Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.

158 replies

Markedforsl · 26/07/2022 20:29

I'm including a translation of an article in a Berlin newspaper, about a concert which took place (or should have taken place) in Switzerland.
A band of white musicians played, among other things, some reggae music. Some of the band had rasta style hair.
Some concert-goers expressed "discomfort" with the situation to the organisers. The organisers stopped the concert and have made abject apologies.

YANBU: White musicians playing reggae music and even wearing dreadlocks while doing so is okay, and doesn't justify the immediate termination of a concert.
YABU: Only Jamaicans should play reggae music and/or have dreadlocks. If white people do either of those things it is racism and should not be allowed. Innocent concert-goers need to be protected from this.

"As reported by several media in Switzerland, the dialect band Lauwarm performed at the Brasserie Lorraine in Bern on 18 July. The five musicians were standing in for another band that had cancelled. The repertoire of the group Lauwarm includes reggae, indie, world and pop. But their colourful programme was not well received - apparently mainly because of the hairstyles. Concertgoers expressed "discomfort with the situation" to the organisers, report Neue Zürcher Zeitung and 20 Minuten.
The concert was stopped after the complaints. In a statement, the organiser now apologised for "awareness gaps". The audience should have been "better protected" before the performance. As the Brasserie Lorraine cooperative announced on Facebook on Monday, the discomfort of the visitors had been related to the topic of "cultural appropriation". That is: the band Lauwarm is criticised for being white musicians, wearing partly rasta haircuts and playing Jamaican reggae music, although they themselves have never experienced the racial exclusion of Jamaicans.
The organisers apologised "to all the people for whom the concert has caused bad feelings". They said they were responsible because they had invited the band. "We failed to deal with it enough in advance and to protect you." The lengthy apology to all those who suffered ends with the words, "Not a millimetre of room for Racism and other discrimination.."

OP posts:
debwong · 26/07/2022 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EmmaH2022 · 26/07/2022 22:51

RaininginDarling · 26/07/2022 22:29

This stuff is nuts but some sensible comments here (in-between the language police) Where will it stop? I'm so glad I grew up in the 80s.

I work in the charity sector and in the last year, I've been invited to no less than three EDI race seminars online where there were breakout rooms designated by...skin colour. I find this appallingly racist. My sister is half Pakistani, I'm white, we'd not be allowed in the same room! What message are we giving young people? John McWhorter calls it woke racism. He's not wrong.

Oh my god! If I was packed off to a seminar based on skin colour, I'd be furious!

Honestly, the racism I encountered twenty years ago was way better than what's going on now.

glad to see sense on this thread.

Discovereads · 26/07/2022 22:50

Here’s a picture of the band. Only one musician is Rastafarian based on hair and his hat. But again, Rastafarian is a worldwide religion with adherents of many races and nationalities.

White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.
bellac11 · 26/07/2022 22:47

Recently I watched a documentary about dance, specifically tap dance/Irish dance.

Theres lots of cross over in tap/Irish/clog dances over a number of countries, histories and cultures.

A couple of the dancers/commentators in the documentary felt strongly that things like the Irish Riverdance had appropriated tap from black culture and African dance histories and had no comprehension that there are other clog/tap type dances which are indigenous to other cultures and ethnicities.

Similarly a huge amount of music has its history in black gospel particularly in the US, but also African and Caribbean slave sounds or sounds of the south of the US, but a large amount of music also came of out traditional folk from Ireland/Scotland and that modern 'pop' is an amalgamation of this, its a mixture of simple country or religious or motivational singing, singing about lives and experiences, the sounds of feelings like that. Equally a lot of dance beats and sounds coming out of that, added to military type beats from army type influences across centuries. A huge mixture.

Its not a simple as saying that white musicians play 'black' music and make money from it.

Markedforsl · 26/07/2022 22:44

Lacey247 · 26/07/2022 21:48

‘Rasta style hair’??

As I've already said, I was quoting from the newspaper article, which says this:
"the band Lauwarm is criticised for being white musicians, wearing partly rasta haircuts and playing Jamaican reggae music, although they themselves have never experienced the racial exclusion of Jamaicans."

OP posts:
user1471474462 · 26/07/2022 22:43

Loc’s are associated with multiple cultures, and are also associated with “counter culture”.

Cultural appropriation is a problem, but this isn’t an example of cultural appropriation.

I don’t think anyone can seriously think the band are trying to take from another culture, and pass it off as their own.

I would say the music is appreciation, and the band member with Loc’s likely has them as they are counter culture, or perhaps he is Rastafarian, or Hindu...

He hasn’t surely “put on” those Loc’s as a costume, to make a mockery, or to claim them as his own invention. He just happens to have Loc’s, whilst playing reggae.

Florenz · 26/07/2022 22:42

Have UB40 been "cancelled"? What about the Levellers?

crwnhgow · 26/07/2022 22:40

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 21:26

You're part of the problem

OP - Sad news that Switzerland who I always assumed were quite sensible have turned lunatic.

One venue made a decision so the whole country is "lunatic"? (Whatever the fucking hell that means)

juice92 · 26/07/2022 22:39

I am a ska/reggae fan. People from all cultures play and appreciate this style of music and although the Rastafari movement had its start in Jamaica, people all over the world are Rastafarians. I do feel like we now run the risk of going too far the other way and what a shame that a band who has possibly travelled quite a way, and who were excited to play, weren't able to and any fans who went there to see them lost out too. Reggae and ska does not get the love and attention it deserves as a genre and if the band did get to play their whole set that day, someone might have been introduce to genre and explored other artists, many who are black , these artists will have missed out too

fukkit · 26/07/2022 22:39

Sounds like they were doing the organisers a favour by stepping in last minute! We're going down a route now of only gay actors can play gay people, bisexual people act as bisexual people.. and on and on. I mean where does cultural appreciation end and cultural appropriation begin...?

catandcoffee · 26/07/2022 22:35

I'd be interested to know the backgrounds of the audience that complained.

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 22:32

Runnerbeansflower · 26/07/2022 22:29

Well, it does raise the question why white artists get the fame and money, while the black artists playing the same music don't....

Like who?

Georgeskitchen · 26/07/2022 22:30

All this is getting very tiresome and does nothing to promote racial harmony. What is so wrong about embracing and enjoying different cultures?

RaininginDarling · 26/07/2022 22:29

This stuff is nuts but some sensible comments here (in-between the language police) Where will it stop? I'm so glad I grew up in the 80s.

I work in the charity sector and in the last year, I've been invited to no less than three EDI race seminars online where there were breakout rooms designated by...skin colour. I find this appallingly racist. My sister is half Pakistani, I'm white, we'd not be allowed in the same room! What message are we giving young people? John McWhorter calls it woke racism. He's not wrong.

SprinklesMcDoodles · 26/07/2022 22:29

When you say Jamaican, what do you mean? There are lots of different cultures and colours in Jamaica and it’s a very inclusive culture overall. I’m assuming you mean black Jamaica, but the indigenous people of Jamaica are Taino.

Runnerbeansflower · 26/07/2022 22:29

Florenz · 26/07/2022 22:12

It's fucking insane. Pretty much all popular music played by white people, going back to Elvis and the Beatles was inspired by black music. You'd have to pretty much ban white people from making music except for classical music if this continues.

Well, it does raise the question why white artists get the fame and money, while the black artists playing the same music don't....

RichardMarxisinnocent · 26/07/2022 22:21

I assume the complainers were also unaware of Jamaica's national motto - "Out of many, one people", referring to the various cultures and races which make up the country.

TooManyPJs · 26/07/2022 22:17

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 21:50

I think society is becoming more and more polarised by cultural splitting like this.

Where as years ago, there was a good level of inclusion in all groups and communities, with a view for that to improve even further, there is a trend now to encourage divisiveness and separateness.

Also the use of words and language to put people down, a good example in this thread, accusations of using the 'wrong' word, undermining the OP, invalidating their point by using language as a weapon.

Well said!

RichardMarxisinnocent · 26/07/2022 22:15

Discovereads · 26/07/2022 22:08

The uncomfortable complainers were being racist:
There are white Jamaicans
There are white Rastafarians
There are white Reggae musicians

“Jamaicans of African descent represent 76.3% of the population, followed by 15.1% Afro-European, 3.4% East Indian and Afro-East Indian, 3.2% Caucasian, 1.2% Chinese and 0.8% other.”

Perhaps the most famous Jamaican, Rastafarian Reggae musician was Bob Marley who was mixed race: 50/50 African and White.

Yes, this. My DP is Jamaican but not black (he's also not white, his ancestors were from India)

Scianel · 26/07/2022 22:14

You'd have to pretty much ban white people from making music except for classical music if this continues

And then you'd need to ban that in the spirit of decolonisation.

Florenz · 26/07/2022 22:12

It's fucking insane. Pretty much all popular music played by white people, going back to Elvis and the Beatles was inspired by black music. You'd have to pretty much ban white people from making music except for classical music if this continues.

Discovereads · 26/07/2022 22:08

The uncomfortable complainers were being racist:
There are white Jamaicans
There are white Rastafarians
There are white Reggae musicians

“Jamaicans of African descent represent 76.3% of the population, followed by 15.1% Afro-European, 3.4% East Indian and Afro-East Indian, 3.2% Caucasian, 1.2% Chinese and 0.8% other.”

Perhaps the most famous Jamaican, Rastafarian Reggae musician was Bob Marley who was mixed race: 50/50 African and White.

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 22:01

Scianel · 26/07/2022 21:57

God that's sad. Where I grew up, people from all backgrounds were into reggae and some actually followed the Rastafarian faith. None were Jamaican.

A person doesnt have to be Jamaican at all, or from any country/nation/heritage

As someone said above, hairstyles are not owned by any person or group.

Neither is a belief system.

I can imagine most people dont even know what Rastafarianism is in the first place.

Scianel · 26/07/2022 21:57

God that's sad. Where I grew up, people from all backgrounds were into reggae and some actually followed the Rastafarian faith. None were Jamaican.

Winter2020 · 26/07/2022 21:56

I think it's mad. People can have mixed heritage backgrounds/different cultiral upbringings and who are we to look at someones appearance/skin colour and decide what their heritage and culture should be.

People have always learned/adapted culture from other cultures.

In a world where there is war and climate change and possible looming famine I think it is mad to get wound up about hair that is sincerely and respectfully worn. No one owns a hairstyle.