Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What age would you let your DC swim in the sea by themselves

191 replies

Seawars · 25/07/2022 09:41

DC are good swimmers though not used to swimming in the sea. Sea quite a long way out and adults sat up the other end of the beach - so DC in sight but as the beach is busy it is hard to keep track of them. Children swimming properly (not just paddling) with body boards etc - though they've been told not to go out of their depth.
What age would you let them do this?

I'm intrigued as me and my friend clearly had totally different expectations about this on Saturday - despite my DC being the stronger swimmers.

OP posts:
AgathaMystery · 25/07/2022 11:17

Seawars · 25/07/2022 09:55

Thanks for the reaponses - very interesting. No lifeguard present and no flags. The oldest child was 10 - and highly likely to panic if there's a problem. (I can say that as they are mine!)

it would be a no from me.

We swim in the sea 3-4 times a week & DC are 10. They swim in a club 3 times a week & have been in the sea since they were tiny. We use a few beaches with lifeguards and always between the flags. They know how to spot a rip and the basics of sea swimming survival. I do not use this as a substitute for me being there. I think I helped 2 swimmers last summer and 4 in 2019. The sea is a different animal.

Burnedoutdr · 25/07/2022 11:17

JustJeans · 25/07/2022 11:09

@Burnedoutdr of course nothing happens at midnight on their 18th birthday. Bit of daft comment that.
As with everything else, their comes a time when you let go. Otherwise we'd all still be crossing our adult children across the road.
I grew up in a sea side resort with a fierce tide. Sadly someone drowned there only this week. My kids know how to watch for the dangers and not to swim alone (or drunk) because that's all that we've ever modelled to them.

I think you're quite naive unfortunately. The most over-protected students go off the rails the hardest at uni.

parietal · 25/07/2022 11:15

wave jumping from knee-deep to waist-deep is ok (and more fun) but swimming out of your depth - no way. not until age 18 or older.

RockinHorseShit · 25/07/2022 11:13

I should have added. As a 8 yo DC I nearly got swept out to sea on an ultra safe beach that me & cousins regularly swam in with no adults in with us. The tide suddenly switched on one occasion & I was suddenly been dragged out & getting nowhere fast swimming against it, despite being a strong swimmer. I was lucky that my almost adult competition swimmer cousin spotted me & grabbed me. Unless there's some sort of sea wall protecting the area & you know it well to swim in, its a locally known safe spot, it's really not worth the risk

edenhills · 25/07/2022 11:12

The hardest thing thing is my children are of the age (12) where they are invited to the beach without me, and sometimes without any adult supervision. So far I have said no but it's only going to get harder as they get older.

carefullycourageous · 25/07/2022 11:10

Seawars · 25/07/2022 09:55

Thanks for the reaponses - very interesting. No lifeguard present and no flags. The oldest child was 10 - and highly likely to panic if there's a problem. (I can say that as they are mine!)

I would never advise a person to swim in the sea on a beach without lifeguards. An adult must make their own choices, but I would not let my child do that.

JustJeans · 25/07/2022 11:09

@Burnedoutdr of course nothing happens at midnight on their 18th birthday. Bit of daft comment that.
As with everything else, their comes a time when you let go. Otherwise we'd all still be crossing our adult children across the road.
I grew up in a sea side resort with a fierce tide. Sadly someone drowned there only this week. My kids know how to watch for the dangers and not to swim alone (or drunk) because that's all that we've ever modelled to them.

edenhills · 25/07/2022 11:09

I'm so glad I read this thread. I live by the beach and it's normal here for gangs of kids (8 +) to be in the sea with paddle boards, kayaks etc while all the parents chat and drink beer some distance away. No lifeguards or life jackets. This terrifies the life out of me but I have been made to feel like I am the one who is over the top about safety! I suffer from an anxiety disorder so its hard to trust my gut.

Doingmybest12 · 25/07/2022 11:08

The oldest is 10? Crazy. I think there must be more to this. Were they in a little pool that sometimes happens in the sand and you were actually fairly close and could get there super quickly if there was a problem? Otherwise this seems unbelievable, I would probably avoid going to the beach with this person again.

SweetPeaGirl · 25/07/2022 11:08

I don't think this is age dependent, but skill dependent. Not just swimming in a pool skills, but being used to the sea, knowing how to identify riptides and currents, what to do if you get in trouble, etc. It's also a trust thing - will they definitely stay well within their depth because they understand the seriousness of not?

An 8 year old could be fine with all of the above, and a 14 year old not.

Also depends on the beach, both the conditions of the sea and who is around.

brokengoalposts · 25/07/2022 11:06

I'm a former international swimmer; I used to do some ocean training too, we always had coaches counting heads from the beach, even though we were better swimmers than them. It's not about ability.

2bazookas · 25/07/2022 11:06

My GC ( very strong swimmers age 11) were swimming and snorkelling in wetsuits in the sea on Tuesday; their father and grandfather were in the water with them at all times. (Scotland north coast).
These kids are very hardy and experienced coldwater swimmers in sea and lochs, but they are never unattended and never ever allowed out of their depth except with an adult in the water. (sitting on the beach doesn't count).
DS and DH waited until the children had come ashore before going for a long swim by themselves.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/07/2022 11:05

Those posters who seem very relaxed about the risk ... I think it's telling that those who live close to the sea/swim in it regularly all year advise caution.

The sea is a beast. Beautiful but deadly at times. We must respect it

rhowton · 25/07/2022 11:03

I completely depends on the sea. Ocean in Australia, at least mid teens. If it was Gulf of Mexico, probable 10. If it was UK, then 12. The sea has so many variables.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 25/07/2022 11:03

I open water swim regularly, and frankly my answer would be... not until they're an adult! And even then you'd want a bouy/swimming tow, good quality wet suit and preferably be in a group.

For children, I let my 5 year old in with me in the sea. She sees me do it weekly so of course has an interest. She's never out of my sight, never more than an arms length away so I can always get to her. She has her swimming tow, wetsuit and I wouldn't let her out past her chest height.

You also need to be savvy about tide times, currents, water temperature, winds etc.

Blows my mind that someone would let under 10s in the sea whilst they're up the other end of the beach. Obviously absolutely no clue about open water swimming and the risks.

Don't even get me started on paddle boarding...

Princessoftheuniverse · 25/07/2022 11:01

Take care they are not lulled into a false sense of security because they are good swimmers. I remember telling DS not to go too far out and he said ‘Why not? I’m a good swimmer’. I also remember him getting further and further away due to the current. He was totally unaware. I ended running in (up to my knickers ) because he couldn’t hear me waving and shouting.

mumonthehill · 25/07/2022 11:01

we live by the sea and dc swim, sail, paddle board all the time. Dc are 15 and 21 and understand the sea and tides but I am still always aware where they are and how long they have been out. Most times they take a radio. The number of times I watch young kids on their holidays go into or on the sea without life jackets and with parents not watching them is frightening. The sea is unpredictable, near me a dad died recently saving a group of kids. All these kids were local and used to the sea. The sea is not the same as a swimming pool.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/07/2022 11:01

Seawars · 25/07/2022 10:15

@Fitzfatsfeist good question about if kids know what to do if one of them got into trouble. I'm not sure I'd know what to tell them apart from calling for help. None of them would be strong enough to help another child and probably end up in trouble themself.

I think another problem is that from a distance it's not always obvious whether a swimmer is struggling or just messing about. You can't rely on them calling either as waves wind distance etc mess with acoustics when your in the water. And struggling while trying to call for help will tire you very very quickly

silvertailedcat · 25/07/2022 10:57

Late teens. A few adults in Portugal (Algarve) struggled to get out of the sea when I was there due to the current being so strong, and that was at edge of the sea - they had to be pulled out of it. It looked calm!

blobby10 · 25/07/2022 10:56

Surely it also depends on how often the children go in the sea? If its a child brought up somewhere like Newquay they will be proficient from an earlier age than mine who saw the sea once a year on holiday. Mine were all proficient swimmers but didn't go in without either their dad or me also in the water until around 12. Always had the rule no deeper than waist deep or possibly boob deep if the sea was calm (not often in Cornwall) but I would never switch off! Even this year when I went away with my two youngest ages 22 and 24 I kept an eye on them the whole time they were swimming/bodyboarding - I'm not overprotective - honest!!! 😊 I would have done the same for an adult friend!

PrivateHall · 25/07/2022 10:54

Should have added, we only get in where there are lifeguards and lots of other people around. DH stands at the shoreline watching us as he can swim but prefers not to Grin

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 25/07/2022 10:53

DD is a far stronger swimmer than me, used to swim competitively. We live by the beach and she swims in the sea several times a week if the weather is good. But I sit at the waters edge and watch her like a hawk. Our beach is generally safe, we check the tides and she knows it well, there are many places where it dips down a ft before going shallow again (obviously this can change). The number of people we see on holiday who let their toddler into paddle and dont bother going in with them, not realising that there is a sudden dip before it goes shallow again is ridiculous.

Initially you should go in with them, check out the lay of the land, dont let them in alone at all if the tide is going out and then sit waterside to watch them, not up the beach where you have many people in front of you and it would take you 5 mins to get to the sea.

PrivateHall · 25/07/2022 10:52

My DC are 11, 14 and 17 and I get in with them still and won't let them more than a few feet from me, also no deeper than waist height. They are well versed in what to do should they get pulled out. I read a horrendous thread on here once, that completely left me terrified, I will try and link to it.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4331128-AIBU-to-say-rip-currents-can-get-you-in-shallow-water-and-body-boards-are-actually-quite-dangerous?page=1

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/07/2022 10:52

EnglishGirlApproximately · 25/07/2022 09:45

No advice but interested in the responses. DS is 10 and has completed all of his swimming awards and no swims for a club. Even so the thought of him being in the sea with a body board without me close by scares the life out of me. I think I'm probably too protective but curious about the replies.

I think there is a world of difference between being a good swimmer in a pool environment on being mature and calm enough to know what to do if you get into difficulty in the sea.

Absolutely this. And as pbdr rightly says, the sea is dangerous even for competent adults.

Clymene · 25/07/2022 10:52

I wouldn't let go deeper than their waists them on a non lifeguarded beach as teens.

Under 10s? You should be in the water with them.