Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people on mumsnet are not from this world?

57 replies

AmICrazy1 · 27/07/2022 00:07

Or rather most people on mumsnet. I’m shocked very often of how people react. I’m half way through reading a thread that’s 9 pages long and I’m gobsmacked by some of the comments. Seriously people cannot be living in the same world as me. I’m not gonna say what thread as I don’t want to draw attention to the poor OP whose having a hard time. I keep reading the comments and shocked. It’s not even a huge thing it’s an everyday question she/he asked.

at least 3 or 4 threads a week seem to be like this more and more I would say recently. Does anyone else feel like this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
the80sweregreat · 27/07/2022 09:12

The ones I have a problem with are they people who take one sentence from a posters paragraph and it's then taken out of context when the rest of what they wrote is perfectly reasonable and concedes certain points.
It can be very brutal. Going against the tide of the general consensus is so hard on here too , some threads are just echo chambers and woe betide the one with a different point of view.
It can also be supportive and have some very good advice too though and it's good people have an anonymous place to post. People are rarely as blunt in real life. It's also made me think a lot too.

Ticksallboxes · 27/07/2022 09:09

worraliberty · 27/07/2022 00:22

It's a massive website.

Some people are completely batshit, some are quite sensible, some are nasty, some are passive aggressive, some are proper wet lettuces and some are drama llamas.

No different to real life really, but the batshit-ness is what keeps me here 😁

This!!

Floogal · 27/07/2022 08:57

I admit I have noticed a lot of misandry, classism, job shaming, and anti-autistic ableism on MN. As well as "ugh, everyone fancies me" threads.

However my personal favourite is:
"My husband is fat and gives me the Ick" threads.
Mumsnet replies are along the lines of "YANBu, LTB. He sounds disgusting!".

Followed by:
"DH spends to much time at the gym/cycling/playing golf/playing football".
Mumsnet replies are along the lines of "LTB, he's a hobby obsessed man-child who's vain".

Anyone else see the contradiction?

OhMerde · 27/07/2022 07:59

ImustLearn2Cook · 27/07/2022 01:57

@AmICrazy1 I get where you are coming from. So many threads and I am blown away by how nasty some comments are and the resulting pile on. Then there are the most ridiculous assumptions being said with absolute certainty as if it were fact. You do have to wonder what planet some of these people are they from.

People often say that posters on here are nasty, too forthright, there's a pile-on etc. I've honestly seen very little of that and I've been here for donkeys years. People are often blunt, straight-talking and no-nonsense but rarely nasty. People do say things that they wouldnt say IRL but that's the beauty of it. You get honest opinions that social niceties put a stop to IRL. If you want to be brought back down to earth and a cold dose of reality, this is the place for it.

User34352515 · 27/07/2022 07:33

Classic MN scenarios:

Q: OP posts a thread describing any type of negative behaviour from DH
A: She must leave that bastard immediately and made to feel like she will be a weak, non self-respecting doormat if she chooses to stay. Of course, many posters have no idea what sort of context exists outside the behaviour described, and are probably not living in the lap of happiness or luxury themselves but still instructing OP to do exactly what they did.

Q: OP posts a thread describing disruptive/unpleasant behaviour from children
A: Lots of thoughtful responses from parents of children with ASD/ADHD which leads OP to consider assessment or re-evaluate the situation with more compassion.

Q: OP posts a thread describing unpleasant or odd behaviour from an adult, either DH/PIL/sibling/friend
A: Said adult is an utter garbage human being and any sort of remote suggestion that they might have undiagnosed ND issues is absolutely forbidden. You must NEVER EVER equate bad behaviour in adults with ASD/ADD, regardless of the fact that both disorders were far less known let alone diagnosed & treated many decades ago. Interestingly, the most vehement crusaders on MN of forbidding anyone to suggest that difficult behaviour in adults could potentially be ND are ND adults who have been diagnosed themselves.

Q: Literally anything about Meghan & Harry
A: You are racist. Don't even think of going any further.

Q: OP is worried about how much her toddler eats and posts a typical daily meal plan which clearly contains more food and calories than most full grown adults eat.
A: Unanimous agreement that it's "perfect normal and healthy" and all kids "need the calories". This is odd considering 1/3 of UK adults are obese and the weight boards on MN are full of people with extremely unhappy relationships with food stemming from childhood.

C0mfyChairP0se · 27/07/2022 07:29

I do think that when my DC were tiny and I lived with my parents (helpful financially but controlling, and they projected a lot on to me) posting all my opinions did make me feel a bit more heard, a bit more important. It was subconscious, but I can see why people get in to the habit of handing posters their arse on a plate.

They feel higher up the food chain, for a moment.
It's fleeting though, so, rinse and repeat until they get a job/leave the loser/find themselves or all three.

JohannSebastianBach · 27/07/2022 07:26

@florianfortescue I made the mistake of asking a completely innocuous question on a thread yesterday.
Got called allsorts entitled, thick and various other things.

Apparently you should never ask others, that's lazy. You should only ever Google.

Ironically the thread was about people being rude. Sigh.

Lilacmintgreen · 27/07/2022 07:12

I think there’s always been a tendency towards aggression, to be honest.

But there were safe havens in years gone by - relationships would be generally supportive, as would parenting and SEN. Also, a lot of the aggression was at least informed and sometimes very funny.

My personal feeling is that a lot of posters try to replicate those sorts of replies but they are so far off the mark. What they think is biting sarcasm is actually just rude and stupid. So a post like DH keeps leaving the windows open during the day and I’ve talked to him about it and about how unsafe I feel and he agrees it’s wrong but then a week later does it again - help and the first reply is I don’t know OP, have you ever considered … talking to him about it Confused and then replies come in like how does the OP manage to do anything in life if she has to come to MN about how to close a window and so on.

They aren’t funny and they aren’t remotely helpful. They are just spiteful and cruel.

Sometimes you do just strike lucky with a thread. I had one a while ago about DS sleep which was really helpful, not least because as well as practical advice it ‘allowed’ me to vent a bit about the impact poor sleep was having on me. But for the most part you do get responses that are curt and commanding in nature.

Bpdqueen · 27/07/2022 07:10

The whole point of anonymous posting is to allow people to give their honest opinions and sometimes harsh truths if the OP doesn't want that they might aswell just ask family and friends who will sugar-coat it for them

Oblomov22 · 27/07/2022 07:08

I find MN'ers wierd. They are either incredibly intelligent or dim as fuck. Where are the middle ground people, normal, non anxiety ridden.

One minute I'm on a feminism thread re Maya Forstater, solicitors explaining it all to us idiots, non solicitors understanding complicated legal stuff. I'm thinking I'm out of my league here.

Then I jump to AIBU. Do I need to .... shall I go to the beach with a baby, last week in 40 degree hottest day in UK history. God, these people are stupid I think!

balalake · 27/07/2022 07:08

It's not just on Mumsnet.

StRaphael · 27/07/2022 07:06

Over the years I’ve noticed the site get more and more aggressive. I think new people join and follow in tone.

Oblomov22 · 27/07/2022 07:02

@C0mfyChairP0se , no file? Phew! Wink

But seriously, I disagree. No point telling them they shouldn't of ..... No, they do need telling. Most of them STILL can't see, because they don't have the emotional savviness to understand that they never should've married that twat. Most are so emotionally damaged, such low self esteem, that this hasn't actually dawned on them yet, or rather not truely sunk in.

georgarina · 27/07/2022 07:00

People love a pile on. I would never post a sensitive question on AIBU 😂

LadyCatStark · 27/07/2022 06:52

It’s always been the way. The first few responses set the tone and people just post more and more OTT responses to try to get noticed. If you’re unlucky enough to get a count let of negative responses to start with, you’ve had it. Two threads about a similar thing can get two totally different responses.

toohotforthistwinmummy · 27/07/2022 06:45

recently I’ve felt that unless you post about a SAHM or about a partner cheating in AIBU you get very little response. People really only want the mega drama, the rest of the everyday topics which are still so important get very little response

C0mfyChairP0se · 27/07/2022 06:37

Well there's no point telling somebody (eg) you shouldn't have bought in 2007/ had another baby with him / given him another chance / should have left already/ married him. They know they have a problem to solve, with no easy solutions. That's why they post.

I don't think I've seen you do a drive by '' you brought this on yourself'' kind of post @Oblomov22 could be wrong! I don't have a file on you.

justfiveminutes · 27/07/2022 06:33

I worry when an op is advised with some certainty to take a very absolute course of action based on the scantest, one-sided evidence.

I worry about the other people in op's life, who will be affected if op takes the mn advice.

I have seen people advised to LTB, go NC with family and so on and I often think - op could have MH issues or just be at fault in this situation, they themselves could be the mn-favourite 'narcissist' and here we are telling her to cut off a friend/partner/adult child who may be innocent.

florianfortescue · 27/07/2022 06:28

I find the aggression and hostility hard to understand sometimes. Someone can ask a perfectly innocuous question and a bunch of keyboard warriors will jump on them to say some version of "so you think you're better than everyone else? You sound like hard work, give your head a wobble." It's really tiresome and makes the site less enjoyable for sure.

There are still so many pockets of empathy and humour and brilliant advice though so I keep coming back!

IncompleteSenten · 27/07/2022 06:27

No.
You only need to read the news, watch you tube, go on FB etc to clearly see the full range of human beings! From saintly to puppy murdering for likes and everything in between.

We each inhabit a miniscule piece of the world and tend to fill it with people like ourselves.

Doesn't mean the rest of the human race isn't out there, very different, very real

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 27/07/2022 06:23

I find it quite refreshing to read peoples honest opinions and thought processes. Its taught me to be a better listener, read between the lines. Online people watching if you will.

I find it v annoying when people get hung up on linguistics AFTER the op has clarified what she meant.

Rinatinabina · 27/07/2022 06:13

I think there is just so much stumbling over whether a post was worded “right” or whether a question should even be asked. I think it’s symptomatic of public discourse becoming increasingly difficult. Instead of dealing with a question or comment posed by an OP poster rationally, posters can easily spiral into purity circles or attacking the OP’s character. Posters regularly compete to show how empathetic they are by tearing down an OP for not being empathetic enough.

I disagree quite a lot with posters, I don’t think I’ve ever criticised how a post has been worded, I may ask for clarification. I also don’t think OP means posters can’t disagree. I’ve seen perfectly reasonable pondering turn into war zones. It’s an utter shame really because questions that can bring to light different perspectives/experiences descend into a fight. it has echos of the whole culture war attitude, attack people instead of their arguments.

Oblomov22 · 27/07/2022 06:12

I'm not reading enough threads then. Or not enough meaty ones, contentious ones. I don't recognise what OP is talking about.

@C0mfyChairP0se : "but what emotionally healthy person wants to tell somebody that her problems are her own fault (or version of that judgement)"
I do that. Most peoples problems are often their own fault. We all make choices. Mostly, They made those choices so need to take personal responsibility for them. I don't see what your issue with that is.

EinsteinaGogo · 27/07/2022 06:07

You're not wrong, OP.

For me, it can be summed up by the post where an OP's was very upset that her nasty brother in law has named his dog after her - literally called it exactly the same name as her.

Many, many posters telling her it's a compliment and to get over herself 🙈🙈

girlmom21 · 27/07/2022 05:56

There's no disputing that some people are absolutely batshit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread