Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say suck it up like the rest of us???

331 replies

ticktickticktickBOOM · 26/07/2022 17:55

I come from a socialist family, we had striking miner's kids living with us for respite during the strikes. However, the railway unions are taking the pee aren't they? Transport workers aren't the only people taking a hit right now. What about the 100's of thousands of hospitality, leisure, carer and charity workers in bars, cafe's, restaurants, theme parks, swimming pools, hotels, campsites, working in supporting all our children and elderly relatives etc that are getting between tiny and zero wage increases yet have no option but to carry on and make ends meet. Why can't railway workers see the problems they are going to cause and why can't they see that they are IN THE SAME BOAT AS EVERYONE ELSE (except the wealthy obvs).

YABU - striking railway workers are more deserving of pay increases than the rest of us

YANBU - we need to pull together and see every member of society through this and not cause each other harm

OP posts:
Itisasecret · 27/07/2022 14:10

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 13:52

It is. Look at what the Dutch, the French, the Germans and the Scandinavians are paying. Much more than us. They pay health insurance too.

Their incomes are much higher. We are an extremely high tax country in comparison to other countries because our salaries are so low. They take a a high percentage of a much lower salary.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 14:06

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 13:12

Well here's a link to an article about First Group making huge profits - they award contracts to GWR and other rail companies: www.sharesmagazine.co.uk/news/market/1655202247213645200/firstgroup-extends-gwr-contract-as-annual-profit-surges-on-disposal

It shouldn’t come as a shock to you that a rail business’s profits improved the year after a pandemic. I read the link. Which also tells you that a big chunk of the profit for the year to March 2022 came from selling off European businesses unconnected with U.K. railways. That’s what businesses do when they need to raise cash.

None of which qualifies as ‘obscene’. Even with the profit on disposal for the year to March 2022, which has nothing to do with profits from running U.K. railways, their pre-tax profit margin was 11.6%. That is not ‘obscene’.

That doesn’t surprise me. Whilst not all of our government departments are fit for purpose, there are some clever people in the Department for Transport’s commercial team. Have you ever seen one of the contracts for private sector providers to supply services to government? They aren’t written in crayon and signed off with ‘be kind’. They are full of service credit and gain share provisions. They might not be perfect contracts, but they aren’t written or managed by idiots. To suggest that the people responsible are incapable rather insults them, don’t you think?

(No, I am not one of them!)

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 13:52

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 13:12

Also it's not true that we're low tax once you include National Insurance as well as Income Tax.

It is. Look at what the Dutch, the French, the Germans and the Scandinavians are paying. Much more than us. They pay health insurance too.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 13:51

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 13:11

Iamthewombat
can we assume that you’re happy to accept a pay cut on your own behalf, and a loss of your personal pension then?

How would my losing a personal pension increase rail workers’ salaries? Are you the one who thought that Network Rail was a private business making ‘obscene profits’?

Re pay cuts, anyone whose annual pay rise is below inflation is accepting an effective pay cut. That’s how maths works. Who do you know that is getting a 10% pay rise? I’m in the private sector and pay increases are being restricted, as you would expect.

Igmum · 27/07/2022 13:17

I don't agree with either of your options. As a rail passenger I'd like to travel in safety so I share the RMT's concerns about station staffing. I'm also concerned at the massive profits some companies are looting from the taxpayers and the rail industry

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 13:12

Also it's not true that we're low tax once you include National Insurance as well as Income Tax.

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 13:12

Well here's a link to an article about First Group making huge profits - they award contracts to GWR and other rail companies: www.sharesmagazine.co.uk/news/market/1655202247213645200/firstgroup-extends-gwr-contract-as-annual-profit-surges-on-disposal

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 13:11

Iamthewombat
can we assume that you’re happy to accept a pay cut on your own behalf, and a loss of your personal pension then?

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 13:08

Topgub · 27/07/2022 13:02

@Iamthewombat

I didnt mention loopholes.

I'm aware it's practically impossible to enforce.

But that is the only viable answer

We cant keep pretending that capitalism works. We cant keep pretending that the massive and ever widening wealth gap and inequality is ok.

You're blaming the wrong people.

Its not those at the bottom to blame

No, but you said, “properly taxing them”. Which means that you think that they are currently being improperly or insufficiently taxed, in a manner that is unfair to equivalent businesses. That is the hoary old ‘loophole’ argument.

It’s a shame that you’ve veered off into bemoaning capitalism and claiming that I’m ‘blaming those at the bottom’. I’m not. Look upthread and you’ll see a post from me in which I set out the consequences of inflation-fuelling pay rises, achieved by strikes, on the very poorest people.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 13:02

@Iamthewombat

I didnt mention loopholes.

I'm aware it's practically impossible to enforce.

But that is the only viable answer

We cant keep pretending that capitalism works. We cant keep pretending that the massive and ever widening wealth gap and inequality is ok.

You're blaming the wrong people.

Its not those at the bottom to blame

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 12:58

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 12:51

Statement by Network Rail ONE of many rail networks in the Uk
“This year we made a profit before tax of £1.6bn (2019/20: £375m). This improvement was mainly due to the changes in the five-year funding settlement which made allowance for additional renewals activity which we successfully delivered, together with much improved train performance.”

Network Rail is an arms’ length public body. The shareholders are us. We should be welcoming the profits they make. It’s the train operating companies that are paying to use the track.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 12:54

Topgub · 27/07/2022 12:37

@Iamthewombat

You said you had solutions. Your solution was to deny and minimise the issue. Thats not a solution

And yes, I would like to see all lower paid workers get a wage increase. 10% seems about right.

I'd like this to be funded from the massive profits corporations are making.

Properly taxing them.

Introducing linked wages.

Tackling housing and fuel costs

I'd be willing to pay more tax and for goods if things were fairer rather than just making billionaires richer

Not this again. Every poorly thought out argument about tax is the same. Close the loopholes! Make Amazon pay more tax! Etc. !

Firstly, what is a ‘loophole’? I’m familiar with the tax legislation. Do you think that the finance acts are deliberately written to contain ‘Easter eggs’ that only the wise can spot and exploit? Like a treasure hunt, whilst all the tax boffins gently laugh at each other’s brainy endeavours, like on Only Connect? No.

I’ve already explained, upthread, that the U.K. government cannot itself prevent businesses shifting profits to lower tax environments. The international BEPS legislation does that. To reiterate the example above, we can’t invade Luxembourg and say, “we’re occupying you until you agree not to sign any forward agreements with multinationals, you rotters”. However, you might want to consider that when you buy cheap stuff from Amazon rather than from a U.K.- based business that pays all its tax in the U.K., you’re indirectly facilitating tax avoidance.

Re the billionaires: you or somebody else say that there are 200 in the U.K. what’s your plan? To take a billion off each of them because they won’t miss it? How successful would that be, do you think? Even if you did get £1Bn off each of them, how far do you think that would go towards the 10% pay rise you think that every public sector worker should get? Not very, is the answer.

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 12:51

Statement by Network Rail ONE of many rail networks in the Uk
“This year we made a profit before tax of £1.6bn (2019/20: £375m). This improvement was mainly due to the changes in the five-year funding settlement which made allowance for additional renewals activity which we successfully delivered, together with much improved train performance.”

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 12:44

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 11:59

The profits that the rail companies are taking and passing on to shareholders are obscene, while they keep workers on appallingly low pay - NOT the drivers - the cleaners, ticket office workers etc
Of course they are going to strike, if there's no progress in talks. And we should support them. And I very much regret that Mick Lynch is a Brexiter, but that doesn't mean that he's wrong about this.

What profits ARE the rail operating companies remitting to their shareholders? How do you know that those profits are obscene? Measured how? What net profit margin is, in your opinion, obscene? It’s a genuine question.

Topgub · 27/07/2022 12:37

@Iamthewombat

You said you had solutions. Your solution was to deny and minimise the issue. Thats not a solution

And yes, I would like to see all lower paid workers get a wage increase. 10% seems about right.

I'd like this to be funded from the massive profits corporations are making.

Properly taxing them.

Introducing linked wages.

Tackling housing and fuel costs

I'd be willing to pay more tax and for goods if things were fairer rather than just making billionaires richer

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 12:35

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 12:03

How on earth are the lower paid workers going to pay additional tax though if they're struggling to pay for fuel/heating/food? I personally think rates like 70% in France for high earners are too high and likely to just encorage evasion. However, it would be nice if the government would work a bit harder in closing the loopholes that allow businesses and high-net worth individuals to avoid paying their fair share.

Lower paid workers don’t pay as much tax, proportional to their income, as higher paid people. That’s what the personal allowance is for (and, parenthetically, why flat rate tax is a terrible idea). We have some of the lowest tax rates in Europe. We can’t have a free at the point of delivery healthcare system and low taxation. That should be obvious. Everyone will claim that they can’t afford to pay more tax. That doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t.

And nobody is talking about 70% income tax rates for the U.K.

RamblingEclectic · 27/07/2022 12:29

No-one should suffer to effect improvement for all. No-one except the people that have the power to make the changes that is.

Impacting those in power without anyone else suffering is a fairy tale idea. We can reduce that suffering with good community networks, but we can't eliminate it.

by boycotting using their services and refuse to buy tickets until they give comply with mass demand? That would be MUCH more effective in getting some fast action.

Boycotts are not the route to fast action. Most effective boycotts last months, many into years - and they work by building an alternative and networks of safety nets for those affected, like that family respite. That's a big part of why no one has called for it yet - they take a lot of effort and involve pain over a long period of time.

I can only feel history education and our society's commemoration of the work and lives put into improving work standards that there are so many who think strikes should be painless to the public, boycotts make fast anything, and that many having it worse or being unable to strike is somehow a reason why people shouldn't be fighting for better.

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 12:28

Just to add, that currently the price of our train tickets is not reflected in the pay packets of the rail workers. Bosses are taking huge salaries. And, to ME, even MORE annoyingly, many of our rail companies are owned by other countries, who are using OUR fares to subsidise their own countries public transport systems.

Iamthewombat · 27/07/2022 12:28

Topgub · 27/07/2022 11:47

@Iamthewombat

So you don't have any solutions then.

Thought not.

Just ignorance of the reality of the situation.

The only ‘solution’ that would be acceptable to you, it seems, is immediate 10%+ pay rises for everyone who decides to go on strike. I asked upthread, in response to a different poster who thought that all public sector workers should get a 10% pay rise backdated to last April, where the money was coming from. How much more tax was she prepared to pay, personally? What sacrifices would she make?

Funnily enough, neither she, nor anyone else replied. But that’s a pretty fundamental question, isn’t it?

Flutterbybudget · 27/07/2022 12:26

There seems to be an entire level of ignorance about the implications for EVERY worker, if the rail bosses are allowed to rip up the contracts of the rail workers (and yes, that include does the drivers)
Currently YOUR contract, offers you protection from your employer frankly “shitting” on you.
Of these proposals go ahead, the implications are


  • the rail workers will be worse off financially than they are currently, not in comparison to inflation, but in ACTUAL terms. A rail worker currently working 5 days will be taking home less money they will be under the new proposals.

  • Their pensions will be worth less than they are now.

  • They will be forced to work unsocial hours and weekends - currently the law states that we all have the option to opt out of Sunday working

  • cuts to rail safety will impact everyone. Just the other day, there was an incident on a train, and passengers needed to be escorted to safety by the crew. No crew - no one to do this. No one to help a disabled person alight and get to safety. An incident on the unmanned DLR saw a lady dragged along the platform after her coat got caught in the door. If her coat had been done up, and she had not managed to wriggle free, she would have been under the wheels. A train manager/ guard checks tickets, but they also play a huge role in ensuring that passengers are safe and feel safe. They remove people from dangerous situations all the time. Staff on stations make people feel safer than standing on deserted platforms, and assist with making sure you get on the right train. Staff on trains can keep you informed about any delays or potential problems with your journey - the train manager arranged a taxi for someone who missed her connection


If these contracts can be ripped up, and these workers can be left with no job security, and financially worse off, so can I and so can YOU

GiraffeInTheCity · 27/07/2022 12:05

YABU. They have a right to demand a decent wage - and tbh nobody should have to 'suck it up' when there are almost 200 billionaires in the U.K, and a bunch of mega - corporations making massive profits; who if taxed fairly would make these demands moot.

We should all be on strike really. Boils my piss.

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 12:05

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 27/07/2022 12:02

Agreed with you. I've used public transport almost every day for approx 30 years and originally when British Rail weren't privatised things were better.

However, I've stood on platforms waiting for trains which are delayed, cancelled, driver doesn't turn up, etc and it's awful. My main train if I get it is Thameslink to King's Cross (via Tulse Hill) yet every day it's packed and I don't get a seat. Who designed these bloody trains?! It's better than pre-pandemic where some mornings you'd literally fight to get on the trains. I now get an express bus to work and back which costs a fraction of the train ticket and is less for me to walk to as well and I always get a seat. Downside is no cafe at the bus stop but I can live with that!

One of the main reasons rail strikers are striking is because like me (only in office 2 days a week) they're worried about less people using their services. Well the train companies should've thought about improving their services sooner.

But what you're complaining about is policy on the part of the companies who are also screwing over their workers, which is why the workers are striking.

nojudgementhere · 27/07/2022 12:03

How on earth are the lower paid workers going to pay additional tax though if they're struggling to pay for fuel/heating/food? I personally think rates like 70% in France for high earners are too high and likely to just encorage evasion. However, it would be nice if the government would work a bit harder in closing the loopholes that allow businesses and high-net worth individuals to avoid paying their fair share.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 27/07/2022 12:02

djdkdkddkek · 26/07/2022 18:09

I have to use public transport everyday
and I genuinely believe that they’re just greedy as fuck now and I’m fully over it
I actually don’t care about their cause, wants or needs and also wouldn’t care if they just employed a whole batch of new workers

and I know that’s shitty and heartless and blah blah blah
honestly couldn’t give a shit
thei get paid more than most, better working than most, and just simply hold the county to ransom because they’re just greedy as fuck

Agreed with you. I've used public transport almost every day for approx 30 years and originally when British Rail weren't privatised things were better.

However, I've stood on platforms waiting for trains which are delayed, cancelled, driver doesn't turn up, etc and it's awful. My main train if I get it is Thameslink to King's Cross (via Tulse Hill) yet every day it's packed and I don't get a seat. Who designed these bloody trains?! It's better than pre-pandemic where some mornings you'd literally fight to get on the trains. I now get an express bus to work and back which costs a fraction of the train ticket and is less for me to walk to as well and I always get a seat. Downside is no cafe at the bus stop but I can live with that!

One of the main reasons rail strikers are striking is because like me (only in office 2 days a week) they're worried about less people using their services. Well the train companies should've thought about improving their services sooner.

liliainterfrutices · 27/07/2022 11:59

The profits that the rail companies are taking and passing on to shareholders are obscene, while they keep workers on appallingly low pay - NOT the drivers - the cleaners, ticket office workers etc
Of course they are going to strike, if there's no progress in talks. And we should support them. And I very much regret that Mick Lynch is a Brexiter, but that doesn't mean that he's wrong about this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread