Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to pull out if they don't agree?

243 replies

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 14:50

Reposting for traffic

Short version - are these issues bad enough to withdraw from property purchase and collapse the chain. Or should this be expected when buying a house.

YABU - Even without a reduction, these issues are not that bad

YANBU - They definitely need to reduce the price a bit

Full version

We are trying to purchase our "forever home", have gone madly over budget on something that isn't perfect, but we are happy enough with. Survey has come back and the work that needs doing seems to be quite a lot. We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being) - estate agent (of course) is saying they won't agree but she doesn't have their actual answer yet. To complicate matters, they are overseas and we cannot reach vendors directly (currently trying via the solicitors instead though)

Basically, we are not quite sure the best way to approach this and how much of this the vendor thinks should have been priced in to our offer, bearing in mind we were unaware of 99% of the issues prior to the survey. The 1% is an issue we believe they should and could still deal with through their buildings insurance.

For context here are some of the issues:

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

OP posts:
commonsense61 · 27/07/2022 11:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

jillybeanclevertips · 27/07/2022 10:40

I would retract my offer completely, and make sure the reason given is that there is too much repairwork needed, and you'd like to renegotiate the price, and then look for your forever home elsewhere. If you are sold STC, it is OK to do this right up until contracts are exchanged.

Jeclop · 27/07/2022 10:26

Clymene · 26/07/2022 19:36

And right now in this market, seasoned vendors would tell you to piss off.

Perhaps, perhaps not. But it would be silly not to try.

I wouldn't back out of the sale if the vendor didn't come down and I loved the house. I would still try to get the best possible price I could. My husband would be even more ruthless. It's always worked for us.

Especially in London, where there is always more room for negotiation given the higher asking prices.

AnwenDolly · 27/07/2022 08:37

It's a sellers' market. The vendor is extremely unlikely to accept your proposal.

The real problem seems to be that you can't afford to pay the market value and repairs. That is your problem, not the vendor's. However, it is probably a good reason to pull out of the sale.

RachaelN · 27/07/2022 08:11

Yikes. I think you are taking the Mick. House will be valued appropriately. Maybe you should have viewed it and taken lots of pictures so you could have taken this into consideration when you put in an offer.

Titsflyingsouth · 27/07/2022 08:08

It depends how serious some of these issues are. Loose tiles, airbricks, wonky doors etc are considered small issues and YABU to push for a reduction. However if the whole roof needs replacing or there are large structural cracks that need treatment then that might be leverage to lower the price.

We have managed to get 10% off our original price on a previous sale when the survey revealed some larger-scale structural issues. (We decided not to proceed in the end.)

However, I think the point someone raises about 'just because you are over budget doesn't mean the house is over-priced' is a good one. Your budget is irrelevant to the seller. What's important is whether the price accurately reflects the property/location. Would other similar properties in similar condition within the area command the same price? If so, YABU to push for a reduction.

Inkyblue123 · 27/07/2022 07:36

Regardless of what the issues are - and every house has them to a degree- you must decide on a price that works for you - and then the vendor decides whether to sell or not. What is the house worth to you ? The property will be of differing values to different people - I found that vendors who Inherited a property and therefore had no mortgage - were more likely to want a higher sales price whereas a family upsizing wanted a quick sale and were more willing to negotiate. I have offered on several properties that needed significant work - and my offers were rejected. But the homes were not worth the asking price to me. There is no such thing as the perfect house. Even when you self build ! Just be realistic in what you can afford… don’t let it become a burden.

RubyandPearl · 27/07/2022 07:25

Oh dear! Good luck OP. YABVVVU. Sorry!

MamaBearBoo · 27/07/2022 04:33
  • no obligation
MamaBearBoo · 27/07/2022 04:32

The problem you have is they have obligation to replace the entire roof due to a few tiles having slipped.Also a lot of the issues you highlight you should have been able to see from your own inspection prior to putting in your offer - so it would be expected that you were already aware of these prior to making an offer! If you aren't happy you can pull out or sometimes a seller will offer an allowance to for you to carry out the works once the sale has gone through you would need to get quotes for this work though! I think YABU to ask for a12% reduction!!

ThinWomansBrain · 26/07/2022 23:31

Samanabanana · 25/07/2022 15:16

YABVU. Buy a new build if you want perfection, all surveys come back like this!

cos new builds never have snagging issues to fix 😆

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 26/07/2022 22:27

petelacey · 26/07/2022 22:24

The types of repair work you are listing will end up costing well over £20,000 for a 3 bed house. Been there done that.

Only because OP wants a new roof rather than a repair!

petelacey · 26/07/2022 22:24

The types of repair work you are listing will end up costing well over £20,000 for a 3 bed house. Been there done that.

C0mfyChairP0se · 26/07/2022 22:10

British people are terrified of offending the vendor for some reason.

@NeedANewNameBriefly two things on that list sound serious, the crack and the tiles on the roof.

I would forward them the list and say you're reducing your offer by 3%

That could be enough to get the most urgent of those two jobs looked at.

In the context of a long list and you only mentioning two of the things, I think asking for 3% reduction mightn't seem too unreasonable and end up KILLing the deal.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 26/07/2022 22:00

Let's see

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
That's ongoing maintenance, cheap to do

•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
Replacement is up to you. Small repairs will do the job just as well. You want it to look good, you pay!

•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
What kind of crack. Surface? Just fill it. Again cheap and ongoing maintenance

•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
You mean they are not brand new, may be blown but work OK. Aesthetics again

• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
Why the tiles? Damage to a supporting upright could be reasonable

•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
Add air bricks? Why? Replace them? Cheap enough and easy to do

•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
That's your perspective. They live with it as is... again much of that is aesthetic

•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
Old house? None of ours fit the hole either. We see it as character. Again aesthetics

•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
Now the leak I would agree with, they should have insurance and should have had that fixed

•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
Why not get a combi boiler instead? Normal upgrade in a new house

•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
Waste pipe is cheap DIY job. Leak? Paint or actual repair?

•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required
Erm, you might be reaching there.

Much of that would have been as seen when you viewed and made a bid based on what you actually saw. That isn't really fair on the vendor!

Nocutenamesleft · 26/07/2022 21:59

Replacing the whole roof tiles?!?

hehhehehehehe

MercuryOnTheRise · 26/07/2022 21:56

We had a list of requests made like that after a survey and a reduction of less than 12%.

My response via the agent was "please inform the purchaser that I am not compelled to sell him my house, the price reflects the work that needs doing, and that the house will be remarketed from Saturday."

He crawled back by lunchtime with the original offer reinstated. The only person we've ever sold to who wasn't left a new home card and bottle of champagne. Soured the sale.

Ticktocktuck · 26/07/2022 21:55

Wow the birches of eastwick are just lining up to stick the boot into the op. Do you all feel better about yourselves by putting her down?
Hide this thread op and just ignore all these random strangers who have nothing better to say do apparently than put you down

Remona · 26/07/2022 21:50

PurBal · 26/07/2022 19:02

These all sound like normal things to expect on a survey. Buy a new build maybe?

Exactly this. Go and buy yourself a new build. You want something absolutely perfect - buy a new build.

Any older property is going to have a number of things pop up on survey. None of what you’ve mentioned sounds like the end of the world. A few tiles are wrong so this apparently necessitates a whole new roof? Do me a favour!

Any survey will highlight faults of some description. Most are just part and parcel of buying an older house. If you asked me for a 12% reduction I’d tell you to foxtrot oscar and it’d be back on the market.

madasawethen · 26/07/2022 21:48

You do sound naive.

The place sounds like a money pit and you'll have regrets.

I'd look for something else.

JudgeJ · 26/07/2022 21:45

We once had someone expecting us to knock £20k off the price, at the time it was about 8%, because she wanted to build a conservatory!

Doris86 · 26/07/2022 21:31

Surveyors tend to cover their backsides, and list every minor little thing which might cause a problem in future, or isn’t quite up to modern standards. Even if the house have been standing for 100 years and they have never caused an issue before.

No seller is going to give you 12% off just to do all the jobs on the surveyor’s wish list. In fact if you ask many sellers would see you as a cheeky and fussy buyer who wasn’t worth the hassle of dealing with, and pull out themselves.

Londoncallingme · 26/07/2022 21:21

You’ve already said that you knew about 99% of these before you agreed a price!
our buyers tried to drop us 10%, this was for some external pointing, a foggy window and removal of a fitted wardrobe. 🤣
We advised estate agent to put it back in the market and lo and behold, they found the faults acceptable and paid up.
try it on if you like but I think they’ll tell you to bugger off.

SallyB392 · 26/07/2022 21:14

It sounds like you are not a very experienced home owner, and are being unreasonable to think that any of the items listed should be repaired at the cost of the vendor.

Most of the items you mention can be carried out by a competent DIY'ER, and at a very low cost!

As others have suggested, perhaps you would feel more confident with a new build with all the associated guarantees etc. And there is absolutely no reason for you to see this as a negative!

InChocolateWeTrust · 26/07/2022 21:10

Most of what you list would come under "sold as seen" in my book, particularly if it's a period property.

You need to factor in the age and wear of a property when you offer.