Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is unreasonable here?

113 replies

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 10:47

2 parents divorced. Small DC

Parent A has DC 60% of the week and parent B has 40%. Not court ordered, mutual agreement.

both work. Both have new partners. Parent A does not live with partner

Parent A does most school runs and day to day things.

Parent B misses the DC and likes to check on them and texts, calls and video calls Parent A daily. Parent B makes plans with the DC in parent A’s time. Parent B’s new partner does childcare while they are at work.

Parent A does not hear from the DC during parent B’s time and there are no calls.

Parent B took DC on holiday and offered to facilitate the DC to call Parent A, then forgot to call or text.

If parent A puts in boundaries with regard to contact in their time, is this unfair to parent B who has less time with the DC and misses them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Triffid1 · 27/07/2022 12:35

I got the genders completely messed up, but for the record, I want to state that my advice remains the same - Parent A needs to simply stop taking the calls. Or, as it sounds like the issue is the LENGTH of the calls, he should simply refuse to facilitate long calls. A cheery, "right, Maisie is doing a puzzle and I've got Pete in the bath so we'll talk to you tomorrow" is fine and the mum needs to accept that. It's not really his problem if she can't.

Similarly, if she wants a day out with them during his time, he needs to treat her the same way he would OP - ie if OP said, "me and DC are off to the park tomorrow, shall I take your DC with us?" he might think, "Ooh, that would be fun for them and it would allow me to get some DIY done" and send them OR he might think, "I was looking forward to taking them to the cinema so no, that's not convenient."

WhereYouLeftIt · 26/07/2022 17:52

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 17:12

Oh no I am not the partner. I am a school mum, who is friends with both parents but more so with dad as I see him more. Our kids are friends

he asked me for advice as I am a woman, and a mum. He asked if it was normal, like would I call a lot if it was me? And I said no I wouldn’t call this much.

Ok from what he has said the call comes, he answers it, hands his phone to kids, they lose interest and put the phone on the table/bed/floor or whatever, they wander off and mum is still on the other end trying to engage with them cos she won’t hang up. Dad ends up ending it eventually but it’s drawn out as she wants the kids coaxed back to the phone before she will give up on the call. He’s cooking or bath or doing dad stuff and then running round with this bloody phone call getting stressed out.

Well, I'm afraid dad is just going to have to grow a spine and put some boundaries in place. I know you said "She would be upset if he brought it up and feel wounded", but - tough shit if she is. She needs to rein it in. At the moment she's treating him like a nanny who's there to do the donkey work whilst she's in charge calling the shots. He's (at least) as much the parent as she is and she needs to accept that. I'm not sure she has.

Anyway, boundaries:

  1. No calls during meal times, bathtimes, bedtimes. Its disruptive for both the children and him.
  2. When the child wanders off, the call is over and she hangs up. There will be no coaxing, the child has ended the call.
  3. Consider telling her that he'd rather she didn't call every day. It's his time with his children, and he'd rather be with them uninterrupted than talking with his ex.
  4. No more making plans with the DC in his time. If it's something special he would accommodate, but it is to be the exception and not the rule.
And he has to stick to it. They have a conversation, he tells her what his boundaries are, and from that point on the boundaries are enforced. If the kids have wandered off and she's still on the phone, the most she gets from him is 'they've gone to play and I'm making dinner, bye'. Rinse and repeat - "it's disruptive to my home life and the children's routines". He needs to stop feeling bad about it. He has every right to peace and quiet in his own home without his ex ringing all the time and expecting him to do her bidding.
maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 17:27

Ok from what he has said the call comes, he answers it, hands his phone to kids, they lose interest and put the phone on the table/bed/floor or whatever, they wander off and mum is still on the other end trying to engage with them cos she won’t hang up. Dad ends up ending it eventually but it’s drawn out as she wants the kids coaxed back to the phone before she will give up on the call. He’s cooking or bath or doing dad stuff and then running round with this bloody phone call getting stressed out.

Thank you, OP for clarifying this.

In short, this woman has issues and needs to get a grip. DC’s (especially small DC’s) really have no interest other than saying Hi and Bye to the other parent when they are away from them. They don’t understand Mummy wanting to check in, Mummy having issues with checking in, Mummy getting offended when DC puts the phone on the floor and goes on about their business.

Now I realise I was actually spot on. The mother is vindictive. Because in what normal world would anyone expect the father to coax a small child into talking to their mother or merely engaging in any form of conversation with someone, when they do not want to? Who would do that to a child?

And a better and more relevant question, who would expect a parent who is doing all the other bits and bobs, sorting out the children, evening routine etc, to go and get the children and essentially force them to converse with someone? Mother or not?

An unreasonable, selfish and vindictive person. That’s who. I’m going to rest my case right here now.

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 17:12

Oh no I am not the partner. I am a school mum, who is friends with both parents but more so with dad as I see him more. Our kids are friends

he asked me for advice as I am a woman, and a mum. He asked if it was normal, like would I call a lot if it was me? And I said no I wouldn’t call this much.

Ok from what he has said the call comes, he answers it, hands his phone to kids, they lose interest and put the phone on the table/bed/floor or whatever, they wander off and mum is still on the other end trying to engage with them cos she won’t hang up. Dad ends up ending it eventually but it’s drawn out as she wants the kids coaxed back to the phone before she will give up on the call. He’s cooking or bath or doing dad stuff and then running round with this bloody phone call getting stressed out.

OP posts:
maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 16:30

@Hankunamatata Same as if mum rings during dinner. I wouldn't answer, I'd send a text saying they will ring after dinner

True. But then, I would actually keep my word and ring after dinner. Then if the child seems uninterested, then oh well, such is life, end of conversation, child is happy and content, goodnight and goodbye kinda thing.

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 16:29

@Hankunamatata Surely if kids loose interest they put phone down?

Lol DC hangs up the phone on me on a regular basis whenever I call to see if they are okay. I just laugh.

Kids are both odd and hilarious creatures 😄

Hankunamatata · 26/07/2022 16:27

Surely if kids loose interest they put phone down?

Theres no harm in saying to dc if its bedtime to say night to mum, younwill ring her tomorrow and then hang up.

Same as if mum rings during dinner. I wouldn't answer, I'd send a text saying they will ring after dinner

Friend gave her kids old iPhone/ipads so she cam facetime directly without bothering so if kids answer great if they dont that's life

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 16:26

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 16:22

@maisieandvicks The OP isn't in a relationship with him she's already said

Ah I see. I thought that OP is the lady that is in a relationship with the father but not living with him and that the mother is the person who is in a relationship with another person that does live with her.

So, OP, may I ask, what is your relationship with DC’s father? Is it just a casual thing? Please don’t answer that question if you feel I am being intrusive, I am merely asking just to try and get a better understanding of the mother’s state of mind and behaviours.

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 16:22

@maisieandvicks The OP isn't in a relationship with him she's already said

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 16:20

I’m still confused but here’s the bottom line.

If a co-parent is doing their job properly, their child is happy and content, then there is absolutely no reason whatsoever for the other co-parent to make them feel bad in any way shape or form. For missing a call, for not getting back to them. Whatever. Big whoop.

Based on what I’ve read so far, and forgive me if wrong, but even though the mother is in a new relationship also, it actually sounds like she is somewhat jealous of the father’s relationship with who I presume is OP.

I genuinely believe that is sole reason for her difficult, sporadic and just generally unreasonable behaviour.

I could be wrong. Sure. But I don’t think I’m far off to be honest.

OP, please do not let this woman come in between your relationship. You have done nothing wrong here whatsoever. She has issues that she needs to sort out for herself and by herself.

Bottom line? As long as the child is happy and content? That is all that matters here.

I take back my previous comment regarding a need for potential Mediation. No.

The mother needs professional help for her obvious resentment, potential anxiety regarding her DC which is probably the only thing I can relate with, and just her overall mental health.

Time to move on. Time to be an adult. Time to be a PARENT.

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 16:09

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:57

I asked why! He said he felt bad like he was keeping the kids from her or something. I think it’s a weird dynamic where it’s all about how she feels about stuff. I get this impression from talking to her sometimes too. He’s trying to be amicable but feeling mugged off

It's still his own fault for doing that, he needs to stop blaming her for his actions tbh, he's not a baby, if she kicks off because he didn't answer the phone he needs to just repeat "It wasn't a convenient time"

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:57

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:42

I mean seriously that's his fault for answering, if it isn't convenient don't pick the phone up, what's wrong with this guy?!!

I asked why! He said he felt bad like he was keeping the kids from her or something. I think it’s a weird dynamic where it’s all about how she feels about stuff. I get this impression from talking to her sometimes too. He’s trying to be amicable but feeling mugged off

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:42

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:40

I dunno I don’t know her. Also at like family events he will end up on the phone with kids in a room while he’s with his family. I plan to tell him to get some backbone!

I mean seriously that's his fault for answering, if it isn't convenient don't pick the phone up, what's wrong with this guy?!!

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:40

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:39

well tbf that's all on him, he chose to hang up on his g/f to take the call from his ex and why does she need to go in a different room if the children are talking to their mother on the phone?

I dunno I don’t know her. Also at like family events he will end up on the phone with kids in a room while he’s with his family. I plan to tell him to get some backbone!

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:39

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:35

He told me his girlfriend got pissed off once cos he hung up the phone on her for one of these child related calls or she feels like she has to go sit in another room for an hour if she’s at his house

well tbf that's all on him, he chose to hang up on his g/f to take the call from his ex and why does she need to go in a different room if the children are talking to their mother on the phone?

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:35

He told me his girlfriend got pissed off once cos he hung up the phone on her for one of these child related calls or she feels like she has to go sit in another room for an hour if she’s at his house

OP posts:
Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:31

rainrelief · 26/07/2022 15:24

The Mum needs to accept they have split up as a family and that means there are days she doesn’t have contact with her kids. She can’t expect to remain a big part of their evenings or days on her non-resident days.

it sucks perhaps, but that’s the reality of separated families.

Yeah it does suck I kind of feel bad for her about this but in reality it must also fucking suck a bit to have to talk to /listen to your ex every single day in your own home 😆

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:29

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:20

He only didn’t call as no convenient time was put forward and as he is pissed off about time encroachment he didn’t want to be guilty of the same thing. I said this to him, just call if you want to call! Just call them and she will have to call you back if it’s not a good time. Turns out he really wants her to call a lot less

Ok, well I think the part about him pretending he was annoyed that she didn't call back is muddying the waters a bit. That seems like a non issue when he knows he could have just called so I think he needs to drop that reasoning and just focus on what really is bothering him. Clearly he needs to sit down and speak to her, and try to work out a different system that works for everyone, would he think about getting a cheap pay as go phone just for the purpose of the kids speaking to their mother so his phone isn't tied up? Maybe tell her what times generally do and do not suit (and don't answer the phone if she rings in those times)

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 15:29

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:23

He text and she replied saying she'd call him later but didn't, maybe she forgot, who knows but it sounded like she wouldn't be annoyed if he'd just picked the phone up and rang them later instead like she probably would have done in the reverse situation

Right, okay, I see your point now.

But again, one could argue, how do we know she wouldn’t have minded? How do we know that she would have picked up? Do you see my point?

What one says and what one actually does are not always the same thing.

Again, unless I’m just talking out of my arse because I haven’t RTFT. In which case, ignore me. Lol.

rainrelief · 26/07/2022 15:24

The Mum needs to accept they have split up as a family and that means there are days she doesn’t have contact with her kids. She can’t expect to remain a big part of their evenings or days on her non-resident days.

it sucks perhaps, but that’s the reality of separated families.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/07/2022 15:23

Once kids have their own phones it’s better as they can either speak to the parent they are not with, or not, as they choose!

AryaStarkWolf · 26/07/2022 15:23

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 15:16

Hmm okay fair… but then… why didn’t she call? Why didn’t she drop a text to say you know what, sorry but it’s not convenient right now, we’re doing XYZ and will call tomorrow. Why just ignore him? That’s bang out of order imo.

He text and she replied saying she'd call him later but didn't, maybe she forgot, who knows but it sounded like she wouldn't be annoyed if he'd just picked the phone up and rang them later instead like she probably would have done in the reverse situation

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/07/2022 15:22

Sorry - I see in this case it’s the exw not exh who does this and has no respect for boundaries - same principle though!

maisieandvicks · 26/07/2022 15:22

Turns out he really wants her to call a lot less

Can’t really blame him since:

A) It is his time with his child, and

B) It’s a different rule for her whenever DC is in her care.

Earpieced · 26/07/2022 15:20

He only didn’t call as no convenient time was put forward and as he is pissed off about time encroachment he didn’t want to be guilty of the same thing. I said this to him, just call if you want to call! Just call them and she will have to call you back if it’s not a good time. Turns out he really wants her to call a lot less

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread