Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is little incentive to work hard in the UK

487 replies

BeachTree · 25/07/2022 20:08

Context. 30's, no kids, single, work full time.

Just a bit disheartened. I have never claimed benefits, or any type of support, I work hard to make sure I can support myself (Not disputing those who genuinely require benefits/support) I have always paid all my taxes, and national insurance. I expect by the time I reach retirement age, the 'state pension' may look very different to what it does now and may not be available despite having paid in my whole life.

I feel sometimes that I pay so much into the 'system' and get very little return and don't 'take' from it, whereas there are many people claiming every benefit possible, and constantly 'taking' from the system they don't pay into. There are so many ways to extract money from the system but only for those who don't work full time. I know someone who worked for about 1 or 2 year in late teens in the UK, then worked abroad for a number of years, during this time did not keep up with national insurance payments and obviously not paying UK tax as no in the country, also didn't pay tax in the country they resided in. Returned to England to have a baby on the NHS, now residing back in England, claiming benefits as a single parent for 2+ years, gets assistance with rent council tax etc despite having paid next to nothing in to the system. I cannot compute how this is fair.

For example the cost of living payment, people who claim benefits will get £650, where as those who work and do not claim benefits will get £400. The cost of living crisis affects all of us - perhaps more so the people who work their socks off and aren't 'entitled' to 'support' The system is backwards and not in favour of people who work full time to support our ridiculous benefit system. So many examples - ie. people get help with rent, council tax, working tax credits etc etc etc - however those who work get zero, zilch.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Walkaround · 09/01/2023 18:48

MilkyYay · 09/01/2023 07:13

The problems with the uk economy atm:

  • life on benefits is shite, but life on a median income is barely any better in terms of the lifestyle it affords.
  • quite stressful jobs with more responsibilities provide almost no better standard of living than entry level work (especially with benefit top ups) in many fields - see nursery manager pay, teaching, nursing
  • working costs a lot so comparisons of income on benefits vs from work are skewed due to costs eg commute, childcare, having to be smartly dressed
  • lack of time when working can push people to need to spend some income on things which cost more but are convenient/save time (public transport/driving over walking or cycling, convenience or prepared foods due to lack of time for cooking)
  • there's huge wealth disparity. The vast majority of wealth creation in our economy is flowing to a small number of high earners
  • there's poor social mobility. The tax system and prioritisation of return to capital owners is heavily weighted to keeping the wealthy rich regardless of their skills, abilities or other contributions beyond ownership of wealth.
  • too much wealth is tied up in property values propped up by undersupply, low interest rates and government schemes to drive demand (help to buy etc).

I agree.

MilkyYay · 09/01/2023 07:13

The problems with the uk economy atm:

  • life on benefits is shite, but life on a median income is barely any better in terms of the lifestyle it affords.
  • quite stressful jobs with more responsibilities provide almost no better standard of living than entry level work (especially with benefit top ups) in many fields - see nursery manager pay, teaching, nursing
  • working costs a lot so comparisons of income on benefits vs from work are skewed due to costs eg commute, childcare, having to be smartly dressed
  • lack of time when working can push people to need to spend some income on things which cost more but are convenient/save time (public transport/driving over walking or cycling, convenience or prepared foods due to lack of time for cooking)
  • there's huge wealth disparity. The vast majority of wealth creation in our economy is flowing to a small number of high earners
  • there's poor social mobility. The tax system and prioritisation of return to capital owners is heavily weighted to keeping the wealthy rich regardless of their skills, abilities or other contributions beyond ownership of wealth.
  • too much wealth is tied up in property values propped up by undersupply, low interest rates and government schemes to drive demand (help to buy etc).
malificent7 · 09/01/2023 06:27

I expect you are saying this as you don't have kids. Many benefit claimants are single mums...i was one and no, it wasn't a tax dodge.
It's a bit unfair for you to come onto a parenting forum to criticise benefit claimants if you don't have kids, especially as you know that many claimants have them.

Oh but wait...i bet you are childless as you can't afford kids and people who can't afford them shouldn't have them etc.

Hesma · 09/01/2023 06:06

YABVU, I work full time but still get benefits since my ex-H left me and our kids. I had a senior management role but stepped back so I have time to look after my girls. You never know when you might need help if circumstances change.

Thistlelass · 09/01/2023 01:15

No you are not being unreasonable. A lot of people feel like you and should be able to openly express. I am now on benefits (PIP and ESA) and have a son who is unlikely ever to do paid work. I have no problem drawing on the system though as my family and self have paid into it massively. Daughter and hubby, Son and his wife, Son and his partner x 2! Plus ex husband and his wife.
It is difficult but what an achievement when you have a sustained period of making a worthwhile contribution to society. I managed to raise a family of 5 and did 23 years in my second career.

Walkaround · 28/07/2022 17:14

Itisasecret · 28/07/2022 11:37

This and without people investing and completing these jobs, there would be no work for others.

Often higher paid staff are higher paid because of the responsibility. For example. They are in prosecutable positions. Think data, health and safety, etc.

Except the increased responsibility and stress only seems to work up to a point - at the highest levels, it frankly looks more like a merry go round, where the same faces appear again and again in different guises, never accepting the risks and responsibilities that were supposed to have justified the obscene rewards. At worst, it seems these people have such astronomically high pay offs to get rid of them that they never need to work again, anyway, but can live off their thoroughly undeserved profits. There was no real accountability at the highest levels for those who effectively encouraged and oversaw the behaviours that led to the global recession. It took a phenomenal amount of lying and buck passing before Boris Johnson was forced to stand down - and in no way is he ruined by this. He will no doubt profit from the fact he was prime minister for years to come. It is therefore eminently possible to feather your own nest and ensure the middle ranks are the ones who bear the true weight of responsibility and carry the real risk of career ruination, while those at the top consider themselves to big and too important to fail.

ZaraElizabethIsMyNewSpyName · 28/07/2022 15:56

vivainsomnia someone managing a team of carers will only be on about 25-28k max. More than the carers but not a high salary.

Spikeyball · 28/07/2022 15:11

Low paid doesn't mean unskilled or not stressful.

Itisasecret · 28/07/2022 14:39

AchatAVendre · 28/07/2022 11:52

Thats not how those jobs work. Nor how life works - I have to pay the mortgage, no-one else is going to come along and give me a house to live in for free.

Only now that I have reached some level of seniority after 20 years hard graft, do I have some flexibility. But I had to show that I could be trusted.

I have of course done plenty of low paid jobs while a student. I used to work on farms (because I'm from a farming background and have certain skills) during the university holidays, and no matter how much heavy manual labour and dealing with potentially dangerous animals I did, it was never approaching as hard as working in a professional job. Mainly because someone else was always there to tell you what to do. You didn't have to make important decisions for yourself. If you got something wrong, there was always someone whose job it was to explain to you or show you how to do it. If you made a mistake, someone else would cover for you or sort it out. You turned up on time, worked hard, went home and didn't think about the job until work again the next day. If you weren't one of the best workers, you weren't labelled as being not ambitious enough or not enough of a highflyer, you just stayed at the level you were competent at as long as you did the job reasonably well and turned up on time. It was so unstressful by comparison. I also worked in a factory and in a dog kennels and as a supermarket cashier (albeit while still at school) and every single one of those jobs was a complete doss compared to a professional job.

This idea that no-one in a professional job has ever done any hard physical work is one of those myths that some people who have no idea of the real world or how many struggle for years to make life work for them actually live. They think everyone in a professional job bounces out of Eton, gets a job with a friend and immediately commands a 5 figure salary. Or they think you can just hop from 1 well paid job to another in a completely unrelated field. So unrealistic.

This drives me bonkers. I earn less than my husband but I’m a professional with masters level quals. I have done it all. Shop work, care work bar work.

My husband (I did stay at home and was lucky to do so) is a very high earner but he never used to be. He was in the military. Honestly, no one needs to tell me about family sacrifice for crap pay.

These misconceptions are harmful and just keep people stuck where they are.

AchatAVendre · 28/07/2022 11:52

Ilikepinacoladass · 28/07/2022 07:37

@AchatAVendre
Quite a few people also earn 75k and don't particularly hard at all - maybe find one of those jobs if you're finding yours too stressful.. no one is forcing you to stay in the job. Or find one with a better work life balance (but potentially less pay)

Thats not how those jobs work. Nor how life works - I have to pay the mortgage, no-one else is going to come along and give me a house to live in for free.

Only now that I have reached some level of seniority after 20 years hard graft, do I have some flexibility. But I had to show that I could be trusted.

I have of course done plenty of low paid jobs while a student. I used to work on farms (because I'm from a farming background and have certain skills) during the university holidays, and no matter how much heavy manual labour and dealing with potentially dangerous animals I did, it was never approaching as hard as working in a professional job. Mainly because someone else was always there to tell you what to do. You didn't have to make important decisions for yourself. If you got something wrong, there was always someone whose job it was to explain to you or show you how to do it. If you made a mistake, someone else would cover for you or sort it out. You turned up on time, worked hard, went home and didn't think about the job until work again the next day. If you weren't one of the best workers, you weren't labelled as being not ambitious enough or not enough of a highflyer, you just stayed at the level you were competent at as long as you did the job reasonably well and turned up on time. It was so unstressful by comparison. I also worked in a factory and in a dog kennels and as a supermarket cashier (albeit while still at school) and every single one of those jobs was a complete doss compared to a professional job.

This idea that no-one in a professional job has ever done any hard physical work is one of those myths that some people who have no idea of the real world or how many struggle for years to make life work for them actually live. They think everyone in a professional job bounces out of Eton, gets a job with a friend and immediately commands a 5 figure salary. Or they think you can just hop from 1 well paid job to another in a completely unrelated field. So unrealistic.

Itisasecret · 28/07/2022 11:37

vivainsomnia · 28/07/2022 11:10

It's not so much about 'working hard', it's more commonly about risks and stress. Risks to others, risks for the company and other employees. It's about making decisions that have significant impact on others.

It's about the stress that results from the above. Stress that comes with responsibilities. Managing staff is stressful. It involves a level of mental demands that you don't have when you have no direct management duties. It takes a small mistake to have sure consequences.

Yes, a carer who makes a mistake might get sack, but so does their manager who has responsibility for that staff, so if they manage 20 staff, that's 20 chances of potentially losing their job.

I used to operate at two level higher. The level of responsibility was too much for me. I downgraded. The job and tasks are not that different, but I don't deal with corporate politics any longer, only manage 3 staff, and if something goes wrong, I can just escalate. My job is much easier. It is rightly reflected in the pay.

This and without people investing and completing these jobs, there would be no work for others.

Often higher paid staff are higher paid because of the responsibility. For example. They are in prosecutable positions. Think data, health and safety, etc.

BSQ44 · 28/07/2022 11:20

I am a higher rate tax payer and I don’t think I will ever pay enough tax for what my family have had from the NHS, let alone everything else. DS1 has had several months of hospital admissions, several surgeries and is on a medication that costs probably £100000/year at least (they haven’t disclosed the deal they have struck with the drug company). We’ve also had IVF with genetic testing. Plus more usual run of the mill
stuff.

Namechangerr1 · 28/07/2022 11:13

Exactly what @Supersimkin2 said.

vivainsomnia · 28/07/2022 11:10

It's not so much about 'working hard', it's more commonly about risks and stress. Risks to others, risks for the company and other employees. It's about making decisions that have significant impact on others.

It's about the stress that results from the above. Stress that comes with responsibilities. Managing staff is stressful. It involves a level of mental demands that you don't have when you have no direct management duties. It takes a small mistake to have sure consequences.

Yes, a carer who makes a mistake might get sack, but so does their manager who has responsibility for that staff, so if they manage 20 staff, that's 20 chances of potentially losing their job.

I used to operate at two level higher. The level of responsibility was too much for me. I downgraded. The job and tasks are not that different, but I don't deal with corporate politics any longer, only manage 3 staff, and if something goes wrong, I can just escalate. My job is much easier. It is rightly reflected in the pay.

BloomingGreatTiming · 28/07/2022 10:34

Alconleigh · 27/07/2022 08:45

Of course there's an incentive to work. Its genuinely never occurred to me to think "oh I'll just jack it in and claim benefits". Or anyone I know (as far as I can tell from their actions anyway). I understand the feeling that as a single person with no kids that you're using less of the system than others, and cost of living can be horrendous, but as PP said you are presumably still using roads / doctors etc, and also none of us know what is round the corner. Any one of us is only an accident or illness away from needing a lot of support.

Also, and not meaning to sound like a dick, but I have a well paid, interesting job and am shortly off on my third holiday this year. How is that not better than not working?

See I have thought about jacking it all in and living on benefits. At the moment, I'm a single parent working 40 hours a week. I get paid a pretty good salary. I get a decent amount of maintenance from the Ex-husband. But despite that, I get no help with anything else. I'm stressed all the time, juggling full time work with household tasks, kids activities, etc. I'm knackered, my lifestyle is unhealthy because of it, I can't afford to cut my hours (even if there were any part time roles in my industry).
Yet I have to have a very basic holiday (camping usually) and I strongly suspect I'll be working until I drop dead.
Really the only reason I'm still working is because I've no idea what sort of housing I'd end up with on benefits.

Nothappyatwork · 28/07/2022 10:26

apairofblueeyes100 · 28/07/2022 10:12

I personally believe the benefits system is here to help people in genuine time of hardship - for some this may be long term, others shorter. I don't think anyone has any issues with this.

What I do have a problem with is people using the benefits system as a career and a way out of working to support themselves ever. My 21 year old DD went to school with a girl who was one of 7 children by parents who never worked. Come secondary school stage, the children barely even went to school and left with no GCSES. A few of these children are now pregnant and/or have had children and the whole cycle begins again.

I blame the government for allowing this type of thing to happen - this is what needs to change.

The government has changed all this my cousin got pregnant at 17 with her daughter S. S is very pretty but hasn’t got two brain cells to run together. So naturally she had her first at 19.
but it’s all changed now hasn’t it there’s no decorating grants after you’ve been allocated council flat. There’s no £500 to buy you a new pram no healthy start vouchers to pay for the fruit and vegetables.
it’s all come as a bit of a shock

apairofblueeyes100 · 28/07/2022 10:12

I personally believe the benefits system is here to help people in genuine time of hardship - for some this may be long term, others shorter. I don't think anyone has any issues with this.

What I do have a problem with is people using the benefits system as a career and a way out of working to support themselves ever. My 21 year old DD went to school with a girl who was one of 7 children by parents who never worked. Come secondary school stage, the children barely even went to school and left with no GCSES. A few of these children are now pregnant and/or have had children and the whole cycle begins again.

I blame the government for allowing this type of thing to happen - this is what needs to change.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/07/2022 09:23

You do realise that the largest recipient of benefits are pensioners, followed by people in employment? This benefits bashing post reflects badly on you.

I think many on this thread include top up payments being an incentive to do less paid work too.

If it is available of course people will use the option of top-ups.

It encourages people who've never considered working to get a paying job which in turn improves the lifestyle and MH of the claimants and enables single parents to have a work life balance.
.
Without top-ups people would starve and crime would increase.

Walkaround · 28/07/2022 09:14

Maverickess · 27/07/2022 23:33

God, the hard work thing.

Why do people who work hard and are earning a lot seem to think that realising/understanding/admitting that some other people who also work hard but don't get paid a lot, somehow takes away from their hard work?

It doesn't, all it means is that society values some hard work more than other hard work, and in some cases that's completely and utterly fucked up.
People who care for our children, our elderly and vulnerable relatives are among some of the lowest paid in society, but arguably some of the most important jobs to be done well.
We don't require much in the way of checks around the type of person to do this, we don't require much in the way of education and training to ensure these jobs are done well.
As a society we expect these services, demand them, but devalue the people doing them, and woe betide that someone says they work hard in one of those jobs, because someone who also works hard but earns 4 times as much will be along to slap you down all offended at the notion.
Honestly, it's ridiculous.

Here, here!

I know working as a solicitor can be exactly as @AchatAVendre describes - I used to work as a solicitor in a City law firm, where starting salaries of newly qualified solicitors can now be as high as £125,000 with big pay hikes every year. It was highly stressful, many colleagues drank heavily and complained incessantly about the work which was not emotionally rewarding in any way, because it all revolved around money at the end of the day, not principles or people, or causes I might feel were important enough to justify the blood, sweat and tears. Of course, I could have earned a fraction of the amount doing legal aid work, or a different type of private practice work that held more meaning for me, but it did strike me that to do a good job as a solicitor always required a lot of work and stress regardless (although it would be possible to fine tune the amounts, depending on practice area), and not always work that made you feel good about yourself, and I could see no reason whatsoever to stay where I was in the City other than greed - certainly not job satisfaction or pleasure. So I left, as the only reason I had for staying where I was was the money, and what a shit thing to have to reflect on at the end of your life, if you have spent a whole career working with competitive, heavy drinking people you mostly don’t like much, just for the money.

I think the problem really is, pay does not reflect effort well at all; nor does it reflect value to society. Pay reflects proximity to money and the ability to generate more money, and this doesn’t have to be for good causes - it could be, and frequently is, pushing things colossally harmful to humanity. In fact, if your role is too vital, a cap has to be put on your ability to profit from it, or you may be denied the chance to profit at all, because society needs you too much. We wrap a lot of this up in the claim that some roles don’t require particularly valuable or unusual skills, but the truth is, that’s just so we can find enough people to do the work, lumping the atrocious in with the brilliant and paying them all the same crap for very different qualities of output. This is also why increasingly extreme disparities in wealth between the richest and almost everyone else are obscene, because they are not merited in any meaningful way, and indicate that money generation has ceased to benefit society, instead just benefiting a greedy few. Yet so many people react to this by kicking out at those closest to them and arguing for changes that effectively widen the gap between the elite and the rest still further, and thus in the long term, push the majority ever closer together, making it less and less financially worth making extra effort.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 28/07/2022 07:39

You do realise that the largest recipient of benefits are pensioners, followed by people in employment? This benefits bashing post reflects badly on you.

Ilikepinacoladass · 28/07/2022 07:37

@AchatAVendre
Quite a few people also earn 75k and don't particularly hard at all - maybe find one of those jobs if you're finding yours too stressful.. no one is forcing you to stay in the job. Or find one with a better work life balance (but potentially less pay)

Damnautocorrect · 28/07/2022 07:29

AchatAVendre · 27/07/2022 20:00

If you want to start work at 7.30 and finish around 7pm, but only be paid for 8 hours, come in at weekends or wfh all weekend, eat dinner at your desk, divide nearly every day of your life into 6 minute units which you have to meticulously log so that you are deemed to be profitable enough not to sack every following a review every 3 months, deal with high value, high risk deals where if you make even a slight mistake, the whole deal is lost and so is your career, compare difficult to understand legal principles, research obscure, often foreign case law, deal with colleagues who are competitive not supportive, difficult, shouty senior partners, do 7 years of university and training, then feel free to take over my 75k pa job.

DH does complicated algorithms from scratch. Fancy that, do you? Must be dead easy. A bit like being a hairdresser or a checkout assistant, what with the calculation of all those amounts.

I've done other jobs while supporting myself through university, none even approached being a lawyer for stress, difficulty and effort.

Alternatively, if you feel like paying me 75k to do something a bit nicer, maybe like a bit of gardening, or being a mystery buyer or diner, feel free to employ me. I'll be demanding that salary from you though, since according to you its no less hard work.

I'm sure some doctors, builders, engineers and dentists would feel the same as me.

Cheers!

You’ve described a lot of trades there.
life and death if they fuck up.
lots of training.
long hours, billing for hours worked.

be lucky if they get 75k.

it’s not a race to the bottom what’s valued, people have different skills.

carefullycourageous · 28/07/2022 01:13

AchatAVendre · 27/07/2022 20:00

If you want to start work at 7.30 and finish around 7pm, but only be paid for 8 hours, come in at weekends or wfh all weekend, eat dinner at your desk, divide nearly every day of your life into 6 minute units which you have to meticulously log so that you are deemed to be profitable enough not to sack every following a review every 3 months, deal with high value, high risk deals where if you make even a slight mistake, the whole deal is lost and so is your career, compare difficult to understand legal principles, research obscure, often foreign case law, deal with colleagues who are competitive not supportive, difficult, shouty senior partners, do 7 years of university and training, then feel free to take over my 75k pa job.

DH does complicated algorithms from scratch. Fancy that, do you? Must be dead easy. A bit like being a hairdresser or a checkout assistant, what with the calculation of all those amounts.

I've done other jobs while supporting myself through university, none even approached being a lawyer for stress, difficulty and effort.

Alternatively, if you feel like paying me 75k to do something a bit nicer, maybe like a bit of gardening, or being a mystery buyer or diner, feel free to employ me. I'll be demanding that salary from you though, since according to you its no less hard work.

I'm sure some doctors, builders, engineers and dentists would feel the same as me.

Cheers!

Oh get over yourself @AchatAVendre !

I am sure everyone thinks you're very clever and hardworking, but also everyone with half an ounce of understanding knows that plenty of people work very hard and receive a fraction of your pay.

Maverickess · 27/07/2022 23:33

God, the hard work thing.

Why do people who work hard and are earning a lot seem to think that realising/understanding/admitting that some other people who also work hard but don't get paid a lot, somehow takes away from their hard work?

It doesn't, all it means is that society values some hard work more than other hard work, and in some cases that's completely and utterly fucked up.
People who care for our children, our elderly and vulnerable relatives are among some of the lowest paid in society, but arguably some of the most important jobs to be done well.
We don't require much in the way of checks around the type of person to do this, we don't require much in the way of education and training to ensure these jobs are done well.
As a society we expect these services, demand them, but devalue the people doing them, and woe betide that someone says they work hard in one of those jobs, because someone who also works hard but earns 4 times as much will be along to slap you down all offended at the notion.
Honestly, it's ridiculous.

Alexaplaykatebush · 27/07/2022 21:01

Not everyone on benefits gets free prescriptions or free school meals.
I'm a single parent, went back to work as soon as my paid maternity leave ended and have always worked, currently work full time for the local council and get some universal credit.
I've never been entitled to either of those things and I can't afford to do a degree either as someone up thread was moaning about; it's all changed with universal credit, loans are counted as income so it's near impossible for a single parent to go to university unless they are having housing and childcare heavily supported or subsidised by family.
If a life reliant on the state looks so easy and appealing why not quit your jobs and leave your husband's and join all of us lazy scroungers in the bed of roses?