Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Footing the bill?

57 replies

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 24/07/2022 20:19

Jane and Bob are brother and sister. Bob has a birthday coming up.
Jane decided it should be celebrated.
Jane and Bob both have two children who are the same age (early 20s)
In attendance is Jane, Bob, their dad, Jane’s children and Bob’s children.
Jane decides the bill should be split four ways. Herself, her dad and Bob’s DC1 & DC2.

Is it fair that Jane’s children don’t pay?

YABU - no they’re just as old and if they’re attending they should be paying too
YANBU - it’s Bob’s birthday and only his own children should pay

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 24/07/2022 22:48

Did anyone ask Jane why?

HollowTalk · 24/07/2022 22:46

Why doesn't Jane just cook a meal and invite everyone, asking those who want to drink alcohol to bring a bottle.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/07/2022 22:41

Bob'sy children should take their dather for a meal and forget about Aunty Jane & her CF children.
Aunty Jane sounds like a manipulative PITA

Bookshadow · 24/07/2022 22:36

Jane pays or Jane and Bob pay or dad pays our dad and Jane or dad and Jane and Bob.

Bob's children should not pay a portion of Jane's children's meal. That would be weird. Happy birthday Bob. For your birthday this year I have fleeced your children.

Penguinsaregreat · 24/07/2022 22:29

It should be split 6 ways or Jane pays the lot.

Goldbar · 24/07/2022 22:24

Jane's children should either give the meal a miss or pay for themselves. No reason why Bob's children should pay for them.

Lochroy · 24/07/2022 21:58

There are billions of options, and this kind of thing really should be sorted out in advance, at the time of booking.

As a going in, I assume each should pay their own way.
Then, one or all of the following could offer to pay for the birthday boy:Jane, his Dad, his DC.

Splitting the whole bill four ways is crackers because it means Bob's DC and Dad are picking up part of Jane's DC's bill.

Africa2go · 24/07/2022 21:40

Are you sure Jane meant that it was split equally 4 ways? I can see some sense in those 4 paying - but Jane obviously paying 50% of the bill (3/6th for herself + her 2 children), Dad pays 1/6th, each of Bob's children pay 1/6th each.

TokyoSushi · 24/07/2022 21:32

All DC should pay or none. Goodness knows about the rest of it!

JenniferBarkley · 24/07/2022 21:31

Presumably you're Bob's wife or DD? Why not just say so.

Jane presumably has a reason why her DC shouldn't pay, so what is it? How would the post read if Jane posted it?

On the face of it, obviously either all DC should be paying or none, so presumably there's some logic to Jane's suggestion.

AllFreeOwls · 24/07/2022 21:14

Why should Bob's children have to pay but Jane's children not be expected to?! Most unfair (does come with the caveat that I'm assuming both sets of children are adults)

Beautiful3 · 24/07/2022 21:09

Think it should be split between Jane and Bob. All the others are guests.

Transformatio · 24/07/2022 20:50

As it was a surprise then it should be split 6 ways (excluding Bob) if Jane wishes to pay 3/6 and treat her children then that’s up to her but other people shouldn’t be expected to cover them! Alternatively, Jane pays for all of it.

Craftybodger · 24/07/2022 20:43

7 people, Jane, Bob, their Dad and 4 adult children.
Either the bill is split between the 6 (with each paying a little of Bob’s share), or 7 or Jane pays the lot as the person organising and inviting. However the bill is split should be made clear at the time of inviting them.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 24/07/2022 20:38

Cross post- that's bizarre. So she wants Bob's kids to pay for hers? I could understand her kids not contributing to Bob's share whilst asking his kids to- I wouldn't do it but I wouldn't think she was from another planet. But asking his kids to subsidize hers is very odd.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 24/07/2022 20:36

Unless she thinks her, her dad and bobs kids should split bobs and then pay for themselves and she pays for her kids 🤷‍♀️
Are hers in full time education? Or SEN? Or some other reason that they may or be financially as well off as Bob's kids?
Either way bobs Dad and kids shouldn't cover the cost of Janes kids.

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 24/07/2022 20:35

xyzandabc · 24/07/2022 20:27

Too many different permutations to go with your voting.

Why would Jane's children not pay but Bob's children do? Is there a difference in their circumstances e.g Jane's children are still undergraduate students whereas Bob's children have well paid jobs?

Was the whole thing Jane's idea?. Does Bob even want to go out for a meal with the family?

Without any further detail I'd say either:

  1. Jane pays for the lot as it was her idea and she invited people
Or
  1. Split 3 ways, Jane, Bob and dad depending on dad's circumstances, if he can't afford it, then split 2 ways between Jane and Bob.
Or
  1. If all working adults and able to afford it, then split 7 ways. Or 6 ways if you all agree to cover Bob's share.

No there’s no circumstances why Bob’s children should pay and Jane’s shouldn’t. There’s no difference in financial situation like the example you made.

Whole thing was Jane’s idea yes. She wants to be “hostess with the mostess” without the burden of the full bill. Bob probably isn’t bothered about going for birthday meal (Surprise meal btw hence why he wasn’t included in bill)

OP posts:
butterflied · 24/07/2022 20:34

If Jane thinks there should be a celebration then she should pay. She doesn't get to spend other people's money for them.

KyaClark · 24/07/2022 20:34

Bill split 6 ways. It's up to Jane if she pays for half herself or not.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 24/07/2022 20:34

Jane , dad and all adult children should split the bill.
Bob shouldn't pay.

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/07/2022 20:33

Jane should have been very clear if she didn't want to pay, right at the planning stage.

If she didn't want to pay, then she can either pay for her kids, pay for Bob and her kids, or everyone pays their own way. What she can't do is make other people pay for her kids.

BitOutOfPractice · 24/07/2022 20:33

Just tell us who you are ffs. I hate these disingenuous posts.

In my family Jane and Bob would split it 50/50 and the dc wouldn’t be involved. But clearly you have an issue somewhere. Do spit it out.

BeenThereBoughtTheTeeShirt · 24/07/2022 20:30

7 bills split 6 ways.
Or each pay own way and Jane treats Bob.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 24/07/2022 20:30

The meal should have either been Jane's treat (as she arranged it), or split evenly among all adults.

If Jane didn't want her dc to pay, she should have paid their part.

PuttingDownRoots · 24/07/2022 20:28

Unless Jane means she is covering her children's share along with her own, that is unreasonable.