Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Florenz · 27/07/2022 00:49

AchatAVendre · 26/07/2022 21:03

So whats the point in doing a really tricky, stressful, highly qualified job with lots of unpaid overtime (or taking a promotion that involves that) if you only get just under 40% of what you earn over 50k? You would be as well doing it part time.

I personally think the personal tax allowance is a bit high in this country. It disincentivises people from working longer or harder because they have to overcome that barrier of paying tax and it disenfranchises people because they do not pay tax. Even a nominal rate, eg 2% kicking it at around £4000 would be better because then people would at least then know they are a taxpaying member of society.

If you earnt £100,000 a year you'd be paying £35,000 in tax. Which seems fair to me.

entropynow · 27/07/2022 00:11

OriginalUsername2 · 26/07/2022 10:19

The rich have always pointed the masses towards the poor. “Look at them! Look how they’re living! Look at them TAKING!”

..and while we all look that way, the rich scoop up everything for themselves.

Yep

XenoBitch · 26/07/2022 22:57

OP YABU

The "system" is not like a bank that you pay into and take from as and when needed. It is more like insurance everyone pays in (and even those on benefits do in the form of tax on items/services they buy). You can go a long time paying in and not need to take from it. A lot of people never need to claim anything. A civilised society looks after the most vulnerable and poor.

If you are earning too much to get any help, then that is not the fault of the people that are getting extra help.
If you earn too much to get any benefits, then what would you like to see happen? People on benefits get less? Far too many think that life on benefits is amazing, and we all have the latest phone (you can be tied into a contract for years), a big flatscreen (flatscreens are the only TV you can buy now), a new car (probably paid for from DLA/PIP... meaning that person has a disability).

I have seen a few posts on this thread where people have said there should be a stigma about being on benefits... that people on it should be shamed and feel embarrassed. I got into a lot of debt because I was brought up to be too proud to claim. I lived for far too long on zero income and no savings... just got deeper into debt because I did not want to 'sign on'. I pretty much got dragged to the Job Centre by my CPN because the way I was living was making my mental health tank big time.
Friends/family, social media/MN... all of the judgemental comments about claiming put me off and almost cost me my life.
I do claim now and have done for a few years. I still feel ashamed. I am single... how do I bring up being a "scrounger" with a potential date? I don't. I just don't put myself out there because who would want to date someone on benefits? According to some on this thread, I would make their friends sick.

Sorry, I am ranting and probably not making much sense. I just fucking hate seeing threads like this, and all the benefit bashing. Stop punching down, and stay humble.

XenoBitch · 26/07/2022 22:20

Nothappyatwork · 26/07/2022 21:39

I also find it hard to believe someone is indefinitely signed off with depression. My relative had major surgery on their back and the DWP has her in every 3 months for assessment.

I know 2 people who are on ESA for depression and have never been called up for re-assessment. Both have been on benefits for well over a decade... possibly close to 20 years
When UC is rolled out everywhere, maybe they will be re-assessed, I don't know.

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 21:58

Bordesleyhills · 26/07/2022 21:12

Worked hard, now a SAHM through choice. Husband doesn’t earn a fortune and yet I don’t qualify as it’s if you earn less than £154 a week. Friend arrives from abroad - full benefit and yet never paid in. What I think is sad is people having to be paid benefits who are in work. Yes there will be the professionals who claim for forever and they shouldn’t and yet there are the ones who should claim and won’t / can’t/ don’t realise . Hate the fact that uk is seen as a easy touch

I'm confused. What didn't you qualify for?

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 21:54

Bordesleyhills · 26/07/2022 21:12

Worked hard, now a SAHM through choice. Husband doesn’t earn a fortune and yet I don’t qualify as it’s if you earn less than £154 a week. Friend arrives from abroad - full benefit and yet never paid in. What I think is sad is people having to be paid benefits who are in work. Yes there will be the professionals who claim for forever and they shouldn’t and yet there are the ones who should claim and won’t / can’t/ don’t realise . Hate the fact that uk is seen as a easy touch

I earned more than £154 per week and could claim. Although I guess if you don't rent you might not qualify.

Nothappyatwork · 26/07/2022 21:39

I also find it hard to believe someone is indefinitely signed off with depression. My relative had major surgery on their back and the DWP has her in every 3 months for assessment.

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 21:18

Bordesleyhills · 26/07/2022 21:12

Worked hard, now a SAHM through choice. Husband doesn’t earn a fortune and yet I don’t qualify as it’s if you earn less than £154 a week. Friend arrives from abroad - full benefit and yet never paid in. What I think is sad is people having to be paid benefits who are in work. Yes there will be the professionals who claim for forever and they shouldn’t and yet there are the ones who should claim and won’t / can’t/ don’t realise . Hate the fact that uk is seen as a easy touch

What country did she come from, under what status, how long ago did she leave the UK, what benefits is she now claiming?

