Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
OriginalUsername2 · 26/07/2022 10:19

The rich have always pointed the masses towards the poor. “Look at them! Look how they’re living! Look at them TAKING!”

..and while we all look that way, the rich scoop up everything for themselves.

Maverickess · 26/07/2022 10:18

And the PP who said less would be paid in benefits if NRPs were made to pay maintenance. Maintenance isn't classed as income so it wouldn't make a difference.

Yes, it's not counted as income - but why? Because by and large it's something that is very successfully ignored and not paid, with zero will to change that. Instead of changing that, using the powers already in place to make sure it's paid at the right amount, on time, and regularly, the government choose to pay benefits to single parents on a low income instead, and any maintenance is a 'bonus'.
It's bloody backwards, benefits are the default for single parents and maintenance the extra, which allows NRPs to disappear into the sunset doing this again and again.
If you're an RP there's a 2 child limit, yet if you're an NRP you can have as many children as you like, and they can be funded by benefits, as long as they're with someone else, with no requirement you pay anything for any of them.

Perhaps if that changed, as in every NRP has maintenance taken at source when they refuse to pay (similar to council tax) for each child, then benefits are the back up rather than the default and maintenance is the default. Thus meaning that men NRPs fund their own children and not benefits.

But we're too entrenched in seeing the RP as the one in receipt of benefits and therefore the scrounger, the one who should be better, it's way too tempting to kick them. While the other one, by their lack of responsibility for their own behaviour is the problem.

I worked ft and paid more than 50% of the cost of bringing up my daughter, he worked full time and paid sweet fuck all, benefits filled the gap. Yet I'm the problem according to so many. Like I said, backwards.

Spikeyball · 26/07/2022 10:15

"I have also seen people with no benefits cap due to disability claiming the equivalent of a 60k salary."

Disability benefits are not extra spending money. They cover the extra costs associated with having a disability. I am sure this has been explained before about a million times.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 10:14

@LadyCatStark for PM! Forget Rishi and Truss.

So much this that it deserves quoting:

“I think a lot of people on Mumsnet are supportive of those on long term benefits because they live in their middle class bubble and don’t actually know anyone that can’t be arsed to work.”

I get the impression so many PP who think living on benefits is awful don’t actually know anyone on benefits. There is nothing like the peace of mind of a secure council tenancy.

My sympathies lie with the couple earning under £40k between them and trying to make ends meet for their DC. Renting from a private landlord who can ask them to leave at any time and having to uproot their DC from one school to another, every few years.

vermicello · 26/07/2022 10:10

YANBU. If you are not working or work part-time and have kids, benefits are very generous, sometimes far more than the take home salary of people in full time work. The ones who are really screwed are, like you say, single people in work or single people on benefits who are only entitled to minimum benefits and normally a room in a house share. Benefits should be time-limited and based on previous contributions.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/07/2022 10:07

The grass isn't always greener. Unemployment brings up more serious problems than no weekly wages, it impacts on the entire family and their MH too.

Others are brought up without any incentive or confidence to start work.

The social issues go much further than unemployment benefit.

In your situation I think you need to appreciate the fact you have the skills, confidence and ability to hold down a FT job.

wellhelloitsme · 26/07/2022 10:07

@ComtesseDeSpair

So forgive me for being bitter that the MN mantra about the NHS is always “well, if we want a better NHS then we all need to be prepared to pay more for it” - usually from posters who pay very little tax in the first place - when I already pay more than plenty and get fuck all in return.

But if you did need it, it would be there. None of us know if we will become disabled, get a serious or life limiting illness etc. And savings would be depleted incredibly quickly if it was necessary to pay for treatment privately here in the UK. The NHS provides a safety net for everyone. If you never need to use it then in many ways you're very lucky.

BlaseBalletDancer · 26/07/2022 10:07

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 09:40

@BlaseBalletDancer

We actually have the situation where a lot of people end up paying twice for healthcare - once through general taxation and once again privately for the conditions that the NHS misses or refuses to treat within a reasonable time. That is appalling.

Ugh this is like people who moan about being made to pay the license fee because they also pay for Sky+. The NHS is a public good, you are not paying for 'your healthcare' through general taxation, you are paying for a good level of basic care to be available free to anyone in society at point of need. Unfortunately it is funded and staffed so badly the system is creaking now, which means that 'basic standard' is not really being met anymore. But it's still a damn sight better than people being bankrupted by their long term conditions.

No, its not like "people" moaning about a completely unrelated thing that you have for some reason added to your rant.

It is about someone who has lived in The Netherlands and France comparing the appalling "service" the NHS provides and people sometimes having to pay twice to get their cataract operation or hip replaced just to be able to enjoy a normal life. It is nothing to do with tv licenses or the US healthcare system.

You do realise that there are more than two countries in the world? Perhaps you should try living in one of them to broaden your life experience.

Itisasecret · 26/07/2022 10:07

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/07/2022 10:04

Yes, I know how the system works, I’m married to an American who lived with and paid into it for many years. The fact still remains that what we pay in tax and NI as a household in the UK - getting in for £80k a year for both of us - is still more than double what the people we know with similar incomes and circumstances in the US pay in income tax, health insurance, copays and deductibles combined. So forgive me for being bitter that the MN mantra about the NHS is always “well, if we want a better NHS then we all need to be prepared to pay more for it” - usually from posters who pay very little tax in the first place - when I already pay more than plenty and get fuck all in return.

This is true. Also salaries in the US are often double what they are here in the UK for technical jobs.

BungleandGeorge · 26/07/2022 10:07

You haven’t hit the time in your life when you may need help. Unless you’re a high earner you won’t be paying that much in because we don’t have high taxation in this country.
yes there are definitely those who are work shy/ ‘sick’ etc but to balance that there’s also a lot who are providing 24/7 care for another person and getting very little from the state to cover the costs. It does need reform, it’s not a fair system at the moment but I don’t think those reforms will put money into your pocket necessarily

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/07/2022 10:04

chutzpahchick · 26/07/2022 09:35

Actually you pay a shedload for healthcare in taxes in the US. Someone has to fund medicare, medicaid, veterans healthcare, public hospitals. In fact the public $$$ spent in the US are broadly equal to that of the UK. The difference is that it does not entitle you to healthcare for the most part (unless you are old enough to be on medicare, poor enough - i.e. bare bones of your ass - for medicaid or veteran). You're paying for others' public health care and THEN need to fork out for your own private healthcare. Your inlaws have paid just as much as you have in tax for publicly funded healthcare. They then need to pay their premiums, copays, deductibles etc.

Yes, I know how the system works, I’m married to an American who lived with and paid into it for many years. The fact still remains that what we pay in tax and NI as a household in the UK - getting in for £80k a year for both of us - is still more than double what the people we know with similar incomes and circumstances in the US pay in income tax, health insurance, copays and deductibles combined. So forgive me for being bitter that the MN mantra about the NHS is always “well, if we want a better NHS then we all need to be prepared to pay more for it” - usually from posters who pay very little tax in the first place - when I already pay more than plenty and get fuck all in return.

Fe345fleur · 26/07/2022 10:04

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 25/07/2022 20:32

Why are so many people under the illusion that just because they don't receive benefits they don't 'take' anything from the state?

Presumably you were delivered at a nice safe NHS hospital by midwives who were trained by the NHS. Received over a decade of state education and if you are in your 30s probably had government subsidised university fees. Immunised on the NHS from all those nasty diseases that people from countries without 'the state' have to suffer. You can sleep soundly tonight knowing that it isnt legal for someone to come and break into your house because we have a functioning legal and policing system, a prison system to keep dangerous criminals locked away so they cant rape/rob you walking down the street. The ministry of defence and armed forces are making sure countries with hostile intentions can't just come and drop a bomb on your house. Your friends and family are hopefully healthy but if they arent and they get sick or fall on hard times the state will be there for them, as it would be for you.

So yeah, dont tell yourself that you don't 'take' cause it's just BS.

This 👏👏👏
The 'system' isn't just benefits.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 26/07/2022 10:03

It boils my piss that mostly men have a family then pay the absolute minimum for their children.

pangolina · 26/07/2022 10:01

I have no children, my partner and I both work full time and have never claimed benefits.
I am delighted to live in a society with a welfare system that supports those who need it, and to be in the fortunate position to currently put in more than I take out.
My great grandfather died suddenly leaving my great grandmother with 5 young children, no benefits to be claimed, no support. She had to pack her youngest off to boarding school so she could work 3 jobs. Not a preferable situation, to my mind.

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 10:01

@NelStevHan I think it is partly a result of the gutter press pushing the narrative that the undeserving poor get "free" stuff while everyone else has to slog for it.

There are of course people who play the benefits system, but most don't and anyway is is mich harder to do tgese days. Playing of the tax system is a far bigger problem.

SaintHelena · 26/07/2022 10:00

I would guess you have the freedom to move, change jobs - can you look into that.
I think your view is shared by many - how can you improve your income.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 10:00

@NellesVilla Thank you for your kind message. Your mum did amazingly. It is very sad that you felt you couldn’t afford DC. I felt and put them off for 15 years to save as much as I could to buy a flat. I have one now but can’t afford another.

Deadbeat fathers are as much of a problem as the system. If I don’t judge my 3 friends for choosing not to work, I will judge them on the type of men they chose to have children with. It was obvious from day 1 these men would not be sticking around or “providing”. Had they chosen better fathers for their DC they probably wouldn’t be on benefits and their DC would have stable fatherly influences. Alas, they all only fancy a certain “type” of man and that sealed their fate.

Twinsmummy1812 · 26/07/2022 09:56

My husband used to have Italian business partners and they one said the UK is the best country to be poor in, not so great for those in the middle.

NelStevHan · 26/07/2022 09:53

It astonishes me that people who seem to have enough in their lives, like OP, to live, pay bills, eat, do what they want are resentful towards people who need help or aren't in as good a financial position whether that's from poor choices, poor starts in life, health reasons etc.
We're one of the richest economies in the world. We should be able to look after the health of our population, feed our children, educate and look after everyone.
Op - perhaps you should spend less time looking at what other people have and appreciate what you have.

Twinsmummy1812 · 26/07/2022 09:53

My DM and MIL are similar ages. Both worked most of their lives at fairly low paid jobs. Both on state pensions. Difference is my mum saved and now has to pay £550 per month for retirement flat she is in. My MIL knows how to play the system and has a brand new LA 2 bed bungalow, a disability car (gold convertable anyone) and honestly has money coming from everywhere.

it’s the inequality that is galling, MIL wanted wardrobes so got a company in and had them installed at £1,400. My mum needed wardrobes and bought flat pack and me and DSIS spent all day building the bloody things. Both DM and MIL wear varifocals, DM are £400 a pair, MIL gets them free.

My mum is upset because eventually her money is going to run out and she is going to have to claim housing benefit, which distresses her. My MIL’s attitude is that “I paid in for years, why shouldn’t I claim”. DH has pointed out that whatever she paid in won’t account for 1% of what she’s had out but she thinks there is a magic porridge pot that prints money.

Sorry for rambling. Gets my goat sometimes!

LadyCatStark · 26/07/2022 09:51

YANBU. I think a lot of people on Mumsnet are supportive of those on long term benefits because they live in their middle class bubble and don’t actually know anyone that can’t be arsed to work.

The whole system needs a massive overhaul. Employers need to be made to pay a true living wage so that there’s no need for top up benefits.

There needs to be universal free child care for all rather than free if you don’t work but paid for if you do (and yes I do understand the reasons for free nursery places).

There needs to be a massive push in schools to teach children work/ life/ budgeting skills and show some that there’s more to life than the estate that they spend their whole life on. Make it a subject in its own right rather than a few lessons. There’s children now who are growing up as the 4th generation to only know a benefits lifestyle and if you believe that there isn’t, you haven’t looked very far.

Increase the amount of school hours jobs or (controversially) increase the school day and pay teachers and support staff accordingly.

Charge everyone for prescriptions, dental care and eye tests which would allow them to charge a much lower price for everyone. It’s not fair that many working people have to forgo these completely as they can’t afford them while others get them for free.

It would probably take a few generations to make changes but surely it would be worth it for everyone in the long run.

NelStevHan · 26/07/2022 09:49

@notyetpregnant 'It is simply not true that everyone on benefits genuinely needs them. And I say that as someone from a family where there are generations of worklessness.

My own parents very rarely worked despite being able to and probably claimed a significant amount in benefits due to having a large family, and a lot of that money was usually squandered on cigarettes/alcohol etc.'

So your post is interesting - In your case you DID genuinely need benefits, your parents weren't working for whatever reason, you as a kid would have suffered. The UK social and benefits system meant that you and your siblings had an education, had healthcare and had a roof over your head and food. Your basic needs met.
Maybe, in your case, your parents would have got off their arses and worked if they had no choice, but more likely they wouldn't have and you kids would have suffered more.

Whiteflowers1 · 26/07/2022 09:48

YABU. I'm 30yrs old. Spent my 20s being a high earner paying sickening amounts into the system, I now work (full time) for the ambulance service, am a single parent and claim UC. Because if I don't I can't live! I qualify for the £650 payment and I work full time so your information is incorrect.
What is the alternative? Kids starving and dying? Life on benefits alone is a shit life otherwise you'd pack your job in and live off them, but the reality is for those unable to work it is a pathetic amount of money to "live on".
You will always get people abusing the system but they are the exception not the rule.

Itdoesntreallymatter · 26/07/2022 09:44

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 26/07/2022 08:50

I don't think my friend is having a fun life but I do think he's being facilitated to be a smelly, anti social angry, lazy and ignorant man because he doesn't do anything except smoke dope. Anything. If he wasn't given a fancy flat and money to buy the dope with, he could work. He is being let down

I think there are always going to be people like this sadly. Could be underlying MH issues or just plain laziness. Nobody really knows. Either way, I would prefer not to work with someone who really didn't want to be there. Makes your workplace less productive, probably costs more money than paying benefits. It's the same with paying people a pittance to live on who are on benefits. The impact on physical and mental health probably costs the government more in the long run.

My main issue is that aside from maternity leave, I have worked FT pretty much with young kids and am still renting. It has put enormous stress on us as a family. Probably impacted my health too. Just poured all my wages into a childcare provider pretty much. Pre-Tory, the government enabled one parent to go part time through top ups, or you could work FT to build wealth and have a decent standard of living, but now we have both parents working FT only to still struggle. I just want to be treated the same as the generation that got this help. Its the ageism of this government that bothers me. They don't give a shit about anyone under the age of 60.

And before anyone mentions the magic money tree. I think we can all safely say our government find it very easily to provide their cronies with dubious contracts and for their vanity projects. They can find it to take a private plane at the tax payers expense too. So that is not a sound argument.

NellesVilla · 26/07/2022 09:42

Thanks, @wellhelloitsme, will look into that. It’s so expensive with all my prescriptions!!

And @FreyaStorm , I know this is no consolation- when others get more for doing f all- but you should be proud of what you have achieved without help and providing a great example to your child. I have no children and couldn’t afford them anyway, so I respect you so much for managing a job and parenthood. I promise you that your child will appreciate the example you give. You sound like a hard-working, decent person.

My mother was deserted by my deadbeat father who was/is fairly well off (great career) and she brought us up while nursing on night shifts. Back then it was not easy to get any benefits as a single mum (not compared to these days). She has her issues but I admire her greatly for doing that. My father? Not so much.

Swipe left for the next trending thread