Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I overreacting or was this woman just very rude?

35 replies

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:11

It's agency work so thank goodness I don't need to see her again.
We're supporting a lady who's quadriplegic, 2 of us working at her supported living home. I'm agency and she's one of the permanent staff.

I've only done one night shift here before but never a day one, the other night shift staff member had been lovely and welcoming.

Anyway he had told me that some of his colleagues 'hate' agency staff, which didn't exactly fill me with confidence.

I arrived and l make some polite conversation with her, just 1 or 2 questions, then she instantly put in her headphones to make it clear she didn't want to talk. This is fine, I mean I don't expect to chat all day long but I thought she'd make the bare minimum of polite conversation.

She was mostly fine then and the actual work we had to do was very minimal, there was a lot of sitting around but still no conversation, maybe one comment from her and that's it. In 11 hours.

I then assisted her with moving and handling. I put some pillows in the wrong position for the client which I understand is annoying, but the colleague snapped, NO, I SAID under her feet. She then sighed and said 'jesus'.
I bit my tongue but I was very close to telling her not to speak to me like that.

Generally she would tell me if she'd need me to assist with the client or not as at one point I followed her to the lady's room and she said no you can stay here until I call you.

A while later she was with the client. She then came in and said angrily, "Are you coming?!" And pulled that exasperated face at me. I apologised as I genuinely hadn't heard her call me.

There's a sign at the front of the room which outline 'agency' jobs. Then it says 'permanent staff will give you clear instructions regarding what to do and when'.

About 15 minutes before the end of the shift she told me, "Next time, you need to make sure you clean the toilet and mop the bathroom at 7pm."

This information hadn't been passed onto me at all so I said I was sorry I hadn't been told that was my task. Then she went "That's why it's in big writing so you can read it."

I defended myself again but I figured she's just a nasty piece of work.
Also how she was talking about the client on the phone, the client's room is only next door. She was speaking like the client was 3 years old, not 35.

I didn't even say bye to her, just left and vowed I wouldn't be returning there.
I understand it's annoying to work with agency staff and we may get things wrong, but we are there to help. I didn't like her rude attitude.
Was I overreacting? What would you have done?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LuckyLil · 24/07/2022 21:39

My mum was a carer for social services almost 30 years and there was always a thing about full timers not liking working with agency staff, like an ingrained belief the work wasn't done to the same standard and they didn't have enough time. It was almost a rivalry thing. This was over a decade ago.

When my mum became terminally ill and needed agency staff she mellowed a bit but it took time to find one she liked, I actually refused to allow access to another one from the agency because she was too rough and hurt my mum. The carer we stuck with was Portuguese and was so kind and caring. My mum used to lend her books to read on the bus on her way home as she loved to read.

She sat with me and cried the day we decided mum needed to go into hospice at the end because she knew she wouldn't see her again. She said to me some of my clients are so horrible to me, they shout at me but your mum is so kind to me.

I think like everything even with full timers you'll find some that are just not very nice to work with but having needed to rely on agency myself it's not all bad. Unfortunately there does seem to be a culture where some full time staff don't consider agency staff as equals but don't let one person spoil it for you.

Agency do an amazing job under very difficult circumstances and I couldn't have coped with a terminally ill loved one without them. All we had was agency at the time and it was a little hit and miss at first, but we did find the right carer.

Carlycat · 24/07/2022 21:37

And you were treated appallingly. I'm a health care professional myself and have always treated agency staff with the utmost respect ( as have my colleagues )

Carlycat · 24/07/2022 21:31

I'd report her. She's not fit to look after a vulnerable person.

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 21:31

Thanks I feel more confident about reporting it now.
I understand there are a small number of agency staff who will just turn up and listen to music/sleep on the shift, but most are not like this.

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 24/07/2022 21:24

Absolutely inappropriate and disrespectful behaviour from her, both to you and the client. I would have called her out there and then and then I would have reported her. People like her do not belong in that sector.

PattyMelt · 24/07/2022 21:23

Make sure your agency lets the facility know that staff are hostile to agency staff and have told you that agency are not liked. The facility will soon nip it in the bud when the staff with shitty attitudes are have to work shorthanded.
We are bloody grateful for the agency staff we get, most work really hard and like our facility and request to return. There have only been two in the last three years we have asked the agency not to send to us again.

BronwenFrideswide · 24/07/2022 21:18

However she is probably like that to other agency staff so I need to speak up for their sake.

Yes, @Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree sadly you do no-one should have to endure that during their working day, it's completely out of order.

N00tN00t · 24/07/2022 21:16

Sorry, bit of a long post for no reason there!

N00tN00t · 24/07/2022 21:15

That sounds horrible and I wouldn't take a job there again.
I used to love having agency staff come in, it changed the conversations and was nice. The only time I struggled was when we had a new agency woman come in on a day a resident had died. She didn't speak any English at all except the odd word.
We had to get the resident ready for the undertakers and it was really difficult explaining to her what we needed to do. I told her not to roll the lady towards her and did a kind of movement with arms to show what I meant. She thought I was saying to roll her. It was very messy and unpleasant. I felt awful for the agency woman.
It wasn't her fault, she seemed very awkward and like she had been thrown in at the deep end.
I did make a complaint, but not against her, against the agency for not making sure she would be able to work safely.

runlittlemonster · 24/07/2022 21:12

OP I’m sorry to hear you spoken to like this, she was completely out of order and it must have been upsetting. It’s no reflection on you at all, of course you aren’t expected to know everything on your first shift in that setting. This woman is not acting in the way a care practitioner should.

Reading your post was worrying. This rings alarm bells from the point of view of safeguarding for the client. Is this woman (the care worker) alone with the client at any point? If she is frustrated and short tempered to the point she’s openly rude to colleagues, I’d be very worried about how she interacts with the client when not observed. The comments she made about the client on the phone, the use of her headphones etc, as well as the way she snapped at you in front of her, show a blatant disregard for the dignity and comfort of the lady she is supposed to be supporting in her own home. This lady cannot get herself out if the situation or easily make her preferences known, so it’s up to others raise the alarm about concerns on her behalf - and there are a few concerns here. Please, please report everything you’ve posted here to the manager of the care provider!

PassThePringles · 24/07/2022 21:10

That's the reason I'll never work in care again, the people I had to work with are awful. And that's been my experience in two different care homes. Some are awful to other workers and some sickened me by the way they spoke about the residents.

I can see why you weren't very assertive in getting her told, you're way more professional than she is and she caught you off guard with the shitty attitude. I complained about a lady I was working with and was basically just sighed at (apparently she'd been complained about a few times but there wasn't a 'real' reason to sack her) so I left. It's ridiculous.

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:46

I should have been more assertive, I think it's just because I knew I'd be going very soon and would never see her again. However she is probably like that to other agency staff so I need to speak up for their sake.

OP posts:
cansu · 24/07/2022 20:45

I think you need to be more assertive with people like her and call her out on the way she is speaking to you. There are lots of care jobs and if she is going to treat people like shit she is going to make it harder for her team to find agency support when they need it.

BronwenFrideswide · 24/07/2022 20:44

What would you have done?

Told her in no uncertain terms not to be so damn rude.

I would also complain in writing about her attitude and complete unprofessionalism. Include the examples you have listed in you opening post, there is NO excuse for that behaviour towards you or the client NONE.

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:42

The other staff member seemed great, very clear instructions, patient and friendly.

OP posts:
Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:41

The thing is she literally could have asked me to clean the toilet at 7 and I would have done so right away. I really don't know why she decided to just make passive aggressive comments instead, I'm not a mind reader.

OP posts:
123Callie · 24/07/2022 20:41

It seems like this client has a very poor quality of life. I imagine she doesn’t want to ask for anything as she knows how the staff feel about her.

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:34

Thank you for the help. Sometimes I hate how we're referred to as 'the agency!'
In another place I went to they needed someone to go to another building for 15 minutes and the manager said, "I'll send the agency." Meaning me

OP posts:
Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:32

Thank you for the help. Sometimes I hate how we're referred to as 'the agency!'
In another place I went to they needed someone to go to another building for 15 minutes and the manager said, "I'll send the agency." Meaning me

OP posts:
WTF475878237NC · 24/07/2022 20:29

She was extremely rude and unprofessional and I would complain!

Thefriendlymoth · 24/07/2022 20:27

She was unpleasant and your feelings are totally valid. I agree that you should make them aware, she was behaving in a very unprofessional way, in front of a client and presumably does with all agency workers, if it known some people “hate” them. She shouldn’t be letting her personal feelings about the use of agency staff impact how she treats them (particularly in front of clients - it must feel incredibly awkward). If she has issues with agency workers she needs to speak to someone about her concerns/reasons rather than assuming the worst of all agency staff. Sorry this happened to you OP, I’m glad you don’t have to go back.

Poppinjay · 24/07/2022 20:26

You need to report her behaviour for the sake of the lady you were supporting. I a member of my team were behaving like this, I would consider it a safeguarding to the children in our care.

Please write a detailed description of everything you observed and send it to someone senior in the supported living complex, asking them to ensure that the family is informed if appropriate.

Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:26

It seems that the client is permanently bedbound, maybe they come to the living room in their chair sometimes but I haven't seen this happen so far.
The staff are based in her living room

OP posts:
Clubtropicanadrinksarenotfree · 24/07/2022 20:25

I only go back to places where I'm a regular, I don't think I will go to any new places as of now

OP posts:
Bonbon21 · 24/07/2022 20:24

Bit confused, how your colleague is going to hear the client calling for assistance if necessary when she has earphones on... not only unprofessional but neglectful?
This really does not sound like a happy supportive atmosphere for the client... so I would definitely be reporting this to your agency.

Swipe left for the next trending thread