Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to stay in a 3 star hotel

183 replies

Cheekycheeky12 · 24/07/2022 21:33

Am I being really snobby, anybody stayed in a 3 star hotel? Looking for holidays for the summer and not used to the summer holiday prices as my daughter is now in year 1, DH says I’m being ridiculous and should just appreciate a holiday.

OP posts:
Divebar2021 · 25/07/2022 10:53

Three years ago we went on a big trip to California and stayed in a couple of 3 star hotels at San Francisco and Yosemite. It was the difference between going for 14 days or going for 10 days and quite frankly we were not in the room that often? I’m now at a 5 star in Mauritius but it’s low season here at the moment… I wouldn’t pay the increase to come here in high season I’d definitely downgrade the hotel. I don’t need a butler turning down the bed and throwing rose petals in the bath which is what you seem to get. I’d definitely think about the type of holiday you want and which “services” are must haves.

QueSyrahSyrah · 25/07/2022 10:42

This is a 3* that a friend of mine used to work at during the summer season. Indoor pool, outdoor pool, gym, refurbished rooms, 2 restaurants, evening entertainment, creche, kids club, sports facilities, spa treatments available.

Doesn't look too grotty to me, I've stayed in much worse 4 and even 5 star hotels.

www.seymourhotels.com/merton-hotel/

gatehouseoffleet · 25/07/2022 09:55

luxxlisbon · 24/07/2022 21:37

I don’t think it’s ridiculous. If I’m spending hard earned money to go on holiday I never want to stay in some grotty hotel with no amenities that is basically paying money to stay somewhere much worse than my own nice home.

Three star isn't grotty though. High star ratings usually apply to facilities like if there's a bar or a spa.

JustMarriedBecca · 25/07/2022 09:28

Depends what you want from a holiday. I spent my childhood staying in 4-5* hotels which would probably now be AI. I can't think of anything I'd rather do less.
I'd rather either camp and use the money we save on some really lovely days out and really REALLY good food (we spent the same on a single meal this week as our total accommodation cost for a week camping somewhere naice and it was ERMOMG) or a great self catering break and have a few nights at a local bistro.
I can never shake that feeling of sitting by a pool and watching a coach load of people arrive.
Horses for courses.

Goesbothways · 25/07/2022 09:04

Remember Trip advisor reviews are written set against the expectations of the author which may vastly differ to yours. I stayed in a hotel in Majorca, can't remember the star rating. It had great reviews but wasn't nice. Broken tiles in bathroom, dirt on ceiling, soaked carpets in parts, one area reeked of rotten fish, food awful. Many broken sunbeds. I thought I was booking a cheap but cheerful as that's all I could afford at the time post separation but have previously stayed in far nicer places, having researched well. I was used to better, but to many guests this was a great place to stay.

Dreamstate · 25/07/2022 08:51

I go for modern contemporary decor and then look at facilities. I have seen 4/5 star hotels but they just have old fashioned decor and I would not stay there. Equally some 2/3 star hotels are stylish and I've booked it.

Depends on what your looking for really.

Cadot · 25/07/2022 08:34

I'm firmly in the camp of must be as nice/nicer than my house for a holiday. So no, I wouldn't choose a 3 star and I think that's fine if you can afford it.

If it was the choice of not having a holiday or staying in a 3 star then I would choose the 3 star.

I have stayed in hostels and basic hotels when younger, but at this stage in my life it's just not what I want to do anymore.

I would stay in eg a Premier Inn for an overnight trip for a conference, event etc but not for an actual holiday.

TripAdvisor reviews can be misleading as well because people will have higher expectations of a 5 star hotel and will mark it down for minor irritations with service, whereas a basic place will be marked highly simply for being clean. I like to look at what people have actually written.

balalake · 25/07/2022 08:25

I stayed in one the week before last, in Paris. Lovely, comfortable bed, air conditioning, friendly staff (I speak French but they were pleasant to those who don't).

Not all three star hotels are the same.

BarbaraofSeville · 25/07/2022 08:16

It's not the 'wanting more facilities' it's the idea that a 4 star hotel is automatically nice and a 3 star hotel will be inferior and less nice that people are taking issue with, because it's really not true at all.

Some 4 stars will be lovely. Some will be tired, old fashioned, grubby, in poor locations etc etc.

Some 3 stars will be tired, old fashioned, grubby, in poor locations etc etc. Some will be lovely.

You can't automatically determine whether a hotel will be nice to stay in based solely on the star rating because it just doesn't work like that.

iBrows · 25/07/2022 08:09

What’s wrong with wanting to stay in a hotel with more facilities than a 3 star? I wouldn’t want to stay in a 3 star unless we really couldn’t afford anything else and were desperate to go on holiday.

hareandrabbit · 25/07/2022 08:00

Cheekycheeky12 · 24/07/2022 21:33

Am I being really snobby, anybody stayed in a 3 star hotel? Looking for holidays for the summer and not used to the summer holiday prices as my daughter is now in year 1, DH says I’m being ridiculous and should just appreciate a holiday.

I wouldn't stay in a 3 star hotel. You have to knock one star off to UK standards (in resorts not cities). So you'd be staying in a 2 star.

As pp pointed out there are some 3 stars that don't have great facilities but are nice. I assume because you have a child you're looking for pool etc.

JustDanceAddict · 25/07/2022 07:47

Much better to check Trip Advisor and go in general consensus than the star rating.
premier Inn is 3* and is fine for a city break but you’d want more From a resort hotel.
Star ratings are v different overseas too.

NippyWoowoo · 25/07/2022 07:45

entropynow · 24/07/2022 21:47

Sure you do 🙄

I live near there too? What’s so hard to believe?

And I agree with the PP, it’s really rough-looking on the outside.

To OP, I’m currently staying in a 3 star in Belgium, it’s nice, clean, has AC but I’m here just for a couple nights and the aim of my trip is sightseeing, so I really just need a decent place to sleep.

SleeplessInEngland · 25/07/2022 07:44

The OP seems to have fucked off but yes, shamefully ridiculous.

KnittingNeedles · 25/07/2022 07:43

I can't stand hotels and their poky rooms/standardised bed covers/lack of privacy/space

Yet you go on about how marvellous Youth Hostels are? About as cheap and basic as you get with lots of communal sharing and living? You also have a very weird idea about what a hotel is, based on the big chains like Hilton.

People like different stuff. A week in a youth hostel or camping would be like a prison sentence for me. Spent my childhood camping/caravanning and NEVER AGAIN.

Oblomov22 · 25/07/2022 07:42

I've stayed in loads of hotels of varying stars. Most are fine. 3 or 4 stars in East Ibiza or East Majorca were lovely.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 25/07/2022 06:55

It’s not snobby at all, it’s a holiday I like a little comfort. 4 or 5 stars for me only!

mogsrus · 25/07/2022 06:54

Having worked in 4star hotels one with a cocktail bar. The bar was removed after many years hotel lost 1star

BalloonsAndWhistles · 25/07/2022 06:32

i don’t stay in anything less than 10 star personally.

ivykaty44 · 25/07/2022 06:29

People get hung up star rating

user1497787065 · 25/07/2022 06:28

Star ratings are usually a red herring. I've stayed in plenty of four and five star hotels with rooms requiring attention. Equally I've stayed in some fab 2 star rated hotels and b and bs.

If a pool and a squash court are important you will need to book a high star rating. For me I like a good sized, well appointed room with a good bathroom with plenty of storage. I'm always irritated by the number of hotels where there is no socket near the mirror you would for drying your hair, poor lighting for make up etc.

So 3 star does not necessarily mean grotty. It could be but so can 4 and 5 star hotels.

kateandme · 25/07/2022 06:17

Yes ud say bigger hotels with the stars and facilities can still be shit holes.
That little green village where the family runs it,clean,amazing food,nice people might have less stars because it a home,bed,food place buy it's a sight more lovely than the gritty bigger hotel.
It's really confusing nowadays.
We go for area then start searching the lists and click straight down to review from picture.sometimes without even reading description.
Actually a quick hotel search and blog review can be good( if they aren't paid)
Do not look on social media( will be paid usually)
And be mindful on reviews nowadays if they were asked to stay by so and so which means they want a review in their favour.
And to the person that said that's why they won't camp.ha! Lots of posh campsites with 5 stars 😬

bluetongue · 25/07/2022 03:54

I’m not the type that needs my hand holding a gym or a swimming pool for sightseeing type trips. I’ve stated in some very nice 2 and 3 star hotels in France and Italy. One in Venice was near St Marks Square for a very good price. It was cheaper because reception and breakfast were in the lovely 4 star ‘sister’ hotel next door.

ManateeFair · 25/07/2022 03:25

I don’t think you understand how the star rating works - it’s largely a matter of facilities available, not the quality of the rooms or service.

Stayed in a 3* last week. Beautiful room, absolutely stunning location and views, wonderful breakfasts, fab service all round. But did not have stuff like lifts, its own car park, lots of TV channels, guest laundry service, night porter, super fast WiFi, air con etc because it was in a remote location in a historic building and only had about ten rooms.

By contrast I’ve stayed in chain hotels in shit locations with a mediocre restaurant, average service at best, a lukewarm buffet breakfast, shoddy cleaning, a view of the bins etc that had four stars because they had a load of stuff I couldn’t give a shit about, like a gym, 24-hr room service, an underground car park etc.

CorvusPurpureus · 25/07/2022 03:20

I would expect 3* to be perfectly ok. Clean, well run.

If I'm travelling for fun & will be busy doing stuff in the day, then I am totally fine with 3* to sleep.

On the other hand, if I'm booking a lazy overnight & it's on expenses, I'll go 5* & enjoy the...well, I don't know, really. The free cardboard slippers? Too many cushions?

Possibly I'm a bit jaded because of work travel, but 5*, meh. It's still a room with a bed in it.