Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you always lose out on car insurance?

60 replies

AlumhurstRoad · 26/07/2022 15:06

So three years ago I bought my "dream car" with the lump sum of my pension pot for £5,250. It was hi-spec, low mileage, full service history, one owner. Since then I have driven it at weekends and have looked after it well. Similar vehicles are currently available on Auto Trader for about £4,500.

I have not been involved in any accident for over 30 years, and that was in a company car. In my own name I have 17 years no claims bonus, the last 13 years with the same company.

A few weeks ago on a dual carriageway, I was slowing to 30 to stick to a speed limit as advised by an overhead gantry, and the car behind ran into the back of me. The impact caused sufficient damage for the insurance company to write the car off, against my wishes as I wanted it to be repaired.

However, the most the insurance company are prepared to offer me is £1,500, being calculated as £2,350 "market value", less £350 excess, less £500 salvage (numbers have been rounded to avoid identification). The remaining £1,500 is not enough to purchase a replacement vehicle, nor is it enough to repair the car, so basically I have lost my vehicle.

Is this a normal result from a "no-fault" accident? I'm feeling pretty fed-up as I have been with this insurance company since 2009 and never made a claim until now. I was expecting them to "look after" me and repair the vehicle, and instead they have scrapped the vehicle and cancelled my insurance.

Has anyone been in a similar situation and were they able to resolve it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tessasanderson · 15/08/2022 13:49

Duettino · 26/07/2022 15:45

Used to work in insurance so willing to answer any questions.

You may have received a low ball offer but they will be using book price. You should be able to challenge it and provide 3 identical examples. We got so many examples that were a different fuel or engine size and completely irrelevant.

Your premium may go up once this has been resolved because statistically you are more likely to have another accident regardless of fault.

Ignore the rest. This is someone who knows. I also did quite a few years in Insurance Claims in a past life.

The valuation is an OFFER. If you dont agree with it, it takes seconds, minutes at most to do a autotrader search of similar cars on forecourts for sale. Screen print and send them to insurer. Base them on forecourt sales rather than private as they should be more expensive and you need as much as possible to replace.

The excess is part of your uninsured losses. Your own insurers will be chasing for their own loses so reques that your excess is included. If they wont, just make contact with other insurers and they should be accommodating. Its not difficult unless you want it to be.

Duettino · 15/08/2022 13:35

AlumhurstRoad · 15/08/2022 11:12

Sorry to resurrect an old thread, I'm still not having any joy with the insurance company. They've increased their offer by £90 but there is still a shortfall of almost £3,000 compared to a replacement vehicle of the same year / model / mileage. They are saying that you pay the excess whether the accident is your fault or not? Does anyone have any ideas? Thanks again.

Might be worth getting a valuation elsewhere or ask them to evidence theirs.

Jammysod · 15/08/2022 12:36

AlumhurstRoad · 15/08/2022 11:12

Sorry to resurrect an old thread, I'm still not having any joy with the insurance company. They've increased their offer by £90 but there is still a shortfall of almost £3,000 compared to a replacement vehicle of the same year / model / mileage. They are saying that you pay the excess whether the accident is your fault or not? Does anyone have any ideas? Thanks again.

The advice in respect of the excess is correct, though you should be able to get that back once the other side accept liability either:

  • your insurer will reimburse you once they receive confirmation of acceptance of liability (they'll include it in the amount they recover)
  • if you have legal expense cover on your policy; they will do it for you.
  • you can phone the other insurer and request it (they'll just require proof it was deducted from your settlement- your insurance can provide you with this)

If you're still not happy with your offer you need to escalate via their complaints process & then via the ombudsman if still not resolved satisfactory. That could take months to go through though.

You can always accept payment of what they're offering on an interim basis though (make it clear it's only on interim and not full & final) if you need money in the meantime.

AlumhurstRoad · 15/08/2022 11:12

Sorry to resurrect an old thread, I'm still not having any joy with the insurance company. They've increased their offer by £90 but there is still a shortfall of almost £3,000 compared to a replacement vehicle of the same year / model / mileage. They are saying that you pay the excess whether the accident is your fault or not? Does anyone have any ideas? Thanks again.

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 28/07/2022 23:34

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 27/07/2022 17:16

So you agree @SofiaSoFar is right and you were wrong. You categorically stated it is for financed vehicles and are now saying it's usually for finance. It's not, it's for anyone who doesn't have RTI cover on their motor insurance, regardless of how they've funded the purchase.

I wouldn't buy a car on finance without GAP, but TBH, I wouldn't pay cash for a car without it either. Too many idiots on the road to risk a shortfall, but as I say, I'll get my boss to contact our compliance officer and the Financial Conduct Authority to tell them to change our compliance procedures because some random on MN claims to know better.

Yep. We buy our cars outright 9 times out of 10 and always take out GAP, as do most people I know.

And the 'vehicle replacement plus' cover is brilliant, isn't it - even better than RTI - as it covers the difference to get a brand new equivalent car even if there's been a complete model change since your car was built. That can be a really big sum of money 3 or 4 years later when a new model has come out.

Maybeebebe · 27/07/2022 23:16

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 27/07/2022 17:16

So you agree @SofiaSoFar is right and you were wrong. You categorically stated it is for financed vehicles and are now saying it's usually for finance. It's not, it's for anyone who doesn't have RTI cover on their motor insurance, regardless of how they've funded the purchase.

I wouldn't buy a car on finance without GAP, but TBH, I wouldn't pay cash for a car without it either. Too many idiots on the road to risk a shortfall, but as I say, I'll get my boss to contact our compliance officer and the Financial Conduct Authority to tell them to change our compliance procedures because some random on MN claims to know better.

Yawn... go you!!

most gap insurance is taken for finance cars - happy now??

Your life must so boring

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 27/07/2022 17:16

Maybeebebe · 27/07/2022 16:29

Gap insurance is usually for finance agreements

When is Gap insurance needed?
We think Gap insurance can be useful and is therefore worth thinking about – but it won’t make sense for everyone.
Generally speaking, Gap is likely to be worthwhile in the following situations:
You used a large loan to buy your vehicle

Gap insurance can offer a means of paying off outstanding finance on your car, which means if your car’s stolen or damaged beyond repair you won’t have to continue to make payments on it.

You’re concerned about the depreciation of your vehicle
The quicker your car loses its value, the less your insurer will pay after a total loss incident, compared to what you paid for it. Gap insurance means you’ll get more back.

Your car is on a long-term lease
If you have a long-term rental agreement for a vehicle with a mileage allowance, a write-off could leave you without a car and a bill for thousands of pounds. Gap insurance can help protect against this.

So you agree @SofiaSoFar is right and you were wrong. You categorically stated it is for financed vehicles and are now saying it's usually for finance. It's not, it's for anyone who doesn't have RTI cover on their motor insurance, regardless of how they've funded the purchase.

I wouldn't buy a car on finance without GAP, but TBH, I wouldn't pay cash for a car without it either. Too many idiots on the road to risk a shortfall, but as I say, I'll get my boss to contact our compliance officer and the Financial Conduct Authority to tell them to change our compliance procedures because some random on MN claims to know better.

Maybeebebe · 27/07/2022 16:29

SofiaSoFar · 27/07/2022 15:51

@Maybeebebe

Gap insurance is for when you have finance on the vehicle and may not pay enough if the car is written off during finance.

No it's not just for that. You are wrong.

Gap insurance is usually for finance agreements

When is Gap insurance needed?
We think Gap insurance can be useful and is therefore worth thinking about – but it won’t make sense for everyone.
Generally speaking, Gap is likely to be worthwhile in the following situations:
You used a large loan to buy your vehicle

Gap insurance can offer a means of paying off outstanding finance on your car, which means if your car’s stolen or damaged beyond repair you won’t have to continue to make payments on it.

You’re concerned about the depreciation of your vehicle
The quicker your car loses its value, the less your insurer will pay after a total loss incident, compared to what you paid for it. Gap insurance means you’ll get more back.

Your car is on a long-term lease
If you have a long-term rental agreement for a vehicle with a mileage allowance, a write-off could leave you without a car and a bill for thousands of pounds. Gap insurance can help protect against this.

AlumhurstRoad · 27/07/2022 16:16

@Dotjonesthanks for your reply, could you point me in the direction of a specialist insurer? My policy is due to renew soon.

OP posts:
AlumhurstRoad · 27/07/2022 16:12

Thanks @Oblomov22, yes I have been fighting, it took them 9 weeks to make their offer. I just feel so incredibly let down having been with the same company for so many years without ever making a claim.

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 27/07/2022 15:51

@Maybeebebe

Gap insurance is for when you have finance on the vehicle and may not pay enough if the car is written off during finance.

No it's not just for that. You are wrong.

Oblomov22 · 27/07/2022 15:48

Please fight. Don't just accept their first offer. They will try every trick in the book. Negotiate with them. You could get it repaired. You could ask then to replace it like-for-like. Watch them squirm.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 27/07/2022 15:41

If I were you I would go directly to the other person's insurance and deal with them directly.

GimmeSleep · 27/07/2022 15:20

Find a few for sale of a similar spec, mileage and use this to show your insurance company how much it would cost to replace like for like.

(apologies haven't rtft if this has already been mentioned)

Wowjustwow99 · 27/07/2022 15:18

Some have settled down other not of much! Some manufacturers have stopped production on some models as they can't get the parts.
Vans are still crazy.

Tyres prices and supply could be interesting as most come from Russia.

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 27/07/2022 15:13

Wowjustwow99 · 27/07/2022 15:06

If you are claiming in your own policy you have to pay your excess, if you have legal cover they will look to claim it back for you if non fault and the other vehicle was insured.

They should not be deducted the salvage value of the vehicle unless you are keeping it.

If you are not happy with the value challenge it, look online at sites like auto trader for vehicles the same spec as yours, with a similar mile and present this to the insurers and ask how they came to the pre accident value they have given you.

Second hand car values have gone through the roof at the moment.

Just out of interest which insurers is it?

They had gone through the roof over the last year, but have started to settle down a bit now. Demand is slow at the moment so prices are falling.

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 27/07/2022 15:11

Maybeebebe · 26/07/2022 16:30

Gap insurance is for when you have finance on the vehicle and may not pay enough if the car is written off during finance.

However, the most the insurance company are prepared to offer me is £1,500, being calculated as £2,350 "market value", less £350 excess, less £500 salvage (numbers have been rounded to avoid identification)
if the accident was not your fault, you should not be paying any excess. I'm not sure what salvage is in this case, but again, I'm pretty sure you shouldn't be paying it

Bloody hell, all my employers over the last decade and the Financial Conduct Authority need to bow down to your superior knowledge. All this while, we have been offering GAP to any eligible customer, regardless of whether they are financing the car or not under the FCA Treating Customers Fairly principle.

Obviously we are all wrong. Off for a meeting with my boss to tell him someone from MN knows better than him.

Wowjustwow99 · 27/07/2022 15:06

If you are claiming in your own policy you have to pay your excess, if you have legal cover they will look to claim it back for you if non fault and the other vehicle was insured.

They should not be deducted the salvage value of the vehicle unless you are keeping it.

If you are not happy with the value challenge it, look online at sites like auto trader for vehicles the same spec as yours, with a similar mile and present this to the insurers and ask how they came to the pre accident value they have given you.

Second hand car values have gone through the roof at the moment.

Just out of interest which insurers is it?

AlumhurstRoad · 27/07/2022 15:04

Thanks @BadLad, what is so frustrating in this case is that if they had used a more realistic vehicle valuation, it probably would have been worth repairing the vehicle. The verbal estimate I got was £2,000 plus VAT.

OP posts:
AlumhurstRoad · 27/07/2022 15:01

@DontMakeMeShushYou Hello thanks for the reply. The insurance company are agreeing that this the accident was not my fault. I was hit from behind on a dual carriageway. They were able to find the other drivers' details very easily, so much so that it did occur to me that they might be his insurers as well.

OP posts:
BadLad · 26/07/2022 23:30

AlumhurstRoad · 26/07/2022 16:19

@ReginaFilange001 Yes I think that is what the salvage figure of £500 is for. The problem is that the £1,500 they wish to pay after all deductions is not enough to get the repair work done.

The very definition of a write off is that the repair costs are more than the car's value. So naturally what they offer you will be less than the cost of getting it repaired.

Your excess is not lost money, and will be claimable from the other driver's insurance.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 26/07/2022 23:04

@AlumhurstRoad So why would your insurance company think this was a no-fault accident?

If it wasn't your fault then you don't have to pay any excess and your insurance company should be working on your behalf to get the maximum payout from the other driver's insurance. Unless the other driver wasn't insured, or you failed to get any of their details ...

Isonthecase · 26/07/2022 20:17

Put in a formal complaint with evidence. It costs them every time someone goes to the ombudsman so they're more likely to settle. Remember it's your right to be left in the same position as you were before the accident, not thousands short of buying the same car. Your car will also be worth less for being a write off, even with the repairs done.

AlumhurstRoad · 26/07/2022 17:18

@BarbaraofSeville Yes I sent details of comparable vehicles on Auto Trader right at the start of the process. My vehicle is particularly low mileage for its year though so it is difficult to get an exact comparable.

OP posts:
AlumhurstRoad · 26/07/2022 17:03

@BarbaraofSeville Thanks for the reply. I thought the damage was not too bad but I sent photographs of the damage to the insurance company and they decided to write the vehicle off. Frustratingly in the meantime they asked for photographs of all sides of the vehicle, which were of course undamaged, before making that decision, thus wasting another two weeks.

OP posts: