Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to be sick of judgemental comments regarding my puppy?!

44 replies

NameChangeForThisPost213 · 25/07/2022 18:40

I got a puppy a couple of months ago, he is now 5 months old.

He is fed butternut box for his normal food.

For his treats he has natural stuff like rabbit ears, fish skin crisps, chicken feet etc. I buy it from a reputable pet food online store and always stick to the age guidelines of what is appropriate.

My family members who I see very regularly always has something to say about them. They aren’t vegetarian so that isn’t an issue. Every time they see him with one they will say things like ‘I don’t like dogs having those things’ or anytime the dog is unwell in any way they will blame the treats I give him.

I personally think it’s a generational thing, when they owned animals years ago dogs were fed treats full of crap basically, none of the natural treats that are around today. I have tried explaining to them that the treats he has is full of nutrition, minerals, vitamins, good for their coats and digestion etc but it falls on deaf ears.

They pop round anytime of the day so it’s inevitable they will see with him a treat at some point, but I’m sick of walking on egg shells about it and feeling like I’m doing something wrong.

They also make comments about the harnesses that he wears (that they make him look like a ‘poof’) and the stuff I use on his skin (he has irritable skin so I use special oatmeal sprays to condition it all and so far it works) they end up blaming that for his skin condition in the first place. They don’t like the fact that I do spoil him and he does have nice things for some reason.

AIBU to be getting really fed up with this?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
catfunk · 26/07/2022 10:45

Honestly I wouldn't invite them round any more or let them in.
Make it perfectly clear that if they make any interfering or weirdly homophobic comments about the way you look after your pet, they are not welcome in your home. Pull them up on it every single time.

Ps: if you have kids, move away

CoraPirbright · 26/07/2022 10:40

Well, the whole harness/poof thing would be enough to make me think that they are as thick as pig-shit and therefore not worth the time of day.

As an aside, ddog had the most terrible dry itchy skin - he was scratching all the time. We had an emergency and he had to go and stay with his dog walker for a couple of nights who did not have his usual food in. He went from raw, natural stuff to Forthglade and he is SO much better! Nothing like as dry so not scratching so often and his coat is much softer too. If your ddog is so dry, it might be worth tinkering with his food just to see?

Whataretheodds · 26/07/2022 10:23

Next time the family turn up unannounced just tell them, at the door, that you can't let them come in because you've all caught a maasive dose of GAY from the dog and need to stay in listening to Britney and watching Priscilla until is subsides.

Blossomtoes · 26/07/2022 10:17

Your dog, your rules. We had a Scottie that had horribly irritable skin. The vet told us to give him a human antihistamine every day and actually recommended the uber cheap ones from Amazon. Apparently they’re exactly the same as the ones vets prescribe that cost ££££. That worked a treat.

MindfulBear · 26/07/2022 10:13

Oh my word. Just one of those comments would be enough for me to tell them to stfu!!

Tbh doesn't matter whether it is is kids or dogs, some people have an opinion on everything and do not hesitate to share.
Either stop letting them in, wear ear plugs, ignore them or tell them very clearly this is your dog your rules and so stfu.....

Very frustrating tho!!!!

AuntieStella · 26/07/2022 06:42

You are unreasonable to think its a 'generational thing' rather than these specific people being dicks

Never write off a whole generation in this way

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2022 05:59

I'm trying to work out why, even for a homophobe, it would be a problem for a pet dog to be homosexual.

Even ignoring the ridiculousness of a harness making a dog look like it's gay through stereotypes of camp or effeminacy as though the dog chooses the harness and makes its selection based on human cultural aesthetics of recent Western origin signalling homosexuality, even ignoring the incredibly silly idea that taking care of a person and being affectionate turns them gay and that this somehow transfers to pet dogs… just why would it be a problem if the dog preferred the affections of other dogs? It's a dog. It's not like it was going to give you grandchildren.

DetMcNulty · 26/07/2022 05:57

You're family are crazy - or maybe I'm not the best judge, I take my dog out to breakfast with me on a regular basis, he has the full Barkfast and a puppiccino, so I may be skewed on what's normal or not.

FatToFitPart3 · 26/07/2022 05:43

Watchthesunrise · 25/07/2022 23:58

It's possible whatever the pigs ears or whatever are preserved in is making your dog itchy.

They aren’t usually preserved in anything. They are just dried out.

Madwife123 · 26/07/2022 00:21

Tell them your dog your rules so fuck off!

By the way are you aware most harnesses encourage dogs to pull? That’s why they use them on sledding dogs etc. I found this out after my dog had an awful pulling the lead problem so mention it on the off chance you haven’t come across this.

Watchthesunrise · 25/07/2022 23:58

It's possible whatever the pigs ears or whatever are preserved in is making your dog itchy.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/07/2022 22:52

There is also the following point you could make about canine dietary choices -

'this is an animal for whom biologically, eating its own (or the cat's) vomit and shit is an entirely viable choice for dinner. Seems like bits of chicken and pig is Cordon Bleu cuisine in comparison'.

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/07/2022 22:18

Well anyone who thinks that being kind and comforting to anyone will 'make them gay' wants yeeting from your life forthwith.

JR Pets is an excellent source of all things absolutely disgusting and therefore fabulous for puppies and adult dogs - I send all my clients there for their disgusting dried animal part needs.

Tell them to fuck off.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/07/2022 22:16

When you inform the idiot that your dog is being neutered (because you're a responsible dog owner), give us all a laugh and film the twat's reaction. If at all possible, go into extreme detail about the procedure as well.

Because you know that if the fool believes a dog will turn gay because it's got a harness rather than an inch thick choke chain, he's going to completely lose his mind over castration.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 25/07/2022 22:10

NameChangeForThisPost213 · 25/07/2022 18:58

@LoobyDop the same person who said that I mollycoddle him and turning him ‘gay’ by giving him too much attention…

OMG Grin how can you take someone seriously that says shit like that?!

Notanotherwindow · 25/07/2022 19:51

Tea Spoonful of coconut oil in his food every day will help his skin too. And deter fleas. I swear by it. Haven't given either of mine flea treatment for years now.

Flaunch · 25/07/2022 19:48

I thought this was going to be about your puppy having cropped ears or being some massive behemoth you have no chance of controlling and was going to say you deserve it bur your family are knobs if they’re complaining about you feeding healthy treats 😂 tell them to sod off.

Cherrysoup · 25/07/2022 19:45

The harness makes him look like a poof and you’re turning him gay? I don’t care who that person is, they would not be allowed in my house for being such a complete homophobic arsehole. I hope you’ve told him what an utter knob he sounds. I used harnesses on mine with a longline to teach recall, you aren’t meant to use collars with longlines in case you break their neck! This person is an idiot, ignore and ban them from your house.

MaChienEstUnDick · 25/07/2022 19:39

My friend had a bit of success with her dog's itchy skin when she upped his fish intake. Lots of salmon. It didn't cure it but she definitely thought it made a difference. There's something else for them to get judgy about!

Darbs76 · 25/07/2022 19:36

Definitely generational, I had the same

WonderingWanda · 25/07/2022 19:36

They sound quite insecure op. I know very little a out dogs but I suspect that this is the same as some grandparents take it personally when their children raise their grandchildren very differently. Usually it's because deep down the recognise that your way is probably better and it makes them feel bad so then they try and put your way down to ease their guilt.

WinterMusings · 25/07/2022 19:32

I'm not even going to look up pizzles 🤮

I don't currently have a dog 😪but when I did she didn't get pigs ears or anything like that. She got fed well & treats that weren't obviously a part of an animal but not vegetarian!

I am vegetarian (largely eat a vegan diet & largely ethically vegan) I just can't face watching them chew on a pigs ear etc.

but my friends do give them to their dogs and I keep my mouth shut! Most of my friends give them them in another room etc as they know how I feel, but I don't bang on about it, the same way we respect each other's eating habits.

As for saying his harness makes him look like a poof & will turn him gay. I haven't heard anything like that in years!! Took me right back to my '70's childhood. What did you say when you stopped laughing at him??

YOU keep on treating YOUR dog how YOU want to & just tell them 'ok
ok, so you've said, it's now repetitive & boring. MY DOG MY RULES'.

AHamSandwich · 25/07/2022 19:23

How old are your family? my mum in her mid 60s and her dad fed their dogs raw bones from the butchers and pig trotters and animal carcasses from the allotments. so I'm not sure it's a generational thing more and arsehole thing maybe.

I went from not being a dog person to a total dog person after getting my dog and my extended family tease me about it but in a normal family teasing kind of way apart from fil who also used a homophobic slur about dh and the dog and was told if he didn't like it

My mum will make jokes that my dogs diet costs more than ours, or that her bed cost more than her sofa but it's all lighthearted and my mum always wants me to take her to her house when I go and always has the digs fave treats there ready.

My dog knows when we get near her house and starts getting all excited in the car.

Mariposista · 25/07/2022 19:22

Ugggh I remember this OP. Not so much from family but neighbors and other dog walkers, they always had a ‘comment’ or ‘suggestion’ to make about my labrador puppy (yep big energetic lad who they all expected to walk like a guide dog from 12 weeks old 🙄). Sometimes advice is great - but when you ask for it, people making random comments is just irritating, when you and your pup are trying to learn from each other. It’s a special time and new puppy owners can get upset by these silly people. Now my boy is a lovely gentle almost 3 year old, I always offer encouragement to a new puppy owner, not judgement.
The gay comment is just ridiculous and immature. Put your dog in whichever harness is comfortable for him and you. People kept on at me to get mine on a Halti head harness as he pulled but I hated the look of them and wanted to train him to walk nicely. With time and patience he now does! Ignore them OP, they sound ridiculous. Find a supportive doggy community with puppy classes or walking and just enjoy him!

UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername · 25/07/2022 19:21

Sounds like my FIL, who refused to get a female dog on the basis that he'd be too humiliated walking one.

People are strange.