Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say suck it up like the rest of us???

331 replies

ticktickticktickBOOM · 26/07/2022 17:55

I come from a socialist family, we had striking miner's kids living with us for respite during the strikes. However, the railway unions are taking the pee aren't they? Transport workers aren't the only people taking a hit right now. What about the 100's of thousands of hospitality, leisure, carer and charity workers in bars, cafe's, restaurants, theme parks, swimming pools, hotels, campsites, working in supporting all our children and elderly relatives etc that are getting between tiny and zero wage increases yet have no option but to carry on and make ends meet. Why can't railway workers see the problems they are going to cause and why can't they see that they are IN THE SAME BOAT AS EVERYONE ELSE (except the wealthy obvs).

YABU - striking railway workers are more deserving of pay increases than the rest of us

YANBU - we need to pull together and see every member of society through this and not cause each other harm

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:54

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:28

@Iamthewombat

A quick Google brings up loads of articles about the UK staffing crisis across multiple sectors

Yes, but where is the evidence of widespread TA shortages, or significant teacher shortages such that schools are offering recruitment and retention premia for subjects other than STEM, in statistically significant numbers?

WhiskersPete · 27/07/2022 11:54

I hope they strike too. I hope there is a General Strike like in 1926, expect longer lasting & more successful.

I also hope this. We all need to take action together.

sHREDDIES19 · 27/07/2022 11:53

The issue with workers (understandably) asking for inflation matching wages is that firstly the rates of inflation we see currently are hopefully not permanent. The idea is that the rate of inflation falls if/as things stabilise globally. So employers aren’t going to want to offer a 10% plus increase that will be permanent to meet a temporary inflation spike. Also if all workers had an increase to match current inflation this would be self defeating as prices would rise causing further inflation. For me the answer to this issue lies in tax cuts.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:53

@Iamthewombat

No, I'm happy to pay more tax too.

Not for a tory govt granted but otherwise sure but only if tax avoidance and evasion are properly tackled and wealth inequality actually dealt with

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:52

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 11:36

@Topgub - me too! Will probably see hell freeze over first though.

I work in a school and anecdotally have never seen morale so low. Both Teachers and TAs talking about leaving / retraining in another career and some already have. We are also really struggling to get supply.

Yeah, the problem is that they are still talking about leaving and retraining. Nobody will take any notice until they put their money where their mouths are, in significant numbers.

I worked in the public sector for a few years. In finance, not frontline. I worked in three separate bodies. In each of them, the first and last thing I heard from colleagues was that morale had never been so low. Morale was on the floor. It was negative. They were all going to leave and get jobs in the private sector etc. etc.

Guess what? None of them actually left. So morale can’t have been as bad as they claimed, can it?

SofiaSoFar · 27/07/2022 11:52

I don't support the RMT's actions.

They, and "Brexit Mick" campaigned for us to ruin our economy which is the root cause of our country being even more financially fucked than all the other rich nations.

Mick Lynch and co' can FRO.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:49

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:27

@nojudgementhere

I dont want lower taxes.

I want those who earn /take the most to pay at least what they should and probably more

Are you saying everyone except you should pay more tax? Tax the rich, that old chestnut? High earners already pay most of the income tax collected by the Treasury. You’re not going to bring in significantly more income tax unless both basic rate and higher rate tax increase.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:47

@Iamthewombat

So you don't have any solutions then.

Thought not.

Just ignorance of the reality of the situation.

KettrickenSmiled · 27/07/2022 11:46

What about the 100's of thousands of hospitality, leisure, carer and charity workers in bars, cafe's, restaurants, theme parks, swimming pools, hotels, campsites, working in supporting all our children and elderly relatives etc that are getting between tiny and zero wage increases yet have no option but to carry on and make ends meet.

I hope they strike too. I hope there is a General Strike like in 1926, expect longer lasting & more successful.

As would you OP, if you gave a solitary shit about ordinary workers, instead of appropriating socialist credentials via your family history, & displaying your appalling ignorance about the actual nature of the current rail strikes.

Eat The Rich!

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:46

Of course you WOULDN’T, that should read!

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:44

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:14

@Iamthewombat

Nursing

Teaching

Doctors (not low paid but still unable to recruit or retain)

Carers

Airport staff

I'm sure there's loads more

Nursing: the people doing nursing roles are not helping their own profession’s bargaining power by doing bank work, are they? It might help them personally, because bank work pays well, but if trusts know that they can fall back on bank staff, they aren’t going to address recruitment and retention problems immediately. They are too busy firefighting.

Are nursing roles poorly paid? They aren’t well paid, but the Agenda for Change pay scales shows that Band 5, where most qualified nurses start, pays up to £31.5k. Then there’s a generous defined benefit pension scheme.

Nursing is a hard job, but I don’t see how increasing pay is going to make some bits of it less hard. Staff will still need to work shifts, to provide 24 hour care for sick people. The job involves dealing with difficult people. Nurses know that before they choose the profession. Earlier this year, it was reported that applications to study nursing hat hit an all time high.

Teaching: I’ve already covered this. It’s only the STEM subjects at secondary level that attract golden hellos. That tells me that there can’t be a crisis in recruitment for other subjects.

Doctors: there are plenty of people studying medicine at university. Applications for places outstrip supply. NHS consultants and GPs are very well paid, and many do private work on the side. Some of them are complaining about the fact that their NHS pension pots are over £1.1m and that they might leave the profession rather than pay tax on it. That’s not a retention crisis. It’s moaning.

Carers: care home fees need to go up, and we all need to deal with it. And no whining about ‘losing your inheritance’ when an elderly relative’s house or assets are used to fund care. Everyone who attempts to hide assets from local authorities, and councils are getting pretty good at recovering them incidentally, is indirectly contributing to low pay for carers. I’d relax immigration rules to help deal with this. If there are people who want to work in Britain, let them do it.

Airport staff: we all need to get used to paying more for our holidays. Cheap flights with eg Ryanair mean that corners are cut and somebody, usually the poorest paid people, get the pain. Would you choose baggage handling at Manchester airport if you could get more for working in the Amazon warehouse down the road? Of course you would.Those people have truly voted with their feet by leaving their airport jobs.

WhiskersPete · 27/07/2022 11:39

Of course they shouldn't be sucking it up! We should ALL be demanding fair pay. As PP have said, it's not a race to the bottom.

12 years we have had this government. All that austerity for what? We are mostly in a worse financial position than before. Unless you happen to be rich, it's only going to keep getting worse.

We shouldn't be attacking others for standing up for fair pay and treatment. We should be supporting them and standing up for ourselves too.

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 11:36

@Topgub - me too! Will probably see hell freeze over first though.

I work in a school and anecdotally have never seen morale so low. Both Teachers and TAs talking about leaving / retraining in another career and some already have. We are also really struggling to get supply.

Mardyface · 27/07/2022 11:31

I see it as them doing the work for the rest of us at the moment tbh. A victory for people striking is a victory for every worker in my view.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:29

Including teaching

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:28

@Iamthewombat

A quick Google brings up loads of articles about the UK staffing crisis across multiple sectors

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:27

@nojudgementhere

I dont want lower taxes.

I want those who earn /take the most to pay at least what they should and probably more

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:23

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:13

@Iamthewombat

Yes. They are quitting those jobs in huge numbers.

Lots of sectors, including care and healthcare are in crisis due to staffing

Where is the evidence that people are quitting TA and teaching jobs in significant enough numbers to cause a rethink of salaries? I can only see it in STEM subjects, for teachers.

I’ll cover healthcare in response to the other post asking me how I’d deal with recruitment and retention in other sectors (clue: it’s not encouraging the people doing those jobs to go on strike).

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 11:19

I agree with @Iamthewombat that seeking lower taxes all the time is not going to help improve public services or wages/conditions. However, what annoys me is the sheer amout of waste that the goverment take no accountability for. In particular with Covid and all the dodgy PPE contracts etc.

Sistanotcista · 27/07/2022 11:16

I would be much more supportive of NHS staff and teachers striking, as I think those staff have far harder jobs than RMT union staff, in general. But the point remains - if they stopped work as often as the RMT did, there would be a much bigger knock on effect.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:14

@Iamthewombat

Nursing

Teaching

Doctors (not low paid but still unable to recruit or retain)

Carers

Airport staff

I'm sure there's loads more

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:13

@Iamthewombat

Yes. They are quitting those jobs in huge numbers.

Lots of sectors, including care and healthcare are in crisis due to staffing

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:12

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:08

@Iamthewombat

How do you propose we fix the recruitment and retention crisis in so many lower paid sectors?

Tell me what sectors you mean and I’ll answer. It’s a bit difficult to come up with a solution for unnamed professions.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 11:10

My daughter is not a member of a union, she says she cant afford the extra costs. Hence, in her full time job as a TA, she is expected to teach and has been teaching a class of up to 34 primary school children, over the last 18 months, whilst the teachers are off on maternity leave and covid/ long covid. Her income covers her rent on an ex council flat (shit hole) and her council tax, that' is all. Perhaps if she was in a union things might be different.

I’m sorry that your daughter isn’t earning enough to live comfortably. Sadly, I don’t think that unionising TAs is the answer. TA wages are low because demand for the jobs is high, much of it coming from people who want to work hours compatible with their own children. Where roles are highly sought after, wages tend to be depressed.

The only way that TAs, and teachers, and other public sector staff, will get above-average pay increases is if (1) people simply don’t choose to do those jobs, or quit the profession in significant numbers and (2) everybody agrees to pay more tax, so that there’s more to spend on public sector salaries. But neither of those things are happening, are they? Everybody keeps voting for lower tax. Both candidates for the Tory party leadership are promising tax cuts, achieved through different methods but tax cuts nonetheless. Even people whom tax increases would indirectly benefit react with horror at the thought of paying more tax. We get what we vote for.

10HailMarys · 27/07/2022 11:09

Firstly, the strikes aren't entirely - or even mostly - about pay, so you're already coming at this from a false premise.

But regardless of that: railway workers are not 'more deserving' of pay rises than other workers. They are 'as deserving' of pay rises as other workers. It's not their fault that the other workers you've mentioned either cannot or will not strike.

There is a power in a union and that power extends beyond the members of that union. When one group takes a stand (and bear in mind people aren't paid for being on strike, so they are losing money to take that stand) it empowers other workers to do the same and can drive up wages overall - if some employers are forced to look after their workers, other employers have to start following suit if they want to keep their staff.

My idea of 'pulling together' isn't passively accepting that workers can be treated like shit - it's supporting striking workers and having solidarity with them to make things better for everyone.