Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Kamia · 26/07/2022 07:17

It's not the fault of people who claim benefits the whole system is unfair. Nobody working full time should have to suffer. There are people who are working really hard full time and still receive such bad pay that they cannot meet the cost of living without benefits. Some people work full time and only earn £350 per week and is supposed to cover rent, council tax, bills and food even with benefits they have nothing left after that. Bear in mind working tax credit is at most £40 or £50 a week it helps but you're not rolling in it. They can't buy new clothes they wear the same clothes for years, no chance of holidays, it's hard to save for a rainy day because something constantly needs paying. When you do buy something nice you have to sacrifice something else such as the kind of food you can afford to buy. Are you really envious of that kind of life? It's time to make politicians accountable for the cost of living and pay rather than look down on people who are claiming what they are entitled to because it will help put food on the table, heat their home the basic necessities.

saleorbouy · 26/07/2022 06:42

The system is stacked against you in your situation and there is little support for you even if you lost your job tomorrow.
Working is not rewarded and earning well is seen as a means to overtax you to support the needy and the feckless.
Personally I think there should be a standard rate of tax eg. 25% applied across everything. No sliding scales for higher earners, just a tax free allowance below 40k that reduces incrementally as you earn more.
If people kept more of what they earned it would return to the economy as you spent it and support businesses, the wider economy and jobs.
Tax would be recouped in other ways, VAT, business tax, and income tax from workers supported by spending you higher disposable income.
The current tax system does not support taking on more responsible roles as wage rises are lost in increased taxation.
Presently the system supports working less for more handouts at the expense of those who work Full time.
Administration of the tax system is also too complicated and allows many loopholes for evasion.

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/07/2022 06:40

I have sympathy (and respect) for you OP. But refocus on what you have been given by the system. Free schooling at primary or secondary? Any prescriptions you pay a few pounds for that would be hundreds if not for the NHS? Any visits to GP or hospital checkups or tests all free? Decent roads to drive down: well lit streets. Libraries and museums to visit for free. If these all vanished you'd realise that you have benefited and taken the benefits for granted.

Spectre8 · 26/07/2022 06:04

bellac11 · 26/07/2022 00:20

You can get a ulez compliant car for about 3k upwards

Right but you have to factor in engine size, mileage ready done and what type of car you need to fit your needs. Getting a 1.0 litre car when your doing mostly motorway driving isn't the best idea so by the time you factor that in the cost is alot more. Not the time alot of those 3k cars have significant mileage which means more chance of paying for repairs

PhilInt · 26/07/2022 05:39

@Alexandra2001

The only problem with that argument is that your Polish friends have an improved life to look forward to, keeping them going working crazy hours on a low wage. For the British person, this is probably it. Rental prices will probably keep them unable to ever buy that house (or piece of land) and own their own future.

MotherOfPuffling · 26/07/2022 05:33

Discovereads · 25/07/2022 20:15

In all this I think you have failed to notice that over half of benefits claimants are in full time work.

^^This

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 05:23

Horatioshelmet · 26/07/2022 05:20

I’m with the op here, so many people out there who won’t work more than 16 hours a week “cos it’ll affect my benefits”

That's not the case on UC though is it?

It was on tax credits (my colleague thought I was mad to work full time and lose benefits when he worked 16 hours so he didn't).
So anyone claiming they can't work more than 16 hours will get a shock when they move to UC.

Horatioshelmet · 26/07/2022 05:20

DenholmElliot1 · 25/07/2022 20:18

I sympathise OP. Single childless people on low wages are particularly disadvantaged in this country. A sizable amount of people with children use some of that funding for their own needs rather than spending it on the children, which means a single person on minimum wage is worse off than a married person on minimum wage TOPPED UP WITH TAX CREDITS.

I’m with the op here, so many people out there who won’t work more than 16 hours a week “cos it’ll affect my benefits”

mathanxiety · 26/07/2022 05:13

everyone is focusing on the benefits issue but the OP is correct in her comments about single working low wage people struggling with no help/top ups and having to afford rent, bills, food etc themselves. It’s impossible

This is because British employers can get away with paying people peanuts.

It's not because other people are taking all the money.

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 05:09

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 04:34

@CbaThinkingOfAUsername

I've seen your magic numbers on other benefits threads... Unless they're related to maternity leave (or some other special circumstances that I'm unaware of) your magic numbers are total bull*!

As a single mother I was on £1300 (plus child benefit) in total.
My rent for the most basic-box 80s flat was £750 until the landlord asked for £895 and I moved out straight after.
I was paying full council tax (because you do as soon as you earn the most basic minimum ).
My son was eating his free school meals.
I wasn't paying prescription charges.
We were getting holiday food vouchers.
And I'm grateful for the above!!

I didn't have a car, didn't drink/smoke, no subscriptions (no TV in fact! ), phone bill paid by a relative on a family contract, no broadband, no debts, never ever ordered a takeaway, never went on a holiday whilst on UC.
To my eternal shame, partial to avocados.

We were OK only because of my frugal ways. Something like a car would have financially tipped us over.

£1300 after rent?! Pull the other one!

Glad I'm not the only one who thinks that doesn't add up!

Plus the PP who went from getting all their rent paid to getting none, because they increased their hours by 2? Why? That doesn't make sense. There's a taper rate so you don't go from full benefits to nothing just for an extra 2 hours per week.

And the PP who said less would be paid in benefits if NRPs were made to pay maintenance. Maintenance isn't classed as income so it wouldn't make a difference.

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 05:05

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 22:34

But you could choose to get a job which would give you those options, if you were physically able? I know people on benefits who still seems have everything they want, a car, the latest iPhone, days out etc...

Oh sweet child.. I was just like you some moons ago... The young, childless know-it-all.
That simplistic view of life went the same way where my well-intended hypno birthing plan did. It was never quite the same again.

Try to be the lone parent who can go and get the jobs that afford "Things". Try. And then speak. The logistical nightmares of that scenario will be the least of your new-found worries.

And for : I know someone on benefits with a new iphone/holiday/car"... There is a nice house somewhere in England where the new double-glazing was paid for by me selling my body "on the side".
I don't want to make it more dramatic than it need to be. Just take it that you know NOTHING. Try your own life first.

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 04:34

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 25/07/2022 21:24

I'll be honest, I'm not finding it that difficult. I'm a qualified nurse who changed jobs and then became single while pregnant, before I found out I was pregnant actually and so missed being eligible for maternity pay. Therefore, I am currently on benefits. My full rent and a percentage of my council tax is paid for me. I then have approximately £1300 per month left over to cover bills and anything else. It isn't that hard a life. Contrasted to when I was single and working my 30 hours per week, which is all my trust was handing out to newly qualified nurses at that time, I'm definitely better off now, financially at least.

I do want to go back to work though, and will once my baby is 9 months/a year, I couldn't sit down on my backside all day every day, it would be soul destroying.

@CbaThinkingOfAUsername

I've seen your magic numbers on other benefits threads... Unless they're related to maternity leave (or some other special circumstances that I'm unaware of) your magic numbers are total bull*!

As a single mother I was on £1300 (plus child benefit) in total.
My rent for the most basic-box 80s flat was £750 until the landlord asked for £895 and I moved out straight after.
I was paying full council tax (because you do as soon as you earn the most basic minimum ).
My son was eating his free school meals.
I wasn't paying prescription charges.
We were getting holiday food vouchers.
And I'm grateful for the above!!

I didn't have a car, didn't drink/smoke, no subscriptions (no TV in fact! ), phone bill paid by a relative on a family contract, no broadband, no debts, never ever ordered a takeaway, never went on a holiday whilst on UC.
To my eternal shame, partial to avocados.

We were OK only because of my frugal ways. Something like a car would have financially tipped us over.

£1300 after rent?! Pull the other one!

Lightning020 · 26/07/2022 04:08

So you think most single parents are enjoying a good life raising children alone with a low income and child tax credit? Children are a job even if you are married. A huge commitment plus not c heap. You know nothing op.

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 03:43

bluegardenflowers · 25/07/2022 20:19

Working part time, husband full time, mortgage, children, only child benefit and never claimed other benefits. Just about treading water, and if anyone says some people don't take the piss on benefits they are deluded. A lot of people do and milk the system for all its worth. More genuine people of course, but it doesn't make the milkers not exist.

Such lack of self-awareness... Mortgage? Well, nice for you!! Sell up, ensure no money is left in the pot, get your sweet family on Universal Credit and see what housing/money security you ever get.

Fancy paying your landlord's mortgage for the rest of your lives??

Badgirlriri · 26/07/2022 03:34

everyone is focusing on the benefits issue but the OP is correct in her comments about single working low wage people struggling with no help/top ups and having to afford rent, bills, food etc themselves. It’s impossible.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 26/07/2022 01:45

I've never had to claim benefits thank god.
I have benefited from the NHS. Ground breaking heart surgery as a child, 3 births, a hysterectomy. 3 kids educated for free. Having just sat and watched my db die in USA free healthcare at the point of need is huge.
I understand how you feel but honestly do not underate what help you might need.

jaundicedoutlook · 26/07/2022 01:45

The whole point of having a welfare state (of sorts) isn’t that you should try to take out more than you put in and feel aggrieved if you are putting in more than you take out.

Think of it as (1) like an insurance policy - better to pay the premium and not need it, but be happy it is there is if you are in need; and (2) the country is generally a better place with a certain degree of wealth redistribution - not having a large starving underclass of people living in misery is generally a good thing for everyone.

Crunchygrass · 26/07/2022 01:38

Social welfare payments are very low in the UK. This contributes to the low wage economy. Salaries are far higher in many European countries including next door in the rep. of Ireland, benefits are also much higher in rep. of Ireland, and productivity overall is much higher. If generous benefits were the problem- surely rep. of Ireland would be much worse off?

The way it works is, benefits are low and unreliable here so companies can pay a pittance and still be more than benefits. In fact you can get paid benefits while working so the government essentially subsidises the profits of big companies who pay wages to low to live on. So Tesco can have people working full time or almost full time, and this still won’t be enough to cover the basics in life often (rent, food, clothing, entertainment, adequate time with family and friends). If the government tripled benefits tomorrow, then Tesco would have to pay more to attract workers, and your pay would go up too as a knock on effect.

Add to the poor working conditions and low minimum wage the fact the the state offers little in the way of state childcare, elder care, and often inadequate healthcare and then you have people who might otherwise be working full time taking care of relatives, or dealing with their own poorly managed chronic illnesses instead. This limits earning power and productivity.

My point is, there is no reason for it to be this way. Plenty of countries do it differently and people are far better off. The problem is not lazy scroungers taking advantage of the system, while virtuous people like you keep it all afloat, the problem is the government is facilitating the extraction of wealth from all of us to big corporations like amazon, Tesco, Google, BP, all the public transport companies etc. Think about the fact that energy crisis is happening across Europe l yet the prices aren’t going up everywhere equally. The UK solution is to transfer money to us so we can all pay the insane bills from the energy companies who are making record profits due to the fact the government won’t tax them enough or regulate them enough to make sure we get reasonable energy prices even in times of uncertainty. Furlough scheme was similar, it was the companies who were the ultimate winners, sure people got to keep their jobs which was good but it would have been more efficient to pay people directly probably, and it would have covered the self employed far better.

You are right to be angry, but I think you have the wrong target.

mathanxiety · 26/07/2022 01:11

Do you want to come and live in the US where there is little or no safety net?

The British safety net - such as it is - is there for you should you ever need it. In the meantime, you've made a lifestyle choice that means you haven't yet drawn benefits that are available to others - you have no children.

You don't know whether the day will come when you have a stroke or your luck in employment runs out. Entire industries have disappeared in the space of a few years. Similarly, many a single mother has found herself living a life that is very different from the one she thought she was going to.

Hopeforall · 26/07/2022 01:11

Interesting geographical comparison- Africa is lumped together when the other countries are all separated

The Caribbean is also made up of several different countries.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 26/07/2022 01:10

I was you once op. I worked for 30 years with only 6 months off maternity leave in all that time.
Then my life changed overnight. I'm now disabled and have been awarded pip ongoing with no end date. It wasnt nice reading the summary saying that in their opinion I will never recover so there is no point doing further assessments.
I would much rather be back at work and not claiming benefits. After all those years working, all I'm entitled to is pip because I managed to save too much for my old age to be entitled to means tested benefits. That's fine by me though. My savings will last me 3 years if I'm careful then ill have no choice other than to claim uc

BeatieBourke · 26/07/2022 00:56

We've been flat out unemployed and on benefits, worked and claimed UC, and currently earn just enough not to qualify for any help.

I know what I'd prefer.

The crippling anxiety, poverty and stigma of not being able to work and relying on a punitive benefits system was the hardest time of my life and truly awful. Those benefits are there for when people are at their lowest but the system only serves to make you lower. Given enough to only be hungry not actually starve, but be degraded, talked down to, derided and made to jump through pointless hoops when you're already at your wits end. Being that poor is time consuming and exhausting. It's enough to make anyone turn to drink or drugs frankly.

Doing part time / low wage work is a bit better. You have a bit more control, a few more choices. You're out of the house more which lowers bills. Sometimes you're left with no choice but to play the system because the margins are so tiny (eg local housing allowance being so much lower than the cheapest market rent). Sometimes, between paying for childcare, the threshold for council tax reductions and the minimum income floor, you can't afford to work those extra two days for a few quid that month because it could make you £100s of pounds worse of next month. That flaw is in the system not in people who are trying to survive as best they can. It's a flaw caused by a system that is designed to punish people.

We are now both working full time. Joint income (2 adults with one child to support) about 50k. We get no help. We just about meet our (very prudent, minimal) outgoings with few treats. It's hard work. But we have stability, we're in control of our finances and don't live under the threat of a random decision by the DWP risking us being suddenly plunged into debt, turfed out of our house, colder, hungry, relying on family and holding our head in our hands wondering how the hell we can escape the trap.

We have a child - only one because we can't afford more. Your kindly donation, through the tax system, has meant they haven't starved or been ill because of damp, unsafe housing, family breakdown and crisis. It's given DC a roof over their head and an education. All of which is cheaper for the tax payer than a homeless, starving, ill person with no education. And their future wages will pay your pension.

So YABVU. You have no experience of what it's like to walk in other people's shoes. Your judgement is crass, and lacks any awareness of very well researched and evidenced issues. Do some bloody reading OP.

crazyplanet · 26/07/2022 00:55

Berksandbeyond i don't think anyone living on benefits is living a lavish lifestyle. Some won't be able to afford a holiday and some will manage to save over time for a holiday.

ugifletzet · 26/07/2022 00:53

wellhelloitsme · 25/07/2022 23:03

Let's hope you never find yourself becoming disabled then OP. Or pregnant unexpectedly. Or lose your job due the industry changing. Or any other of the many reasons people claim benefits.

If there's little incentive to work full time, try going part time and living off that wage and the benefits you get. You'd be wanting to work full time again pretty soon I imagine.

If OP did find herself in that position, her attitude probably wouldn't change. She'd just see herself as one of the Good Genuine Deserving Poor, and she would blame the Lazy Feckless Fake Conniving Poor if she got sanctioned for missing an appointment or told she was fit to work while in a hospital bed on oxygen. "They have to be tough because of all the scroungers, and then honest hardworking people like me get punished by mistake!" I've heard it depressingly often.

Alexaplaykatebush · 26/07/2022 00:52

I work full time 37 hours a week, for the local government, I'm entitled to universal credit because they don't pay enough to keep a single parent with one child out of poverty on the crappy wages.
I love my job and I'm not uncomfortable yet, but would it not make more sense for the government to pay me a living wage than for the government to pay me a shit wage and then the government top it up via universal credit???