Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a third baby? DH doesn’t and I am 10 wks pregnant

208 replies

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 01:21

No anti abortion haters please. DH and I DTD loosely knowing i was in my window and now I am 8-10 wks pregnant. I am one of three kids and my mum never had enough time for us, and I always said I just wanted 2 healthy kids and DH agreed. DD1 had severe health issues as a baby that she has luckily grown out of but the strain on our marriage was hard due to stress, anxiety of her health and years of lack of sleep: not to mention traumatic labour leaving me with broken coccyx.

We reluctantly agreed we didn’t want DD1 to be an only child, and ironically our own siblings have all been shit in the last 18 months so perhaps we shouldn’t have focused on giving her a sibling. But we did: and My DD2 was born with a genetic condition that is totally life limiting, she is registered disabled, and yet she’s the cutest baby around (aged 18 months but looks younger). We know the future will be hard - we have been told by professionals- we just don’t know exactly what it will look like. I’m so sick of people saying look at what you do have tho. We have lost our future as a couple; individuals and as a family - we know all the things we will never be able to do, and that she won’t work or live alone, for example.

Of course we are trying our best but we are devastated for her and for her sister who I fear will need to be her carer when we are gone. I look at DD1 sleeping at night and cry for her future; for the sibling she hasn’t got; and for everything I’ve done to keep her a happy healthy child. DD2 is our lifelong project, we love her dearly too and work really hard and spend a lot of money doing our best for her.

I want a DC3 to be a sibling/ support to DD1 and a role model/ friend to DD2. Many parents I’ve come across with same rare condition found having a third / subsequent child very healing and selfishly I really want this too; to have all the cuddles and experiences I had with DD1 that I didn’t get with DD2 due to her horrific birth and NICU experience.

DH is totally in fear of it happening again/ anything else going wrong which I totally get. We argue loads and are not in a good place:

yet we are both turning 40 soon so time is really running out. I feel like I can cope with a third child but if DH not on board I don’t know what to do. AIBU to want It anyway and go against his wishes?

Ps DD2 condition statistically impossible to happen again and would be tested for in pregnancy

OP posts:
lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 06:36

You’re right I used the wrong words I should’ve not said ‘need to be’ as we will work hard to ensure this won’t happen and I would never ask it of DD1. I wrote it in the middle of the night when I couldn’t sleep.

OP posts:
Cyberworrier · 27/07/2022 06:36

What a difficult situation.

I know it's hard but I think you need to try to unpick being pregnant from your situation with your two children.
Counselling is a good idea, by yourself and possibly with your partner?
You definitely need to talk to him. It is your body and your decision ultimately, but of course there's a chance that what you decide will affect your relationship and everything going forward. This could be very difficult with a disabled child I imagine?

I have a disabled relative who has one sibling. The sibling was involved in care/decisions about relatives future in their twenties. But being the sibling of a severely disabled person definitely impacted their childhood/adolescence and ultimately relationship with their parents. They moved abroad in their thirties and now their parents are old, my sibling and I are having to take on some of the responsibilities for disabled relative (which we're happy to).
I've said all this as a way of saying- I think I get it OP. It's really difficult being the sibling of a severely disabled person. Especially if you're the only sibling perhaps. I know there's a chance child 3 and child 1 won't be particularly close, but they may well be.

I think if you do proceed with the pregnancy, in fact either way, family counselling is really important. As is time for your first child to have space away from their sibling, as so often the entire family dynamic is dominated by the disabled child understandably but that can be difficult for the other child.

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 06:33

Thanks all for your responses and sorry if the original post wasn’t clear: in no way to I expect DD1 to become a carer for her sister, we actively are planning for that not to happen and financially planning/ worrying about it already. But as others have said this can happen in these situations and she is already a gentle, kind and loving big sister. I would actively encourage her to move to a Australia or do anything she wants as an adult, she deserves to be happy.

I also don’t ‘expect’ anything from an unborn child. The question of ‘what happens if something goes wrong’ is the one that we can’t get our head around though. I think I’d be totally broken. I guess I had the same images of family life in my head as everyone else, but it was not meant to be for us. My DH fears that DD2 will get less resources but I guess I feel able to give her time and energy even if we had another.

Ultimately I don’t want to be a single mum of 3 kids, one of which has real additional needs. I guess I will have to always live with a what if scenario and focus inwards on the two beautiful girls that I do have.

OP posts:
MeenzAmRhoi · 27/07/2022 06:33

redtshirt50 · 27/07/2022 02:19

Sorry for what you're going through right now, it sounds really hard and I understand where you are coming from.

But PP are right.

DD1 will not have to be a carer for DD2 when she is older. That is not her responsibility, she may want to, but she may also want to move to the other side of the world and only come home for holidays.

DC3, if they arrive will also not have to be a support system to DD1 if they don't want to. They could hate each other.

Stop pre-defining roles for your children, one who is not even here yet. It will only push them further away if you force responsibilities on them.

I would listen seriously to your husband on this one. Can you afford a third child without impacting the other two?

What would happen if he left and you had to care for all three children on your own?

Totally agree with this.

I'm sorry to sound harsh but I find it disturbing how you are planning out your own children's futures which are to just be there for their other siblings... That's not why you have more children.

Musti · 27/07/2022 06:27

But you’re already pregnant so it is a different dialogue. I didn’t want a 4th child. I wanted to go back to work and my relationship with my ex wasn’t in a good place. But I got pregnant and couldn’t abort. I did consider it but couldn’t . I’m glad I didn’t.

It sounds like you really want this baby so I can’t see how you can terminate it.

And I can also see how you want some siblings to support each other but please don’t make it their responsibility to do so.

MargotChateau · 27/07/2022 06:24

This sounds like one of those ghastly Jodi Picoult novels like ‘My Sister’s Keeper’. Please don’t raise your daughter with the expectation she will be your other child’s carer!!! And definitely don’t expect her to be a carer or assistant in her siblings care while she grows up.

If the disabled sibling is unable to ever live alone you will have to start planning for that eventually now, and looking to getting her set up in a residential care home when she is older. Her sister CANNOT be expected to take up this role.

I would say keep the baby, but your motivations for having it are really unethical. I think you need some counselling alone and joint therapy. You cannot raise your poor daughter with the expectation she will be her sister’s carer, that’s beyond awful.

DuarPorte · 27/07/2022 06:23

I have read it carefully thanks @user1477391263 . The OP says “her sister who I fear will need to be her carer when we are gone”

DD1 will not “need to be” her carer. Parental resignation/acceptance of this as a “will need to be” certainty will not help DD1’s life chances.

namechange7654 · 27/07/2022 06:22

It doesn't come across very well trying to rationalise the "pros" of having this baby, and the ways in which it might step up and save your whole family.

I know ultimately there's no "good" reason to have a baby, but I feel like if you are going to keep it, it has to be purely because you'll love this child for themselves, like any other child.

Clymene · 27/07/2022 06:20

I suppose the question you have to ask yourself is how will you cope as a single parent? Because it sounds like there's a very real risk your marriage is going to break down.

Hard agree that your husband should have taken a lot more responsibility if he didn't want another child.

Shoxfordian · 27/07/2022 06:18

It sounds as though you have a stressful enough time of it without having an extra child

Creating a fantasy in your head about how they might be friends with one and look after the other sister isn’t helping either. They might dislike both sisters or move to Australia

It’s your decision but whatever you decide you need to sort out reliable contraception in future

Celeryfavour · 27/07/2022 06:16

What a difficult time you've had. I can see why you're hopeful of a healing process but I'm glad you can see that is a selfish thought. It's not a child's responsibility to heal us. Seek counselling, there is a lot you're dealing with here.

Appleblum · 27/07/2022 06:14

I can understand your want for another child and also your DH's worries. However if he really didn't want another child he really shouldn't have been having unprotected sex.

I don't know if I'd go on to have another child though. We often paint this romanticised picture of all our children growing up happily together but the reality is many siblings do not get on in real life at all. And I do not agree with your view that DC3 will be DC1's support system because DC1 will become DC2's carer. That's so limiting and unfair on your children.

justfiveminutes · 27/07/2022 06:04

In your situation, I wouldn't have the third baby. I would fully focus on giving the two I already had the best lives possible. DD1 needs to know that she can have whatever life she wants to have, with your love and support.

It sounds as if all aspects of your life will come under intolerable strain if you proceed with the third pregnancy.

Having said that, you are already pregnant so it is now a huge and difficult decision that must be yours. if you feel that you must proceed, please do not place expectations on your third child and plan for the possibility of parenting alone.

girlmom21 · 27/07/2022 06:04

OP what happens if you have another traumatic birth or if DC3 has a life limiting condition too?

user1477391263 · 27/07/2022 06:02

DD1 absolutely isn’t destined to be DD2’s carer. DD1 is free to move to Australia to study X or Y or to US to study Z and build her career and raise her family there. Accept and encourage her absolute free choices to be free. I cannot believe you are raising her with the notion that she will be a carer for DD2.

The OP said she "fears" DD1 will end up being a carer for DD2 after she is gone, not that she is deliberately raising her to be one.

The reality of these family situations is that this is very often what actually happens, no matter what the parents say or do and no matter how hard the parents try to make the health sibling feel that they are not obliged to do anything in terms of care. The guilt factor and feelings of responsibility in the healthy sibling can create such a difficult situation.

People need to read the OP's post more carefully.

DuarPorte · 27/07/2022 05:53

Is this a Jodi Picoult novel plot?

siblings aren’t meant to be created to be their sibling’s keepers and carers.

Human beings aren’t meant to be created for the “cuddles and the experience”.

DD1 absolutely isn’t destined to be DD2’s carer. DD1 is free to move to Australia to study X or Y or to US to study Z and build her career and raise her family there. Accept and encourage her absolute free choices to be free. I cannot believe you are raising her with the notion that she will be a carer for DD2.

your time energy and resources are clearly heavily needed by your DD2. Splitting these resources further : well, splits them further.

so in other words - not sure what the thinking is.

Cervinia · 27/07/2022 05:43

So hard for you OP. Are there any genetic tests that could eliminate the worries you have about DC3 before you make you’re decision?

Eek3under3 · 27/07/2022 05:39

I think the responses here are harsh. As someone who also had a dd with a life limiting rare genetic condition, I totally get what you are saying. I cried over the family life we wouldn’t have and felt a need to have more children. As it happens, dd1 died after a year, we had another child and I’m 37 weeks pregnant because I want them to have a sibling. It was a roulette for us as the condition is so rare it can’t be tested for.

In your shoes I would get the testing done asap as it seems that will make a huge difference to DH’s anxiety.

Weatherwax13 · 27/07/2022 05:39

You have to completely jettison this fantasy of a DC3's future role in the family. It's utterly bonkers.
You already know that the reality of having DC can differ wildly from what you'd imagined !

Marvellousmadness · 27/07/2022 04:56

But may I add. That if your dh doesn't want any more kids he should get a vasectomy otherwise you'll find yourself in this position again in a years time

Marvellousmadness · 27/07/2022 04:54

Your husband isnt on board
You already feel overwhelmed with 2. And your baby #3 wouldnt be a friend/sibling to #1 in real-life. They could end up hating eachother. Just because they are siblings doesn't mean they will get along.

Look at what you have right now. How full your plate already is

Imagining adding a third child to that mix BUT MINUS a husband. ..

Hugasauras · 27/07/2022 04:50

Please don't groom DD1 into being a carer for your other child. That's not her job or responsibility. If she needs care after you are gone, start putting money aside for it now and think about options that don't involve your other child. Perhaps she will want to be a carer but just as likely she will want to live her own life.

No one here can tell you whether to go ahead or not. But I would be thinking very hard about whether I have the capacity - mentally, emotionally, physically, financially - for another child, and how life would look if I had to do it solo, and how that would affect my existing children as they have to be the priority.

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 27/07/2022 04:20

First of all do not assign DD1s role as carer. That is completely unfair and if I were her as soon as I were old enough I’d move out to uni and be just a little to far away so I could visit but not become a carer. Put plans and money in place for carers.

As for DC3, I can see why you’d go for it to be honest aa long again as there’s no expectation that they would become ‘support’ or ‘carers’.

Ottersmith · 27/07/2022 02:41

I think maybe you have already decided to keep the baby. How would you feel if you had an abortion? Would you regret it? Would you resent your husband. Really it's your decision, not his. People have had way more than three children before and managed just fine. I think as long as you stop assigning roles for them and placing unrealistic expectations on them then you just have to concentrate on what you want to do and how it will make you feel.

There are lots of people here flippantly telling you it will be too hard and to get an abortion. Well it's up to you. They have no idea how you will cope with a third. Your husband knows how babies are made. If he didn't want one he should have used contraception instead of impregnating you and then thinking you can simply have an abortion and all the pain / anguish that may bring you.

RenegadeMatron · 27/07/2022 02:34

The expectations you’re already placing on your unborn third child are completely and utterly unfair.

I feel really sorry for them.