Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you have the number of children you have?

258 replies

TheGeoffLinton · 26/07/2022 21:35

I keep hearing that we’re having too few children to maintain the population. It seems to be a problem in a few countries in the West now. Often practical reasons are cited - having children later due to expensive childcare and not being able to get on the housing ladder means having fewer children. Sometimes they have a bit of a weird tone, like women and families aren’t doing their duty, does anyone else feel that?

You see suggested solutions like you could get a payment if you had more than 2 children? Would that be an incentive or would you find that weird?! Do you think subsidised childcare would be a better idea?

Personally I have no children, I’ve just never felt broody or maternal. I’d just be interested in what women actually think about this, not just the stats presented - if you have kids would you have more if you could afford it or would you always have stopped at 1 or 2?

I know this is the most journalist-sounding post but I really am just curious. I also appreciate there will be lots who can’t have any at all Flowers

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
resuwen · 29/07/2022 08:20

I didn't know number two would be the last before I had her, but after cholestasis, a severe pph requiring several days in HDU, and an adorable but extremely high maintenance baby, I didn't really fancy it a third time. 😂

shivawn · 29/07/2022 08:18

I have one baby, I will try for one more in the next year but if I can only have one then that's okay too. I probably would have liked 3 if I didn't wait until I was 34 to get started.

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 29/07/2022 08:11

I have 1. We tried to have a second but I had two miscarriages and then DH had an accident which resulted in life changing injury which put the brakes on everything. I am mid-40s now so I don't really think it's on the table. When I was younger I wanted three and an envious of my friends with three kids! I adore DD though and know I'm very lucky to have her.

Immaterialatthispoint · 29/07/2022 08:04

I have one living child. Like many on this thread, I have several more pregnancies I couldn’t carry to term. Some of the losses were life threatening for me, including a molar pregnancy and Charing Cross treatment slog.

We wanted more. After the last loss and the subsequent three surgeries and over 10 days in hospital, my husband begged me not to try again. I respect him and we didn’t. I am coming to terms with it- 1 is wonderful and I read repeatedly on here about all these people whose kids fight, how hard it is, how they struggle to go out alone with their kids, plus the risk of significant disabilities which wild have an impact on our first child’s life as well as mine/DHs….. it’s made me not want to roll the dice again either.

I have pangs, I cry at night for the children that didn’t make it, I cry for what I wish I had. I feel angry when I read in here about “giving children siblings”, how lonely onlies can be. I rage when I think about the school
parent WhatsApp debate where one mother falsely accused my child of bullying hers and a second mother chimed in that it was probably “because C is an only child and understandably jealous of those with siblings”.

my husband had to stop me from screaming at them. If that woman is on mumsnet, I hope you know what you did.

3ormoredogs · 29/07/2022 07:50

I have 2.
I would love a third but I had damage from the birth of DC2 and I don’t want to make it worse.

Also money is a consideration. Children are stupidly expensive!

Namechangedone · 29/07/2022 07:39

I have 1, never felt the urge for another but even if I did, probably wouldn't be able to afford it due to the cost of childcare.
We also don't have any family to help and I do think the lack of that has made it really difficult. We've only had 3 nights out alone in nearly 7 years!

MinnieMountain · 29/07/2022 07:37

1 due to deciding quite late in our relationship to have DC, my mental health and environmental reasons.

DH is an actuary, so is well aware of population decline etc but we didn’t feel we have a “duty” to contribute.

Camomila · 29/07/2022 07:24

I have 2 and would like 3.

We need to buy a house first and also I had hyperemisis with DS2 so would need some extra savings in case I spend month on sick leave again.

I had a mental "DC3 cut-off age" of 36 but I have revised it up to 38. We'll see! If I end up with just the 2 I'll still consider myself lucky.

SquigglePigs · 29/07/2022 06:21

I have one and won't be having any more. I had a horrendous pregnancy that has left me with long term issues. There's too big a risk of further damage if I had another one, plus I'd be more or less opting out of my DD's life for the duration of the pregnancy.

Glitterblue · 29/07/2022 05:53

We have 1, but always wanted at least 2, if not 3.

The reason: I had severe pre eclampsia during my pregnancy with DD, and she was born 13 weeks premature. We both almost lost our lives and we didn't feel we could take that risk again. There isn't a day goes by when I don't wish we'd been able to have more.

sashh · 29/07/2022 05:44

I never wanted them, I've often been told I will when I 'meet the right person' or that my biological clock will start.

I'm 55, post menopausal and not in a relationship so I don't think I'm going to change my mind.

whattodo2019 · 29/07/2022 03:12

DH and I have 2 DC.
1# girl at 31
2# boy at 33
Would have loved 4 DC but could only afford to privately educate 2 children and it was important to us to be able to do this

Coyoacan · 29/07/2022 03:03

I find the premise of this thread a wee bit odd. Why does the west need to encourage people to have bigger families while at the same time repelling all would-be immigrants to the point of leaving them to drown?

BarnacleNora · 29/07/2022 02:54
  1. I very much want more. I have the two I have because my exh left me when I was 8 months pregnant with our second child.

Since then I dip in and out of online dating but it is depressing out there and I haven't met anyone. Not even come close.

I'm still hoping to meet someone (and not just for a baby obviously) but I'm 37 this year so it's starting to feel like quite a vain hope that more children or even one more child will happen.

In an ideal world and if I hadn't married such a prick then I would have had three, possibly four depending on how we felt, finances etc. I just don't feel in any way 'done' or like my family is 'complete' with the (extraordinary, wonderful, fantastic and brilliant) two I have. It feels like there's at least one more child missing somewhere.

I am of course incredibly grateful for my children that I do have and am aware that I am very very lucky to have them. But this being a thread about why we have that number well that's why; two is not the number I would have decided on

thenewduchessoflapland · 29/07/2022 02:18

I had my oldest and then wanted a second close in age to them;mainly because there was a huge age gap between myself and my siblings.

Then I fell pregnant (unplanned) when DC number two was only 6 months which was a shock and then had a MMC:afterwards we tried immediately for another because it made us realise that we wanted a third.

After three in three years we decided DH would get a vasectomy.The procedure was booked then cancelled and rebooked by the hospital and in those 3 months between those two dates I fell pregnant (unplanned) with my 4th DC.

I was young when I had my DC's (under 25) and don't know if I'd make the same choices now I'm older and wiser as it was seriously hard having 4 small children when we were so young and financially unstable whilst DH was trying to establish a career and living in a house that needed a complete renovation and I look back and I honestly don't know how I got through that early years.

Cakecakecheese · 29/07/2022 02:15

One who I gave birth to yesterday! I'd say anymore is highly unlikely as we had IVF to get him, things got very difficult in the last few weeks before giving birth and I know my partner does not want me to go through all that again.

larkstar · 29/07/2022 02:08

Two - I wanted a third but my wife just didn't feel the same so.... just the two.

Flatmountains · 29/07/2022 02:04

I was only allowed one. Now I wouldn't touch a man with a bargepole.

Wilburisagirl · 29/07/2022 01:12

rainbowmilk · 27/07/2022 18:23

Have 0. Wanted some (my parents abused me and I have no contact with them, so wanted a family of my own). Unfortunately life decided otherwise and at 32 I had to have an emergency hysterectomy to save my life.

Can’t help feeling like I must’ve been a monster in a past life!

I'm so sorry to hear of the difficulties you've faced. I have an Aunt who couldn't have children and it breaks my heart as she is such a wonderful, kind and fun Aunty. She would have made the best Mum, but it just wasn't to be. I know she will always grieve for what she couldn't have, but she has had a full and wonderful life as an adult. She has lived and worked abroad in a number of countries, travelled extensively and had lots of local adventures too. She took up triathlons in her 50s and started learning Italian in her 60s for example. I hope that you can similarly have a fun and happy life even if it's not in the way you had previously hoped for.

felulageller · 28/07/2022 17:40

I had the number I planned to have as a child.

Women in developed countries are having fewer because having DC's ruins your life!

If we could have the lives fathers have...

The birth rate would surely be higher...

CanYouNotReadTheSign · 28/07/2022 17:22

One and done. Too old for another (I'm 42) and I honestly couldn't be arsed now.

ghostyslovesheets · 28/07/2022 17:19

I have 3 - started lateish at 32, next at 34 - happy with the two but at 38 had number 3 because I really wanted one more

CharlotteOH · 28/07/2022 17:14

I and several of my friends all had similar experiences:


  • met life partner at university ie the couple are approximately same age

  • woman starts wanting babies around age 25-8, man says ‘definitely one day’ but doesn’t propose til age 30 and marriage is age 31

  • couple starts trying for babies around age 32

  • they have 1-3 children in their mid-thirties then discover to their extremely grief that the woman’s eggs no longer work.


Do I sound bitter? I am. My generation was taught that the worst possible mistake a woman can make is have babies young and that the ‘best’ women focus on their careers first. What total crap. You can build a career any age but for most women, eggs stop working in mid to late thirties.

My advice to young women is to marry a guy 5 years around older if possible, and have babies asap.

To answer your question l, I have one child, I’d have loved to have 4-5.

cheekychatta · 28/07/2022 17:13

Two as I we wanted to go travelling when they were grown up and we had our health . Plus it would have been a tight squeeze in our house and we could not afford to move . So two was enough. Got sick of people asking if we were going to try for a girl !

littlepeas · 28/07/2022 17:09

I have 3 - boy, girl, boy and very close in age. I did (intentionally) get pregnant with a 4th baby, but had a miscarriage, lost my confidence and didn’t try again (already so lucky with 3 great kids, didn’t want to push it). I’m never quite sure how I feel about it - sometimes sad, sometimes relieved and that it worked out for the best. I could probably just manage another in terms of age - I’m nearly 40 - but the age gap would be huge now and life has moved on from babies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread