Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to pull out if they don't agree?

243 replies

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 14:50

Reposting for traffic

Short version - are these issues bad enough to withdraw from property purchase and collapse the chain. Or should this be expected when buying a house.

YABU - Even without a reduction, these issues are not that bad

YANBU - They definitely need to reduce the price a bit

Full version

We are trying to purchase our "forever home", have gone madly over budget on something that isn't perfect, but we are happy enough with. Survey has come back and the work that needs doing seems to be quite a lot. We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being) - estate agent (of course) is saying they won't agree but she doesn't have their actual answer yet. To complicate matters, they are overseas and we cannot reach vendors directly (currently trying via the solicitors instead though)

Basically, we are not quite sure the best way to approach this and how much of this the vendor thinks should have been priced in to our offer, bearing in mind we were unaware of 99% of the issues prior to the survey. The 1% is an issue we believe they should and could still deal with through their buildings insurance.

For context here are some of the issues:

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MyrrAgain · 17/10/2022 23:17

It's not a new build. Deal with it. Of course there's going to be issues from the survey. Yeesh.

WindyHedges · 17/10/2022 22:50

We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being)

No way, if I were the vendor! Those are all quite normal and pretty minor things in a house.

CrazyLadie · 17/10/2022 22:28

You get a period of time to check all that and if anything costs more than a set amount (5 days and £400 on the house I have just bought) to notify them if said issues and it is the sellers responsibility to pay for it

MuddlingThrough1724 · 17/10/2022 19:18

Yeah, that all seems in the realm of "normal" feedback I'd expect from a survey to be honest, and I'd be laughing if you asked for any more than a token amount off the agreed price.

CrazyLadie · 17/10/2022 14:12

The survey completed on behalf of the seller prior to putting the house on the market and gives the market value taking into consideration any repairs required. You are being very unreasonable and I know if I was your seller I would put my house back on the market if you came to me with the silly things you have listed

Insanelysilver · 22/08/2022 14:18

12% of the purchase price! Those issues you’ve stated don’t sound like they warrant such a big reduction in the PP. Quite likely the vendors and agents probably knew there was some work required and that’s already reflected in the valuation.

Could it be that really you have over stretched yourselves and have been looking for an excuse to ask for a reduction which would make the house price s lot closer to what you’d have liked to pay. ?
if I were the seller I’d tell you where to go tbh.
If you love the house then patch up the roof and save up to replace eventually. It’s not the sellers fault you’re stretching yourselves.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 30/07/2022 14:29

So basically, you can't afford it.

I think you have got a real cheek tbh and I would tell you to jog on.

Whammyyammy · 30/07/2022 14:25

Plus this is all standard for older houses. OP I think you should just look for new builds

Whammyyammy · 30/07/2022 14:24

If I was the seller I would refuse to reject your reduction request/demand and no longer negotiate with you.
Agreed price or I'd pull out myself and relist

SarahSissions · 30/07/2022 14:07

I’d tell you to F off to be honest. Most of those things I would expect you to have noticed without a survey to be honest and put in an offer accordingly.

User367259791 · 30/07/2022 11:53

Solonge · 26/07/2022 20:07

Wow....I would be halfway down the road running with that list of repairs. The fact non of the internal door will close suggest the house might be slipping....especially as its so many doors. Roofing the whole house is a huge expense....I know...we had to do an A barn in France three times before the roofers got it right. Broken airbricks? why are they broken?

Having owned a couple of Victorian houses, these are all pretty standard.

Mum00122 · 30/07/2022 11:10

If I was selling to you I'd say no way am I reducing for things that are normal on a survey! Had a buyer try this with me. Not a chance. Maybe you should look for a different house that you really really love.

GoldenSpiral · 29/07/2022 10:23

YABU.

YarnSquirrel · 29/07/2022 10:14

if the estate agent says they probably wont accept even without asking them this means one of two things - either (a) the vendors cant possibly afford to sell at that price or (b) the estate agent thinks the reduction you are asking is too much.