Nothappyatwork · 26/07/2022 21:16

Bordesleyhills · 26/07/2022 21:12

Worked hard, now a SAHM through choice. Husband doesn’t earn a fortune and yet I don’t qualify as it’s if you earn less than £154 a week. Friend arrives from abroad - full benefit and yet never paid in. What I think is sad is people having to be paid benefits who are in work. Yes there will be the professionals who claim for forever and they shouldn’t and yet there are the ones who should claim and won’t / can’t/ don’t realise . Hate the fact that uk is seen as a easy touch

I thought you had to be in the country 3 years before you had recourse to public funds

Bordesleyhills · 26/07/2022 21:12

Worked hard, now a SAHM through choice. Husband doesn’t earn a fortune and yet I don’t qualify as it’s if you earn less than £154 a week. Friend arrives from abroad - full benefit and yet never paid in. What I think is sad is people having to be paid benefits who are in work. Yes there will be the professionals who claim for forever and they shouldn’t and yet there are the ones who should claim and won’t / can’t/ don’t realise . Hate the fact that uk is seen as a easy touch

AchatAVendre · 26/07/2022 21:03

Florenz · 26/07/2022 20:58

I think tax brackets need an overhaul, there should be a 10% rate before the 20% kicks in. The simple way to do it would be:

£0-10,000 - 0%
£10-20,000 - 10%
£20-30,000 - 20%
£30-40,000 - 30%
£40-50,000 - 40%
£50,000+ - 50%

So whats the point in doing a really tricky, stressful, highly qualified job with lots of unpaid overtime (or taking a promotion that involves that) if you only get just under 40% of what you earn over 50k? You would be as well doing it part time.

I personally think the personal tax allowance is a bit high in this country. It disincentivises people from working longer or harder because they have to overcome that barrier of paying tax and it disenfranchises people because they do not pay tax. Even a nominal rate, eg 2% kicking it at around £4000 would be better because then people would at least then know they are a taxpaying member of society.

Florenz · 26/07/2022 20:58

I think tax brackets need an overhaul, there should be a 10% rate before the 20% kicks in. The simple way to do it would be:

£0-10,000 - 0%
£10-20,000 - 10%
£20-30,000 - 20%
£30-40,000 - 30%
£40-50,000 - 40%
£50,000+ - 50%

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 20:58

I can’t imagine having so little self respect that I didn’t think of was “worth it” to work rather than scrounge, knowing I’m able bodied and healthy and have the option

I agree. I don't know how the likes of Boris and Carrie Johnson, who have perfected high value grifting and scrounging to a fine art, can live with themselves. But it is OK for them to do it as it's all gold wall paper, rich Russians and fancy wedding celebrations rather than fags, cider and flat screen TVs.

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/07/2022 20:44

doingitforyorkshire · 26/07/2022 17:42

In some ways, I can see the point of this post and can empathise a little with it. However, I work hard because I couldn't live with myself if I didn't. Sometimes things just need to be done, not because you're getting paid, but because it's the responsible thing to do. It can be so easy to say why bother, I would hate to think that someone might see me as coasting through life or as lazy though. So why bother working hard? Because of a sense of purpose, because you want to do something with your life, because you want to, because you want to make those close to you proud, you want to make a difference, I could go on quite a bit once I give it a bit of thought.

Agree. It’s why I never understand the posts of “well why don’t you just give up your job and go on benefits then?” and “I can totally understand why people don’t want to work when they can get almost the same in benefits instead.” It’s never occurred to me to be one of those people because I’d feel utterly embarrassed to do it. My parents would be ashamed of me. My friends would think less of me. I can’t imagine having so little self respect that I didn’t think of was “worth it” to work rather than scrounge, knowing I’m able bodied and healthy and have the option.

RainCloud · 26/07/2022 18:52

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 25/07/2022 20:24

None of us know what life is going to throw at us. Don't be so quick to get rid of the safety net.

There is no safety net for those without children.

TBH if I'd left school with only a few exam passes, I'd be looking at being a single mother on benefits, rather than looking forward to a dead end, zero hours contract, min wage job. As the saying goes, don't hate the players, hate the game. The issue is, what happens to these women when the kids turn 18 and there are no more benefits available?

Alltheseasonsaregreat · 26/07/2022 17:44

Fab post doingitforyorkshire.

doingitforyorkshire · 26/07/2022 17:42

In some ways, I can see the point of this post and can empathise a little with it. However, I work hard because I couldn't live with myself if I didn't. Sometimes things just need to be done, not because you're getting paid, but because it's the responsible thing to do. It can be so easy to say why bother, I would hate to think that someone might see me as coasting through life or as lazy though. So why bother working hard? Because of a sense of purpose, because you want to do something with your life, because you want to, because you want to make those close to you proud, you want to make a difference, I could go on quite a bit once I give it a bit of thought.

XenoBitch · 26/07/2022 17:27

newbluecurtains · 26/07/2022 14:13

The system is the issue, not people. Some humans are rubbish are there will always be people who abuse it, like there will always be people who commit crimes, but the system as a whole does not work when people who work full time and pay a lot into it are constantly short-changed by what they get out of it - ie. under funded NHS, social care and school systems under huge strain.

I work full time as a teacher, my husband has suffered for many years with very bad depression. He has been on benefits for this for many years but they just supplement my income, he could not afford to live on them alone. The big issue we have is that he has spent years working really hard to overcome/find coping mechanisms for his depression so he is now looking at getting a job.

When he gets a job will it work out? Or will it send him back? Will he actually be able to continue with this job long-term? More likely he'll need to start with something part time, developing more coping strategies, then build up. However, the second the gov even get a whiff that he is thinking of working, they will declare him fit for work and we will lose ALL benefits. So I am having to save my earnings in case he tries to work, isn't able to continue, and we are left with no support. This did happen many years ago and it was a hard slog to get him back on benefits. He is really trying.

Compare a friend(ish) is ours who has also been on benefits for years for depression and she does exactly nothing. No doctors, drugs, therapy, even personal meditation. She sits at home all day doing exactly what she likes - she doesn't have much money, but she has enough to live in a cheaper area and spends her days doing nothing. My husband's incentive to work came from himself - to be an equal contributor with me, to get better so we can have children, improve his life. While she's content to spend her life as she currently is without trying to get better.

Problem is - how do you incentivise her to work, without punishing those people that WANT to get better but haven't been able to?

It's a complicated thing that that requires a complete overhaul. I read a book about Universal Basic Income recently that left me fully convinced it would work MUCH better than the current system, but it won't happen, especially while people continue to vote Tory (but realisitically, the current labour gov wouldn't look at the idea either)

Recovery from mental illness has to come from within. It sounds like your husband and your "friend" are along different parts of their recovery journey. Your husband also has you and your encouragement. Who does your friend have? Do you think stopping her money will suddenly make her get help for her depression?

TimBoothseyes · 26/07/2022 17:23

Why aren't all those moaning about people they "know" that live the high life on benefits, claiming them for themselves. Why are you so intent on saying how hard you work when, according to you, life is soooooo much better living off the state. My guess is that you know it's all BS and you couldn't manage on them.

woodhill · 26/07/2022 17:17

Spikeyball · 26/07/2022 16:26

"I'm sure that some of them could work but chose not to"

Those that can't. Do you agree with that poster that they should be left to die.

No of course not but ooh do you think all those you mention fall into the can't work category

teenagetantrums · 26/07/2022 16:53

Yabu. Of course some people choose not work and live on benefits.good luck to them, more jobs for people who want to work.
I have worked for most of the last 35 years. But have had two periods of being on JSA. It's really not a life of luxury. Last time l think l got my rent paid and £78 a week.
I got more the time before as l had dependant teenagers but that was hard to. We regularly ran of credit on our pre payment meters.
I just worry about my own finance's l can't be worried about people claiming benefits.
It's a lifeline you can use if anything unexpected happens in your life

Spikeyball · 26/07/2022 16:26

"I'm sure that some of them could work but chose not to"

Those that can't. Do you agree with that poster that they should be left to die.

woodhill · 26/07/2022 16:08

Spikeyball · 26/07/2022 15:04

"Yanbu. Benefits should stop after a certain period, they are too generous."

So people who cannot work will suddenly develop the ability to work? Or those on low wages will suddenly get their wages increased?

I'm sure that some of them could work but chose not to

girlfriend44 · 26/07/2022 15:58

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 14:41

So what happens then? We leave people to die homeless on the street?

Exactly. You have to have money to live on by law. Nobody would vote for a party that took away ppls money and let them die either.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 26/07/2022 15:22

Benefits are essential. We shouldn't belittle anyone. Why should a single parent have to work, surely they should be allowed to focus on their children. People who lose their job or business should be given the dignity to survive while they move on. Hopeless people who have been let down by the education and care system? Surely we should be trying to make amends and offer training, education and support. The whole system is geared to people who are good at negotiating, the number of homeless tell us this. My ideal is where we offer a safety net to all people and also try to make sure that benefits are not part.of the problem. People I love are caught up in this mentality that it's the council or others, the only reason I am glad I am self sufficient is because the people who deal with the hopeless disempowered people feel scared, vulnerable and angry. It's so unfair. Why can't we admit that the system let's families down, let's children down and starts to invest in making people feel safe and secure and cared for. I do think cannabis has a lot to answer for in young people but that's just my.opinion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread