Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's an unfair stigma around recreational drug use?

219 replies

janef001 · 26/07/2022 13:32

I have a female friend who recreationally uses weed, ecstasy and xanax from time to time. They live in a houseshare with two other women.

Last week one roommate couldn't find an Apple Watch and asked my friend if they've seen it. They said no. My friend went to sleep later during the day and overheard the other two downstairs saying "I think x must have taken it for cash, you know she does drugs all the time."

My friend was upset to say the least and especially when the roommate later found it in the next day at the bottom of her clothes hamper near the washing machine.

I know these attitudes aren't uncommon and I've heard my own family who are quite educated express them. I understand the devastation addiction causes but many people take drugs apart from weed and alcohol and don't end up stealing from friends/family/roommates.

I wonder why there's still such a strong stigma

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 01/05/2023 14:10

MrsWooster · 26/07/2022 13:58

There’s a “strong stigma” because drugs are illegal. Your super-cool friend is supporting an exploitative, criminal culture. She makes that choice and shouldn’t be surprised if people judge her by the company she keeps.

This explains it very well.

It might not be fair to assume she would steal, but she can’t expect people to not bother about her drug use.

HellonMN · 01/05/2023 14:07

ZOMBIE THREAD

EBearhug · 01/05/2023 14:03

If you take drugs with weeks, months or even years in between, I'd say that's definitely recreational not addicted. Not just verbal acrobatics.

Is everyone who drinks only at weekends addicted to alcohol?

DaSilvaP · 01/05/2023 01:51

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 23:41

In your example though you're talking about addiction, not recreational use.

"addiction, not recreational use"?
The way I see it, it's just verbal acrobatics to mean "these addicts still have some control over their addiction".
I can't see anything "unfair" about out being cautious when dealing with addicts be them plain addicts or "addicts-light".
Although, to be fair, dishonesty and short-term thinking is far from being the reserve of drug addicts.

Walkaround · 02/08/2022 09:02

Any habit that is purely hedonistic, potentially addictive, and relatively costly is going to attract some stigma, particularly if indulged in on a regular basis, likely to make the person indulging in it less in control of their faculties, potentially hazardous to their health, and illegal. Not everyone approves of alcohol consumption, either.

EBearhug · 28/07/2022 13:55

if alcohol and tobacco had been discovered recently, they would certainly NOT be legal. They are so ingrained into Western culture that no party who proposed to ban them would get elected - unfair, but true.

Absolutely this.

I don't think all drugs should be legal, but I do think that that drug laws should be reviewed and rationalised based on science.

Legalising (some drugs) does not make it a free for all; I would assume that like alcohol, there would be a lot of restrictions around its manufacture, especially more dangerous ones (spirits) - you're not allowed to set up a distillery without a lot of paperwork. You can’t sell alcohol without a license. You can’t buy it if you're under 18. You can’t do things like drive if you've been drinking (not legally, at least; obviously it does happen.) Being drunk on duty would be gross misconduct in every job I've ever had.

If drug control laws were changed, I would expect them to be similarly controlled and restricted, and alcohol and tobacco should be part of it all. I'd be happier to consume drugs that I knew had been through some control process and that I knew the strength of, like you see on beer and cider and wine and spirits labels. It wouldn't eliminate under-age use (many of us will have sneaked a fag round the back of school and been drinking before we were 28.) It wouldn't eliminate crime (there's plenty of that around alcohol and tobacco still,) but there's already a lot of time and money spent on fighting drug-related crime (and smuggling of otherwise legal alcohol and tobacco,) but it would reduce it, and would generate tax income. It wouldn't eliminate all harms and addiction, but we already have a lot of support for addicts who want help, drugs and alcohol, and going back my alcoholic mother, if they don't want help, it won't matter how much is out there.

Lots of people go out at weekends and have a few drinks without becoming addicted; others wreck their own lives and those of other people. Same happens with illegal drugs. Legality doesn't change this. (Same with abortion, as someone said upthread. You don't stop them, you just stop them being safe and legal.)

I wouldn't expect every drug to be legalised. I would expect some to be strictly controlled within medical settings, as is currently the case - opiates have always been massive important in pain management, for example. It's ridiculous that medical research into drugs like cannabis wasn't allowed for so long. And decisions around legality should be based on actual research into known risks, not on whether it's a vote-winner or not, but no political party will go for that,because they want votes more.

Carpy88999 · 28/07/2022 06:53

Florenz · 26/07/2022 19:23

I'd be in favour of 10 year sentences for anyone caught in possession of illegal drugs. I'd be happy for alcohol to be cracked down on too. Supermarkets shouldn't be able to sell it like they do carrots or bread. It should be restricted to off-licenses. (Maybe supermarkets could still sell low alcohol beer or wine of less than 3%ABV).