Talk to estate agent and ask what they think would be a fair offer given the work that needs doing and see what they come back with (the estate agent wont take into consideration anything cosmetic). You can get quotes for work and then negotiate but I would only stick to "essential" rather than cosmetic repairs as its unfair otherwise.

No house is perfect and its unfair to assume that the vendors will bear the cost of what you think needs doing. i.e. a house is still worth the same with certain things like skirting boards, doors etc, changing them does not make the house worth more it just makes it look better and be more saleable.

With you mentioning a crack and the doors not shutting properly i wouldn't touch it with a barge pole until you got a complete full ding-dong survey on it in case the subsidence is not settlement and may be an ongoing issue.

word of warning though older houses are a bit of a money pit and if its not been maintained for many years it will need a lot of money spending on it, half the time people wont even turn up to quote and then you have to check they do a decent job and dont damage anything else while they are at it. Living in a damp house is awful - you need to have windows open almost all the time and heating on all time to keep mould at bay and dont get me started on the lovely clothes i have had to throw out because of a wardrobe with mould inside it. Buy something that is not damp its no good for your health.

Borisisafecklesstoad · 28/07/2022 21:25

With all the damage you mention to the roof i would suspect they may have damp as well (which id be more worried about ) but a lot of this seems to be relatively cosmetic.

An old house will always need ongoing repairs and maintenance so i suspect you might be a wee bit unrealistic with your expectations. You can only ask, if you are going to struggle it is not the time to overstretch yourself

Jedsnewstar · 28/07/2022 15:00

Fund

Jedsnewstar · 28/07/2022 14:59

Butterflymosaic · 25/07/2022 16:05

What a fecking chancer, I’d have pulled out!

We had a potential ask for a 12% reduction because that was the cost of the extension he wanted to build!
Of course let me find your extension. Ffs

Jedsnewstar · 28/07/2022 14:52

I don’t think all of these warrant reduction. Specifically these should not effect the house price:

Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house-

•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom- as above

•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround

•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

I think it’s quite cheeky to include these tbh.

Tessasanderson · 28/07/2022 14:46

To the weirdo that I’ve already responded to once but who has posted the same question a bunch of times - why are you so invested personally invested the timeline? The owners have emigrated. They are not in a chain/waiting on the sale of this house for an onward purchases. As I have already said, from acceptance of offer to now
it’s been a matter of weeks. We are still waiting for their responses to our solicitors enquiries. So do please untwist your knickers.

Haha, sorry i come across as a weirdo. If thats the case it wasnt meant. However i believe in straight answers. If someone asks you how long its been then a simple answer is 3 weeks/4 weeks/48 weeks.....see what i mean. In all your answers you didnt give a simple answer which usually indicates CF going on. Anyhow, from your "matter of weeks" answer i am assuming not very long so that isnt CF territory to me. I would have given you much more benefit of the doubt.

Anyhow, tbh its all a bit he said, she said, missing info and opportunist for me. I'm not really bothered but hope you end up getting what you want.

SillyMeee · 28/07/2022 14:35

NeedANewNameBriefly · 25/07/2022 14:50

Reposting for traffic

Short version - are these issues bad enough to withdraw from property purchase and collapse the chain. Or should this be expected when buying a house.

YABU - Even without a reduction, these issues are not that bad

YANBU - They definitely need to reduce the price a bit

Full version

We are trying to purchase our "forever home", have gone madly over budget on something that isn't perfect, but we are happy enough with. Survey has come back and the work that needs doing seems to be quite a lot. We want to renegotiate the price and based on repair costs for the most significant things, so not just decorate issues for example we want to go lower by about 12% (that's what I've worked it out as being) - estate agent (of course) is saying they won't agree but she doesn't have their actual answer yet. To complicate matters, they are overseas and we cannot reach vendors directly (currently trying via the solicitors instead though)

Basically, we are not quite sure the best way to approach this and how much of this the vendor thinks should have been priced in to our offer, bearing in mind we were unaware of 99% of the issues prior to the survey. The 1% is an issue we believe they should and could still deal with through their buildings insurance.

For context here are some of the issues:

•Repointing of brickwork to two chimney stacks
•Replace a number of missing, slipped and damaged roof tiles (particularly to the front and rear slopes). However, given their age it may be more economic to recover the whole roof rather than continuing to repair. This is our main issue - we want to replace not further patch up the roof. Lots of patchy repairs previously done apparently.
•Carry out crack repair to the front elevation.
•Replace some of the double-glazed units to the conservatory - showing damage
• Porch – replace several roof tiles, and carry out longer-term repair to the far right post which is damaged
•Install additional air bricks and replace damaged air bricks to the right side - doesn't have anywhere near enough. Those it has are damaged
•Reduce the height of the external ground level at the front (or install a French drain) - drain is right in front of doorstep and cut back the timber decking at the rear- to mitigate damp penetration
•Adjust five of the internal doors - almost all doors do not close at all within the house
•Rectify leak from the shower hose/replace shower in the family bathroom
•Hot water cylinder appears undersized/replacement needed
•Replace the waste pipe from the dishwasher and rectify leak from gulley surround
•Secure boarding to the timber decking and carry out timber repairs where required

This property isnt in Stockport is it ?

ItsJustLittleOldMe · 28/07/2022 08:12

We have just bought our first house which was at the very top of our budget but also a fixer upper. We will live in it and save to do it up as we go as it was more than we really wanted to spend but this house is ideal for what we want in the future but even I know that list is ridiculous! And a 12% reduction 😅 good luck with that…

pilkywilkymoansalot · 27/07/2022 16:57

We have built new and converted 18 properties, The price should reflect the state of the property on the day, give or take, in this market they will tell you to get lost, if the identical house next door is flawless it will be £40000 more! Move on and stop stretching yourself, but then again some vendors are trying it on at the minute, supply and demand.

NeedANewNameBriefly · 27/07/2022 16:56

Sigh. Thought this thread died out. I’ve read most reponses, will try address what I can in one go.

I was trying not to make my first post too long, by just listing a few things that were mentioned. The list in total was 23 items that I saw at first. When I got the report, there where 26 items. 2 of which highlighting potential issues with electricity and gas supply.

I have arranged for a roofer to go round and also an electrician and gas engineer. I have since also had back some budget costings most of the other issues (came to around £25k - and we don't have any intention of asking for everything thing on that list at all, we know most will be for us to do).

Unlike the every other single person on mumsnet, I had ZERO clue what any of these things would cost to fix. And did not notice/know to look out for most of the issues raised - we used a couple of lists we found on the internet to help us know what to ask/look for when viewing properties - based on this thread, I might even create a blog post to help others like us who could have used very detailed advice on what to watch for (maybe). The house looked “shiny”, freshly painted inside and at the front outside too (though not painted at the side or the back. Nicely staged etc. Clearly our lack of experience has shown.

To a pp - kindly note I said we were unaware of 99% not aware.

The way the house sits, it’s a hipped roof (another new term I’ve learned) and whilst from the bottom of the garden (looking at a picture of it again), I can definitely see something is awry, because the colours are uneven/differ, I still even now could tell if that was actual damage and I can’t really see the roof at either side because of the properties on either side being so close.

The statement that concerned me was that it may be more economical to replace than repair. To me that sounded like the costs would be pretty similar. However, the surveyor’s budget cost list has the (external) roof repairs at around £5,500 and a total replacement at £25k. So even I don’t think it’s beyond economical repair on those figures. But if it’s going to be needing money spent on it every year to keep it together, then that would be a different consideration.

Someone mentioned the cylinders- thank you! I’d been meaning to look up what they even were really/why they were needed and I forgot. I’ve only ever lived in places with combis / didn’t know this was some sort of (old-fashioned?) alternative. We will definitely be replacing the boiler for a normal one.

As previously mentioned (a few times) , the survey undertaken was a level 3 survey (a structural survey, in old money).

Again, apologies, but I haven’t gone back to double check names and tag people. But at least one person said that the report was actually quite positive in some ways - clearly there are more things we could have read that didn’t get mentioned as you say, so happy to think of it in that context now also.

The surveyor specifically said to us that he isn’t about a million disclaimers and cover your a** type statements. He made clear calls, to the extent possible. I think the only thing he didn’t go into detail on were the state of the floorboards under carpet (because he couldn’t of course rip that up), so I’m very happy with the work he has done.

He has categorically said the movement was not caused by subsidence - so presumably if that ever turned out to be untrue, this is where his public liability insurance would have to kick in. Because we would of course sue. I’m happy to take the word of a very experienced chartered surveyor on that and put the Mather to bed.

To the weirdo that I’ve already responded to once but who has posted the same question a bunch of times - why are you so invested personally invested the timeline? The owners have emigrated. They are not in a chain/waiting on the sale of this house for an onward purchases. As I have already said, from acceptance of offer to now it’s been a matter of weeks. We are still waiting for their responses to our solicitors enquiries. So do please untwist your knickers.

On the budget - I’ve set us a budget. We are are over it BUT even with interest rate rises on the horizon and a bunch of traits to do, it’s will still be affordable (although we have taken a 5 year fix). I’m very cautious - which is why we bought the house we live in now. Because I wanted to keep costs comfortably below our means (we were newly married with no kids at the time) whilst we figured out life as “grownups”. Whilst the property we have now isn’t awful, there are a few issues that we simply can’t do anything about, which means it doesn’t work for the family we have now. Otherwise we would have extended it and stayed here. Now the bigger houses we could have afforded if we stretched ourselves back then cost silly money. And our present home hasn’t gone up by nearly as much. So this time, I’m trying to take that into account and buy a house we know our family will be comfortable in in the long term.

I called it a forever home not because I love it - I am really not the type to get all sentimental about bricks and mortar, but because it’s the home we plan to stay in until our children are grown. Perhaps the better phrase was “long term”. New build versus old was less important to me. What I wanted was good square footage and consistently the new builds we viewed fell short on that front - on the bedrooms especially.

PIL himself has now said trying to get £150k off was more of a CF move - based on the fact he knows how agents overprice things on purpose. He didn’t actually base that figure on what he thought the repairs would cost. This particular agent is well known for that (is. overvaluing), which is why the house I’m sure sat on the market for a while and was reduced twice before we went to view it (and even then, was still priced on the high side). Had they priced it right in the first place, I’m sure it would have flown like everything else was, at the time.

Anyway, I am grateful for all that I have learned from this post, but I've had enough of it now. So I'm out and won’t be checking any further posts. We will be requesting a reduction - it won’t be 12, probably in the 2-3% range at this point. But don’t yet have all the information I need to make a final decision on all that.

Thanks to all those who were kind and helpful with your responses (sorry if I didn’t reply to you directly). And even to those of you who were not as kind, but still helpful I guess I’m somewhat thankful to you too.

OP posts:
mybiggestfan · 27/07/2022 16:30

My survey came back much worse than that. It isnt a new house things will be wrong with it. I wanted the house, it was worth the money so I stumped up. Like others have said get a new house if you want everything like new.

Tessasanderson · 27/07/2022 12:01

I am still very suspicous of how long down the line this conversation is taking place. If its 1-2 weeks after accepting their bid, fair enough. If we are weeks/months down the line when the seller is trying to get their own house purchase in order then its complete CF.

OP has only replied they organised the survey straight away......

Swipe left for the next trending thread