Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Footing the bill?

57 replies

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 24/07/2022 20:19

Jane and Bob are brother and sister. Bob has a birthday coming up.
Jane decided it should be celebrated.
Jane and Bob both have two children who are the same age (early 20s)
In attendance is Jane, Bob, their dad, Jane’s children and Bob’s children.
Jane decides the bill should be split four ways. Herself, her dad and Bob’s DC1 & DC2.

Is it fair that Jane’s children don’t pay?

YABU - no they’re just as old and if they’re attending they should be paying too
YANBU - it’s Bob’s birthday and only his own children should pay

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Transformatio · 25/07/2022 14:20

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:55

Yes it happened slyly and I don’t think anyone really appreciated what had happened until afterwards.

Are you planning on doing/saying something now?

Must admit we never did (never affected young adults like this though) but put things in place to stop it happening again - which definitely annoyed them!

longdistanceclaraaa · 25/07/2022 12:25

I don't actually think young adults in the position of Bob's children should be forced to pay for extended family meals that are in general like ones they have accepted hospitality for but where the payer, likely Jane or Jane's dad, had paid. It's not equal. They might not even have wanted to attend those other events and certainly not if reciprocity was expected.

I appreciate the way my extended family dealt with us in a situation where my dad's family might be expected to pay but where we were young adults with no spare cash for that type of thing.

longdistanceclaraaa · 25/07/2022 12:16

I am one of three adult children. Our mum and dad divorced long ago. For dad's celebrations with extended family you might generally expect my dad and mum, if they were together, 'taking everyone out for a meal'. That's how it works in his extended family.

My sisters and tend to organise his celebrations. When we we're young adults we would try to pay but my extended family would have none of it and insisted the bill was shared among adults. Now we are older adults we have more clout, and finances, to insist.

I do not agree with Jane at all, but could her thinking be traced here? If she takes extended family out, and pays, for celebrations for her side of the family (if she does), maybe she thinks Bob's side of the family should do the same.

Terrible behavior, but at least perhaps an explanation, albeit a poor one

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 25/07/2022 11:26

So bobs children paid for themselves, and a quarter of Janes kids, you and their dad?

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:55

Yes it happened slyly and I don’t think anyone really appreciated what had happened until afterwards.

OP posts:
Lochroy · 25/07/2022 09:49

OakPine · 25/07/2022 09:43

One of the adults should have jumped in and helped the “shy awkward children” who were being manipulated by their CF relative.
Easier with hindsight. You’ll know next time.

Exactly!

Transformatio · 25/07/2022 09:46

I've got a [wealthy] family member like this - they can only get away with it for so long. I think it was some kind of game to them.
I'm surprised none of the older family member present, who know her form (?) called her out at the time. Did she do it slyly? I hope now it has come to light that this is at least discussed with Bob's children so they feel empowered not to just accept this kind of manipulative shit.

OakPine · 25/07/2022 09:43

One of the adults should have jumped in and helped the “shy awkward children” who were being manipulated by their CF relative.
Easier with hindsight. You’ll know next time.

Sweatinglikeabitch · 25/07/2022 09:38

Did Bob pay? She's a right CF!

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:37

Lochroy · 25/07/2022 09:22

So why doesn't anyone call her out on it? Time, and time, and tie, again on here there are threads like this, or 'I didn't have any booze and had to pay a share' and so on. All it takes it for someone to say 'actually I think it would be more fair if xxxx'.

IMO it’s because they only do it to people they know won’t say no. Shy younger people is a good example. Putting them in an awkward position.

OP posts:
Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:33

Yes, came to more than even a 1/4 share

OP posts:
Newmumatlast · 25/07/2022 09:30

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:17

I am also of the opinion that Aunty Jane is a manipulative PITA.

Exactly what I wrote is what happened. I am another relative who was also there but wasn’t asked to contribute to the bill as I arranged cake and decorations. No one questioned Jane as she goes about it in a way she knows people won’t, puts people on the spot etc. She has form. It was playing on my mind and I didn’t know if my opinion was swayed as I know for a fact Jane is a PITA. But I agree with the majority, there no good reason for her DC’s to not have paid a penny.

Did the cost of the cake and decorations come to more than what your share would've been (and to make it accurate, your share of the cost of the meal plus cake and decorations divided by the adults attending)? Otherwise why didn't you also contribute to the meal? That's unfair too.

Lochroy · 25/07/2022 09:22

So why doesn't anyone call her out on it? Time, and time, and tie, again on here there are threads like this, or 'I didn't have any booze and had to pay a share' and so on. All it takes it for someone to say 'actually I think it would be more fair if xxxx'.

Birthdaysbloodybirthdays · 25/07/2022 09:17

ThinWomansBrain · 24/07/2022 22:41

Bob'sy children should take their dather for a meal and forget about Aunty Jane & her CF children.
Aunty Jane sounds like a manipulative PITA

I am also of the opinion that Aunty Jane is a manipulative PITA.

Exactly what I wrote is what happened. I am another relative who was also there but wasn’t asked to contribute to the bill as I arranged cake and decorations. No one questioned Jane as she goes about it in a way she knows people won’t, puts people on the spot etc. She has form. It was playing on my mind and I didn’t know if my opinion was swayed as I know for a fact Jane is a PITA. But I agree with the majority, there no good reason for her DC’s to not have paid a penny.

OP posts:
PaddleBoardingMomma · 25/07/2022 01:39

Jane is a dickhead. Don't be like Jane.

Eightiesfan · 25/07/2022 01:35

Jane wanted to have the birthday dinner so she should pay the bill. It’s bad form to invite people to a celebration and expect them to pay.

LocalHobo · 25/07/2022 01:19

I would say Jane pays but it is a nice gesture for her Dad to chip in.

Meraas · 25/07/2022 01:17

friendlycat · 25/07/2022 00:43

I hate this type of post as well. Just state the facts correctly and then you might get sensible answers. If you can’t communicate properly between yourselves perhaps this is why the situation arose in the first place.

And they don’t even come back to say what actually was raised with the CF…

easyday · 25/07/2022 01:02

Either Jane foots the bill, Jane and her Dad do, or all the adults OTHER than Bob does. Why should he pay for his own party when it wasn't even his idea? Hey bro I'm arranging a dinner for you but you gotta pay..
But regardless I see no reason why Jane's adult kids shouldn't pay (unless she pays for them).

friendlycat · 25/07/2022 00:43

I hate this type of post as well. Just state the facts correctly and then you might get sensible answers. If you can’t communicate properly between yourselves perhaps this is why the situation arose in the first place.

Wotaloadofshit · 25/07/2022 00:15

Neither or your options.
Jane decided the birthday should be celebrated so foot the bill or cancel the celebration

Dic · 24/07/2022 23:51

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 24/07/2022 23:37

I find there treads even more annoying than reverses. Just ask a simple honest question and you’ll get a simple honest answer. If you can’t even do that anonymously with strangers on the internet no wonder you can’t even talk to your family about splitting a bill!

Absolutely

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 24/07/2022 23:37

I find there treads even more annoying than reverses. Just ask a simple honest question and you’ll get a simple honest answer. If you can’t even do that anonymously with strangers on the internet no wonder you can’t even talk to your family about splitting a bill!

LimboLass · 24/07/2022 23:27

All DC should pay or none. Goodness knows about the rest of it

This

Meraas · 24/07/2022 23:19

I hope someone told Jane way?

Swipe left for the next trending thread