Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What age would you let your DC swim in the sea by themselves

191 replies

Seawars · 25/07/2022 09:41

DC are good swimmers though not used to swimming in the sea. Sea quite a long way out and adults sat up the other end of the beach - so DC in sight but as the beach is busy it is hard to keep track of them. Children swimming properly (not just paddling) with body boards etc - though they've been told not to go out of their depth.
What age would you let them do this?

I'm intrigued as me and my friend clearly had totally different expectations about this on Saturday - despite my DC being the stronger swimmers.

OP posts:
Purplepatsy · 25/07/2022 10:51

I wouldn't allow it at all. Watch the programme about lifeboat rescues. People can get into trouble in the sea at any age even though they are good swimmers.
No matter how well someone swims in a pool, the sea is a different beast altogether with tides and currents that can be dangerously strong.

RockinHorseShit · 25/07/2022 10:49

It really depends on the sea. On our main beach, not until she was a teen & she's always been a very strong swimmer

We have a beach just out of town with several long stone sea arms, the water between the sea arms is always calm, no current at all & just deep enough for her then 8 yo self to stand up in. We let her swim there on her own with us on the beach as we knew it to be very safe & she was a very strong swimmer

Discovereads · 25/07/2022 10:49

Burnedoutdr · 25/07/2022 10:41

Isn't it far more dangerous to never let them in the sea without direct supervision and only finally let them loose when they're going on holiday at legal drinking age?

What happens at midnight on their 18th birthday that suddenly makes it OK? Or is it "out of sight out of mind"?

No, it’s never more dangerous to have an extra pair of eyes for as long as you can, whenever you can. You’re a safety net.

For me 18 is when they leave home so I can’t physically watch out for them anymore. But even when we go on holiday together (most in their 20s), I still keep an eye on them though am more relaxed as they know not to ever swim in the sea alone and are past some of the craziness that teens get up to. Teens have impulse control issues and risk taking behaviour.

Splicebaked · 25/07/2022 10:43

So âge 12 onwards preferably near lifeguards

Danger can happen in a split second, waves, cramp, exhaustion, rip tides

Burnedoutdr · 25/07/2022 10:41

JustJeans · 25/07/2022 10:38

This ☝️

We have always swum in the sea with them and we're all very strong swimmers. DC, 19 & 17, know about rip tides and flags etc. DC1 was a club swimmer too. Neither swam without us until their first independent holiday.

Isn't it far more dangerous to never let them in the sea without direct supervision and only finally let them loose when they're going on holiday at legal drinking age?

What happens at midnight on their 18th birthday that suddenly makes it OK? Or is it "out of sight out of mind"?

Splicebaked · 25/07/2022 10:41

The sea can be deceptively dangerous even the calmest

ChilliPB · 25/07/2022 10:40

I think a lot depends on the conditions - one sea swim can be very different from another.

My sister lives near a very popular swimming beach, which has lifeguards, is generally very calm etc and her and her kids swim there all the time. I’d still be very cautious there - but it is very different to a rough sea/somewhere with currents/somewhere you’re not familiar with etc.

Burnedoutdr · 25/07/2022 10:38

Ducksurprise · 25/07/2022 10:15

All those saying they wouldn't watch teens, teenage boys are most likely to drown. The dreadful news of drowning recently have been teens and upwards.

Posts like burnedoutdr are not helpful, those that drowned can't reply.

The vast majority don't drown. It's a matter of weighing up risk.

Arguably, a teenager who's never been allowed in the sea and has to wear life jackets walking through a puddle is more at risk when they go to uni at a coastal city and run into the sea pissed on a night out, vs. those who weren't wrapped in cotton wool.

JustJeans · 25/07/2022 10:38

DSGR · 25/07/2022 09:51

I will watch them closely in the sea until they leave home at 18. Sea swimming is dangerous

This ☝️

We have always swum in the sea with them and we're all very strong swimmers. DC, 19 & 17, know about rip tides and flags etc. DC1 was a club swimmer too. Neither swam without us until their first independent holiday.

Goldbar · 25/07/2022 10:37

Adults get to take calculated risks like this, children don't.

You may as well ask at what age would you let your child cycle through heavy city traffic, around multi-lane roundabouts and where there are lorries, buses and motorcycles.

My answer is never. I wouldn't let my child do that. Cyclists are frequently crushed to death by buses and lorries or caught up in collisions round here. And yet lots of commuters still cycle to work. Their call. My DC can make that call as an adult, I won't be making it for them.

Same with sea swimming...I can't protect them from risks which lead to many adults drowning so I won't be allowing this. It will be their decision when they are an adult.

Fairislefandango · 25/07/2022 10:30

Mid to late teens. The sea is dangerous. Adults drown in it pretty regularly.

Numbat2022 · 25/07/2022 10:30

My mum always used to come with me, even when I was late teens (last few family holidays) and she was deeply engrossed in a book. I always found it a bit odd, but now I completely understand why. I'm not a strong swimmer and the sea is really fucking dangerous.

Absolutely no way I would leave 10 and younger on their own.

Ithinkwemightgetaholiday · 25/07/2022 10:28

On holiday right now with DC 18 and 14. When we go to the beach I won't be stood at the waters edge watching them, but I won't be sleeping on a lounger either. Me and DH will def have an eye on them at all times between us.

bridgetreilly · 25/07/2022 10:25

I don’t understand why the adults aren’t sitting on the beach near them.

But mostly I think the answer to your question is not really about age but experience. If you live near the sea and have taken them swimming there regularly, and are confident not only in their swimming but also their understanding of the risks and how to deal with them, then 10 is completely fine. If this is their first time swimming in the sea, then I would be keeping an eye even at 15 or 16, tbh.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/07/2022 10:22

Seawars · 25/07/2022 10:15

@Fitzfatsfeist good question about if kids know what to do if one of them got into trouble. I'm not sure I'd know what to tell them apart from calling for help. None of them would be strong enough to help another child and probably end up in trouble themself.

And they shouldn't anyway. The advice is to hold hands (first of all, but mainly adult/child) and float to stay alive - you calm yourself & your nervous system down, breathe easily, whereas when floundering & panicking, a swimmer in trouble will take in water & drown v quickly.

Eleusa · 25/07/2022 10:22

Depends on the sea. We mainly swim in the North Sea, it can be very rough and I wouldn’t let my kids swim unless I was right there (despite the fact that 15yo DS is 6’2” and far more able to save me than I am to save him). The Med is a completely different matter.

BatshitBanshee · 25/07/2022 10:21

I'm a sea swimmer, not a hope would I let a child (read: under 18) out swimming in the sea on their own. I swim in pairs or as a group, all the experience and confidence in the world cannot compete with stray currents, riptides, strong waves... Once they're adults that's different, do what they want but not kids. Especially if they don't know how to get themselves out of a situation.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/07/2022 10:20

And I know what tide time is safest to swim, what to do if there's a rip current, etc.

Exactly.

One of the other points - relevant to those holidaying at this time - is knowledge of the sea / beach you are at.

Often when we go on holidays, we have no idea - and the drownings typically happen when people are unfamiliar with the place wheel they are swimming. They may well be strong swimmers, and being sensible, but the sea can be so dangerous (we had three drownings in ten days in Ireland, 2 were on well-supervised beaches, with lifeguards, and where the rescue services were alerted immediately.)

I go to a beach in West Cork for years. It's idyllic. But it's incredibly dangerous. There are lifeguards, and clear warning signs (lethal riptide & a 'shelf' so you get out of your depth scarily quickly & unexpectedly). But just looking at it, it's hard to see the danger.

acornpattern · 25/07/2022 10:20

I'm a very confident swimmer and still feel quite nervous to swim in the sea. I'm not sure I would ever let mine do that and I'm usually quite a relaxed parent!

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/07/2022 10:19

Honestly, never. Waist deep at most, the sea is just too dangerous.

coodawoodashooda · 25/07/2022 10:19

MisgenderedPaul · 25/07/2022 09:48

25

I agree.

Ducksurprise · 25/07/2022 10:15

All those saying they wouldn't watch teens, teenage boys are most likely to drown. The dreadful news of drowning recently have been teens and upwards.

Posts like burnedoutdr are not helpful, those that drowned can't reply.

Seawars · 25/07/2022 10:15

@Fitzfatsfeist good question about if kids know what to do if one of them got into trouble. I'm not sure I'd know what to tell them apart from calling for help. None of them would be strong enough to help another child and probably end up in trouble themself.

OP posts:
queenatom · 25/07/2022 10:15

I'm glad to see I'm not the only one very nervous about the sea! I'm a confident swimmer and swim (in pools) multiple times a week but the idea of sea swimming stresses me out and I definitely wouldn't be comfortable going in without someone keeping an eye out for me nearby.

housemaus · 25/07/2022 10:14

I'm a strong swimmer, swam competitively for years, and I still avoid the sea unless it's very flat and unusually warm out as we're on the Irish sea and it is bloody freezing. And I know what tide time is safest to swim, what to do if there's a rip current, etc. I wouldn't let kids swim here pretty much ever - paddling/wading about with supervision, but not swimming. Abroad on a beach that was shielded by breakers further out or was very flat and shallow for a long way I'd be slightly more lenient but I'd still want to make sure they were old enough to understand how dangerous it could be, that they were strong swimmers who knew what to do instead of panicking and have an eagle eye on them.

I grew up at the coast, there's a few drownings a year. All too easy for it to go wrong quickly.

I don't have children, so this is hypothetical for me, but I'm generally quite a laid back person about my hypothetical parenting choices (spoken like someone who has no idea as they haven't done it, obviously haha!) but this is something I wouldn't mess about with.

Swipe left for the next trending thread