Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to pull out if they don't agree?

243 replies

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 14:50

Reposting for traffic

Short version - are these issues bad enough to withdraw from property purchase and collapse the chain. Or should this be expected when buying a house.

YABU - Even without a reduction, these issues are not that bad

YANBU - They definitely need to reduce the price a bit

Full version

We are trying to purchase our "forever home", have gone madly over budget on something that isn't perfect, but we are happy enough with. Survey has come back and the work that needs doing seems to be quite a lot. We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being) - estate agent (of course) is saying they won't agree but she doesn't have their actual answer yet. To complicate matters, they are overseas and we cannot reach vendors directly (currently trying via the solicitors instead though)

Basically, we are not quite sure the best way to approach this and how much of this the vendor thinks should have been priced in to our offer, bearing in mind we were unaware of 99% of the issues prior to the survey. The 1% is an issue we believe they should and could still deal with through their buildings insurance.

For context here are some of the issues:

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

OP posts:
Soonberaining · 25/07/2022 17:07

I'd be worried about the movement preventing the doors from closing. It sounds far more serious than normal movement.

I bought a house with some loose slates on the roof. There was a storm and half the roof blew off. Patching was a waste of money. I had to remortgage to get a new roof as the structure holding the slates on wasn't suitable for modern roofing and insulation. It was a big job, and of course, the chimneys and other brickwork on the roof needed repointing.

It sounds like a money pit to me. I'd avoid it.

I only buy new builds now. At least there's a two year guarantee and 10 years NHBC. I couldn't put up with the hassle of constant repairs.

thejall · 25/07/2022 17:06

Wonky houses aren't necessarily bad but I would be wary of subsidence.

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 17:05

Tessasanderson · 25/07/2022 16:58

Can you answer my question please. How far down the line are you to be considering a discount?

Copying from another response I posted above (I realise now due to poor posting etiquette, some people haven't seen all my replies):

And as I said, since posting i now have had the full report through (survey was booked the same week offer was accepted. Was done last week and only bullets in an email to go off, which I received on Friday - there were 23 points in all, I listed a few here).

OP posts:
thejall · 25/07/2022 17:05

@NeedANewNameBriefly of course, no one wants to overpay on what they are buying or under sell what they are selling.

WinterMusings · 25/07/2022 17:03

@NeedANewNameBriefly if I were you I'd get a specialist out to check for subsidence or just pull out. It doesn't sound like you actually even like this 'forever' house.

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 17:02

Sorry about that. Didn't know the capitalisation changed things - learn something new everyday!

We are really clueless on all this DIY stuff. We have asked the surveyor to produce a costs estimate for us, but as this may take a while (and is primarily being done for us, rather than to impact the sae) we have now also decided to get a roofer out and also people to look at gas and electrics too.

OP posts:
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 25/07/2022 17:01

bubblescoop · 25/07/2022 15:48

Ugh. Just post as yourself instead of using a reverse.

This.

alibongo5 · 25/07/2022 16:58

My daughter bought a similar aged house last year and I warned her that the survey would sound awful, with loads of things to worry about.

One of the things that the surveyor said was "obviously it needs a completely new kitchen", she laughed and said, "I was thinking of repainting the doors and replacing the doorknobs". Which is what she did, as well as tightening some screws and fitting soft closures. Absolutely fine now!

Tessasanderson · 25/07/2022 16:58

Can you answer my question please. How far down the line are you to be considering a discount?

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 16:57

thejall · 25/07/2022 16:44

both off houses at 900k

That's interesting.

And I guess perhaps responses here will be skewed depending on whether someone is picturing selling their own home/has sold their own home vs thinking as just a buyer.

OP posts:
NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 16:55

DoNotGetADog · 25/07/2022 16:21

Can you go back to your name with capitals, OP? At the moment you’re more like “need2newnamesbriefly” as you’ve changed again so your posts aren’t highlighted as OP posts, which makes it more difficult to read!

Oops - sorry! Will do

OP posts:
needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:53

LumpyandBumps · 25/07/2022 16:09

Assuming that the crack on the front elevation and the non closing doors are not symptoms of movement/ subsidence - which should certainly have been mentioned in the survey, it has revealed very little hidden problems.
I have only bought a handful of houses and don’t think the roof has been judged as good in any of them. The most common comment seems to be it has not been fully inspected and ‘may’ have issues. ( home buyers standard survey, rather than structural).
Getting a house re roofed is a large and expensive job, but the last small repair I had done on my roof cost £120.
I am curious as to which of the problems raised you think might be covered by the vendor’s insurance.

The house has apparently be subject to a lot of movement in the past, more than normal according to the report. I asked why this was and the surveyor said the foundations were not deep enough. But he has said on the phone that this is primarily historical, but that there is cracking in a couple of the bathrooms that could also be down to movement.

In the house we can feel the floors sloping in front places. In one bathroom very noticeable. So for me, I really wanted reassurance it's not going to fall down in us or that it's going to be a problem to insure. But he said he said he thought the issues were long-standing.

Surveyor said all the doors upstairs don't close (which fireman friend has said is bad from a fire safety perspective) because of the movement of the house. The doors not closing we knew about/had noticed. But PIL said insurance would pay to fix those. I don't know how true that is.

OP posts:
BlueMongoose · 25/07/2022 16:47

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:34

It's a level 3 survey. I believe that used to be called a structural survey?

We are comfortable with the price we offered, as we wouldn't have offered it otherwise (even though it's admittedly a lot for us). So it's not really about getting a major reduction, it's just about making sure we aren't paying more than is fair/right.

And from this thread I have learned at least, that the vast majority on here is nothing to be overly concerned about. And as I said, since posting i now have had the full report through (survey was booked the same week offer was accepted. Was done last week and only bullets in an email to go off, which I received on Friday - there were 23 points in all, I listed a few here).

On the report, the two red flagged issues are relating to gas and electrics, but weirdly weren't mentioned in the email summary. But like I've always said, i don't think these warrant a massive cost reduction either (unless further investigations throw up something really bad I guess)

Sorry, missed your later posts due to the namechange. I suggest you get a roofer to look at the roof and give you an idea of what really needs doing and how much it will cost. We did this when something came up on a survey for one we were offering on many years ago, and the roofer said it wasn't at all bad, the roof was well built to the point of being overbuilt, and it would cost peanuts to fix. Our current house is 1920s and it sounds a lot like yours- the airbricks and ground level we're still part way through sorting out!- though it needed a lot more work in other respects than yours, all picked up by the equivalent of the old 'full structural' survey. It's a good house, though, and I hope yours works out for you too.

gogohmm · 25/07/2022 16:45

How obvious were these at viewing? I would tell you to get lost if it was me selling. I priced the house with guidance from the estate agent to take into account the west and tear (which these are) on an older property. I had my estate agent reiterate this at the offers stage to avoid exactly this scenario (my buyer understood, we completed a few weeks ago!

Your list is quite ridiculous anyway - water tank is undersized? Who says? Drain height? What? Shower hoses are a few pounds. Showing damage? Unless cracked why?

It sounds like you have over offered, I would pull out as this is not the house for you

FatEaredFuck · 25/07/2022 16:44

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 25/07/2022 15:04

If I were the vendor I'd take no notice of your list of demands.
Most of your list come under a vague umbrella of 'sold as seen.'
Unless the property is brand spanking new then there are going to a whole host of things that need patching up, replacing or fixing.

You sound like you want some money back, as it were, as you seem to have overspent and are struggling to find more money to do maintenance.

Maybe pull out and find a house that's more within your means.

Completely agree!!

thejall · 25/07/2022 16:44

both off houses at 900k

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/07/2022 16:42

Is FIL a successful estate agent?👩🏻🤦🏻‍♀️

ShrillSiren22 · 25/07/2022 16:39

If I was the vendor and the buyer asked for a 12% reduction based on those issues I’d immediately pull out. I would assume the buyer either isn’t serious, does not have the money to pay full price in the first place or that the entire sale will be an absolute nightmare if they were asking for such a huge reduction on things that must have flagged as issues when they viewed. Wanting new double glazing ffs? That’s like saying I want a reduction because I want to fit a new kitchen.

fourquenelles · 25/07/2022 16:39

The crack, ill fitting doors and "wonkiness" of the house (a 1910s house shouldn't be wonky) are more problematic imho and could, as a PP has mentioned, mean subsidence. Now that is expensive to fix. Does the survey have anything to say on that? Maybe go back to the surveyor and ask for an off the record opinion?

Harrysmummy246 · 25/07/2022 16:39

Oh and none of our doors close/ fit properly. Floors are properly slopy/ lumpy too.

Our new windows were made by the joiner only to discover the holes weren't actually properly square to fit them into.

Ceilings are wonky.

But, if it's still standing after close to 200 years, I think it's likely to be ok for my lifetime

BlueMongoose · 25/07/2022 16:39

Most of those things are the sort of mostly trivial things you have to deal with in course of time in any house that isn't new. Many older houses don't have enough airbricks, or have had drives put on top of other drives, and are too high. And most of those things should have been evident at fist viewing, before you made an offer, so as a vendor I'd think you were taking the whatsit or just a time-waster if dropped your offer by 12% at a later stage .They will cost money to fix, sure, but they aren't, IMO, enough for a significant reduction in an offer. If the surveyor hasn't a concern about the crack, which wouold be my only serious concern, the same would apply there. I'm sorry but these things are just general maintenance.
We bought a doer-upper recently. We certainly had pretty much all of the things you mention, as most older houses do, but a doer-upper is far and away worse than that.You're talking of all the things you mention, plus rewiring, new drains, replastering, ripping out ancient and knackered kitchens and bathrooms, reroofing parts rather than just re-tiling, new floor joists, that sort of thing.

thejall · 25/07/2022 16:38

I know 2 people who got over 100k each off doer uppers buying & selling is cutthroat

C152 · 25/07/2022 16:36

YABU. Those seem minor things to me. Yes, annoying and obviously all costs add up, but not major and certainly not worth pulling out if you really do see it as your 'forever home'. It seems from your post that you may be letting the fact that you've chosen to go "madly over budget" put you into a panic over having nothing left over to do any other work on the house...

Harrysmummy246 · 25/07/2022 16:35

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:12

@sasparilla1 Truly genuine question - how can one see the roof of a house from the ground? Except for maybe right at the edges at the front back and maybe the sides.

Like the guy has got a bunch of photos from the roof with a special camera. What should have been the clue? Because to me, I thought it was fine. I thought the whole house was fine. Except that it was kind of crooked. So main concern was that it wasn't about to fall down really.

It's an old house, circa 1910 (so much older than current home), owners seem to be mid-forties with a toddler.

Not sure how you're making a house from that era out to be old. It's just not new. Oh and we can see most of our roof from the ground. Took the survey for this house with a pinch of salt though as the surveyor's comments on the septic tank showed that there was a wild misunderstanding of how it would function etc. Had the house electrically tested on moving in too, tested fine but didn't reveal the huge clusterf* that the wiring actually is....

We asked a buyer to return papers when they realised what underpinning was- we had been entirely upfront that the house had been etc but they were making very unreasonable demands/ expectations. We even shared details of who it was currently insured with etc. But no.

needanewnamebriefly · 25/07/2022 16:34

Jaxhog · 25/07/2022 16:22

If that's all that's wrong in a 1910 house, count yourself lucky! However, it also doesn't sound like a full structural survey, which I would get done on a house of this age. If this WAS a full structural survey, kiss the ground, you don't have a more serious problem!

None of these things will get you a major discount imho.

It's a level 3 survey. I believe that used to be called a structural survey?

We are comfortable with the price we offered, as we wouldn't have offered it otherwise (even though it's admittedly a lot for us). So it's not really about getting a major reduction, it's just about making sure we aren't paying more than is fair/right.

And from this thread I have learned at least, that the vast majority on here is nothing to be overly concerned about. And as I said, since posting i now have had the full report through (survey was booked the same week offer was accepted. Was done last week and only bullets in an email to go off, which I received on Friday - there were 23 points in all, I listed a few here).

On the report, the two red flagged issues are relating to gas and electrics, but weirdly weren't mentioned in the email summary. But like I've always said, i don't think these warrant a massive cost reduction either (unless further investigations throw up something really bad I guess)

OP posts: