Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to pull out if they don't agree?

243 replies

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 14:50

Reposting for traffic

Short version - are these issues bad enough to withdraw from property purchase and collapse the chain. Or should this be expected when buying a house.

YABU - Even without a reduction, these issues are not that bad

YANBU - They definitely need to reduce the price a bit

Full version

We are trying to purchase our "forever home", have gone madly over budget on something that isn't perfect, but we are happy enough with. Survey has come back and the work that needs doing seems to be quite a lot. We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being) - estate agent (of course) is saying they won't agree but she doesn't have their actual answer yet. To complicate matters, they are overseas and we cannot reach vendors directly (currently trying via the solicitors instead though)

Basically, we are not quite sure the best way to approach this and how much of this the vendor thinks should have been priced in to our offer, bearing in mind we were unaware of 99% of the issues prior to the survey. The 1% is an issue we believe they should and could still deal with through their buildings insurance.

For context here are some of the issues:

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

OP posts:
MaggieFS · 25/07/2022 16:32

As if anyone would accept a £156k reduction for newly discovered issues!

sweetgingercat · 25/07/2022 16:29

You can but try. I got £10K off the price of a house for a new roof and that was in a thoroughly overheated market several years ago.

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:28

Leftbutcameback · 25/07/2022 16:23

You mentioned electrics issues - did you have a full survey done of the electrics? That's the one thing a lot of people regret (including us!). We needed lots of work done for it to be safe, and a friend who bought a slightly older house than ours had a small explosion in a hall. Definitely worth it, and IMO more useful than other surveys.

yes, we had a lot of issues on the electrics on our current house after buying. But even now, didn't realise realise an electrical survey was a "thing". We are going to get gas and electrics arranged asap.

OP posts:
Roselilly36 · 25/07/2022 16:27

As soon as someone says forever home, you know what’s coming! Completely unrealistic expectations.

Leftbutcameback · 25/07/2022 16:23

You mentioned electrics issues - did you have a full survey done of the electrics? That's the one thing a lot of people regret (including us!). We needed lots of work done for it to be safe, and a friend who bought a slightly older house than ours had a small explosion in a hall. Definitely worth it, and IMO more useful than other surveys.

Jaxhog · 25/07/2022 16:22

If that's all that's wrong in a 1910 house, count yourself lucky! However, it also doesn't sound like a full structural survey, which I would get done on a house of this age. If this WAS a full structural survey, kiss the ground, you don't have a more serious problem!

None of these things will get you a major discount imho.

Tessasanderson · 25/07/2022 16:21

Lets test how much of a CF you and your family are.......

How long is it since you had your bid accepted? How far down the line are you before your FIL suggested you lowball these people and hang them out to dry?

Lets get a real measure on whether you genuinely want to negotiate issues with the sellers or you just want to kick them in the testicles.

A leaking shower head....£20
Sticking doors - Fuck off
Pointing the chimney - Who cares, just get it done.

If you have not told your FIL to go to hell then you actually entertain him. If you have waited until the chain is in place for maximum effect then i hope you lose out. If its right at the start then ok but you still risk everything imo.

DoNotGetADog · 25/07/2022 16:21

Can you go back to your name with capitals, OP? At the moment you’re more like “need2newnamesbriefly” as you’ve changed again so your posts aren’t highlighted as OP posts, which makes it more difficult to read!

Cervinia · 25/07/2022 16:20

Course the PIL thinks you should push for a 12% reduction as an estate agent, I bet they wouldn't be saying that if you were selling instead of buying. Their opinion I would take with a pinch of salt!

thejall · 25/07/2022 16:19

You have nothing to lose my asking, the market is turning a bit & there is no guarantee that they will get more overs asking when mortgages are costing more.

badhappening · 25/07/2022 16:19

YABU

I have dropped a buyer like you before.

Beautiful house in the most beautiful location (area of outstanding natural beauty) and idiot woman starts niggling at nonsense.

So for the sake of her wanting to bring the price down by circa £10k she lost it because she wasn't very clever and failed to see the bigger picture/very rare opportunity.

Make no mistake, the vast majority of houses have something(s) wrong with them and if you love it enough you should be wise enough to not let it go.

mummabubs · 25/07/2022 16:13

Adjusting the internal doors tickled me too - I had a carpenter out a few weeks ago to shave off one of our doors as it wouldn't shut... £10 🤣

MaggieFS · 25/07/2022 16:12

I think it's fine to renegotiate when a survey throws up something specific and unknown e.g. my previous flat had damp. Got a quote to have it fixed for £3k, agreed to have £3k taken off the price. All happy.

Your wish list looks like it mostly consists of what would be considered pretty standard maintenance for an older property or upgrades of choice not necessity. You effectively want the vendor to pay for a renovation.

12.5% is clearly a piss take and I would put the property back on the market. In fact at such an extreme, I wouldn't even attempt to renegotiate because it's so far off.

Let us know what happens!! Is it your house or PIL?

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:12

@sasparilla1 Truly genuine question - how can one see the roof of a house from the ground? Except for maybe right at the edges at the front back and maybe the sides.

Like the guy has got a bunch of photos from the roof with a special camera. What should have been the clue? Because to me, I thought it was fine. I thought the whole house was fine. Except that it was kind of crooked. So main concern was that it wasn't about to fall down really.

It's an old house, circa 1910 (so much older than current home), owners seem to be mid-forties with a toddler.

OP posts:
mummabubs · 25/07/2022 16:10

Honestly... YABU. And I say that as someone who renegotiated their purchase price based on survey issues (but we requested to reduce by 3% and it was for large issues).

I think 12% is cheeky (what have you based that on, as a lot of the repairs you mention either aren't essential and also not too costly. You have said you want to replace the whole roof, that's fair but your choice, given that just replacing the tiles would also resolve the issue for example). The fact you say you went madly over budget also hints that you regret your offer amount and now want to haggle down, again not the vendor's fault. I'd be really thinking about whether this is the right house for you?

LumpyandBumps · 25/07/2022 16:09

Assuming that the crack on the front elevation and the non closing doors are not symptoms of movement/ subsidence - which should certainly have been mentioned in the survey, it has revealed very little hidden problems.
I have only bought a handful of houses and don’t think the roof has been judged as good in any of them. The most common comment seems to be it has not been fully inspected and ‘may’ have issues. ( home buyers standard survey, rather than structural).
Getting a house re roofed is a large and expensive job, but the last small repair I had done on my roof cost £120.
I am curious as to which of the problems raised you think might be covered by the vendor’s insurance.

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:06

@MacKenzieMcHale Really? Good repair is the same as having several holes in it and previous repairs don't badly? Ok 🤷🏾‍♀️

OP posts:
constantavoider · 25/07/2022 16:05

Most of those issues are things you can see like the decking so those are unreasonable.

For what it's worth I was told the chimney stack needed repointing and it's still standing after 6 years. A builder looked at it and said the surveyor was just covering his arse. He said he could do it but there wasn't really any need. It all just sounds like the expected survey for a house of its age.

Butterflymosaic · 25/07/2022 16:05

MacKenzieMcHale · 25/07/2022 15:48

I had a potential buyer attempt to reduce his offer by 10% because although the survey said the roof was in good repair, it may not stay that way in the future 🤷🏻‍♀️

You're sort of on that level tbh.

What a fecking chancer, I’d have pulled out!

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:04

@shootfromthehip145

I deliberately gave a percentage, rather than a price at first. And have also name changed for this post. It's also clear from the post that this is a MASSIVE stretch for us. And if further context is required, this is in London.

I truly didn't know who was closer to the right figure, DH or PIL. The stream of of responses is making it clear that DH is right - this is why I'm glad I posted.

But hey, can't post in AIBU without a few meanies popping up to take a shot right? I needed quicker answers than I was getting on the Property/DIY post I made (zero responses) so this is what I have to accept comes from posting over here.

OP posts:
JumpTheGun · 25/07/2022 16:00

A £1.3m house? So you were looking for an £150,000 + reduction?! Absurd.

We had an almost identical list of “issues” on our survey - have lived here 10 years and have addressed maybe one of them. They’re just standard things that will come up on any survey of an older property.

Testina · 25/07/2022 15:59

I bloody hate reverses.
So patronising.
You think we’re all so stupid we couldn’t just answer the question?
It’s not like AIBU has a habit of siding blindly with the poster 😭

shootfromthehip145 · 25/07/2022 15:58

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 15:53

We have a house already, didn't have a structural survey done when we bought, only a homebuyers/L2. Had all manner of issues with it.

So a report like this is new for us. I don't want to lose the house, but we already know we are overpaying due to the current market conditions - or at least how they have been past few months. At £1.3m more than double the cost of the house we are selling, so I understand PIL wants us to be cautious and knows how houses have been priced (considering his day job). But ultimately the decision is for me and DH, having additional perspectives is helpful. So it's appreciated.

So you already knew what every one would say, All you're doing is posting on MN to say look at me I'm spending £1.3Mil on a house 🙄

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 15:53

We have a house already, didn't have a structural survey done when we bought, only a homebuyers/L2. Had all manner of issues with it.

So a report like this is new for us. I don't want to lose the house, but we already know we are overpaying due to the current market conditions - or at least how they have been past few months. At £1.3m more than double the cost of the house we are selling, so I understand PIL wants us to be cautious and knows how houses have been priced (considering his day job). But ultimately the decision is for me and DH, having additional perspectives is helpful. So it's appreciated.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 25/07/2022 15:51

It sounds like this house is not for you. Someone will love it as it is and sort out issues gradually. It sounds like you over bid now looking to claw back. The issues you mention like doors not shutting properly were not hidden from you. They just need adjusting. It needs a few missing or loose tiles replacing that cost about £150 you want whole roof replaced that would cost thousands. If I was selling that house I would be telling you I would get chimney repointed and the few missing tiles replaced. That is it. Nothing off cost of house. Either buy what you bid for it or pull out.