Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to stay in a 3 star hotel

183 replies

Cheekycheeky12 · 24/07/2022 21:33

Am I being really snobby, anybody stayed in a 3 star hotel? Looking for holidays for the summer and not used to the summer holiday prices as my daughter is now in year 1, DH says I’m being ridiculous and should just appreciate a holiday.

OP posts:
SirenSays · 24/07/2022 23:50

I wouldnt pay much attention the the rating. I've stayed in 5 hotels that were absolute dumps. In fact, the first time I had food poisoning it was at a 5* hotel.

KnittingNeedles · 24/07/2022 23:46

Everyone is being very disingenuous when they clam that there is no difference between quality of a 3 star or a 5 star.

Yes they are sometimes graded on whether there's a spa or minibar but it is also often true that you get what you pay for. 2 and 3 star accommodation is cheaper. It's cheaper because it's not as modern, or not as well furnished, or the food isn't as good, or there are fewer facilities, or it's in a less nice area, or it hasn;t been updated for decades, or there aren't as many staff and a whole host of other reasons. There is nothing wrong with a Premier Inn for a night or two, but I'm not spending my whole 2 weeks holiday in one thanks.

A 3 star would have to be very special indeed to get me to book. Usually we look at 4 and 5 star and at the tripadvisor ratings.

Also when booking other types of accommodation the star ratings may vary. Sykes cottages uses these ratings - www.sykescottages.co.uk/tick-and-star-rating.html - nothing to do with facilities. 2 star is "well presented", 4 star is "excellent" and 5 is "exceptional". I am another person who is not spending my holiday somewhere not as nice as my house.

BadLad · 24/07/2022 23:45

Somethingneedstochange · 24/07/2022 23:34

I usually go for 3 star because that's what is within my budget. They are usually basic but clean. I always check reviews My main points to look for are cleanliness comfy beds, a decent breakfast and a bar for the evening and no smoking in the hotel. I couldn't believe the amount of hotels in Blackpool that have smoking and non smoking rooms. I would rather have no smoking in the hotel at all.

When were you last in Blackpool? I don't think you have to worry about smoking rooms now.

Ameliarosethistle · 24/07/2022 23:44

Wow, I didn't realise so many people would refuse to stay in 3 hotels! I'm used to holiday lets but have stayed in a few nice 3 hotels and some exceptional 4/5* hotels too. As others have said, whether the hotel is any good will depend on the cleanliness and the facilities available,

Somethingneedstochange · 24/07/2022 23:34

I usually go for 3 star because that's what is within my budget. They are usually basic but clean. I always check reviews My main points to look for are cleanliness comfy beds, a decent breakfast and a bar for the evening and no smoking in the hotel. I couldn't believe the amount of hotels in Blackpool that have smoking and non smoking rooms. I would rather have no smoking in the hotel at all.

ChickenBurgers · 24/07/2022 23:34

WhoIBU · 24/07/2022 21:43

I'd ignore the stars and check reviews on TripAdvisor.

I'm a total holiday/hotel snob but stars are a total red herring.

Plenty of 3* hotels are clean, friendly staff, great location etc. All matter much more to me than butler service etc etc.

This. I pay zero attention to stars and look at facilities available and trip advisor.

Spaghetti0 · 24/07/2022 23:34

As others have said the stars are not to do with service. They are to do with facilities: so you need a conference room or something to be 5 star.
I used to review hotels (holidays really). I’ve stayed in 2 or 3 star places that are significantly better than 5 star places.

PurpleFlower1983 · 24/07/2022 23:32

We stayed in a stunning hotel in Venice called Hotel Sant’Antonin, I couldn’t believe it was only 3 stars!

Holidaydreamingagain · 24/07/2022 23:30

premier inn 3 not a problem. Big resort 3 not a chance. However, there are lots of really wonderful 3 hotels, often boutique family run hotels and many of them are real gems so totally depends what you’re looking for. We also stayed in a 3 in Bangkok, an Ibis and it was absolutely outstanding

Pinksparkleypanties · 24/07/2022 23:28

I’d rather go 5 star every other year than 3 star each year .

I would never stay 3 star. I’m not wealthy ! I just would just rather save harder for another year and go 4 or 5 star !

Pinksparkleypanties · 24/07/2022 23:28

I’d rather go 5 star every year and 3 star each year .

id never stay 3 star. I’m not wealthy ! I just would just rather save harder for another year and go 4 or 5 star !

PurpleFlower1983 · 24/07/2022 23:27

It really depends! Not all 3 star hotels are created equal!

Skoolsout · 24/07/2022 23:22

Thank you for explaining that.

QueSyrahSyrah · 24/07/2022 23:16

To answer a PP, star rating depends on services offered as much as quality or facilities.

I don't have the exact requirements but as an example it may be that to have a 4th star you need 24 hour reception and offer room service, and for a 5th star you need a concierge and same day laundry service.

Having those things doesn't guarantee you the rating as it's based on lots of things, but without you have no chance.

That's why you can find beautiful luxury 3* hotels with amazing facilities but limited services, and scabby 5 star ones with all the gear but no idea.

HappyBinosaur · 24/07/2022 23:13

We tend to look for the best deal we can afford and am not snobby about the rating. I do look at reviews but they are usually mixed even at the much better hotels.

PegasusReturns · 24/07/2022 23:12

It’s not “snobby” to want nice things, including experiences.

I wouldn’t choose stay in a hotel that was less nice than my own home, so I rarely stay in anything that isn’t 5 star.

As a minimum I want king size beds, great views, rain showers, an enormous bath, a decent mini bar, somewhere to sit, loads of hangers and all spotlessly clean.

noirchatsdeux · 24/07/2022 23:12

*demographics

HappyBinosaur · 24/07/2022 23:12

We stayed here a few years ago and it’s 3 star. We normally stay in a 4 star (and very occasionally 5 star!!) but this was absolutely fine and the facilities were great.
Food was repetitive and everything was basic but it was a good price and clean.

www.tui.co.uk/destinations/greece/ionian-islands/corfu/aghios-ioannis/apartments/aqualand-resort-and-waterpark.html

noirchatsdeux · 24/07/2022 23:11

I'm in the industry and travel a lot for work. I've stayed in every star classification going. I've stayed in terrible 7 stars and wonderful 3 stars. The star system doesn't mean much, to be honest. I prefer to look at the reviews on a number of review sites, and not only the ones in English. Demographs play a big part, too...an older traveller is going to be less willing to put up with some 'poor' aspects of their holiday than an 18 year old would be.

Lots and lots of research before booking, that's what I always advise.

Quia · 24/07/2022 23:09

It depends what you want from the hotel. For us, the hotel we stay in when we go on holiday is just a base. So long as it's clean and comfortable, has wifi and does a decent breakfast, that's all we need, and a three star is usually fine. If you want luxury spas, whizzy coffee-makers in the room, a swimming pool etc, presumably you need more.

darlingdodo · 24/07/2022 23:06

Star ratings are more about the facilities than the quality of the hotel. Used to get marked down for no phone in room, reception not 24 hours, no porter to take your bags to your room, no shower cap (not kidding.....) or shoe shine kit. Most of it is really unimportant.

QueSyrahSyrah · 24/07/2022 23:01

It depends entirely on the hotel. We stayed in a small 3 star in Majorca last year that was lovely, rooms a bit tired but very clean, public areas brand new and food / service great, meanwhile we've just stayed in a 4* in Rome that has great reviews but was distinctly mediocre in every sense.

So yes it's a bit snobby (and foolish) to base your decision entirely on the star rating, and sweepingly rule out anything below 4*

Covidbee · 24/07/2022 22:58

Used to work in a 4 hotel. By the outdated star rating rules rhe only reason it wasn't a 5 was due to no lift/elevator.

Couldn't have one built due to it being a historic building.

Still, if you ask me, lift or no lift, wasn't worth 3 let alone 5.

All about the extras/location ect. Can get amazing 2* still.

zoeFromCity · 24/07/2022 22:53

Depends on where the hotel is. If Egypt/Tunis, somewhere exotic, I'd not do 3 stars unless insanely good references.
Somewhere in EU with good hygienic standards being total norm, 3 stars are totally ok for many kinds of holiday.

whynotwhatknot · 24/07/2022 22:51

Course we have but theyre different in every c9untry-one places standards and hygiene arent as great as another

check tripadvosor for reviews and do some research