Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 09:40

@BlaseBalletDancer

We actually have the situation where a lot of people end up paying twice for healthcare - once through general taxation and once again privately for the conditions that the NHS misses or refuses to treat within a reasonable time. That is appalling.

Ugh this is like people who moan about being made to pay the license fee because they also pay for Sky+. The NHS is a public good, you are not paying for 'your healthcare' through general taxation, you are paying for a good level of basic care to be available free to anyone in society at point of need. Unfortunately it is funded and staffed so badly the system is creaking now, which means that 'basic standard' is not really being met anymore. But it's still a damn sight better than people being bankrupted by their long term conditions.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:39

I’m just sharing facts. Not passing judgement. Good for her! Wouldn’t you try to access the best lifestyle possible for you and your DC?

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:38

@BlaseBalletDancer

I agree.

NHS costs us £10,000 per household. I could get fantastic private insurance for less than that. Not allowed to opt out of NI though.

Link, for those interested:

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/07/23/uks-runaway-health-spending-costs-10k-per-household-produces/

entropynow · 26/07/2022 09:36

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 25/07/2022 20:32

Why are so many people under the illusion that just because they don't receive benefits they don't 'take' anything from the state?

Presumably you were delivered at a nice safe NHS hospital by midwives who were trained by the NHS. Received over a decade of state education and if you are in your 30s probably had government subsidised university fees. Immunised on the NHS from all those nasty diseases that people from countries without 'the state' have to suffer. You can sleep soundly tonight knowing that it isnt legal for someone to come and break into your house because we have a functioning legal and policing system, a prison system to keep dangerous criminals locked away so they cant rape/rob you walking down the street. The ministry of defence and armed forces are making sure countries with hostile intentions can't just come and drop a bomb on your house. Your friends and family are hopefully healthy but if they arent and they get sick or fall on hard times the state will be there for them, as it would be for you.

So yeah, dont tell yourself that you don't 'take' cause it's just BS.

Can we have an A-MEN
Some really hard of thinking, goady, resentful people on here. Who mostly like to play the victim - 'ooh, you're so right, but we're the persecuted ones'
No. You're just ignorant.

chutzpahchick · 26/07/2022 09:35

ComtesseDeSpair · 25/07/2022 20:18

The NHS is utter shit, has been since long before the Tories got into power, and I begrudge paying the amount of tax I do when my in-laws in the US get excellent healthcare for about half the cost in their insurance premiums and co-pays as the amount of my taxation which goes to the NHS.

But otherwise, I’d far rather be in the position I am than have to live like people on benefits do. I have a fantastic life. People on benefits only really get the large payments if they have children, once the children are older or grown they’ll be stuck - poor employment prospects and facing trying to live on JSA or NMW in a crappy job. Not a life I’d want.

Actually you pay a shedload for healthcare in taxes in the US. Someone has to fund medicare, medicaid, veterans healthcare, public hospitals. In fact the public $$$ spent in the US are broadly equal to that of the UK. The difference is that it does not entitle you to healthcare for the most part (unless you are old enough to be on medicare, poor enough - i.e. bare bones of your ass - for medicaid or veteran). You're paying for others' public health care and THEN need to fork out for your own private healthcare. Your inlaws have paid just as much as you have in tax for publicly funded healthcare. They then need to pay their premiums, copays, deductibles etc.

Itisasecret · 26/07/2022 09:35

It is really easy to see how people get stuck in the benefits cycle. Like I say £2500 is a 40k salary after tax.

I do know people who are on legacy benefits. As in CTC/WTC still. I have also seen people with no benefits cap due to disability claiming the equivalent of a 60k salary.

I am a socialist at heart. Polar opposite views to most people in our income bracket. However, the people who earn 20-40k are left behind. It’s hard to see the incentive for them to work tbh, if they have children. There is no way of spinning or. To the people who just “miss out” on top up support, they are often the ones who struggle the most.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:34

@foxandbee I think it was something like this www.suitedbootedcentre.org.uk/

But the scheme my friend accessed was run by RBKC. She made a tidy sum selling the bits on Vestiaire Collective.

It’s a great scheme if it does help someone back into work. My friend will not go above 16 hours though as she’s be less well off financially. I don’t blame her. The system is the issue. Work needs to pay (better than benefits, at least!).

Agree with PP that the squeezed middle, on 25-40k are the ones worst off. Not enough to live on (in London, esp with DC) but too much to access help.

Florenz · 26/07/2022 09:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 09:27

Oh and these aren’t just acquaintances, one is my best friend of 30 years, so I know her financial ins and outs very well, she’s very open

Some best friend you are, airing her financial ins and outs on SM. Does she know you are doing this or is she too busy choosing her next Stella McCartney piece/going to Dubai/generally living it up to care?

notyetpregnant · 26/07/2022 09:26

@Completelyovernonsense It is simply not true that everyone on benefits genuinely needs them. And I say that as someone from a family where there are generations of worklessness.

My own parents very rarely worked despite being able to and probably claimed a significant amount in benefits due to having a large family, and a lot of that money was usually squandered on cigarettes/alcohol etc.

I am fortunate that I didn't repeat that cycle and have always worked, never claimed benefits and have made a good life for myself. But the same isn't true for some of my siblings who also have never worked and claim benefits despite being able to work.

I probably have a better understanding than many of how people can get trapped in the cycles of worklessness, but I do feel like the benefits system makes it easy for that to happen to those who are less motivated to break the cycle.

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 09:25

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:20

@FilePhoto yes they’re all on legacy benefits not UC.
Children are all under 16. Youngest is 8.

Then they can't be being IS. That stops when youngest is 5.
Why are they getting so much over the benefit cap? Do they/dc have disabilities?

entropynow · 26/07/2022 09:24

What is this? Has MN suddenly become a branch of Conservative Home with all these goady right wing posts?
I worked hard because I have a work ethic not because I sat calculating what the system 'owes' me

BlaseBalletDancer · 26/07/2022 09:23

Smamplus Loads of countries have higher income tax than the UK (especially if you only compare first world countries) and if you compare NI to the multiple separate deductions covering the same things in other countries NI is an absolute bargain.

They have higher rates but get more for it and also have more deductions - as I pointed out, several higher rate European countries allow your commuting to work expenses to be deducted from your income tax bill and still have mortgage interest tax relief, significantly lower council tax equivalent, etc..

So overall the difference isn't as large as you imagine. Having such a poor infrastructure as the UK has makes working full time difficult and expensive if you live outside the south east.

And national insurance isn't a bargain. Its so complicated to say what it actually pays for in the UK but the NHS isn't cheap. We actually have the situation where a lot of people end up paying twice for healthcare - once through general taxation and once again privately for the conditions that the NHS misses or refuses to treat within a reasonable time. That is appalling.

Itisasecret · 26/07/2022 09:20

You are technically correct. If you clear £2500 not a hard aim if you think rent, council tax, water, UC. That’s equivalent to 40k salary after tax. Higher than the average salary.

The issue is the low wage system has distorted things. The people who really struggle are the ones who just miss out on top up support. For example those on 25-40k ish.

The tax here is high, income tax at around 60% at one point which is one of the highest in the world.

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 09:20

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:58

@foxandbee
The interviews existed, they just had no intention of actually taking a job.
Scheme was in Kensington & Chelsea Borough. Check it out for yourself.

It is for you to prove your claim is true. Got a link?

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:20

@FilePhoto yes they’re all on legacy benefits not UC.
Children are all under 16. Youngest is 8.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:18

@Hrpuffnstuff1

“We have disincentivized working and nuclear families.“

This, exactly. It’s not good for society and possibly behind so many of the mental health issues in this country.

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 09:12

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:56

@FilePhoto I really do wish it was “bullshit”

I will caveat this though by saying the system is set to to force fathers out of the home. If you stay with your DC’s father, or have any (working) man move in with you, the funding dries up.
For this reason, 2 of my 3 friends keep their partners on the DL or it would affect their benefits.
Oh and these aren’t just acquaintances, one is my best friend of 30 years, so I know her financial ins and outs very well, she’s very open.
Many of you who perhaps haven’t grown up in the system and don’t know anyone in it, find it hard to stomach what I’ve said. I wish it wasn’t true and that my friends (and myself) who work full time could achieve similar lifestyles.

So your friends are claiming legacy benefits ( I thought all claims since about 2016 had to be for UC?) Yet their DC are still going enough that their IS hasn't been stopped? And they get more than the benefit cap? Plus free designer clothes?

Righto.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:12

I should add that the big tax dodgers like Amazon, Starbucks, etc. should absolutely be made to pay their fair share.
But that doesn’t make it okay on the other end of the spectrum to have a system where for many, it pays not to work.
Both circumstances are morally questionable.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 26/07/2022 09:10

The government knows these lifestyles are not sustainable in the long run. The green revolution is going to be a dynamic lifestyle change. Some are going to be left behind.
The NHS creaking-unhealthy nation-choices by patients.
Energy usage -is not sustainable.
Business-anyone can set up a business whether it's sustainable or not.
The benefits system-especially for able-bodied adults, and parents-is not sustainable people resent this now.

We have disincentivized working and nuclear families. The road is running out, what we take for granted now is going into reverse. It's going to be painful for quite a large portion of society.
People have made what was thought of as a great idea at the time terrible choices. For those of us independent from the government, net positive contributors it's a great place to be. Plenty of reasons to work. For others not so good.
It's time to pay the piper.

KeyboardWarriorsUnite · 26/07/2022 09:06

Florenz · 26/07/2022 08:56

Anyone convicted of a crime should be disqualified from claiming benefits for a period of time, and those convicted of serious crimes should be disqualified from claiming benefits forever! And yes they should still pay tax.

That's one way of guaranteeing crime rates rising.

SpamplusOnionisntASalad · 26/07/2022 09:05

Loads of countries have higher income tax than the UK (especially if you only compare first world countries) and if you compare NI to the multiple separate deductions covering the same things in other countries NI is an absolute bargain.

As others say you are "taking" even when you don't claim benefits unless you live in isolation totally off grid - as soon as you use the national infrastructure you're using things paid for by taxes.

The things that you don't use are there as a safety net - just like insurance. You may one day need to rely on them due to no fault of your own (life changing accident or illness for example) and if opting out had been an option you'd be buggered.

In the end if children of people like your acquaintance had no basic financial safety net and no state schools they'd die or grow up in worse poverty, potentially with chronic poverty related health issues or no education leading to them being less able to contribute as adults (and a higher chance of turning to petty crime). It's unclear whether you would prefer that if it means that you pay less tax, but it certainly makes for a worse country for everyone.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 26/07/2022 09:05

Yes I did name change because I do weekly bit not for this. I am not bashing nineties but I just wish they would put more money into empowering people to get help and education and a life that holds value. Sitting smoking in a dark flat 24/7 isn't OK for anyone. I don't think he is scrounging, I genuinely believe that he has no power or control. I wish he could be a happy adult. I really do. I would happily pay taxes to do what Scandinavian could tries do, start with care and nurture of the person

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 09:05

@DogsAndGin

But if you put the work in you’ll do a hell of a lot better than someone on benefits. There are high wages out there, for people of all different personalities and skill sets.

Are you suggesting that the OP is struggling because she just isn't working hard enough?

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:04

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 08:55

@FreyaStorm

I am actually thinking of selling my flat to liquidate my assets, rent a lovely place and live well for a few years until the cash runs out and then do as my aforementioned friends have done. It would be one way of getting back into a part of London with very good state schools and I need to think of my DC now.

I would actually be very interested to hear how this works out for you. Do let us know!

I think it would be an excellent premise for a book - one of those “say yes to everything for a year” type of ones. It would be an interesting life experiment.
Do you know any publishers who would be interested? 😊