Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a third baby? DH doesn’t and I am 10 wks pregnant

208 replies

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 01:21

No anti abortion haters please. DH and I DTD loosely knowing i was in my window and now I am 8-10 wks pregnant. I am one of three kids and my mum never had enough time for us, and I always said I just wanted 2 healthy kids and DH agreed. DD1 had severe health issues as a baby that she has luckily grown out of but the strain on our marriage was hard due to stress, anxiety of her health and years of lack of sleep: not to mention traumatic labour leaving me with broken coccyx.

We reluctantly agreed we didn’t want DD1 to be an only child, and ironically our own siblings have all been shit in the last 18 months so perhaps we shouldn’t have focused on giving her a sibling. But we did: and My DD2 was born with a genetic condition that is totally life limiting, she is registered disabled, and yet she’s the cutest baby around (aged 18 months but looks younger). We know the future will be hard - we have been told by professionals- we just don’t know exactly what it will look like. I’m so sick of people saying look at what you do have tho. We have lost our future as a couple; individuals and as a family - we know all the things we will never be able to do, and that she won’t work or live alone, for example.

Of course we are trying our best but we are devastated for her and for her sister who I fear will need to be her carer when we are gone. I look at DD1 sleeping at night and cry for her future; for the sibling she hasn’t got; and for everything I’ve done to keep her a happy healthy child. DD2 is our lifelong project, we love her dearly too and work really hard and spend a lot of money doing our best for her.

I want a DC3 to be a sibling/ support to DD1 and a role model/ friend to DD2. Many parents I’ve come across with same rare condition found having a third / subsequent child very healing and selfishly I really want this too; to have all the cuddles and experiences I had with DD1 that I didn’t get with DD2 due to her horrific birth and NICU experience.

DH is totally in fear of it happening again/ anything else going wrong which I totally get. We argue loads and are not in a good place:

yet we are both turning 40 soon so time is really running out. I feel like I can cope with a third child but if DH not on board I don’t know what to do. AIBU to want It anyway and go against his wishes?

Ps DD2 condition statistically impossible to happen again and would be tested for in pregnancy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kateandme · 29/07/2022 04:55

Cyberworrier · 28/07/2022 10:43

@TheSummerPalace

Much of what you say resonates with me about the care system- however, I don't understand how that's meant to help the OP? Or perhaps it's more a general comment?

She has a disabled child already. She's explained she's trying to plan ahead for her care and I'm sure understands the vagaries and unreliability of the care system.

Ok the siblings may not want to have their disabled sibling home for Christmas- but they might? Equally, I might have time to see my (non disabled) sibling- or I might not?

I almost feel like in some posts, not yours Summers, that there's an implication that the disabled child is purely a burden for the family. A suggestion that the parents should place zero expectations on their other child developing a loving sibling relationship with the disabled child for fear that they will be involved, out of guilt not love, in their life as an adult in the way that a family member of a disabled adult in care is (worried about their well-being, involved in some decision making perhaps, having a family relationship...). There's no guarantee of knowing how the sibling relationship will work out but I do find some of the tone pretty ableist and unaccepting of the existence of disabled people within families.

It can be difficult having disabled relatives but it is also ups and downs like any human relationship.

Thankyou so much for saying this.
This is a sister a son a daughter a wife.they aren't a big bag of meat we're told to look after as it festers in the corner making life misery intruding on our lives .it may not look like the lifespan of other or the life plan. But god,you don't no love like it.a families much stronger

Kennykenkencat · 28/07/2022 17:19

fellopswell · 27/07/2022 11:03

@Kennykenkencat
'Not giving your eldest dd a sibling would be cruel'

There is so much wrong with this comment I don't even know where to begin.

This isn’t about only children v having 2 or 3 or more children

This is about primarily a certain set of circumstances that could come to pass.

A young adult having someone to talk to or discuss issues with that only those that are in the household would understand.
Even if the sibling wasn’t interested and gave an opinion that wasn’t something that sounded right. It would be an opinion that would produce a reaction. Or the opinion would produce a reaction of reassurance or a reaction of “that’s a better idea”
Or even if the relationship wasn’t close just to know if things got too much there was someone else there.

The word cruel was something that my friend used to describe their parents being too old to have another child (it wasn’t that his parents were cruel it was the circumstances and timing that was cruel for not being able to have a sibling)

Not having a sibling to step in for 50% of the week so they could both go out and do what 20 somethings do 3/4 nights per week each would have given him a different life from one where he was a prisoner in his own home after work. Not able to leave because there was no one else to help or step in. That was really hard on him

Others on this thread in a similar situation were able to establish a life outside of the family and even have their own families before they had to step into the role of parent and take responsibility for their sibling.

I wonder what would be the outcome if they had to step into f/t parenting role straight after Uni with no time off

Bringingsexybacktomonaghan · 28/07/2022 12:06

Do what you like but own your decision. You're having a third child going into one of the toughest financial crises we will ever live through. You're going to be paying for a family of five. Do it but don't moan if it works out as being more expensive than you thought!

whumpthereitis · 28/07/2022 11:40

WinterMusings · 28/07/2022 07:38

@lydiangel83 im sorry about the difficulties you've had/had with DD's 1&2. It is totally understandable that you want to 'try again' & hope for a well child without complications.

However, putting aside everything else, as it's not relevant, YOU are pregnant, this is YOUR decision. He stopped having a say in whether there was a DC3 or not when he had unprotected sex with you.

He might walk away, but he might do that if you terminate DC3 as well.

He may, but in one scenario she’s ‘only’ looking at being a single parent to two children, rather than being a single parent to three. It absolutely is her decision to make, and part of making a decsion is considering the consequences.

at a time when the cost of living is through the roof, and in a world where men routinely manage to avoid paying maintenance, she absolutely has to assess her capabilities should the worst case scenario occur. People like to say ‘you’ll cope, you’ll find a way’ when they’re not the ones facing the situation themselves, and without any thought to the realities. ‘Following your heart’ can absolutely be disastrous and result in jettisoning a life that, whilst not perfect, was at least manageable. It’s not just OP’s life either, but the lives of her two children.

Cyberworrier · 28/07/2022 10:43

@TheSummerPalace

Much of what you say resonates with me about the care system- however, I don't understand how that's meant to help the OP? Or perhaps it's more a general comment?

She has a disabled child already. She's explained she's trying to plan ahead for her care and I'm sure understands the vagaries and unreliability of the care system.

Ok the siblings may not want to have their disabled sibling home for Christmas- but they might? Equally, I might have time to see my (non disabled) sibling- or I might not?

I almost feel like in some posts, not yours Summers, that there's an implication that the disabled child is purely a burden for the family. A suggestion that the parents should place zero expectations on their other child developing a loving sibling relationship with the disabled child for fear that they will be involved, out of guilt not love, in their life as an adult in the way that a family member of a disabled adult in care is (worried about their well-being, involved in some decision making perhaps, having a family relationship...). There's no guarantee of knowing how the sibling relationship will work out but I do find some of the tone pretty ableist and unaccepting of the existence of disabled people within families.

It can be difficult having disabled relatives but it is also ups and downs like any human relationship.

Sartre · 28/07/2022 10:00

In your situation I would side with your DH personally but as the pregnant woman, it’s your body so completely your choice. If I had a profoundly disabled child I wouldn’t want another child at all. You’re already placing unfair expectations on the unborn third child by suggesting they will be some sort of role model/support network for your existing children. They won’t be that, they’ll just be a regular human being with needs of their own.

Your marriage is already, shall we say, rocky so unsure why you decided to have unprotected sex but there you go. I think a third child would break you by the sound of things, not bring you closer.

TheSummerPalace · 28/07/2022 09:37

We fully plan on ensuring DD2’s life is as financially secure and independent and full as we can be without reliance on our biological family

Unless DD2 can live independently as an adult, you cannot do that, unless you are so wealthy as to be able to pay for all care, for the rest of her life! Even a cheap care home could be £1,000 per week - that’s £52,000 pa x her life expectancy! Way beyond what most parents can afford! Otherwise, she will be at the mercy of the vagaries of public funding for care, which depend on the ideology of the government - listening to the Tories, their rhetoric and squeeze on public spending, suggests to me, they would like to throw care back onto families!

Even if DD were to be in a care home, advocacy and support from the family is still likely to be needed in my experience, because otherwise the tendency is for everyone else in their life like the care home, Social Services and the NHS to think of their own best interests (ie saving money), not DD’s. Look at the last two years of Covid 19! Then there is the social and emotional aspect - residents in care homes still need a family life. The problem is that the healthy siblings are likely to be juggling (full time) careers, children, the housework, etc. They may not have the time and energy to have a sibling with a life limiting condition home for birthdays, Easter, Christmas, an annual holiday, etc!

WinterMusings · 28/07/2022 07:38

@lydiangel83 im sorry about the difficulties you've had/had with DD's 1&2. It is totally understandable that you want to 'try again' & hope for a well child without complications.

However, putting aside everything else, as it's not relevant, YOU are pregnant, this is YOUR decision. He stopped having a say in whether there was a DC3 or not when he had unprotected sex with you.

He might walk away, but he might do that if you terminate DC3 as well.

arrogantorwhat37 · 28/07/2022 07:05

I don't think anyone can guarentee that number 3 will care for/support their siblings; hundreds of threads here revolve around sibling dynamics, rarely in a positive way.
And how much time will you be able to devote to number 3 if number 2 requires so much care (talking about you and DH before anyone jumps on me for suggesting onlu OP will do caring)

kateandme · 28/07/2022 06:37

extrapillow · 27/07/2022 23:40

*OP, its interesting how many posters with disabled siblings either are grateful for having other siblings too or wish they did have for someone else to share the responsibility with. Most posters with disabled family members seem to get where you're coming from. ❤️

I hope that gives you some reassurance or at least counters the posters who don't understand why you possibly would think it's a good idea*

Of course posters in the position of the child with a disabled sibling get where OP is coming from. Because they need to share the burden. But having another children to impose the burden on is massively unfair. Insulate the existing child from the burden, don't widen it

And also get it's never a burden.ever.
hard.tough.f* impossible at times but never ever a burden.and never a choice of whether we'd be there or not.crawling on our hands and knees if we need to be.

kateandme · 28/07/2022 06:34

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:24

As per other messages I absolutely do not intend for DD1 to be a carer. I just know how naturally kind she is and will feel like she should/ want to look after her sister no matter how we persuade her otherwise. We fully plan on ensuring DD2’s life is as financially secure and independent and full as we can be without reliance on our biological family

People are moaning about hervtaking this on.growing up in a family such as this makes you different.gives you different roles and priorities.AND THAT'S OK.op I think ( not having a go) the "able" families folk on this forum just can't get it.
You become stronger,weirder,more attuned in so many ways.you crumble in others.you don't need what others need in life and need lots more in others.avfamily with disabilities are as unique as they come.
Your sister then,may very likely WANT and be determined and absolutely fine to step into mote of a Caring role.if it's done through choice or even half guilt it ok.its not the end of the world.i wouldn't have it any other way.amd would never ever leave my sister. I dont give a shit what life "others" say I need.things change.thwy are f tough but love is tougher.
It's about being open.syruggling together.what rocks you as a family would break others and vice versa.
Don't plan the next 30 years being in this role.trust me it will not go how you plan and will throw easier,better,fantastic bits.abd harder,worse traumatic bits. But can any family guarantee plain sailing?at least you have a semi idea of your journeys!
We had to just STOP being down and predicting or wondering what ifs and what could have been.bwcause no it couldn t.there is no life just given to people.shithappens every day.
Going forward you have to learn to literally take it as it comes.
Plan as u can for what you can control.
30 years in.trust me if laugh at that woman doing what you might think u need to now.and I'd hug her and just say go with it.somwhow you will be ok.
This current pregnancy is another matter.yiu need to discuss it.openly.lay it all out with your dp. Because you have to be able to be in this together.
Support is key.for special needs families it's essential.
You become an unbeatable army.
And the people her siblings have turned out to be are astounding.i no she's taught them alot.i see so much goodness from what they learnt from being in her life.
Yes everyone has had to do things no one should.but fuck it.love is love is love.its beaten all odds and shit.its held on.
Talk op.
And hold on.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 27/07/2022 23:58

TheNestedIf · 27/07/2022 01:55

You have an unfair expectation of your child / children to step into the parental shoes. Stop that, whether or not you have a third. They might not be able to, and they're entitled not to want to.

Absolutely this.

Children should never become the carers for their siblings. You're writing their future for them.

That's not fair now is it?

You need to find ways of healing that don't involve bringing another life into the world.

Whether you continue with this pregnancy is between you and your husband, but don't assume that your kids will get along. I don't know any one who gets along with their siblings, much less wants to care for them later in life.

extrapillow · 27/07/2022 23:40

*OP, its interesting how many posters with disabled siblings either are grateful for having other siblings too or wish they did have for someone else to share the responsibility with. Most posters with disabled family members seem to get where you're coming from. ❤️

I hope that gives you some reassurance or at least counters the posters who don't understand why you possibly would think it's a good idea*

Of course posters in the position of the child with a disabled sibling get where OP is coming from. Because they need to share the burden. But having another children to impose the burden on is massively unfair. Insulate the existing child from the burden, don't widen it

WendellGeez · 27/07/2022 23:19

DC3 might have different ideas about what he/she wants to do with his/her life.

And, it sounds like all your time and other resources are already invested in DC2.

SleepingAgent · 27/07/2022 23:15

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:24

As per other messages I absolutely do not intend for DD1 to be a carer. I just know how naturally kind she is and will feel like she should/ want to look after her sister no matter how we persuade her otherwise. We fully plan on ensuring DD2’s life is as financially secure and independent and full as we can be without reliance on our biological family

Thanks Op. I'm another one who was moved to write my initial rather vitriolic post after reading your OP rather than the full thread so I apologise for not checking for updates first.

I appreciate you coming back to clarify what you meant.

I still think you need to think long and hard about ALL the possible negatives rather than the best case scenario of Dc1/3 having a great relationship etc and weigh this all up before you decide what to do.
And yes your DH needs to get the snip!!

Stopthebusplease · 27/07/2022 22:03

It sounds to me like both OP and her DH subconsciously wanted a third child, as they were both aware that they were having unprotected sex during her fertile time. If as the OP says, they were both truly of a mind that they didn't want a third child, then surely they would have taken steps to permanently prevent this happening, but neither of them did. So it seems to me OP that you need to speak to your DH and tell him that you want to keep the baby, and that if he really didn't want another one it was up to him to have had a vasectomy, he didn't, so now he has to take responsibility for raising another child. If he does walk away, then I feel sure that the fact that you really want this child will see you through whatever comes next.

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:56

Thank you x

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 27/07/2022 21:53

Sorry op. Just read your updates!

Notimeforaname · 27/07/2022 21:51

I want a DC3 to be a sibling/ support to DD1 and a role model/ friend to DD2.

Do not bring a child into the world who already has a job. I understand why you feel how you do but that is not fair to that child.

You sound like a wonderful mother who would love and adore any child she has!! But please try not to have expectations of what they will be/do for their older siblings.

BrownStripePJ · 27/07/2022 21:49

If I was in your shoes I wouldn't go ahead with the pregnancy

Good luck with whatever you decide ❤

Cyberworrier · 27/07/2022 21:40

I think some posters are skimming your answers OP or maybe not differentiating between being "caring" (adjective) and being a "carer" (noun, profession).

The OP has explained her plans for her disabled daughter. It's clear that her care as an adult is being planned for and that they're not expecting D1 to dedicate her life to sisters personal care.

It is not an unreasonable assumption to think that someone with a disabled sibling, even one living in care, will worry about their sibling and will possibly have to make some decisions at some point down the line. Of course D1 might not want to (like my relative who moved abroad partly to escape his family including disabled sibling). But they more likely, hopefully, will stick around and be as functioning and close a family as can be under these difficult circumstances.

My relative was in a care home, all seemed sorted for his future- then funding was cut and it shut down. There is always an element of uncertainty around care, and I suppose anxiety about having a disabled/vulnerable loved one. I know i feel a lot less pressured in my involvement for disabled relative knowing my sibling and I are sharing decision making, worries, ideas etc.

Gah, I've found this thread quite emotional OP, I can't imagine how difficult it has been for you to read. I really hope everything works out for you and your family.

Motnight · 27/07/2022 21:29

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:24

As per other messages I absolutely do not intend for DD1 to be a carer. I just know how naturally kind she is and will feel like she should/ want to look after her sister no matter how we persuade her otherwise. We fully plan on ensuring DD2’s life is as financially secure and independent and full as we can be without reliance on our biological family

How old is dd1 that you know all this, Op? She can be kind and loving without wanting to be a carer for her sibling. I don't think that you are aware of the responsibility that you are putting onto your dd regarding this, and it's unfair.

lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:24

As per other messages I absolutely do not intend for DD1 to be a carer. I just know how naturally kind she is and will feel like she should/ want to look after her sister no matter how we persuade her otherwise. We fully plan on ensuring DD2’s life is as financially secure and independent and full as we can be without reliance on our biological family

OP posts:
lydiangel83 · 27/07/2022 21:22

Genetic but not hereditary happened by chance at conception. Can test for it and would definitely test for it.

OP posts:
Mummyof287 · 27/07/2022 20:44

You've said you want this baby, so surely there is no decision to be made?

I agree with PP that it was incredibly reckless of you and DH to not think having a third child through carefully beforehand, considering the responsibilities and pressures you already face... your disabled DC and the difficulties in your and DH's relationship.

But it's happened now, and him trying to make you feel bad about it, or suggest not having the baby, is very unfair...He was knowingly just as much a part of creating the baby as you were when you both didn't take precautions.

It must be a very scary and overwhelming time for you both, but he needs to accept what has happened, and you need to both unite, perhaps get some relationship therapy, think about additional support you might need to put in place for middle DD once baby arrives, and buckle up together for the ride.Your children need you to.

FWIW a mum of a child in DD's reception class has 3 DCs (middle one aged about 3ish has a life-limiting disability, think its a genetic condition) I don't know her well, or if the 3rd baby was planned, but on the face of it, whilst i'm sure she faces incredible challenges and mum guilt at times, she is coping well with everything and seems happy with the situation.But I suppose everyone is different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread