Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
wellhelloitsme · 26/07/2022 15:09

HotCaterpillar · 26/07/2022 14:17

Yanbu. Benefits should stop after a certain period, they are too generous.

What period would you suggest?

Spikeyball · 26/07/2022 15:04

"Yanbu. Benefits should stop after a certain period, they are too generous."

So people who cannot work will suddenly develop the ability to work? Or those on low wages will suddenly get their wages increased?

TooBigForMyBoots · 26/07/2022 14:46

How would you work out when to stop the benefits @HotCaterpillar?

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 14:41

HotCaterpillar · 26/07/2022 14:17

Yanbu. Benefits should stop after a certain period, they are too generous.

So what happens then? We leave people to die homeless on the street?

HotCaterpillar · 26/07/2022 14:17

Yanbu. Benefits should stop after a certain period, they are too generous.

newbluecurtains · 26/07/2022 14:13

The system is the issue, not people. Some humans are rubbish are there will always be people who abuse it, like there will always be people who commit crimes, but the system as a whole does not work when people who work full time and pay a lot into it are constantly short-changed by what they get out of it - ie. under funded NHS, social care and school systems under huge strain.

I work full time as a teacher, my husband has suffered for many years with very bad depression. He has been on benefits for this for many years but they just supplement my income, he could not afford to live on them alone. The big issue we have is that he has spent years working really hard to overcome/find coping mechanisms for his depression so he is now looking at getting a job.

When he gets a job will it work out? Or will it send him back? Will he actually be able to continue with this job long-term? More likely he'll need to start with something part time, developing more coping strategies, then build up. However, the second the gov even get a whiff that he is thinking of working, they will declare him fit for work and we will lose ALL benefits. So I am having to save my earnings in case he tries to work, isn't able to continue, and we are left with no support. This did happen many years ago and it was a hard slog to get him back on benefits. He is really trying.

Compare a friend(ish) is ours who has also been on benefits for years for depression and she does exactly nothing. No doctors, drugs, therapy, even personal meditation. She sits at home all day doing exactly what she likes - she doesn't have much money, but she has enough to live in a cheaper area and spends her days doing nothing. My husband's incentive to work came from himself - to be an equal contributor with me, to get better so we can have children, improve his life. While she's content to spend her life as she currently is without trying to get better.

Problem is - how do you incentivise her to work, without punishing those people that WANT to get better but haven't been able to?

It's a complicated thing that that requires a complete overhaul. I read a book about Universal Basic Income recently that left me fully convinced it would work MUCH better than the current system, but it won't happen, especially while people continue to vote Tory (but realisitically, the current labour gov wouldn't look at the idea either)

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 26/07/2022 13:47

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 11:46

@CbaThinkingOfAUsername
So the differential might be that you're in Scotland? Are benefits really thousands of pounds higher in Scotland than in the rest of the country?

Minus the housing element I'm getting £600 in England as a single mother (and it will go down to £400 if I don't up my own earnings within the next couple of months) . With a cheap rent like yours my overall benefit payment would be just over £900.

Yeah, I'd love to have £1300 left over AFTER the rent and council tax!! It's £380 + child benefit in reality.

@QueenCamilla The differential is that I'm in Scotland? The title of this thread is referring to the UK. Which Scotland is in. So who says that the thread is referring to England and that Scotland is a differential? Typical 🙄 Anyway, I don't really care what you get I'm simply saying what I get. You're the who decided to call me a liar. Which I'm not. I guess some folk are just so intellectually challenged that they absolutely cannot get their heads around the fact that other people's circumstances may be different than theirs.

To answer your question "are benefits really thousands of pounds higher in Scotland than the rest of the country?". I have no idea. Clearly there is some difference ie Scottish Child Payment. However I've only had benefits in Scotland, not England/Wales/N.I, so I can't say for sure. Unlike you, I don't spout out my own situation and assume it's the exact same for everyone else and calls them liars when they disagree. Scotland does pay a higher level of income tax than the rest of the UK, so perhaps we do get a higher level of benefits. But again, I don't know for sure.

Glamping4Break · 26/07/2022 13:33

Nobody has a crystal ball

People were made redundant during covid, the Government provided support, including to some of my friends.

Try getting a job in your 60s with some health conditions

You should be proud that the Government has a system in place to help people.

Of course, some people will play the system, but this is not the majority

Please come back in 30 years time & tell us that you have not been on benefits

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 26/07/2022 13:30

hangrylady · 26/07/2022 12:22

It kind of proves OPs point. You can work your arse off and still be poor, so why bother?

I don't think anyone who is riled by the OP is in denial of this or not accepting that it must be demoralising and exasperating.

The issue is that people who are working and then looking at benefits claimants and seeing that they aren't much worse off than them often then turn around and start claiming that it's 'unfair' and that the 'welfare system is broken', which is effectively an attack on benefits claimants.

It is undoubtedly unfair, but the problem in this circumstance is emphatically not a broken welfare system. Benefits are calculated as the bare minimum income that a person in their circumstances requires in order to have a basic standard of living. If people are obtaining degrees, working full-time, and still don't have anything beyond the same basic standard of living as those who are in receipt of welfare, then surely the problem is poor salaries and a government that does nothing to ensure than employers treat employees fairly instead of prioritising profits, share price, and dividends.

If you argue that the problem is Welfare, then what you are essentially saying is 'despite the fact I am working full time and have a basic standard of living, this is unfair, so people on welfare should have a standard of living that is even lower and fails to meet a minimum, basic standard'. Not only is this failing to see the real issue, but it's inhumane due to what it implies for people who can not work through no fault of their own.

If people genuinely want to end the unfairness and bring about some social justice, then they need to stop the self-delusion and stop voting for parties who pretend to care about 'strivers'. The Tories don't give a shit about the people doing the striving, they only care that you do strive because that is a means to maintain or increase productivity and profit. 'Aspriational' Toryism is a lie on so many fronts. They simply don't care about people from lower social strata who do work hard, as evidenced by their economic ideology that has lead to things like the complaints in this very thread. There is also the total nonsense idea of 'trickle down wealth'. If the past 30 years aren't evidence enough that all increased wealth generation does is cause the wealthy to hoard more of it, then god help us. Boom and bust, the never ending cycle of people paying way over the odds for houses followed by negative equity, the 'right to buy' and never replacing lost housing stock, all of it is a con driven by the wealthy elite because they have a vested interest in creating a nation of wage slaves, then keeping those wages as low as possible. Another nonsense, this issue that all you need to do is better yourself then everyone is A-OK. Sure, when everyone in the UK is a high-flying exec, who is doing the street sweeping, the caring for the elderly, the bus driving, the road maintenance?

The 'problem' with working hard and being no better off than benefit claimants is nothing whatsoever to do with welfare claimants, or the welfare system, which is why people get annoyed when it's invariably cited as the issue while the real cause is ignored.

malificent7 · 26/07/2022 13:12

If being on benefits is the life of riley op , then get a sperm donor and claim. Ditch that pesky job. Don't just stop at 1 child though....more kids, more money!

rusticaflores · 26/07/2022 13:07

I think people really need to get a grip with their hatred, prejudice, and 'I know someone who..' shit.

When I was on benefits you might have thought I didn't have anything 'wrong' with me. I'm a private person and wouldn't have told anyone about my severe PTSD. You might have seen me out one day, clean and seemingly happy, but you didn't see that the whole week previously I hadn't been out of bed or showered battling constant panic attacks etc. Like another poster, sometimes I went manic and would sell my soul to get 'things' that I thought would make others like me.

The Tories already did the benefit-bashing media thing when they first got in. It's how they convinced all those not actually living on them that's it's a life of luxury and that 'austerity' needed to be targeted on the poorest. Remember Austerity?? It seems benefit bashing is the agenda again.

For those who want the disability system 'tightened up' - don't you know they already did that?? Those 'reforms' caused the sad deaths of 100s of disabled people, some through suicide sadly like another previous poster's poor mum, and some through starvation.

DWP sees 'sharp rise' in benefit death reviews - BBC

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has begun 124 reviews since July 2019. Ninety-seven of those concerned people who died.
The DWP holds reviews when it is alleged its actions had a negative impact, or when named at an inquest.

Yes - when named at an inquest.

Do we really want this, just so you can have a moan and a kick down on others??

Wake up.

Antarcticant · 26/07/2022 13:06

There's enough wealth in the world for everyone to not have to work and do something they love instead.

If nobody worked, the infrastructure would collapse in hours. How do you think services such as electricity, gas, mains water etc. are provided? We would have to return to a primitive 'self sufficient' lifestyle of foraging for our own food and so on. That would be harder work than many jobs, with no retirement, sick leave etc.

Darbs76 · 26/07/2022 13:02

I’ve relied on benefits and I’ve also earned over 60k per year. Much rather have the latter. But yes you’re right, there’s a lot of people out there who don’t use benefits for what it’s intended, to help out when times are hard, for many it’s a life style choice.

Walkaround · 26/07/2022 13:00

Deguster · 26/07/2022 11:29

@Walkaround I am in no way suggesting that we emulate the systems of government in the ME - no idea how you got that from my post. The point is that there are job opportunities in countries that offer lower tax, and those opportunities enable savings to be made if you are at a stage in life where the tax burden feels unfair.

I am a high earner but I use state schools because my DS has additional needs and would not be accepted in a prep. He was born in the UK and is "allowed" to do so!

I do think the UK has the worst of all worlds in some ways. A tax burden that feels high - perhaps because wages are low and we do not have the same employment protection as in (say) France - but services that are overwhelmingly shit and failing, like the NHS. I would perhaps feel optimistic about DH and I (both HR taxpayers) putting even more into the pot if I believed it wouldn't just be spaffed away by whatever idiots are in charge at the time.

@Deguster - I didn’t get from your post that we should emulate the Middle East. I was merely pointing out that your post would rile the OP as they expressly complained about someone who worked overseas, then came back and claimed benefits, etc, etc. I have no problem whatsoever with anyone with children of school age who lives in the UK using UK state schools for their children.

I do agree that the UK is currently getting it badly wrong and working hard to achieve the worst of all worlds. It’s feels like the country has been doing precisely the wrong thing at precisely the wrong time for years - running down public services, then spending large amounts on building them up, then wasting any gains by dramatically underfunding again and wasting what money actually is available on changes that improve nothing as they are purely ideological, not evidence based. This government just seems intent on promising a lot but actually attempting to evade all responsibility for anything. It’s always local councils that are at fault, or inefficiencies that are totally not the responsibility of the politicians who pushed through the changes, or previous governments, or the rest of the world, never badly thought out government changes or fantastical promises on vastly reduced budgets that are to be carried out by people who are being asked to do things they don’t understand and don’t have the capacity to do anyway, all asked for by politicians who don’t have a clue what they are talking about…

Antarcticant · 26/07/2022 12:58

DogsAndGin · 26/07/2022 09:01

But if you put the work in you’ll do a hell of a lot better than someone on benefits. There are high wages out there, for people of all different personalities and skill sets.

OK, so who is supposed to do the low-paying jobs? Someone has to. And for that reason the min wage needs to rise to a level where people can live in at least a modest level of comfort, without the need for state top-ups.

Alltheseasonsaregreat · 26/07/2022 12:53

I have never been on a benefit thread before. I live in a place where what would normally be minimum wage you get paid between 12 to 20 pounds and hour.
This is because there are not many people here to serve the tourist trade( which is all year here) so employers pay this to keep people. Many people have two jobs. Employers are desperate to get staff. I absolutely know from sitting in on informal.interviews which.are basically a chat and when can you start that applicants seeking to show that they have applied for jobs in order to keep.benefits show they have applied for the job , but either dont turn up or make no effort in the chat at all . They dont want the job are playing the game. My manager has has so much time wasted by these individual s.

Its absolutely true .

Sugarplumfairy65 · 26/07/2022 12:49

Twinsmummy1812 · 26/07/2022 09:53

My DM and MIL are similar ages. Both worked most of their lives at fairly low paid jobs. Both on state pensions. Difference is my mum saved and now has to pay £550 per month for retirement flat she is in. My MIL knows how to play the system and has a brand new LA 2 bed bungalow, a disability car (gold convertable anyone) and honestly has money coming from everywhere.

it’s the inequality that is galling, MIL wanted wardrobes so got a company in and had them installed at £1,400. My mum needed wardrobes and bought flat pack and me and DSIS spent all day building the bloody things. Both DM and MIL wear varifocals, DM are £400 a pair, MIL gets them free.

My mum is upset because eventually her money is going to run out and she is going to have to claim housing benefit, which distresses her. My MIL’s attitude is that “I paid in for years, why shouldn’t I claim”. DH has pointed out that whatever she paid in won’t account for 1% of what she’s had out but she thinks there is a magic porridge pot that prints money.

Sorry for rambling. Gets my goat sometimes!

The only way to get the high rate of pip and be entitled to join the motability scheme if you are assessed. To do that you have to have significant life changing disabilities. if shes still on dla and waiting to be changed to pip, she has a shock coming her way very soon.
If she is entitled to the mobility element of pip she can use it for whatever car she wants to that is on the scheme.

Hallamus · 26/07/2022 12:30

@FreyaStorm opposite - I am middle class- ish, but have had to live on benefits before. Know many people who have been on them. Also know a couple of cheats - but mostly, I know it's no fucking holiday being on benefits.

You can have a secure tenancy from a housing association at market rate without being on benefits. I've done it. But didn't stay very long because the houses (which you expect people to be so grateful for) were in such a dicey spot, which is pretty standard in my part of the country for council/ HA houses now that the system has been decimated by right to buy and underfunding.

hangrylady · 26/07/2022 12:22

Discovereads · 25/07/2022 20:15

In all this I think you have failed to notice that over half of benefits claimants are in full time work.

It kind of proves OPs point. You can work your arse off and still be poor, so why bother?

Hallamus · 26/07/2022 12:21

@Barbadossunset it's all relative. Sure these things occur but compared to huge swathes of the world - including where my family is posted to right now - the UK is extremely safe and the amount of thought you have to give to how safe it is to walk down the street is much less. I never fully appreciated the freedom of it before I lived another way. And no, I definitely didn't only live in nice, happy parts of the UK before!

I wish the phrase "free money" - which I see a lot on these threads - could just be banned. It's a stupid phrase and elides the fact that this money is just about enough to prevent starvation and not enough, in many cases, to prevent abject deprivation.

So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch

But why would you get help if you don't need it? I'm sure your life is difficult, but if you're earning enough to not get any low income support then you don't need help in the way the people you describe do.

People who make this argument sound incredibly childish to me. It's not like mum comes home with a bag of sweets and every kid should get one. It's based on need, not everyone deserving a turn to get something free.

Of course there's cheats. There's cheats at the millionaire and billionaire levels too, causing far more damage, they just look more respectable. If you want to be eaten up by the injustice of something, try that instead.

But you need to think less about what everyone else is getting and just concentrate on yourself.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 26/07/2022 12:15

"Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?"

Maggie178 · 26/07/2022 12:11

Poor you. You've always been well enough to work and had a job that pays enough to financially support yourself.

notyetpregnant · 26/07/2022 12:01

NelStevHan · 26/07/2022 09:49

@notyetpregnant 'It is simply not true that everyone on benefits genuinely needs them. And I say that as someone from a family where there are generations of worklessness.

My own parents very rarely worked despite being able to and probably claimed a significant amount in benefits due to having a large family, and a lot of that money was usually squandered on cigarettes/alcohol etc.'

So your post is interesting - In your case you DID genuinely need benefits, your parents weren't working for whatever reason, you as a kid would have suffered. The UK social and benefits system meant that you and your siblings had an education, had healthcare and had a roof over your head and food. Your basic needs met.
Maybe, in your case, your parents would have got off their arses and worked if they had no choice, but more likely they wouldn't have and you kids would have suffered more.

I was replying to a PP's claim that everyone on benefits has a genuine need for them. I don't think being too lazy to work equates to a genuine need. And I referred to my own family to demonstrate that I had definite knowledge of there not being a genuine need, and that I was just stereotyping all people on benefits.

The government obviously needs to ensure that children are fed and clothed and I don't disagree with that, but in my opinion more could and should be done to make people work if they are able to.

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 11:46

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 26/07/2022 08:55

Perhaps get a clue of what you're talking about before calling other people's situations bs, @QueenCamilla My rent of £330 is paid in full by the housing element of universal credit. 25% discount off my council tax for being a single adult in the home. Universal credit = Personal allowance + child element + child benefit + scottish child payment = over £1300. So perhaps away and get your facts corrent dear. Now do toddle along.

@CbaThinkingOfAUsername
So the differential might be that you're in Scotland? Are benefits really thousands of pounds higher in Scotland than in the rest of the country?

Minus the housing element I'm getting £600 in England as a single mother (and it will go down to £400 if I don't up my own earnings within the next couple of months) . With a cheap rent like yours my overall benefit payment would be just over £900.

Yeah, I'd love to have £1300 left over AFTER the rent and council tax!! It's £380 + child benefit in reality.

Barbadossunset · 26/07/2022 11:45

You get the benefit of living in a safe country where violent crime is rare

Really? Maybe in small towns and villages but in London violent crime is not rare. There are robberies, shootings and mugging the whole time.