Ahh yes, lock them up where drug use is rife, life prospects diminish greatly leading to re offending and thus creating far more crime. Florenz for justice minister

arrogantorwhat37 · 28/07/2022 06:49

luxxlisbon · 26/07/2022 13:37

There is often an odd attitude towards some drugs considering behaviour and negative consequences can be much worse from alcohol.
It is funny that alcohol is not viewed as a drug for some reason despite the side effects.

I also imagine those who assume you do X and therefore must steal clearly don’t have a realistic understanding of how widespread the use of that drug actually is.

Well said, @luxxlisbon ! So little domestic or social violence/verbal or physical from weed users compared to alcohol

Carpy88999 · 28/07/2022 06:41

EV117 · 26/07/2022 14:32

Because most drug usage isn’t ‘recreational’ - it’s an addiction.

Absolute bollocks

Carpy88999 · 28/07/2022 06:39

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 26/07/2022 13:36

Your friend might not be addicted, but their supplier will not doubt supply people who ARE. And NEVER underestimate the misery that addiction causes, for both the addict and the people who care about them.

You might not be addicted to booze but no doubt tesco sells to people who ARE.

Carpy88999 · 28/07/2022 06:37

bridgetreilly · 26/07/2022 13:33

Because many people who do take drugs are addicted and do steal to feed their addiction. This is surely not hard to comprehend.

A small % of people who take recreational drugs are addicted, its no different to Alcohol.

WiddlinDiddlin · 28/07/2022 03:43

Because the side of 'drugs' people see.. is criminal, scum, addicts who will sell their own grandma for a hit and the occasional recreational non-addict who takes a bad pill and ends up dead or a vegetable.

What they don't see is the millions of happy, healthy, full time job (and often highly professional jobs) recreational users doing their thing and getting shitfaced on a weekend.

Because you don't see that, because those people aren't causing anyone* a real problem, nor are they interesting to feature in documentarys, make hard hitting films about, put in reality tv or stick in newspapers.

Addiction isn't just about the substance, there needs to be context - someone with a lovely live, no worries, everything they need, is unlikely to be hooked on smack after a couple of goes at it.

Someone with fuck all to live for, a shitty life in a shitty area with no prospects of anything improving, barely any of what they need and none of what they want.. is highly likely to become addicted, fast.

The other aspect of course is this - no one WANTS you to know that people can use various drugs recreationally and still maintain a normal lifestyle. The idea is drugs are painted as AWFUL BAD DIRTY WRONG DEFINITELY GOING TO BE AN ADDICT... so no one will touch them.

It doesn't work... but thats the official position.

*Of course all illegal drugs are hurting someone because they're illegal and thus the only way to get them is to buy them from a drug dealer. The solution to the criminal element of drugs.. is making them legal.

Andromachehadabadday · 28/07/2022 01:51

I think the main point in the op is that op says ‘time to time’ and the people who live with her, disagree it’s ‘time to time’.

That same judgement would be made if the ops friend drank a lot, beyond their means. Or gambled or smoked.

I would suggest that Op actually had very little knowledge on what’s it like to live with her friend and the ‘taking drugs from time to time’ may not be accurate.

its entirely possible that the house mates wouldn’t have made the judgement if she actually only did so drugs from time to time.

Herbalteahippie · 28/07/2022 01:30

So what drugs have you taken to come to this conclusion? Just out of interest…no one got hurt from the pills my friend pressed himself…but coke heads have a lot to think about. Genuinely interested in your thoughts x

WudYouSayItInRealLife · 28/07/2022 01:22

Unfortunately for a lot of drugs it mean that people who use those drugs are helping support a really evil and dangerous industry that's violent and caused untold misery to all sorts of people but particularly the most vulnerable. Grow a bit of weed for yourself if you insist but only scummy people take coke etc. If you are immoral enough to think your desire to have some fun is more important than the lives of the people the drug trade effects then my guess is your moral compass is fucked.

Herbalteahippie · 28/07/2022 01:12

Darling I’ve tried and it’s not addictive- it’s habitual. Caffeine is, cocaine is, but only idiots do those.

Herbalteahippie · 28/07/2022 01:10

Weed is addictive if you smoke a joint or 12 a day as it’s habit forming. It’s not psychically addictive. Depends on your routine x

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/07/2022 01:06

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 28/07/2022 01:01

Of course weed is addictive FFS. Can we please not pretend narcotics aren’t addictive

Isn't weed typically thought of as a hallucinogenic rather than a narcotic? I know the definitions vary.

And addictive varies as well. Habit forming, or psychologically addictive? Well biting your nails or cleaning the house can be that. Physically addictive? Cocaine isn't. Caffeine is.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 28/07/2022 01:01

Of course weed is addictive FFS. Can we please not pretend narcotics aren’t addictive

Herbalteahippie · 28/07/2022 00:31

Yes there is. I sometimes do e’s and weed and lsd, none of these are addictive; I just have a good time a few times a year. I have done so since 1994. I’ve never robbed anybody, murdered anybody, hurt anybody, never lost one job, LAUGHED MY ASS OFF, and went about my day. Sorry.
I have encountered crackheads and smack head that steal, and alcoholics….but alcohol is a good taxable drug and no one says anything.
peace x love x unity xxx

jcyclops · 27/07/2022 13:21

An acquaintance of mine who is a regular burglar and shoplifter hates the stigma that he only does it to fund a drug habit. He wouldn't dream of sinking that low.

CallmeAngelina · 27/07/2022 12:56

Haven't read the full thread but this isn't about an unfair stigma around drug use; it's about two flatmates who jumped to a conclusion and wrongly accused someone of theft.

EcoEcoIA · 27/07/2022 11:56

GarlicBread4Life · 26/07/2022 18:09

This is such a misinformed opinion, that addiction = lack of mental strength.

A poster upthread said that people are largely incredibly ignorant about addiction, and I agree.

But on a separate note, I just don’t believe people using drugs recreationally is harmless. I don’t think it should be stigmatised, but I’d also like to see a society where people didn’t feel they needed to chase happiness in substances. So I don’t think ‘crack on, it’s fun!’ Is the right message either.

I also hear a lot of justification and denial in some posts.Being a middle class occasional coke snorter or hippie magic mushroom user doesn’t make you immune to addiction or things going pear shaped.. You only have to look at all the ‘functioning’ alcoholics in our society of all walks of life to realise that. Functioning alcoholic usually just means they’ve still got a house and a job. Who knows what other damage their use is causing to relationships, health, their mental health? Drugs are the same. You can’t regularly use drugs as a responsible adult without some consequences. I call BS on people who say they take drugs regularly with no ill effects. It catches up with you eventually.

I've already pointed out that not knowing how many people take drugs and don't become addicted leaves a huge hole in psychological theories of addiction.

When people with objections to a psychological theory are dismissed as being in denial for not believing that psychological theory then that theory ceases to be falsifiable, and therefore becomes unscientific. I thank Karl Popper for that understanding.

WeddingQ · 27/07/2022 11:37

YABU
There is a stigma because people who buy drugs fuel violence, murder and misery in this country and around the world.
Whether they want to accept doing a line of coke or an ecstasy table once a week or whatever does this it is the case.
I'm very surprised there has not been more anti-drugs type marketing to stigmatise it even more as it is needed.

EcoEcoIA · 27/07/2022 11:10

Dreamwhisper · 26/07/2022 19:01

Sure.. Hmm

There literally is a well known cross over of people who have suffered trauma who go on to had substance abuse issue. Addiction issues have many cross overs with vulnerabilities - I don't understand why you're accusing me of conflating two separate entities when a quick google search will tell you as much.

You're a victim of childhood SA, and a drug user yourself. But because you're "a self made millionaire" the adverse affects don't apply to you?

Your opinion is so ignorant and offensive anyway, it's just not applicable to people in the real world. It's an emotive and unfounded statement to say "people who are addicts lack mental strength". Which is what you are saying by the way, if you are saying people who don't have addictions possess mental strength.

The psychology of addiction and the risk factors are well studied. Yet somehow in this day and age it's still okay to have opinions like "all drug addicts are scum" and "mental strength prevents addiction"

My mind truly boggles

I didn't say "all drug addicts are scum". I wouldn't say anything so vague and lacking in evidence.
It's an obvious fact that people who can control their drug consumption don't become addicts. The ability to control oneself is will power. I'm not saying people with will power are somehow morally superior.

I'm skepticism of unscientific psychological theories about abuse and addiction. Unquantifiable missing data leaves huge holes in these theories. There is the unknown factor which is sexual abuse that is not reported. Another error I often see is selection bias, e.g. that would be sampling only people who have become addicts, without considering drug takers who have not become addicts, which introduces another unknown quantity of drug users who might not admit to taking drugs because it's illegal. Then there are all the other factors that could affect addiction. Huge swathes of doubt.