Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SpartacusNotEsther · 26/07/2022 09:04

As someone who works hard for their money, currently earns approximately £350 to £400 more than my rent every month (which has to pay council tax, electricity, food etc. Damn you COVID!) and isn't entitled to any benefits - I think yabu. For all the reasons that have already been said.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 09:03

@Florenz

Anyone convicted of a crime should be disqualified from claiming benefits for a period of time, and those convicted of serious crimes should be disqualified from claiming benefits forever! And yes they should still pay tax.

Oh ffs. This is just stupid nonsense. How can they pay tax from no money? How do you live (apart from by crime) if no-one will give you a job because you're an ex-con and you have no benefits? From a purely pragmatic point of view can't you see how this is just fucking daft?

Jesus. This is why people still think Boris is a good bloke and that the Tories are 'fiscally responsible'. The lack of critical thinking ability in this country is just appalling.

AndreaC74 · 26/07/2022 09:03

Florenz · 26/07/2022 08:56

Anyone convicted of a crime should be disqualified from claiming benefits for a period of time, and those convicted of serious crimes should be disqualified from claiming benefits forever! And yes they should still pay tax.

So where do you think they would then get money etc from? get a job and work 40hrs per week or rob it?

I'd go for amputations if i were you, that'll learn ee.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 09:02

wellhelloitsme · 26/07/2022 08:54

@FreyaStorm

Why are you 'friends' with people whose lifestyle you disapprove of so much?

Because we grew up together, one from the age of 2, one from 5 and one from 7. So they’re almost like family. I’m not saying I don’t approve of the route they chose - they all had children early so has to make the best choices for them, I get it.
I just think the average person would be surprised at their lifestyles.

DogsAndGin · 26/07/2022 09:01

But if you put the work in you’ll do a hell of a lot better than someone on benefits. There are high wages out there, for people of all different personalities and skill sets.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 09:00

Also is @BerryBerryBerryBerry and @Pooet the same person as they both reference the same angry dope-smoking friend? Name changing within a thread looks like sock-puppetry to me, and who knows how many others of those reporting decadent benefits claimants are actually the same anti-poor-people poster (maybe even the OP)?

And this is the trouble of course - people can say what they like about 'people they know', but the only reliable report of what someone can claim on benefits is the benefit calculator and I don't think anyone can show from that that it results in a luxurious lifestyle.

Kamia · 26/07/2022 08:59

HelloAllll · 25/07/2022 20:31

Yanbu op. The benefits system needs a big overhaul so that there is always an incentive to work/work hard. I agree that those that are really disabled and cannot undertake any job should have a decent level of comfort but for everyone else it really should be the minimum. Those on benefits seem to be getting more and more lately yet those who work and don't take from the system get less and less (inflation higher than wages)

It's really the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer not the other way round.

Loopyloopy · 26/07/2022 08:59

ComtesseDeSpair · 25/07/2022 20:18

The NHS is utter shit, has been since long before the Tories got into power, and I begrudge paying the amount of tax I do when my in-laws in the US get excellent healthcare for about half the cost in their insurance premiums and co-pays as the amount of my taxation which goes to the NHS.

But otherwise, I’d far rather be in the position I am than have to live like people on benefits do. I have a fantastic life. People on benefits only really get the large payments if they have children, once the children are older or grown they’ll be stuck - poor employment prospects and facing trying to live on JSA or NMW in a crappy job. Not a life I’d want.

The US health system has the worst health outcomes of any wealthy country, with the highest costs.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:58

@foxandbee
The interviews existed, they just had no intention of actually taking a job.
Scheme was in Kensington & Chelsea Borough. Check it out for yourself.

SaySomethingMan · 26/07/2022 08:58

Hopeforall · 26/07/2022 01:11

Interesting geographical comparison- Africa is lumped together when the other countries are all separated

The Caribbean is also made up of several different countries.

I guess that’s the point? Those areas usually get lumped together but it’s very diverse.

Florenz · 26/07/2022 08:56

Anyone convicted of a crime should be disqualified from claiming benefits for a period of time, and those convicted of serious crimes should be disqualified from claiming benefits forever! And yes they should still pay tax.

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:56

@FilePhoto I really do wish it was “bullshit”

I will caveat this though by saying the system is set to to force fathers out of the home. If you stay with your DC’s father, or have any (working) man move in with you, the funding dries up.
For this reason, 2 of my 3 friends keep their partners on the DL or it would affect their benefits.
Oh and these aren’t just acquaintances, one is my best friend of 30 years, so I know her financial ins and outs very well, she’s very open.
Many of you who perhaps haven’t grown up in the system and don’t know anyone in it, find it hard to stomach what I’ve said. I wish it wasn’t true and that my friends (and myself) who work full time could achieve similar lifestyles.

Mulhollandmagoo · 26/07/2022 08:55

Yabu because it’s small fry to the amount of tax dodging going on.

People often forget about this side of the coin to he honest, I agree with you to an extent OP, but if everyone paid the correct amount of tax instead of seeking out loopholes to cheat the system, the country would be far far better off.

I can see with the examples you've given why you feel fatigued, but wealth hoarding and tax dodging costs us far more than the benefit system.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 08:55

@FreyaStorm

I am actually thinking of selling my flat to liquidate my assets, rent a lovely place and live well for a few years until the cash runs out and then do as my aforementioned friends have done. It would be one way of getting back into a part of London with very good state schools and I need to think of my DC now.

I would actually be very interested to hear how this works out for you. Do let us know!

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 26/07/2022 08:55

QueenCamilla · 26/07/2022 04:34

@CbaThinkingOfAUsername

I've seen your magic numbers on other benefits threads... Unless they're related to maternity leave (or some other special circumstances that I'm unaware of) your magic numbers are total bull*!

As a single mother I was on £1300 (plus child benefit) in total.
My rent for the most basic-box 80s flat was £750 until the landlord asked for £895 and I moved out straight after.
I was paying full council tax (because you do as soon as you earn the most basic minimum ).
My son was eating his free school meals.
I wasn't paying prescription charges.
We were getting holiday food vouchers.
And I'm grateful for the above!!

I didn't have a car, didn't drink/smoke, no subscriptions (no TV in fact! ), phone bill paid by a relative on a family contract, no broadband, no debts, never ever ordered a takeaway, never went on a holiday whilst on UC.
To my eternal shame, partial to avocados.

We were OK only because of my frugal ways. Something like a car would have financially tipped us over.

£1300 after rent?! Pull the other one!

Perhaps get a clue of what you're talking about before calling other people's situations bs, @QueenCamilla My rent of £330 is paid in full by the housing element of universal credit. 25% discount off my council tax for being a single adult in the home. Universal credit = Personal allowance + child element + child benefit + scottish child payment = over £1300. So perhaps away and get your facts corrent dear. Now do toddle along.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 08:54

@BerryBerryBerryBerry

I don't think my friend is having a fun life but I do think he's being facilitated to be a smelly, anti social angry, lazy and ignorant man because he doesn't do anything except smoke dope

You definitely sound like he's your friend. For sure.

wellhelloitsme · 26/07/2022 08:54

@FreyaStorm

Why are you 'friends' with people whose lifestyle you disapprove of so much?

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 08:53

@Andante57

Is that just in UK or in other countries too? I ask because I agree Amazon should pay more tax here and I wondered if it paid more in other countries?

Many other countries are MUCH better at extracting tax from corporations.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 26/07/2022 08:51

@BlaseBalletDancer

I agree with you OP. All I really want as an employee is for the State to provide me with the basics in return for my taxes - decent roads, good affordable public transport and things like footpaths and road crossings to get to my work. It does none of these, or very little well. Where I live, the grass verges only get cut once per year so the few footpaths there were have become overgrown and can't be used. There is no bridge over or underpass under the bypass to the city centre so its impossible to walk safely to the railway station. The bus to work takes an hour to travel 7 miles. There is no motorway between my city and the two neighbouring cities, only a dual carriageway "in places".
I've lived abroad and all of those things were provided everywhere. I think those "count how lucky you are" posts must be comparing the UK with the third world and not with a modern European country. The infrastructure is awful.
Then theres the wages. They are so low. Due to austerity, employers in the UK haven't given decent pay rises in line with inflation for years yet tax has gone up. Unlike in many European countries, employees cannot deduct their travelling to work expenses from their income tax bills - such a measure would instantly improve the lot of working people.
There is no incentive to work hard here. Instead there are disincentives. Earn enough and you lose nearly 50% of any pay rise.
Its damn hard getting up early in the morning to navigate the awful commute to work. Of course its easier to be lazy and not work full time. Of course people can be lazy - its human nature. The notion that Britain is full of saintly angels who are never lazy because they are entitled to benefits is just one of the problems with the UK. Someone mentioned Polish people working hard here because they can buy a really good house back home. Yes, they have an incentive. Here, your reward for working hard is to pay more tax, get nothing for it that improves your life and to be seemingly reviled by a large sector of the population.
And every few years the goalposts are changed by the government in pursuit of yet another vote winner for those marginal votes who might just be won over by a gimmick or a soundbite on tax.
There just aren't enough people who work full time in the UK any more, and there are too many reasons and or excuses for them not to.
One big point - if you compare the UK to France, France has much higher inheritance tax and that also helps keep down house prices. You still get an inheritance but only 40% of it - 60% of all of it goes to the State. And I think thats a great idea - why should income from working hard be taxed heavily but chance of birth not?

Even though you say you agree with the OP and I don't, I do agree with you. Of course a lot of people will choose benefits if the wages and working conditions mean its no better than paid employment. That doesn't mean it's lovely on benefits! It just means it's shit on paid employment if you are low skilled and in a low-wage environment. And sorry but not everyone can 'retrain' to be a high earner. There isn't the availability of either training or jobs, some people don't have the time or capacity, and a LOT of people don't have the ability. Which is fine. In a decent world there should be secure work for all kinds of people that pays enough to live decently. The reason there isn't is not because poor people are lazy and immoral, it's because our economy is being milked by those in power.

A fine example of this is as follows in your post:

One big point - if you compare the UK to France, France has much higher inheritance tax and that also helps keep down house prices. You still get an inheritance but only 40% of it - 60% of all of it goes to the State. And I think thats a great idea - why should income from working hard be taxed heavily but chance of birth not?

Well look at the people who are making the laws and the people who are funding them. They are not the 'hardworking', they are the ones with enormous amounts of inherited assets. Of course they don't want meritocracy, of course they don't want hard work to pay, of course they don't want a level playing field. Look up, not down to see the problem.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 26/07/2022 08:50

I don't think my friend is having a fun life but I do think he's being facilitated to be a smelly, anti social angry, lazy and ignorant man because he doesn't do anything except smoke dope. Anything. If he wasn't given a fancy flat and money to buy the dope with, he could work. He is being let down

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:49

Kamia · 26/07/2022 08:46

I think people who have a "great life" on benefits must be cheating the system somehow. It's impossible to afford designer clothes, holidays and getting nails done at the salon on £500 a month.

Not if you actually get given the designer clothes for free from “dem programs”.

FilePhoto · 26/07/2022 08:48

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:31

YANBU.
I worked my ass off for 20 years to but a 1 bed flat in a shitty part of London. Now have a baby and stuck here as I can’t afford a larger place.

Friends who have, shall we say, a “patchy” work history all had a baby to get themselves a nice 2 bed+ flat in Notting Hill. Yes, they might have had to live in a bed sit in east London for a year first, but they have all ended up getting to live where they want and right next to family.

They get full housing benefit (no rent or mortgage to pay), no council tax to pay, child benefit, income support and who knows what else. One of them also just got £3k of designer clothes for “job interviews” from some scheme when she has no intention of actually getting a job. We’re talking about Stella McCartney, etc. type of brands.

1 doesn’t work at all but the other 2 work the “allowed” 16 hrs per week to be able to claim full benefits, plus do many more hours of “cash in hand” work. The last time I spoke to the non working one, she said she was getting £3,600 per month (she has 1 child she has 50:50 custody of). She has to pay her rent on a 2 bed flat in west London from this (£1700 pm) but it’s still a lot to play with, tax free.

I know 3 individual women doing this.
All 3 can afford to run cars, I can’t.

Regularly off to Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Disneyland Paris, etc. I haven’t been abroad for 6 years.

All 3 have basically done exactly as their mums did, but I was determined to break out of what I thought was the “poverty trap”. I guess the joke is on me.

They have better lifestyles than many of my friends who’ve worked all their lives. The only ones who are doing better in terms of lifestyle are those on 6 figures. Make it make sense.

If I had my time again, I would have lived the life of Riley through my 20s and early 30s and not bothered to save. Then got myself knocked up and gone “on the social”. I can’t see that I would be any worse off than I am already. In fact, I’d probably be better off.

Bullshit.

foxandbee · 26/07/2022 08:47

FreyaStorm · 26/07/2022 08:31

YANBU.
I worked my ass off for 20 years to but a 1 bed flat in a shitty part of London. Now have a baby and stuck here as I can’t afford a larger place.

Friends who have, shall we say, a “patchy” work history all had a baby to get themselves a nice 2 bed+ flat in Notting Hill. Yes, they might have had to live in a bed sit in east London for a year first, but they have all ended up getting to live where they want and right next to family.

They get full housing benefit (no rent or mortgage to pay), no council tax to pay, child benefit, income support and who knows what else. One of them also just got £3k of designer clothes for “job interviews” from some scheme when she has no intention of actually getting a job. We’re talking about Stella McCartney, etc. type of brands.

1 doesn’t work at all but the other 2 work the “allowed” 16 hrs per week to be able to claim full benefits, plus do many more hours of “cash in hand” work. The last time I spoke to the non working one, she said she was getting £3,600 per month (she has 1 child she has 50:50 custody of). She has to pay her rent on a 2 bed flat in west London from this (£1700 pm) but it’s still a lot to play with, tax free.

I know 3 individual women doing this.
All 3 can afford to run cars, I can’t.

Regularly off to Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Disneyland Paris, etc. I haven’t been abroad for 6 years.

All 3 have basically done exactly as their mums did, but I was determined to break out of what I thought was the “poverty trap”. I guess the joke is on me.

They have better lifestyles than many of my friends who’ve worked all their lives. The only ones who are doing better in terms of lifestyle are those on 6 figures. Make it make sense.

If I had my time again, I would have lived the life of Riley through my 20s and early 30s and not bothered to save. Then got myself knocked up and gone “on the social”. I can’t see that I would be any worse off than I am already. In fact, I’d probably be better off.

You have over egged and thus ruined this benefits bashing post. Free Stella McCartney clothes for non-existent interviews? 🤣🤣🤣

Andante57 · 26/07/2022 08:46

the problem is the government is facilitating the extraction of wealth from all of us to big corporations like amazon, Tesco, Google, BP, all the public transport companies etc

Is that just in UK or in other countries too? I ask because I agree Amazon should pay more tax here and I wondered if it paid more in other countries?

Kamia · 26/07/2022 08:46

I think people who have a "great life" on benefits must be cheating the system somehow. It's impossible to afford designer clothes, holidays and getting nails done at the salon on £500 a month.

Swipe left for the next trending thread