siblings, do you think it’s because of a particular parenting style that assists sibling relationships, or is it just luck of the draw whether they have clashing personality types etc? If there’s a particular parenting technique I can use to help them get on I would feel more confident in having a second!

OP posts:
GeriTheBerry · 28/07/2022 00:24

DS adored DD from the day she was born and they are incredibly close well over a decade later. Just luck. I think as a parent you can harm their relationship ( eg through favouritism or unfairness) but you can’t force them to get on. The best you can do is model good relationships.

JaninaDuszejko · 28/07/2022 00:23

Don't you know the first rule of parenting? If your DC does something good it's clearly due to your excellent parenting but if they do something bad it's their personality and there's nothing you could have done to prevent it.

Zoeyclash · 28/07/2022 00:20

My two boys are aged 10 and 12 and they argue with each other around the clock. I find it really really difficult listening to them bickering and picking at each other ALL THE TIME. I need to read that book recommended by a PP.

Gingersay · 28/07/2022 00:16

My dds are 12 and 10 very different personalities dd12 is very academic and focused, dd10 is a totally comedian and full of carry on. But they are the best of friends, yes they bicker but they have each others backs.
I always tell them they have to look out for each other which they really do.
I also have an older sister with the same age gap we were extremely close growing up and despite our lives taking very different paths we remain very close in our 40s.

DoIDareSayAnything · 28/07/2022 00:13

My two get on well. There is a 6 year age gap though and DS1 is the most laid back easy going person you will ever meet. He is just amused by his little brother's antics.

DS2 is also pretty chill but can be more of a pain in the arse and for some reason seeks to compete against DS1 when no competition is necessary.

lastminutedotcom22 · 27/07/2022 23:51

Mine are 6 and 3 and argue all the time so much so I've booked them into the childminders when I've taken leave and cancelled some of my leave over summer as I can't stand it
Move used the excuse we are short staffed at work however the reality is I bloody hate it!

Sideorderofchips · 27/07/2022 23:48

I have 3 very strong willed children ages 15,11 and nearly 7

Safe to say some days they would rsther be an only child. Other days they are amazing with each other and a joy to watch

mindutopia · 27/07/2022 23:46

I have literally not known anyone who would claim their dc get along well. 😂 Mine are 9 and 4 and they do love each other but they could literally have an absolute knock out, hair pulling fight about whether the sky was blue. I truly don’t know anyone in real life whose experience with dc over about 3/4 is any different.

Dh and BIL are absolute best friends now in their 30s, but Dh still has the scare on his forehead from BIL taking an axe to his head when they were 10/13.

badg3r · 27/07/2022 23:39

I think it is a mix of personality, age gap and parenting.

Exhaustedpenguin · 27/07/2022 23:19

Mine are 22 months apart (DD 12 and DS 10) and they are the best of friends. DS 10 is starting to really miss her as she spends more time with her friends. They will play for hours happily with the lego and it was in lockdown especially that i realised just how close they were. Every day together, through home schooling and they loved every moment, whilst DH and I were ready to kill each other!

I'm sure it's luck though and nothing to do with our parenting!

Angelinflipflops · 27/07/2022 23:11

I think parental relationship is a role model to a certain extent

7spanishangels · 27/07/2022 23:08

i have 2 sons. My oldest is 32 and my youngest 22. My oldest recently moved home as he has been diagnosed with bi polar and is finding life hard and needed support. My youngest has just graduated and taking a couple of months out and has every day been there for his brother from encouraging him to get out of bed and shower and dress to going out for lunch and helping him with his medication. I’m shocked they are now so close as they ignored each other growing up

Movingsoon21 · 27/07/2022 22:09

Oh dear, mainly seems to be luck. Not sure I want to roll that dice. @Trivester thst may be true but I’m not sure it would be good for me and my stress levels!

OP posts:
Trivester · 27/07/2022 21:22

18 months between mine and they’re mortal enemies in between being best friends.

I’m sure I’ve heard that siblings have longer marriages on average than onlies, supposedly because they learn conflict resolution and long term relationship skills. Friends can walk away but you’re stuck with siblings and have to work it out.

so all that squabbling is good for them.

Quail15 · 27/07/2022 21:05

My dd is nearly 4 and my ds 18 months. Ds adores his big sister. He follows her everywhere, he calls her name all the time and constantly wants to hug and play with her .... Unfortunately my DD is not overly impressed by him. She loves a hug but only on her terms and doesn't want to play with him. she has no tolerance yet for him so she tries to avoid him when she can. I'm hoping they will learn to at least tolerate each other as they get a bit older.

DianaBarry5 · 27/07/2022 21:02

Encouraging friendship between them

Wonderingmum77 · 27/07/2022 20:40

Me and my sibling never got on. But as I’ve grown older I’ve come to see it was 8000000000% my parents fault.

everything always played off of each other. Always “well your sibling has done this so well” we were encouraged to snitch on each other.

even into adulthood my sibling still tries to fight for our parents attention. “My parents will always love me more because I gave them their first grandchild”

wonderstuff · 27/07/2022 20:39

I really didn’t get on with my brother, we fought like cat and dog and then stopped talking. I don’t remember my parents ever trying to make peace, my mum would get upset, but I don’t remember her helping much. I could be wrong.
However even with us not getting on I’m still glad for him, as adults we rub along okay and help each other out, when my father died it was good to have someone who understood.

My kids get on well, some of that is luck, they’ve got more common ground than db and I, but I also do try to get them to understand each other, be sympathetic and forgiving. My db and I would physically fight and I just wouldn’t tolerate that, different times.

MakkaPakkas · 27/07/2022 20:36

My two get on really well DS and a DD with a 2.5 year age gap. There is a lot of luck involved. I think it helped that when DD was born she was a very difficult baby so she didn't oust DS as the most loved - putting him to bed was a wonderful break from DDs screaming for whoever's turn it was. Now they're older it helps that he is very chilled out and nerdy and she is very kind & is nerdy in a complimentary way. Two with the personality of DD would fight like cat and dog. Two with the personality of DS would ignore one another most of the time or be playing DnD every waking hour

bluesky45 · 27/07/2022 20:35

Me and my sister didn't get on as kids but we get on fine in small doses now. Definitely a personality thing. My 2 ds get on well (for the most part!) And I'd love to say it's parenting but I think it's just their age/personality. They do argue but they are also best friends. There's only 18months between them and they are 3 and 4.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 27/07/2022 20:30

Mine get on great 18 months between them.
Firm friends.
My bro and I get on but we did fight a lot. We used to box so it was quite a sight when we went at it.
DP hates her sister but is close with her brother.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 27/07/2022 20:30

My two are adopted. 15 months apart, DD6 & DD5. They get on really well probably 80% of the time. They have plenty of scraps but usually make up within a few minutes, although the scraps have started to get more pinching, scratching and hair pulling, which I’m desperately trying to stop they’re generally over before I have chance to get involved!!

It’s usually 6 of one, 1/2 a dozen of the other, eldest tries to boss youngest, youngest gives no fucks and is generally annoying in the way only the youngest child can be! but they laugh a lot and play together ever so well.

I’m really hoping they stay close as they get older. I know it’s down to luck, and personality but that feeling that they have each other’s back in time of need must be very comforting.

MatildaJayne · 27/07/2022 20:28

My DB and DSis got on really well as children, just a couple of years between them. I was a lot younger so never really at the same stage. Nowadays they can’t stand each other! Partly due to their OHs who don’t get on either. I’m the go-between, which is weird as I wouldn’t say it’s a natural role for me.

My 3 DSes get on OK. DS1 and DS3 get on fine but not best friends or anything. A 5 year age gap and differing personalities. DS2 has ASD so doesn’t really interact much with the other two. I had smallish gaps, 2-3 years, they’re all the same sex and that helped when planning activities as they like fairly similar things, though DS1 got a bit bored of things DS3 could also do.

MeditationAndMusic · 27/07/2022 20:24

My kids are 18 and 13 and have always been close. I think for us it’s a combination of personality, parenting and age gap.

With just over a 5 year age gap, there was no room for physical fighting/pushing as obviously the younger one could have been really hurt. My son always did the older brother thing very well and my daughter really looks up to him. My daughter is more prone to worrying and my son is very laid back so he helps her a lot. I think the age gap also meant there’s never really been competition between them that so many siblings seem to have. Their personality is quite different in lots of ways but they just seem to get on. And they both love gaming.

We’re not particularly close our siblings so I really
wanted to encourage my own children to be close. We’ve always done lots as a family, the 4 of us are very close, probably due to not having lots of close extended family. My son will be off to Uni next year, my daughter is trying to persuade him to live at home. 😢 I’ve told him not to make a decision based on this but I know it’s weighing on his mind.

Goodskin46 · 27/07/2022 20:21

I have a sister 2.5years younger than me and she is my best friend in the whole world. The day of her birth is my first memory, we got on from that day. Nature/ nurture ? Who knows. In light of our relationship we have both replicated the same gap for our DCs, mine get along OK (DS18, DD 15) but not super close like we were as teens (we shared vlothes make up and boyfriends).