Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

White musicians had Rasta hair and played Reggae music. Concert stopped.

158 replies

Markedforsl · 26/07/2022 20:29

I'm including a translation of an article in a Berlin newspaper, about a concert which took place (or should have taken place) in Switzerland.
A band of white musicians played, among other things, some reggae music. Some of the band had rasta style hair.
Some concert-goers expressed "discomfort" with the situation to the organisers. The organisers stopped the concert and have made abject apologies.

YANBU: White musicians playing reggae music and even wearing dreadlocks while doing so is okay, and doesn't justify the immediate termination of a concert.
YABU: Only Jamaicans should play reggae music and/or have dreadlocks. If white people do either of those things it is racism and should not be allowed. Innocent concert-goers need to be protected from this.

"As reported by several media in Switzerland, the dialect band Lauwarm performed at the Brasserie Lorraine in Bern on 18 July. The five musicians were standing in for another band that had cancelled. The repertoire of the group Lauwarm includes reggae, indie, world and pop. But their colourful programme was not well received - apparently mainly because of the hairstyles. Concertgoers expressed "discomfort with the situation" to the organisers, report Neue Zürcher Zeitung and 20 Minuten.
The concert was stopped after the complaints. In a statement, the organiser now apologised for "awareness gaps". The audience should have been "better protected" before the performance. As the Brasserie Lorraine cooperative announced on Facebook on Monday, the discomfort of the visitors had been related to the topic of "cultural appropriation". That is: the band Lauwarm is criticised for being white musicians, wearing partly rasta haircuts and playing Jamaican reggae music, although they themselves have never experienced the racial exclusion of Jamaicans.
The organisers apologised "to all the people for whom the concert has caused bad feelings". They said they were responsible because they had invited the band. "We failed to deal with it enough in advance and to protect you." The lengthy apology to all those who suffered ends with the words, "Not a millimetre of room for Racism and other discrimination.."

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
turbonerd · 28/07/2022 09:39

And just to add; there were fairly high profile Black slave owners in the US as well.
and there were White slaves, in particular Irish (and some Scottish) indentured labourers.

in the Pacific in the 1850’s I think it was, some had a group of 120-150 sacandinavian slaves, who then mutinated after about 18 months into their 5-10 yr «contract». Due to luck, and luck only, their mutiny was successful.

knowing this does not detract from the horror that was the Atlantic slavetrade. But it shows that it is pointless to police hairstyles and music according to «race».

wonderstuff · 27/07/2022 23:15

He’s spot on. You simply can’t assume you know a person’s ancestry by looking at them (im super pale but also have ancestors who were slaves) and of course music can’t be put into culturally distinct categories only to be played by certain people.

bellac11 · 27/07/2022 23:05

He's right, he might have ancestors who were slaves but even if he didnt, its about what music he wants to create.

And he is also right that the complainers are invisible.

Markedforsl · 27/07/2022 23:01

An update from a member of the band - they don't want to be allowed to play only folk music. Plus slave ancestry:
switzerlandtimes.ch/people/unfortunately-our-critics-remained-invisible/

OP posts:
bellac11 · 27/07/2022 18:53

LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 08:29

There is no such thing as "rasta hair". Sorry if you do not think that language is important. But it really is. Using the right terms is important.

Rasta is short for Rastafarian, which if you've spent any time with Rastas you will have heard a lot

Rastafarians nearly always have dreadlocked hair, aka Rasta hair, or Rasta style hair if the person being referred to is not Rastafarian.

Faciadipasta · 27/07/2022 17:56

God this kind of shit passes me off. I'm mixed race. 1 white British parent and 1 mixed (black and white) Jamaican parent. I already feel like I don't belong anywhere or in any group. If I refer to being "black" or even "mixed" people generally don't believe me a bc i look sort of southern European, but if i say white im denying my heritage. this just enforces it all the more.

Ylvamoon · 27/07/2022 17:07

... and this is how you segregate, entice violence and lure people into ignorance.

Whoactuallythinksthat · 27/07/2022 16:59

CulturePigeon · 27/07/2022 13:26

I think the world of the arts is really screwed up at the moment. Confusion reigns, and I'm just waiting it out until things settle down.

What is now called 'cultural appropriation' was, just a few years ago, regarded favourably as participating/taking an influence from other cultures. I knew of someone (White British and competitively right-on) who was indignant that some participants in the Chinese NY celebrations in China Town in London were European in appearance. Horrors! How very dare they!

Personally I can't see what's wrong or offensive (a word that's the curse of our times, surely...) about, say, adopting hairstyles and dress of other cultures in a positive way (not to make mock, obviously). it used to be fine, and it used to be looked on as progressive but trends and fashions change.

What about cooking curries/stir fries at home? Is that OK?

In the world of acting there's a view that only gay actors can now play gay characters. But if actors had to have experienced all that their character has experienced...how would that work? They used to do careful research and then basically, act. Yet this view is very strongly held by some people - but my question is, where would that view take us if you follow it to its logical conclusion? It's surely about the nature of acting and performing.

There's a huge and very sensitive controversy about race in the acting profession. A few years ago I enjoyed an all-black RSC Hamlet, and I usually think colour-blind casting works - with one exception: when it deals with a real, historic character such as Anne Boleyn. I couldn't get past that fact that we have a record of what Anne Boleyn looked like, and she wasn't black. I couldn't suspend disbelief for the recent TV series which cast a black actor in that part. You wouldn't want to see a white person playing Dr Martin Luther King - we know what he looked like and his race was crucial in his story.

It's all really confused and contradictory, though. If black actors can play supposedly white (say, Dickens or Jane Austen) characters, which of course they can and do, then should a white actor who's just burning to play Othello be allowed to do so? No? I would probably agree, because race is very relevant in that part, but nevertheless, I think there's a huge amount of confused thinking going on at the moment. I'm hoping someone will clear the muddy waters soon using both common sense and humanity.

Yes, I agree. With regard to actors playing roles, if race is irrelevant to the story, then anyone can play it. Likewise gender…….although trickier. If, however, it’s central, then it would be too distracting eg putting a black man in the role of a white slave owner. It would confuse the story and add a nuance that was not there.
Additionally, if straight men are not allowed to play gay roles, then gay men should not play straight roles…….which is ridiculous and we never would have had the Hot Priest…….!

turbonerd · 27/07/2022 13:54

On hair: my one DS (they are all european/asian heritage, don’t look asian but has name) has amazing curly brown/blonde hair that Mats itself into fabulous dreadlocs. He is 17 and has a kind of afro, but bigger curls. He will brush it occasionally, it is almost down to his waist now.
i will let him know promptly that he may be perceived as racist.

my DD had light yellow hair with less curls, but she had normally forming dreads (ASD, no brushing for a few years there. Now shorter and brushed every day).

my other DS has completely straight burgundy hair - bright Orange when he was a kid. No knots, scarcely a wave on his head.

Hair is hair and music is music.
in the words of Ian McKellen: you know I am not really a wizard? I just pretend to be one.

2bazookas · 27/07/2022 13:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 13:33

CulturePigeon You have made some really good, and interesting points in your post.

CulturePigeon · 27/07/2022 13:26

I think the world of the arts is really screwed up at the moment. Confusion reigns, and I'm just waiting it out until things settle down.

What is now called 'cultural appropriation' was, just a few years ago, regarded favourably as participating/taking an influence from other cultures. I knew of someone (White British and competitively right-on) who was indignant that some participants in the Chinese NY celebrations in China Town in London were European in appearance. Horrors! How very dare they!

Personally I can't see what's wrong or offensive (a word that's the curse of our times, surely...) about, say, adopting hairstyles and dress of other cultures in a positive way (not to make mock, obviously). it used to be fine, and it used to be looked on as progressive but trends and fashions change.

What about cooking curries/stir fries at home? Is that OK?

In the world of acting there's a view that only gay actors can now play gay characters. But if actors had to have experienced all that their character has experienced...how would that work? They used to do careful research and then basically, act. Yet this view is very strongly held by some people - but my question is, where would that view take us if you follow it to its logical conclusion? It's surely about the nature of acting and performing.

There's a huge and very sensitive controversy about race in the acting profession. A few years ago I enjoyed an all-black RSC Hamlet, and I usually think colour-blind casting works - with one exception: when it deals with a real, historic character such as Anne Boleyn. I couldn't get past that fact that we have a record of what Anne Boleyn looked like, and she wasn't black. I couldn't suspend disbelief for the recent TV series which cast a black actor in that part. You wouldn't want to see a white person playing Dr Martin Luther King - we know what he looked like and his race was crucial in his story.

It's all really confused and contradictory, though. If black actors can play supposedly white (say, Dickens or Jane Austen) characters, which of course they can and do, then should a white actor who's just burning to play Othello be allowed to do so? No? I would probably agree, because race is very relevant in that part, but nevertheless, I think there's a huge amount of confused thinking going on at the moment. I'm hoping someone will clear the muddy waters soon using both common sense and humanity.

MsPincher · 27/07/2022 13:17

Agree that this is silly. There are white Jamaicans and Rastafarians. Bob Marleys dad was white. No one owns any type of music and we should have cultural freedom to express ourselves regardless of race.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/07/2022 13:13

@apintortwo

You live in a majority white country. You and your children and whoever you’re talking about have representation everywhere.

I suggest you find Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s TED talk but to give you a flavour of why more brown people are allowed on books, here’s an excerpt:

Adichie grew up in Nigeria. In her presentation, she describes herself as a long-time storyteller and early reader. The children's books that were available to her then were British and American. They had characters who had blonde hair and blue eyes. They talked about the weather and drank ginger beer. When Adichie started writing, her characters and plots matched those in these stories, even though her own everyday life didn't resemble this. She says that while these stories 'stirred her imagination,' they also gave her a 'single story of what books are.' When she discovered African stories through authors like Chinua Achebe, the 'father of African literature,' she realized that books can be about the places and characters that she recognized - those with the 'skin color of chocolate' and 'kinky hair.'

beastlyslumber · 27/07/2022 12:27

Hope you're all enjoying the glorious cultural revolution. How long before we get to march the offenders out into the street for a beating?

LadyKenya · 27/07/2022 12:18

kmblark · 27/07/2022 11:54

There are multiple reasons Netflix are losing money, I doubt one of their most popular shows having non-white characters is one of them

This. I looked up Bridgerton. It has been a huge success for Netflix. So obviously a lot of people do not share that posters view, thankfully.

TheKeatingFive · 27/07/2022 11:57

Bridgerton gets incredible viewing figures and has been renewed for multiple seasons. What a stupid suggestion.

kmblark · 27/07/2022 11:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

There are multiple reasons Netflix are losing money, I doubt one of their most popular shows having non-white characters is one of them

apintortwo · 27/07/2022 11:11

Glancing at the band, it looks like cultural appropriation to me

I hope customers avoid this brasserie like the plague, it will teach the owners not to be so wet and lame. What about the diners who did want to enjoy the show, had paid for their meal and had their evening ruined?

TheKeatingFive · 27/07/2022 11:10

God this is such tiresome nonsense.

These purity spirals are so self defeating.

LondonWolf · 27/07/2022 11:10

There is no such thing as "rasta hair". Sorry if you do not think that language is important. But it really is. Using the right terms is important.

It is important, you're right. It's respectful to be informed about the subjects you discuss and have opinions on. However taking offence and issuing shaming, corrective instructions to people who get it wrong is just as bad. We seem to be in a place where that is seen as acceptable when discussing cultural matters and it really isn't.

DoorBall · 27/07/2022 11:07

Let children be children

DoorBall · 27/07/2022 11:07

Can we move on from the bun fight over blonde haired blue eyed children, it's getting a bit obsessive and weird. Let children are children, who cares what colouring they have, treat them as individuals regardless of skin and hair colour. Book publishers should focus less on the woke and more on high quality stories. Glancing at the band, it looks like cultural appropriation to me. We can be sensitive to these things and come from a respectful and aware position rather than remaining comfortably ignorant about racism. It's not the 80s anymore, thankfully and there is a middle way.

LondonWolf · 27/07/2022 11:05

The good sense and push back on this thread is so refreshing not to mention massively informative at times - historical details around Celts and Vikings in particular - thank you for it.

DoubleShotEspresso · 27/07/2022 11:03

That's utterly ridiculous.
The world is turning completely mad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread