Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this hoarding? Doesn't seem as severe?

69 replies

EllaPercy · 25/07/2022 23:23

Evening all. Name change as could be outing to the person talked about in the thread.

When does being sentimental turn into being a hoarder?

I've offended my cousin today but I do think she's more than sentimental.

Moving house and not had many viewings so estate agent said it's because the house is too cluttered and to clear out and take more photos.

So I went to help as I'm quite the opposite - she says too I'm ruthless as I don't keep much.

She's the opposite. Still has her childhood toys. All her school books. All her DC baby clothes and toys.

Which to me is hoarding.

But that's the row - as it's not like on TV where there is filth 5ft deep. Which I did stress.

There isn't a clear surface in the place. But it isn't a dirty home.

But I do think it's not healthy to not part with anything.

Is there a name for it other than hoarding? It is generally things with sentimental value that she has. But there's just SO MUCH of if.

OP posts:
SaintHelena · 26/07/2022 16:15

... and I agree with @loislovesstewie that it increases my anxiety.

SaintHelena · 26/07/2022 16:14

I accuse DH of hoarding - his DF was in the forces and they moved every couple of years. I put it down to that.

TalkingToMyselfAgain · 26/07/2022 15:35

It's hoarding but not to the extreme. She either wants to sell her house or she doesn't. If she does, she'll need to get rid of clutter. Nobody wants to look round a place and see it full of stuff.

I know someone of 70 who has kept the baby teeth of her sons (in their 40s) and also the teeth of her DOG.

Turmerictolly · 26/07/2022 15:32

The London Fire Brigade have a 'clutter/hoarding rating'. If you google this, it gives you an idea of whether the level of clutter is concerning or not.

sueelleker · 26/07/2022 15:30

loislovesstewie · 26/07/2022 10:23

My late husband WAS a hoarder; he did not hoard filthy items, he did not keep items in a way that made them dirty; he kept items in a clean way BUT he had way too many things, he kept childhood items and NEVER got those items out of the door. Our house was floor to ceiling with stuff kept in boxes or storage crates; when we moved, we had to put stuff in storage, so prospective buyers could see what the rooms were like. Too much stuff for the rooms available makes someone a hoarder in my book. He always thought that if we could just have one more room for storage, everything would be OK. Since he died, I have sold/given away absolutely tons of stuff and I feel less anxious, having suffered from anxiety for years.
I would argue that not all hoarders are living in filth, but a lot will end up that was because they just don't have the room to keep items. It does get out of control in the end, and it did with him.

My late husband was the same-the amount of stuff he kept "just in case" was unbelievable. He always complained we had too much stuff, but most of it was his!
I've spent the the last 6 months since I lost him clearing out.

nutbrownhare15 · 26/07/2022 15:18

I have hoarderish tendencies and so does one of my parents. It sounds hoarderish to me. If she wants to sell her house she should rent a storage unit (I did this and it paid off so well in terms of the photos, buyer interest and a very quick sale) presumably all her stuff will need to go into boxes when she moves anyway. A home stager could also be a really good investment.

TimBoothseyes · 26/07/2022 14:54

Does she have DC? The reason I ask is when we cleared mum and dad's house after their deaths in 2020 it took 3 skips loads just to clear random stuff they had kept. My mum was the worst for "stuff", but dad had over 100 files of paper work that he never threw away. Me and my sisters and all of our adult DC have now pledged to de-clutter as the stress involved was off the scale. Maybe point this out to your friend that one day her DC will have to deal with the result of all that clutter and it's something they really will not thank her for.

staceyflack · 26/07/2022 14:29

Its 'attachment issues' (states the obvious 😊)... has she had a lot of loss in the past, or was she very poor / deprived (in any way) as a child. I relate completely. It's scary to be challenged, so she's defensive - tread gently.

10HailMarys · 26/07/2022 14:18

I think people assume that hoarding always means a house piled with rubbish and mess - but it doesn't always mean that. Some hoarders basically keep everything because they can't throw anything away, even things like empty tins or old newspapers.

But there is definitely a lower level, more selective hoarding too, where people are obsessive collectors of certain things or very indiscriminate about what has sentimental value. And of course, if they're still managing to keep everything tidy and under control (eg 100 teddies neatly lined up on shelves is very different to random teddies lying on the floor or stuffed behind radiators or piled on the bed so that it can't be slept in) then it obviously doesn't cause them a problem day to day and it can be put down to personal taste. But of course, there will be odd times like this (selling a house, having to clear space for a home office or make room for a new baby or something) when it will make life difficult.

To be honest, the fact that your cousin got upset when you had the conversation with her suggests to me that she probably does have a problem and doesn't want to admit that to herself.

chesirecat99 · 26/07/2022 14:07

I'm not surprised she was offended. You've armchair diagnosed her with a mental health issue.

Usually, to meet the criteria for diagnosis for a mental health issue, the issue would have to have a negative impact on the individual's life or a negative impact on those close to them eg it is making her unhappy, her home is dirty or unsafe, it is damaging her relationships, she is spending money she can't afford on buying things. It doesn't sound like that is the case here, especially as you said that most of this stuff is on display (ie she isn't just keeping it for the sake of keeping it, she enjoys looking at them). Finding it difficult to sell her home because it has more stuff jammed in than most people like wouldn''t meet the criteria for being a negative impact on her life any more than making it hard to sell your house by choosing to paint your house in bright colours or decorating it in a gothic or 50s theme.

I had about 50 mugs for around 20 years when I had the space for them. They gave me joy when I opened the cupboard and remembered the story behind each one - the mug I bought in Woolworths the first day of boarding school, college mugs, my first work mug with the name of my employer, mugs painted by my DC, mugs I bought for my first home, the one that had a picture that looked like my late cat, mugs to match my dinner/tea service etc. Once in while, it was useful having 50 mugs eg big house parties. Now I have 6 mugs, all plain white. I'm not a hoarder. It's just the benefits of the 50 mugs outweighed the negatives, now they don't, so I got rid of them.

TempName01 · 26/07/2022 12:58

She will need to pack it up when moving anyway so best to box up as much of the personal items now so she can stage the house for selling.

catandcoffee · 26/07/2022 12:53

OP let your cousin get on with it.
When she can't sale her house (due to the clutter ) say nothing.

You can't help others if they don't see the problem.

listsandbudgets · 26/07/2022 12:53

DP is a horder though he denies it. Luckily with have a big house with plenty of storage - but really who needs their bank statements AND cheque stubs from early 1980s? He says you never know Confused He keeps them all tidily in a large plastic box along with all the other paperwork from that era. I did eventually persuade him that maybe we could live without the receipts he kept for VAT purposes though which freed up a certain amount of space. We occasionally have extra shelves built but we're running out of recesses and I'm eyeing up the hallway. We've also got a lot of his childhood books - if anyone has use for scouting manuals from the 1970s and a BBC handbook from the mid 1980s or best yet a copy of Modern Caravan from July 1964 please apply below not that he'll let them go of course because you never know

I think it runs in his family though given I've got some of his mother's old school books and school magazines (which are actually quite interesting at this stage) - she's now 93!!

We also have a very large number of cables with no defined use that may be useful and many many many gadgets of varying and dubious use

Fortunately, I'm slightly better t getting rid of things.

I love him very much so I suppose I've got a certain affection for his "stuff" Smile

ArcticSkewer · 26/07/2022 12:35

What does it matter? It doesn't sound like a problem apart from the house selling. That's time limited and stuff can go in the attic or storage for a few months then back out.

I wouldn't call it hoarding, especially not to someone's face unless they've asked.

Ccoffee · 26/07/2022 12:29

My parents are like this. Not 5 duvet sets, but 20. Not one teapot, 5 of them. Masses of knick-knacks covering every surface and every spare drawer, often duplicates in different colours. Wardrobes groaning with clothes not worn in decades. Hundreds of books not read, or ever intended to be read. When they moved house recently they pretty much needed a skip to empty out the attic, as it had every school book, game etc from me and my siblings' childhood.

Not quite hoarding, as they are extremely neat and tidy, and have space for everything (though at the expense of any visitors, who have no wardrobe or drawer space in the spare bedrooms) but comes close in my opinion.

KnittingNeedles · 26/07/2022 10:39

And @FelicityBeedle there is a whole spectrum between "minimalism" and crowded shelves along every wall.

KnittingNeedles · 26/07/2022 10:34

milkyaqua · 26/07/2022 00:25

It's not hoarding. It may look like "clutter" to the modern eye and need to be removed from sight presale, but it is rather rude to refer to someone's treasured possessions as a hoarding problem.

It's like some of the people on that programme with Stacey Solomon. Houses full to absolute bursting because people attach sentiment to EVERYTHING. Everything is a "treasured possession". They have kept every birthday card, every game/toy their child ever had, every drawing and every baby outfit, every letter from the GP, every book and so on and so on.

Most people will keep a very small percentage of truly special stuff. Not a stub of a pencil you bought in Brighton when you were 7, or a postcard Aunty Gladys sent from Tenerife in 2001. Most of us don't have 100 room mansions to accommodate every item we've ever owned. So yes it's a problem.

loislovesstewie · 26/07/2022 10:26

Oh, and we had over 100 coffee mugs as an example, most never saw use, but he kept on buying.

loislovesstewie · 26/07/2022 10:23

My late husband WAS a hoarder; he did not hoard filthy items, he did not keep items in a way that made them dirty; he kept items in a clean way BUT he had way too many things, he kept childhood items and NEVER got those items out of the door. Our house was floor to ceiling with stuff kept in boxes or storage crates; when we moved, we had to put stuff in storage, so prospective buyers could see what the rooms were like. Too much stuff for the rooms available makes someone a hoarder in my book. He always thought that if we could just have one more room for storage, everything would be OK. Since he died, I have sold/given away absolutely tons of stuff and I feel less anxious, having suffered from anxiety for years.
I would argue that not all hoarders are living in filth, but a lot will end up that was because they just don't have the room to keep items. It does get out of control in the end, and it did with him.

Elleherd · 26/07/2022 10:09

I am a hoarder, and the daughter of a squalor hoarder. It's painful just typing it.

You might not guess from my home. It’s clean, normal looking,
and relatively organized. The 'home' I grew up in, was very extreme and the total opposite, so for a long time I was in happy denial that I was a hoarder, because I presented so very differently from my parent.

I’ve spent years battling myself and eating away at erasing and controlling different parts of the condition. The stuff is just the visible symptom. It absolutely is a MH condition, and genuine educated help is rare.

Part of my issues may be learned behavior, and part may be genetic, but a large part is almost certainly a response to a very horrible shameful childhood which included the repeated loss of everything, and everyone, combined with a creative ability to see potential in lots of things that others wouldn’t.

The clutter scales cause a lot of issues for people who are in control of their possession, homes, and cleanliness, or who are additionally hoarding in storage out buildings etc, because the images don’t relate to how many live.

Additionally you have a raft of people living in extreme foul conditions, considered hoarders who aren't actually hoarders, having no emotional attachment to what they're surrounded by.

When is it an issue? When it damages and impacts yours and others quality of life, and/or mental well being, use of space, and finances. The bigger the home and or additional storage, the more potential of ‘getting away’ with hoarding tendencies, the smaller the home the more likely you are for it to become problematic earlier.

If you’re sentimental and keep everything from childhood, etc, and have the room to comfortably do that, you’re actually fine as long as that situation remains.

The problem comes when you don’t, especially if life changes suddenly, and you find the impossibility of letting go is greater than the need to, regardless of the price of that.

The reason your cousin is so upset is because stupidly we stigmatize people with the condition and treat them as lesser with lesser rights.

While items are kept tidily, displayed, organized and clean, it is technically labeled a collection, only the owner knows how deep or problematic or not their attachment is, and if it's actually organized hoarding.

antelopevalley · 26/07/2022 01:24

@HintofVintagePink stage one is totally normal.

FelicityBeedle · 26/07/2022 01:14

I forgot to add, it does sound like she has too much stuff but calling it hoarding is the least helpful thing to do. She’s picturing those TV images of filth and despair and thinks you see her like that.

FelicityBeedle · 26/07/2022 01:12

Not every one has to be a minimalist. I love my sentimental objects and knick knacks and things on display. Most of MN would probably faint in horror. It’s often linked to age but I’m 24 and I like a full environment, always have.

Don't get me wrong, it doesn’t impede on living spaces or walkways but I have a few shelving units and many pictures hung up. It doesn’t seem like hoarding to me anyway

HintofVintagePink · 26/07/2022 01:12

I think it does sound like hoarding. She is keeping things she will never actively use. 50 mugs is ridiculous!
Full disclosure; even the stage 1 photos look a mess to me!

Swipe left for the next trending thread