Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you have the number of children you have?

258 replies

TheGeoffLinton · 26/07/2022 21:35

I keep hearing that we’re having too few children to maintain the population. It seems to be a problem in a few countries in the West now. Often practical reasons are cited - having children later due to expensive childcare and not being able to get on the housing ladder means having fewer children. Sometimes they have a bit of a weird tone, like women and families aren’t doing their duty, does anyone else feel that?

You see suggested solutions like you could get a payment if you had more than 2 children? Would that be an incentive or would you find that weird?! Do you think subsidised childcare would be a better idea?

Personally I have no children, I’ve just never felt broody or maternal. I’d just be interested in what women actually think about this, not just the stats presented - if you have kids would you have more if you could afford it or would you always have stopped at 1 or 2?

I know this is the most journalist-sounding post but I really am just curious. I also appreciate there will be lots who can’t have any at all Flowers

OP posts:
Idontknowwhattothink · 26/07/2022 21:45

One. I had her when I was 40 after having and recovering from cancer on my womb. I was happy (thrilled) with one.

Then my hormones made one last revolt and I suddenly announced I wanted a second. I was devastated when DH said no, he is too old and five is enough for him. He was right but my rational brain wasn't working.

It didn't matter as it turned out as cancer caught me again, I went into menopause with the treatment and then had to have a full hysterectomy.

The broodiness has passed and I'm back to being thrilled with my one.

Furrydogmum · 26/07/2022 21:45

We have two children, if my husband had agreed to dogs when we married I probably wouldn't have any children.. I don't think anyone needs more than two, and am not saddened that my two, at the moment would prefer not to have children. The world is a mess and they don't want to add to the population. I look at the state of the world and the probable future financial and pension issues and feel guilty for having them.

Lindasllama · 26/07/2022 21:45

.. but I KNEW I wasn't done at 2...

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 26/07/2022 21:45

no 2 company for no 1
agreed to no. 3 in the delivery room high on endorphins from no 2
no 4 because I went to bed poorly 2 hours before I was due to take my pill

RoastingMarshmallow · 26/07/2022 21:45

We had to pay for IVF for DC #2 which ate in to our savings substantially and we don't have the ability to pay for two in childcare at the same time (approximately £1200 a month per child around here). If my age was lower and childcare wasn't as costly we'd definitely try for baby 3. Unfortunately we can't even foster or adopt as we can't afford a four bedroom home, because it's a £180k+ increase around here, to give the child their own room/space otherwise I'd have loved to foster children as well.

HerRoyalHappiness · 26/07/2022 21:45

I have 3.

I did get pregnant again with twins but had a TFMR.

I don't regret that decision one bit as it was the best thing for everyone involved. I do hate that I was ever put in that situation (ex admitted to tampering with condoms)

I can't have any more children due to my health so three it is. I'd have liked one or two more but it wasn't to be.

RebeccaCloud9 · 26/07/2022 21:45

I'm about to have my third. My husband is a third child and always wanted 3. I didn't feel finished at 2 and now my older 2 are old enough I felt I could cope. Getting pg has been easy for us, but being Pg has been hard for me, with several complications so for that reason wouldn't want more. Feel we could cope practically/money wise/car and house space wise with 3, but definitely not more. Feel confident and totally sure that this is my last. Did not feel that way after 2.

HorribleHerstory · 26/07/2022 21:45

Because I have a terrible track record at staying pregnant quite long enough for them to be born “viable” and there are only so many times you can go into the process knowing you might be burying them and then going back to work the next week like nothing happened.

I am lucky I have wonderful living children but the not living outnumber them significantly.

Lindasllama · 26/07/2022 21:45

I had five years of infertility before getting one.

So never really bothered with contraception. 18 year marriage . Never used contraception. 2nd arrived 18 months later .. 3rd 7 years later .. feel absolutely complete and now post menopause ..

PermanentTemporary · 26/07/2022 21:44

Stopped at one because dh was so ill. His doctor said we could only have another one if I could guarantee doing all the night waking. I did most of it but I was never going to guarantee doing 100%. We did in fact have approximately 48 hours where we thought we'd try for another, and I woke up in a total panic with flashbacks to childbirth (v straightforward birth, most women's idea of a 'dream birth' probably, but it hurt like absolute fuck and I didn't want to do it again). Dh had a vasectomy shortly afterwards.

I feel a bit of a failure as ds would have loved a sibling but it was the right decision and it wasn't about money (unless someone was going to offer us 5 years of a night nanny).

BeefCarvery · 26/07/2022 21:43
  1. At 36 im too old for another
AppleBottomRats · 26/07/2022 21:42

I have 0 as I have yet to successfully conceive. In an ideal world I'd have 2. I think more than 2 it's too difficult to give them enough attention.

Burnt0utMum · 26/07/2022 21:42

I have 2. I would've wanted a big family if we could afford it and had a big house and didn't have to work full time, would've had at least 4. However, I'm happy with my 2. They're close in age and each other's best friend.

SockQueen · 26/07/2022 21:42

I have two, which is what I always hoped for. Not sure why that number - maybe just because I'm from a family of 2 kids and it seemed very common among friends. To be honest, while I was desperately broody for the first, I never felt that way second time - it was a "nice to have" rather than essential.

Absolutely no desire to have more. It's not the cost or housing - we own our house and probably could afford another child. But I hate being pregnant, and while I love my boys more than anything, it has been hard, hard work and I'm not sure my marriage would survive another. I also love my career and don't want to take more time out/steps down on the ladder. So the amount on offer would have to be quite significant to make me consider it!

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 26/07/2022 21:42

Even if I could, there is no WAY I'd have more children, not for love nor money!
I love my two DC very much, but fuck me sideways, I have not found being a parent at all easy, thus far. 😅

DashboardConfessional · 26/07/2022 21:42

I was a happy only child and we have one. Quite a few of the aspects of birth/baby/toddler are enormously shit and I didn't want to do it again. My sleep and pelvic floor have never recovered.

Truthlikeness · 26/07/2022 21:42

0 - never met anyone to have kids with.

I understand we have issues with a declining birthrate and not enough working age people to sustain the ageing population, but the planet cannot sustain the number of people we already have. That problem doesn't magically solve itself.

whattheduece · 26/07/2022 21:41

TheGeoffLinton · 26/07/2022 21:35

I keep hearing that we’re having too few children to maintain the population. It seems to be a problem in a few countries in the West now. Often practical reasons are cited - having children later due to expensive childcare and not being able to get on the housing ladder means having fewer children. Sometimes they have a bit of a weird tone, like women and families aren’t doing their duty, does anyone else feel that?

You see suggested solutions like you could get a payment if you had more than 2 children? Would that be an incentive or would you find that weird?! Do you think subsidised childcare would be a better idea?

Personally I have no children, I’ve just never felt broody or maternal. I’d just be interested in what women actually think about this, not just the stats presented - if you have kids would you have more if you could afford it or would you always have stopped at 1 or 2?

I know this is the most journalist-sounding post but I really am just curious. I also appreciate there will be lots who can’t have any at all Flowers

Because her dad wouldn't let me have more than one ☹️

HumunaHey · 26/07/2022 21:41

Not to mention the cost and practicalities of having 3+. Not for me. No way.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/07/2022 21:41

I have 3 (1 girl, 2 boys), wanted 4 but marriage broke down. Though recognise I'm very fortunate, I still regret not having 4.

User48751490 · 26/07/2022 21:41

After the first two DC, I decided to have one more. Then decided three was an odd number and didn't feel comfortable with this, went on to have my last. Luckily have four children who are great company in this crazy world.

RJnomore1 · 26/07/2022 21:40

32 weeks sorry 😳

HumunaHey · 26/07/2022 21:40

I have 2. I always wanted 2. I wouldn't have felt 'finished' with 1 and I feel content that my 2 have eachother (if they at least get along enough to come together in hard times when they are older).

There is no incentive on earth to entice me into having more. It's like society views 9months of pregnancy, childbirth followed by newborn care (no real break for the mother in between) as light work. it may be for others, but certainly wasn't for me.

bananatuna · 26/07/2022 21:40

Two hands...two kids

RJnomore1 · 26/07/2022 21:40

My body is rubbish at pregnancy. I had two and I would have had more, but the second one I was in hospital 3 times, for several weeks at a time, and ended up giving birth at 2 weeks. A third would be likely to have been even more preemie and we just decided we were lucky with what we had and not to gamble with a child’s potential health.

So money would have made no difference. I’d still like another tbh. But it wouldn’t have been fair.