Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.

158 replies

Markedforsl · 26/07/2022 20:29

I'm including a translation of an article in a Berlin newspaper, about a concert which took place (or should have taken place) in Switzerland.
A band of white musicians played, among other things, some reggae music. Some of the band had rasta style hair.
Some concert-goers expressed "discomfort" with the situation to the organisers. The organisers stopped the concert and have made abject apologies.

YANBU: White musicians playing reggae music and even wearing dreadlocks while doing so is okay, and doesn't justify the immediate termination of a concert.
YABU: Only Jamaicans should play reggae music and/or have dreadlocks. If white people do either of those things it is racism and should not be allowed. Innocent concert-goers need to be protected from this.

"As reported by several media in Switzerland, the dialect band Lauwarm performed at the Brasserie Lorraine in Bern on 18 July. The five musicians were standing in for another band that had cancelled. The repertoire of the group Lauwarm includes reggae, indie, world and pop. But their colourful programme was not well received - apparently mainly because of the hairstyles. Concertgoers expressed "discomfort with the situation" to the organisers, report Neue Zürcher Zeitung and 20 Minuten.
The concert was stopped after the complaints. In a statement, the organiser now apologised for "awareness gaps". The audience should have been "better protected" before the performance. As the Brasserie Lorraine cooperative announced on Facebook on Monday, the discomfort of the visitors had been related to the topic of "cultural appropriation". That is: the band Lauwarm is criticised for being white musicians, wearing partly rasta haircuts and playing Jamaican reggae music, although they themselves have never experienced the racial exclusion of Jamaicans.
The organisers apologised "to all the people for whom the concert has caused bad feelings". They said they were responsible because they had invited the band. "We failed to deal with it enough in advance and to protect you." The lengthy apology to all those who suffered ends with the words, "Not a millimetre of room for Racism and other discrimination.."

OP posts:
Markedforsl · 27/07/2022 08:34

LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 08:29

There is no such thing as "rasta hair". Sorry if you do not think that language is important. But it really is. Using the right terms is important.

So I'm not allowed to quote from the newspaper article which is the subject of the post? I have to translate the newspaper article into language which doesn't offend you first?
Tell you what - why don't you write to the newspaper concerned and complain to them? I'm sure they'll appreciate being educated, and they may want to add your concerns to their report on this issue, so that their German speaking readers can learn too.

OP posts:
Forestgate · 27/07/2022 08:33

Ridiculous.

Markedforsl · 27/07/2022 08:30

CuntyMcBollocks · 27/07/2022 08:13

I don't agree with your choices of voting OP. Not every single Jamaican is black, and white people can also be Rastafarian.

People listening to the band complained about them because they were white, played reggae and wore dreadlocks. They presumably had no information about their religious beliefs or ancestry. Would they have complained if they had only played reggae (no dreadlocks)? Who knows - perhaps. What about if they had been black, not from Jamaica, and not believers in Rastafarianism, but played reggae and had dreadlocks?

OP posts:
LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 08:29

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 21:50

I think society is becoming more and more polarised by cultural splitting like this.

Where as years ago, there was a good level of inclusion in all groups and communities, with a view for that to improve even further, there is a trend now to encourage divisiveness and separateness.

Also the use of words and language to put people down, a good example in this thread, accusations of using the 'wrong' word, undermining the OP, invalidating their point by using language as a weapon.

There is no such thing as "rasta hair". Sorry if you do not think that language is important. But it really is. Using the right terms is important.

LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 08:24

apintortwo · 27/07/2022 00:07

The record companies had a tad to do with it surely? Exposure on TV film. And... All that sort of thing. Racism? Repackage with a white face and boom it's a hit.. you don't think so?

Record companies may prop up someone all they like. But the public will decide, always.

Yes it is as simple as that, nothing to do with the fact that racist radio stations would not play music made by black people, so hindering their sales. Racist parents did not want their children/ teens listening to music made by black people, so would not buy their records. So yes a racist system hampering the amount of money that black artist could make. Where for example someone like Elvis who essentially was playing and singing music inspired by Black artist, was acceptable to the public, and played on the radio stations. I know that Arthur Crudup who wrote and sang That's all right mama, did not make anything like Elvis did money wise. His version is considered to be the first rock and roll song!

CuntyMcBollocks · 27/07/2022 08:13

I don't agree with your choices of voting OP. Not every single Jamaican is black, and white people can also be Rastafarian.

Danceswithkids · 27/07/2022 08:03

Just in case anyone was in doubt, I was in Waterstones yesterday with my five year old and loads of books had blonde blue eyed little girls having mild adventures (other hair/skin colours also available).

People really do feel they can tell the stupidest lies on the internet!

SweetBeer · 27/07/2022 07:46

Back to the band, they all look a bit ridiculous and I doubt are Rastafarians. They seem happy and chilled but clueless and have probably been annoying their partners and moms for too long with the Band.

apintortwo · 27/07/2022 07:32

I did actually realise that blonde DD only had dolls of colour when she was about 4. Hand-me-downs from her Jamaicans who obviously were looking at representation for their DD. I don't think she's scarred for life. Although she does dye her hair!!!!!!

So it's ok for your friends to look representation for her daughter but if I do the same it's wrong apparently. Got it. Also why does your daughter feel the need to dye her hair?

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:48

I took too long to post, my post was aimed at apintortwo. I don't think family hand me downs could be a political agenda?

I was being facetious @TwentyOneTwentyTwo trying to show that the only way a poor, desperate blonde child could be deprived of the vast hordes of stuff which represents them (and it's EVERYWHERE) is by a very weird coincidence. The tone was lost I think.

If you removed all the princess nonsense there would be fewer blonde girls. Still far from none though.

antelopevalley · 27/07/2022 01:39

PacketOfPolos · 27/07/2022 00:40

I wish the OP had put a link.

I've been googling but hard to find info. Seems the gig was in brasserie Lorraine in bern. And they did some songs took a break. Manager said some people uncomfy and band decided not to go back on.

Anyone else got more info? Links etc? I really wish OP had given a link or 2.

So on the face of it. Swiss band of bunch of young chaps as per earlier pic, style is UB40. It's Switzerland. Don't know how many on thread have been there/ out on evening etc. It's pretty... Staid.

Standard Swiss folk are moved to say hmmm to manager. (Unconfirmed, the restaurant has not commented). The commenting on numbers feels pretty odd tbh.

Band flounce off, essentially. Incident is reported essentially not much at all anywhere, yet somehow finds a place on MN and comments go off in interesting directions...

This is what I found too. It looks like too much has been made of what is essentially a band flounce.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 27/07/2022 01:35

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:29

I did actually realise that blonde DD only had dolls of colour when she was about 4. Hand-me-downs from her Jamaicans who obviously were looking at representation for their DD. I don't think she's scarred for life. Although she does dye her hair!!!!!!

I took too long to post, my post was aimed at apintortwo. I don't think family hand me downs could be a political agenda?

EmmaH2022 · 27/07/2022 01:33

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:21

I am struggling to understand why a parenting website in the UK needs to have a position on a completely obscure band (not) playing in Switzerland, reported only it seems in German in a newspaper in Berlin.

Have we really got to the point where Disgusted of Cheam has to trawl unheard of stories in diverse languages in order to be oUtRaGeD at political correctness gone mad or wokery?

My theory, having seen the picture and knowing they were a late substitution, is that they were a bit shit and the organisers said they had to get off the stage because of ummmmm complaints. They look like a band whose songs are 10 minutes long with a bongo solo.

OP has explained where she found the story and why.

not like you to trot out nonsense like "disgusted of Cheam". Pity.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:30

I don't know where Jamaicans came from. MN or my laptop keeps cutting out the middle of phrases and that was particularly unfortunate. I wrote 'Jamaican cousins'.

ladydoris · 27/07/2022 01:29

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:21

I am struggling to understand why a parenting website in the UK needs to have a position on a completely obscure band (not) playing in Switzerland, reported only it seems in German in a newspaper in Berlin.

Have we really got to the point where Disgusted of Cheam has to trawl unheard of stories in diverse languages in order to be oUtRaGeD at political correctness gone mad or wokery?

My theory, having seen the picture and knowing they were a late substitution, is that they were a bit shit and the organisers said they had to get off the stage because of ummmmm complaints. They look like a band whose songs are 10 minutes long with a bongo solo.

This.
Fine analysis. Bad music should always be stopped ASAP.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:29

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 27/07/2022 01:26

The political agenda to erase blonde girls at the works... There were more but I can only upload three images. Posts like above remind me of that prussian blue mum on Louis theroux. They have to say this stuff for the kids, to protect the kids, of course, think of the kids.

I did actually realise that blonde DD only had dolls of colour when she was about 4. Hand-me-downs from her Jamaicans who obviously were looking at representation for their DD. I don't think she's scarred for life. Although she does dye her hair!!!!!!

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 27/07/2022 01:26

The political agenda to erase blonde girls at the works... There were more but I can only upload three images. Posts like above remind me of that prussian blue mum on Louis theroux. They have to say this stuff for the kids, to protect the kids, of course, think of the kids.

White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.
White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.
White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.
ladydoris · 27/07/2022 01:26

🙄I call it bollocks. There are "white" Jamaicans. And you can have locks in any type of hair. Seriously. What is that ? The guys could be Rastafarians for all we know, which is a religion. The one who stopped the group has such a lack of culture, and the one writing the article knows nothing. Ja will not be happy me tellin you.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/07/2022 01:21

I am struggling to understand why a parenting website in the UK needs to have a position on a completely obscure band (not) playing in Switzerland, reported only it seems in German in a newspaper in Berlin.

Have we really got to the point where Disgusted of Cheam has to trawl unheard of stories in diverse languages in order to be oUtRaGeD at political correctness gone mad or wokery?

My theory, having seen the picture and knowing they were a late substitution, is that they were a bit shit and the organisers said they had to get off the stage because of ummmmm complaints. They look like a band whose songs are 10 minutes long with a bongo solo.

ScotInExile · 27/07/2022 01:17

apintortwo · 27/07/2022 00:13

It is. I was shocked to read that even in childrens fiction activists are forcing authors to only use characters that match their own sex, ethnicity and sexual orientation

I struggle to find children's books to buy for a family member nowadays. Most of them do not include characters who look like her (blonde, blue eyes - we are in the UK).
I have to resort to oldish second hand editions from charity shops or give her hand made presents crafted by myself. It's ridiculous.

Huh? You only expose your relative to books that feature characters that look like her? You do realise she will meet all sorts of people throughout her life, you cannot shield her from the diversity of the human race and I can't imagine why you'd want to.
I can honestly say I have never ever chosen books for my DD based on what the characters look like. That's ridiculous!

PacketOfPolos · 27/07/2022 01:15

In the end I'm not sure how a Berlin news report on a band not finishing their set in a Swiss restaurant, leads to, well a lot of the posts on this thread!

Is what went on in the restaurant Lorraine, definitely linked to the apparent dearth of books in UK bookshops with any female blonde child characters?

Apparently so. Why are white blonde girls and women so desperately under represented in UK society? One to ponder on.

PacketOfPolos · 27/07/2022 01:08

Oops 20 mins I meant. The site you link. Not sure why won't translate.

PacketOfPolos · 27/07/2022 01:07

Yes I saw that earlier it wouldn't translate for me though which is annoying.

The top results were all 20 seconds. The one I found in English said they called it quits. I'm not sure why that page and the others on that site won't translate. Annoying.

Markedforsl · 27/07/2022 01:04

Here's another article spelling out what happened - they were told to stop playing because of guests complaining of cultural appropriation. I came across the story because I have my Microsoft screen in German.
www.20min.ch/story/band-muss-konzert-abbrechen-weil-weisse-saenger-rastas-tragen-770725450313

OP posts:
PacketOfPolos · 27/07/2022 01:03

This thread is fascinating.

Who would have imagined that a post referencing a Berlin report about a band in a restaurant in Switzerland would get so much traction, and such wide ranging comments!

I'm really interested to know where and when this was 'Where as years ago, there was a good level of inclusion in all groups and communities, with a view for that to improve even further, there is a trend now to encourage divisiveness and separateness.'.

And what age is the relative with no children's books with blond girls? Waterstones has nothing?

Ime there are blonde girls and women everywhere you look in ads, on covers, on TV, children's books... Unless toddler age then usually animals...

What a wide ranging thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread