Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say suck it up like the rest of us???

331 replies

ticktickticktickBOOM · 26/07/2022 17:55

I come from a socialist family, we had striking miner's kids living with us for respite during the strikes. However, the railway unions are taking the pee aren't they? Transport workers aren't the only people taking a hit right now. What about the 100's of thousands of hospitality, leisure, carer and charity workers in bars, cafe's, restaurants, theme parks, swimming pools, hotels, campsites, working in supporting all our children and elderly relatives etc that are getting between tiny and zero wage increases yet have no option but to carry on and make ends meet. Why can't railway workers see the problems they are going to cause and why can't they see that they are IN THE SAME BOAT AS EVERYONE ELSE (except the wealthy obvs).

YABU - striking railway workers are more deserving of pay increases than the rest of us

YANBU - we need to pull together and see every member of society through this and not cause each other harm

OP posts:
Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:08

@Iamthewombat

How do you propose we fix the recruitment and retention crisis in so many lower paid sectors?

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 11:07

Things are not 'tough for everyone right now'. Didn't the MPs all just get a 12% payrise? The rail companies could give a better payrise and conditions to their workers but don't want to as it would cut their over-inflated profit margins.

Also, I don't think we'll have to imagine NHS staff and teachers striking. If their working conditions are not improved soon then it's pretty inevitable surely?

Sistanotcista · 27/07/2022 10:57

TimBoothseyes · 26/07/2022 18:57

railway workers don't get a bad deal at all.

What even the cleaners who are on minimum wage? The train managers and beverage staff who have to cope with abusive passengers? I'd say they have a rather bad deal wouldn't you?

But this only reinforces the point that OP is making - that things are tough for everyone right now - not just rail union staff. There are many, many cleaners on the minimum wage in the UK, some of whom have much worse conditions than the railways staff. There are many, many managers and customer service staff across the UK who are dealing with rude, difficult, abusive people. The whole point is that the rail staff do not have it any worse than others, and they are considerably better off than some.

And no, it's not that much loved MN phrase "a race to the bottom", and of course they have the right to ask for more money, but as the OP notes, there are many sectors where pay has been frozen, and striking has not been an option because of the serious impact this would have on other people's lives.

The RMT and other rail unions are lucky that they have the ability to strike - image if teachers and NHS staff downed tools and spent a lovely day in the sun as often as the RMT do? There would be complete outrage.

Whatafielddayfortheheat · 27/07/2022 10:52

We are absolutely NOT in the same boat. We are all in the same storm, but those in luxury yachts are going to fare a lot better than those on a makeshift raft. That's the issue. YABU and not socialist at all.

housemaus · 27/07/2022 10:47

Augend23 · 26/07/2022 18:11

So what we actually have is a highly unionised workforce is able to choose to leverage that to push for better pay.

Other, less unionised workforces, are not able to leverage that.

Maybe the conclusion should instead be that those sectors need to unionise instead?

Precisely.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 10:46

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 09:47

@Iamthewombat - You still haven't answered my question though! What do you expect railworkers, teachers and nurses to do, right now, to try and improve their situation? Unfortunately none of your pie in the sky ideas are actually being put into practice, which leaves them with nowhere else to go as far as I can see. Although in the longer term I do agree with some of your points, in particular the issues with cheap credit and excessive lending, your arguments seem somewhat lacking and unempathetic when it comes to addressing the immediate crisis people are facing.

Money supply controls, and strategies to grow GDP, and tax levers, are not ‘pie in the sky’. Governments around the world use them every day.

What would an ‘empathetic’ argument look like? Fiscal policy isn’t run on empathy. Do you think that whoever complains the loudest should get the most money?

What do I expect unionised people doing essential jobs to do? I expect them to do what the OP suggests, for the greater good. Loads of poorly-paid people can’t go on strike. It’s all very well saying, “they should just join a union”. Loads can’t. If you work for Sports Direct on a zero hours contract, on minimum wage, how are you going to be helped by the RMT going on strike? It might stop you getting to work: no money then. Agitating to unionise might have the same impact. Should those people be rejoicing at the RMT’s actions?

No, they shouldn’t. Big wage increases for other groups will drive prices up, including food and commodity prices. If the RMT get their 11%, rail fares will have to increase. If you are non-unionised, and poor, you’ll get the worst of it.

If you are somebody who has over-borrowed to buy a house, and you can’t deal with a moderate increase in interest rates, and that is a LOT of people, then my proposal would be that in exchange for government help, you effectively sell the government a percentage of your house, like an equity release plan. There isn’t the money to pay people’s mortgages for them without something in return.

To help with utility costs, I’d do what is already happening: inject some cash directly.

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 10:44

@Mrsparsnip - Fantastic comment - I totally agree. What worries me is that I saw an interview with Grant Shapps this morning saying that they're introducing new laws to stop workers from striking. This complete erosion of civil liberties and workers' rights is shocking and something everyone should be taking issue with in my opinion. People fought long and hard to win these rights for us and anyone who is happy about this government power grab is being very short-sighted indeed.

SpindleInTheWind · 27/07/2022 10:12

The public want a railway that is reliable, safe (for staff and passengers alike) and reasonably priced.

And that's what the strike is about, no matter how the press spins it. The RMT is working harder to give the public what it wants and needs than the government is.

Vikinga · 27/07/2022 10:06

On the contrary, we should all take their lead and revolt.

mrsparsnip · 27/07/2022 10:02

Yet, the strike is not just about pay. It is about job cuts which may lead to a dangerous working environment, it is about conditions of work as well. It is about job loss, the erosion of employees' rights and the weakening of public transport. It is about proposals and cuts that are discouraging people from using public transport after the pandemic, rather than improving services and encouraging more people to use the systems

The RMT are not the only group taking industrial action, or thinking about taking industrial action, and in all cases, the reasons for the strikes are much more profound than pay alone.

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 09:47

@Iamthewombat - You still haven't answered my question though! What do you expect railworkers, teachers and nurses to do, right now, to try and improve their situation? Unfortunately none of your pie in the sky ideas are actually being put into practice, which leaves them with nowhere else to go as far as I can see. Although in the longer term I do agree with some of your points, in particular the issues with cheap credit and excessive lending, your arguments seem somewhat lacking and unempathetic when it comes to addressing the immediate crisis people are facing.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 09:34

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 08:03

@Iamthewombat - As far as I can see you still haven't answered the question. You've only told us what 'isn't' the answer regarding rising inflation. Anyone would think you were a politician! I would be interested to know what alternatives you think railworkers, teachers, nurses etc. have when they're being offered below inflation payrises and can no longer afford to live? Would you rather they went and begged on their hands and knees for a payrise instead? Maybe you would rather they left their jobs and looked for something better paid? Not sure how that is going to improve the current recruitment crisis in teaching and the NHS though. Safety is most certainly an issue and you're the naive one if you really believe it isn't. Empty stations are in nobody interests, particularly vulnerable passengers travelling alone at night. We should all be questioning why the railway companies are making huge profits each year instead of paying their staff a living wage. It makes me angry when workers turn on each other rather than directing their wrath at the people who have the power to change things if only they weren't consumed with greed.

Happy to. Anyone with an interest in economics can tell you what to do in response to high inflation.

Let’s cut the dramatics, shall we? All this ‘begging on their hands and knees for a pay rise’ and ‘consumed with greed’ stuff. It cheapens your argument.

Firstly, I’d cut the money supply. But I’d do it by introducing strict controls over lending for residential property, not for business loans. That would direct lending towards businesses that want to invest. Right now, banks are incentivised to lend to homebuyers rather than to limited companies because they have collateral for the former but not the latter.

That would encourage businesses to grow and develop new products and markets in the U.K.. I’d introduce some corporation tax incentives to help that process along. GDP should increase as a result. Hence, more money to go around.

Reducing mortgage lending will bring house prices down, which will help younger people. High prices have been fuelled by cheap credit and excessive lending. As will increasing Bank of England base rate: I’d put it up to 4% then see what happens to inflation. Many homeowners won’t want to hear that, though: I can imagine the howls of ‘but what about my inheritance?’ and ‘negative equity!’. But that’s the medicine, I’m afraid. You can’t have it all ways.

You can’t treat inflation caused by price shocks by giving everyone pay rises. It doesn’t work. You end up chasing your tail. As the 1970s showed very clearly.

GrowlingManchego · 27/07/2022 09:26

Trains should be renationalised. Cut out the shareholders and there’s more in the pot to pay workers and keep the prices of tickets down for the public using the services.

andi62 · 27/07/2022 08:25

What else are they supposed to do? They cant award themselves a decent pay rise like the politicians do. Lots of people working in the rail industry dont get paid much, despite what the daily mail might say. Billions in dividends have been paid to share holders across all the privatised unitilies/ sectors over the decades, the money is, or at least, was there.

My daughter is not a member of a union, she says she cant afford the extra costs. Hence, in her full time job as a TA, she is expected to teach and has been teaching a class of up to 34 primary school children, over the last 18 months, whilst the teachers are off on maternity leave and covid/ long covid. Her income covers her rent on an ex council flat (shit hole) and her council tax, that' is all. Perhaps if she was in a union things might be different.

EssexCat · 27/07/2022 08:15

VeniVidiWeeWee · 26/07/2022 19:49

Interesting. Only one person who would be happy to be unable to buy food.

The rank stink of hypocrisy is strong here.

You left TWELVE minutes between your two posts….give people a chance to reply for goodness sake.

And yes I would still support your right to strike.

fudfootedfannybangle · 27/07/2022 08:10

So basically you’re a socialist until it inconveniences YOU?

Forestgate · 27/07/2022 08:07

How long till driverless trains

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 08:03

@Iamthewombat - As far as I can see you still haven't answered the question. You've only told us what 'isn't' the answer regarding rising inflation. Anyone would think you were a politician! I would be interested to know what alternatives you think railworkers, teachers, nurses etc. have when they're being offered below inflation payrises and can no longer afford to live? Would you rather they went and begged on their hands and knees for a payrise instead? Maybe you would rather they left their jobs and looked for something better paid? Not sure how that is going to improve the current recruitment crisis in teaching and the NHS though. Safety is most certainly an issue and you're the naive one if you really believe it isn't. Empty stations are in nobody interests, particularly vulnerable passengers travelling alone at night. We should all be questioning why the railway companies are making huge profits each year instead of paying their staff a living wage. It makes me angry when workers turn on each other rather than directing their wrath at the people who have the power to change things if only they weren't consumed with greed.

LadyCatStark · 27/07/2022 08:01

YABU, all public sector workers should be striking and we all need to support each other.

AnotherDelphinium · 27/07/2022 07:54

YABU, if you're 'sucking it up', you're obviously in a great position to do so, or just falling for the rhetoric and lies to try and deflect the blame from the 1% who have spent the last decade+ amassing huge amounts of wealth and are attempting to distract us from this by encouraging in-fighting rather than everyone standing together.

Anyone on strike today is losing a days pay, and will do so for every day they go on strike, but they're making that sacrifice in the hope that long term they'll be paid a living wage and corners won't keep being cut on safety.

If you really fancy some reading, the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) health and safety report from 20/21 highlights the network rail failings and how bad maintenance is getting, yet they want to cut it even more?!
www.orr.gov.uk/monitoring-regulation/rail/promoting-health-safety/annual-health-safety-report

Time to support those on strike in any way we can, join workplace unions and make the 1% live real lives, not off the flesh of their workers, who, like you point out, are the ones doing the essential jobs.

ItsDangerousInKingsmarkham · 27/07/2022 07:44

It's a complex issue, and no it should not be a race to the bottom. As a family we have been badly affected by train strikes so from a personal perspective it is hard to continue to have sympathy with striking train workers, when the inconvenience caused to so many is so huge.

Sirzy · 27/07/2022 07:31

ivykaty44 · 27/07/2022 07:00

I do wonder why billionaires are greedy, fair enough they’ve made a fortune but to keep others in poverty or push workers into poverty is not acceptable

Exactly.

and the less the average person fights back the bigger that gap will become. We shouldn’t be sitting back and happily watching the rich getting richer while more people are pushed into poverty

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 07:31

Nat6999 · 27/07/2022 06:39

YABU I know someone who is a trackside worker, he works nights, weekends, bank Holidays, Christmas, in all weather's in dangerous conditions with very technical machinery, he hasn't had a decent payrise for years. His money may look good but when you factor in the times & days he works & the shifts the money is rubbish. Don't forget if they make a mistake it could cost lives. If they remove ticket offices at stations how will anyone without a smartphone or a credit or debit card buy a ticket or someone who wants to know the best way to get somewhere or someone is lost? Station staff are needed, who is going to assist a disabled person who needs to get on a train, someone who is in a wheelchair who needs a ramp to get on a train? Who will assist someone who has a fall in the station or collapses? I fully support the RMT strike & I'm proud to say ds is going on the picket line today representing the Green Party.

Well yes, of course he works unsocial hours, because that is when track is maintained. Going on strike isn’t going to change that. As a trackside worker he is most likely employed by a third party anyway, not Network Rail.

Re staff at stations: if you think that the RMT care about somebody falling over at a station whilst it is unmanned, you are being naive. They care about their own members’ interests. Loads of stations are already unmanned. Ramps (near me, at least) are usually kept on the trains and operated by the train conductor, not by station staff.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 07:26

AhNowTed · 27/07/2022 06:22

What's your answer @Iamthewombat ?

Workers just roll over and accept whatever shitty terms their betters deign to give them?

Meanwhile billions are uncollected from tax avoiding non-doms, oligarchs, google, Amazon and multi-millionaire cabinet ministers get away with using tax havens, whilst telling the rest of us to tighten our belts?

And you wonder why the RMT aren't taking it lying down. Good for them!

It might help if you articulated the question. But if the question is, “what do we do about rising inflation?” the answer isn’t, “keep going on strike to increase wages”. The 1970s isn’t that long ago. See what happened then.

Do you realise that striking will have zero effect on tax avoidance? You, predictably, use Amazon as an example. Amazon pay tax in the U.K. Everyone with a half-baked argument about tax uses the same example.

Amazon are a US-headquartered business. Do you think that they should pay all of their global tax in the U.K.? How do you propose to make that happen? Individual governments can’t force outcomes like that. We have global tax legislation like BEPS to control profit shifting to low tax environments. The RMT going on strike isn’t going to cause the U.K. to e.g. invade Luxembourg to stop them offering favourable tax treatment to businesses.

ivykaty44 · 27/07/2022 07:00

I do wonder why billionaires are greedy, fair enough they’ve made a fortune but to keep others in poverty or push workers into poverty is not acceptable

Swipe left for the next trending thread