Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say suck it up like the rest of us???

331 replies

ticktickticktickBOOM · 26/07/2022 17:55

I come from a socialist family, we had striking miner's kids living with us for respite during the strikes. However, the railway unions are taking the pee aren't they? Transport workers aren't the only people taking a hit right now. What about the 100's of thousands of hospitality, leisure, carer and charity workers in bars, cafe's, restaurants, theme parks, swimming pools, hotels, campsites, working in supporting all our children and elderly relatives etc that are getting between tiny and zero wage increases yet have no option but to carry on and make ends meet. Why can't railway workers see the problems they are going to cause and why can't they see that they are IN THE SAME BOAT AS EVERYONE ELSE (except the wealthy obvs).

YABU - striking railway workers are more deserving of pay increases than the rest of us

YANBU - we need to pull together and see every member of society through this and not cause each other harm

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 26/07/2022 19:01

No opinion but it might be an idea to think about the data.

Is it greedy to seek a 3% pay cut instead of a 10?% pay cut and redundancies?

Taking a broader view, by what % has transport workers' earning power been reduced over the last 12 years along with teachers, health workers and so on?

By what % has the income and wealth and share of GDP has the top 5%/1%/0.1% increased over the last 12 years? Did that happen by accident?

Perhaps an unmissable opportunity to permanently impair the earning power of public sector employees by more than 10?% over the next few years?

Do you think a 10% haircut of the wealth of the richest 1% would be taken quietly for the good of the country.

When certain corporates scream than consumer demand is impairing turnover and profits then you might see a government incentivised to take action.

locomocol · 26/07/2022 18:57

i don't believe in a race to the bottom, wages have stagnated for most for nearly 2 decades.

TimBoothseyes · 26/07/2022 18:57

railway workers don't get a bad deal at all.

What even the cleaners who are on minimum wage? The train managers and beverage staff who have to cope with abusive passengers? I'd say they have a rather bad deal wouldn't you?

MomwasCasual · 26/07/2022 18:48

I would love to see an organised general strike that hit the right people in the right places

It generally does. The bosses, in their profit margins.

ticktickticktickBOOM · 26/07/2022 18:42

I agree with so many of these comments. I'm just conflicted because the charity I work has been on a pay freeze for over 10 years and although we have had a rise in the last 2 years it still an effective pay cut now due to the NI increases and cost of living. We are unionised but the nature of our work means there would be huge amounts of suffering if strike action was taken - so employees have never voted to strike despite many opportunities in the last 6 years.

Of course I think everyone should be on fair pay but railway workers don't get a bad deal at all. I agree that cuts in employees is a safety issue and this is happening in so many sectors, not least the NHS as we have seen recently. The real reason many of us are suffering is due to the cost of living increases, the higher NI, the petrol hikes and the gas and lecky increases.

I would love to see an organised general strike that hit the right people in the right places. Sadly shutting the rail network only harms the people who depend on public transport for work, hospital appointments, the disables, the elderly and many others.

Why can't we learn to strike in a more general and organised way? For example all refusing to buy petrol for a week (unless essential of course), all refusing to pay the income tax on our wages, collectively refusing to pay our gas and electric bills for 3 months or all cancelling our direct debits.

Now those actions would send a clear and terrifying message to those making money out of us. Collective refusal to pay.

I'll probably end up getting my phone tapped now.

OP posts:
Topgub · 26/07/2022 18:41

@StepAwayFromGoogling

But we can afford to keep paying massive wages and profits at the top?

StepAwayFromGoogling · 26/07/2022 18:40

If every sector of society was striking to get a wage increase then we would send the country into bankruptcy. We simply cannot sustain the level of borrowing required.

Topgub · 26/07/2022 18:38

I hate to see how you cope when everyone else, including carers and nurses strike too.

Manekinek0 · 26/07/2022 18:38

I didn't vote, the options were goady and dumb.

Wealth inequality is such a massive problem in this country, and it's a problem that has got worse over covid. Of course all those in the jobs listed also deserve a pay rise. Unfortunately without unions most will never strike but I would have no problem if they did.

LadyWithLapdog · 26/07/2022 18:34

It’s not a race to the bottom, don’t be a tit.

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/07/2022 18:31

Of course YABU but not for the reason you say. One set of workers is striking for better pay and for work conditions and contractual obligations not to severely deteriorate tat the cost to their safety and work/life balance. This doesn't mean they are more deserving than other shafted workers. It means they deserve respect from their bosses with regard to their work conditions, and fair pay for the work they do.

I'm so tired of this divide and rule mentality. Like when people kick uni lecturers for striking, totally unaware that some of them are on £17ph zero hours contracts, and not paid for the enormous amount of prep and planning or for the essential research they contribute towards.

BigDayToday · 26/07/2022 18:30

The subservient attitude of many people if this country when it comes to employment genuinely baffles me sometimes.

Unpaid overtime expected and accepted in many jobs, pressure to work when ill, blaming colleagues for increased workload or feeling 'guilt' about leaving colleagues to cover absenses when the problem is understaffing, and bitterly complaining when other workers try to enforce their contracts/improve their working conditions.

We're all so easily manipulated into blaming each other. How about supporting people to push back/upward so we can improve things for everyone?

PeekAtYou · 26/07/2022 18:29

Railway workers aren't striking because they think that they deserve pay rises more than other sectors. Their unions have been effective at using their power which is the point of a union.

I sympathise with people who have been inconvenienced by the strikes and are in jobs where there's no unions to advocate for them but railway workers taking effective pay cuts because of inflation helps nobody either.

If you think that the strikers are the problem then you have fallen for the propaganda. The pandemic demonstrated beautifully how we are not all in this together and the people at the top want us fighting amongst each other so they can become richer by claiming pay rises, removing the cap on bankers bonuses, award government contracts to party donors etc. If we were all in this together then we would have seen more leaders rejecting pay rises and accepting temporary pay cuts for the greater good but austerity is only for those at the bottom.

MangoBiscuit · 26/07/2022 18:24

You're angry at the wrong people OP.

LovinglifeAF · 26/07/2022 18:23

It’s not a race to the bottom

Jalisco · 26/07/2022 18:22

Railway workers haven't darfur they are more deserving than anyone else. They are fighting their employer for their terms. They are supposed to sit around on their arses until the general strike are they?

Your "socialist" credentials, to say nothing about theory, appeal to have slipped. Maybe instead of congratulating yourself ( or your parents? ) on the selflessness of taking in poor miners children, you could do a refresher course on solidarity?

girlmom21 · 26/07/2022 18:22

I work in the industry but in the private sector and everyone who works for private companies are getting cost of living increases. Let's not shit on the ones who aren't.

djdkdkddkek · 26/07/2022 18:21

sorry I actually didn’t mean to post that!!

Missmissmissmiss · 26/07/2022 18:21

It's not just about pay though, it's about working conditions. The rail companies are making massive profits on the backs of the workers and passengers; they're laughing all the way to the off-shore bank.

Everyone who works deserves a fair day's pay for a fair day's work, so I fully support the rail, BT and Royal Mail strikes.

I always said I wouldn't strike as a teacher but after more than a decade of real terms pay cuts, it's with a heavy heart that I will be voting to strike when my union ballots in the autumn.

djdkdkddkek · 26/07/2022 18:21

oh gosh imagine someon

EddyF · 26/07/2022 18:20

The whole OP is so basic.

SpindleInTheWind · 26/07/2022 18:19

You don't even understand the arguments, OP.

Lancrelady80 · 26/07/2022 18:19

The massive problem with any strikes is that they are always, always portrayed as being about pay when it's rare for that to be the only (or even main) reason. The media (probably with a bit of government pressure) generally only talk about the money, not undermining of agreements, loss of jobs or worsening of working conditions. Far better to demonize those on strike so the public have zero sympathy.

Postal workers are due to strike. I guarantee it will be reported as being over pay. Actually, it's to far more to do with Sunday working becoming mandatory and being forced to deliver all the post every day regardless of contracted working hours with no overtime pay and no consideration at all of impact on other caring commitments. They will have no idea from one day to the next when they will have finished their work, and family life is being eroded.

Sunday working can be brought in as mandatory for new workers who know what they are signing up to, but is unreasonable to force on workers who may well have looked elsewhere for jobs had Sundays been in the original job description. Sunday is the only day we all have together as a family. And dh's end time of 3pm means he can just about collect the children from school (as a teacher myself, I cannot do so.) Enforcing these things will cause a massive problem.

Pay is not the point.

Posties have just been given a 2% rise and on the whole are okayish with it ("sucking it up") as we are all pretty much in the same boat.

But in the media, it's always "dispute about pay."

FourEyesGood · 26/07/2022 18:18

Your voting options are ridiculous and show that you don’t understand the issue.

CavernousScream · 26/07/2022 18:17

YABU and your statements are so leading that I suspect you’re also being paid. We had enough of this with Brexit, we’re not going to be conned into this shit again. Everyone deserves good pay and working conditions. Everyone should join a Union.